The One and Only Gamefly Thread
#51
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Godfather
No fast return for me. I sent out one on Sat. and one on Mon. and neither are showing up returned in my profile.
#52
They sent my first on Thursday, got it on Saturday - 2 days and I was happy.
They sent my second on Friday, haven't got it yet - 3rd day today (and counting).
I only dropped the first one in my mailbox this morning so we'll see if I get Fast Return.
They sent my second on Friday, haven't got it yet - 3rd day today (and counting).
I only dropped the first one in my mailbox this morning so we'll see if I get Fast Return.
#56
An alternative to free trial going around:
Most of the "Free <insert game item here>" places have Gamefly as one of the offers you can complete.
I did a month of Gamefly for $9.99 + a free trial of Stamps.com, and got a free XBox 360 Guitar Hero II bundle, plus $5 free postage for the stamps.com trial. $9.99 for Guitar Hero II + Guitar, a month of game rentals, and $5 of free postage was pretty darn nice. That was without needing any referrals, so you don't have to spam your friends/message boards.
Note: I'm not looking for any referrals, and anyone that is, please don't spam your referral code. Thanks.
Most of the "Free <insert game item here>" places have Gamefly as one of the offers you can complete.
I did a month of Gamefly for $9.99 + a free trial of Stamps.com, and got a free XBox 360 Guitar Hero II bundle, plus $5 free postage for the stamps.com trial. $9.99 for Guitar Hero II + Guitar, a month of game rentals, and $5 of free postage was pretty darn nice. That was without needing any referrals, so you don't have to spam your friends/message boards.
Note: I'm not looking for any referrals, and anyone that is, please don't spam your referral code. Thanks.
#57
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Joined: Oct 2005
Posts: 6,341
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Muncie, IN [Member formerly known as abrg923]
Originally Posted by Jeremy517
An alternative to free trial going around:
Most of the "Free <insert game item here>" places have Gamefly as one of the offers you can complete.
I did a month of Gamefly for $9.99 + a free trial of Stamps.com, and got a free XBox 360 Guitar Hero II bundle, plus $5 free postage for the stamps.com trial. $9.99 for Guitar Hero II + Guitar, a month of game rentals, and $5 of free postage was pretty darn nice. That was without needing any referrals, so you don't have to spam your friends/message boards.
Note: I'm not looking for any referrals, and anyone that is, please don't spam your referral code. Thanks.
Most of the "Free <insert game item here>" places have Gamefly as one of the offers you can complete.
I did a month of Gamefly for $9.99 + a free trial of Stamps.com, and got a free XBox 360 Guitar Hero II bundle, plus $5 free postage for the stamps.com trial. $9.99 for Guitar Hero II + Guitar, a month of game rentals, and $5 of free postage was pretty darn nice. That was without needing any referrals, so you don't have to spam your friends/message boards.
Note: I'm not looking for any referrals, and anyone that is, please don't spam your referral code. Thanks.
#59
DVD Talk Special Edition
Joined: Jul 2004
Posts: 1,262
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: United States of HELL YEAH!!!
Originally Posted by Jeremy517
An alternative to free trial going around:
Most of the "Free <insert game item here>" places have Gamefly as one of the offers you can complete.
I did a month of Gamefly for $9.99 + a free trial of Stamps.com, and got a free XBox 360 Guitar Hero II bundle, plus $5 free postage for the stamps.com trial. $9.99 for Guitar Hero II + Guitar, a month of game rentals, and $5 of free postage was pretty darn nice. That was without needing any referrals, so you don't have to spam your friends/message boards.
Note: I'm not looking for any referrals, and anyone that is, please don't spam your referral code. Thanks.
Most of the "Free <insert game item here>" places have Gamefly as one of the offers you can complete.
I did a month of Gamefly for $9.99 + a free trial of Stamps.com, and got a free XBox 360 Guitar Hero II bundle, plus $5 free postage for the stamps.com trial. $9.99 for Guitar Hero II + Guitar, a month of game rentals, and $5 of free postage was pretty darn nice. That was without needing any referrals, so you don't have to spam your friends/message boards.
Note: I'm not looking for any referrals, and anyone that is, please don't spam your referral code. Thanks.
I tried doing that once and one of the companys never refunded my money from the "trial", I had to cancel my credit card. Also a few places didn't even register that I signed up for something and on top of that, they never sent what I wanted and after about 6 months they just sent me an amazon gift card.
It's really not worth it folks, I really would advice against signing up for any of these.
#60
It is one of those free item websites. The one I did required you to complete two offers to get a free 360 game. I avoided all the shady offers and just did the stamps.com and Gamefly offers, since those are obviously reputable companies. No problems whatsoever.
I could try to complete more offers and get a free 360 game for every two offers that I complete, but I have ZERO desire to do any offers involving Hoodia/eBay sales tools/weight loss garbage/psychics/etc, for all the reasons that lukewarmwater mentioned. I figured that the big-name company offers would be fine, and they were.
I could try to complete more offers and get a free 360 game for every two offers that I complete, but I have ZERO desire to do any offers involving Hoodia/eBay sales tools/weight loss garbage/psychics/etc, for all the reasons that lukewarmwater mentioned. I figured that the big-name company offers would be fine, and they were.
#62
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Godfather
Well, three days and they still haven't gotten my first back or acknowledged it via fast return.
#63
Senior Member
Joined: May 2003
Posts: 810
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Florida
Originally Posted by Michael Corvin
Well, three days and they still haven't gotten my first back or acknowledged it via fast return. 
#64
Senior Member
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 556
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I can't see a service like this being viable to me when I can just drive down the block and pick up a couple games from Blockbuster in 10 minutes. Waiting 3+ days for them to get a return is a bit much.
#65
Eh, game rentals at Hollywood Video are like 7.99 for 5 days. So if i can get Gamefly for around 10$ for 2 games out at a time then keeping those two games in the month is a better deal for me. If i get another one or 2 in a month it's gravy. I also dig the decent prices on buying used games.
#66
DVD Talk Legend
Joined: Apr 1999
Posts: 13,728
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
From: You might catch me in Atlanta, looking like a boss
two games were mailed on Thursday - was hoping to get them Saturday as PA is only two states away. No dice. Game #1 came Monday - not too bad. Game #2 hasn't shown up yet
#67
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Joined: Jun 1999
Posts: 5,589
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Export, PA
Generally my games take 1 day to get back but take 3 days for the newly shipped games to get to me. The Pittsburgh shipping center wasn't really helping me there for a bit but it seems better now. I'm less than an hour from their shipping center but it seemed to take me as long to get games as my buddy 3 states away.
#68
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Godfather
Originally Posted by xmiyux
Eh, game rentals at Hollywood Video are like 7.99 for 5 days. So if i can get Gamefly for around 10$ for 2 games out at a time then keeping those two games in the month is a better deal for me. If i get another one or 2 in a month it's gravy. I also dig the decent prices on buying used games.
#69
Originally Posted by Michael Corvin
Exactly. That's why I don't rent games. Things come up and I may not get the time I want to spend on a game. At least with Gamefly you can keep them as long as you want, alleviating that problem.
#70
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Godfather
Originally Posted by 1998Nole
I am beginning to think they really do not use fast return.
Tomorrow will be four days since I shipped my second one. So my next one is shipping. One week in and fast return is a joke.I bet they hold people back on the free trials. Didn't Netflix get in trouble for doing that?
#72
Originally Posted by Michael Corvin
I bet they hold people back on the free trials. Didn't Netflix get in trouble for doing that?
#73
Has anyone purchased a used game from Gamefly? Was the manual and case in good condition?
I'm thinking of doing a "keep it" on DiRT (360) and the disc looks fine, but wanted to make sure the case/manual would arrive well taken care of. I assume they are, since they don't send them out, so maybe this is a dumb question...
I'm thinking of doing a "keep it" on DiRT (360) and the disc looks fine, but wanted to make sure the case/manual would arrive well taken care of. I assume they are, since they don't send them out, so maybe this is a dumb question...
#74
Senior Member
Joined: Apr 2007
Posts: 585
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Indianapolis
Does gamefly have NCAA 2008 in stock yet? I have an account with gameznflix and it's still on order. So just out of curiosity I started looking around and pretty much every game that came out in July is on Order. Hell Overlord which came out on the 26th is still on order. when I send games back they normally come off my listing in a day or 2. When they ship a game i get it within a couple of days. The problem is it takes forever for them to get new games in.
When Gears came out though, i had it by the following Monday.
When Gears came out though, i had it by the following Monday.
#75
Originally Posted by House
Does gamefly have NCAA 2008 in stock yet? I have an account with gameznflix and it's still on order. So just out of curiosity I started looking around and pretty much every game that came out in July is on Order. Hell Overlord which came out on the 26th is still on order. when I send games back they normally come off my listing in a day or 2. When they ship a game i get it within a couple of days. The problem is it takes forever for them to get new games in.
When Gears came out though, i had it by the following Monday.
When Gears came out though, i had it by the following Monday.



