Stargate SG-1 S10/ Atlantis S3 General discussion thread
#77
Senior Member
Joined: Feb 2002
Posts: 294
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Montréal, Qc
Originally Posted by mikehunt
I think Meridith's sister was his real life sister
#80
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Season finale for SG: Atlantis next week? Huh?
Epsidodes 0301 - 0308 have aired, and Episode 0311 aired tonight. What did I miss with news of this season?
Epsidodes 0301 - 0308 have aired, and Episode 0311 aired tonight. What did I miss with news of this season?
Last edited by SunMonkey; 09-15-06 at 10:06 PM.
#82
Suspended
Joined: Jun 1999
Posts: 661
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by strife
it's mid-season finale. Scifi has done this the last two years and it confuses people.
that is calling midseason finale season finale
that is calling midseason finale season finale
Yes, so the bastiches can sell season 2.5 and other half season sets.....
#84
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
It does seem like the stakes are getting higher. That guy along with the other ship Captain from the season 9 finale. Looks like we'll be seeing a new recurring character.
Could really care less about the Lucian Alliance B plot though. =/ "Now we're at war." K...
Could really care less about the Lucian Alliance B plot though. =/ "Now we're at war." K...
#86
DVD Talk Special Edition
Joined: Jul 2003
Posts: 1,038
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Falls Church, VA
I guess it goes to speak just how boring the "season finales" were that a day later and just one five word post about both shows. Really though, omg, a dragon! And wow, Atlantis has weapons that cause replicators to break apart. Man, they sure are in trouble. I thought both cliffhangers were utterly boring.
#87
DVD Talk Limited Edition
I didn't mind the Atlantis finale - I actually think it would have been better if the storyline started earlier. Everything just happened way too quickly for my taste. SG1 on the other hand, yea I'm not loving the dragon thing. You knew it was coming but still.
#89
DVD Talk Legend
Well, SkyOne has been playing the remaining SG1 episodes for S10 and the series finale was yesterday.
[Series Finale Spoilers!]
I'm sad to see it go.
[Series Finale Spoilers!]
Spoiler:
I'm sad to see it go.
#90
Senior Member
Joined: Mar 2004
Posts: 304
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I watched all of the 2nd half of Atlantis and SG-1. You guys will be VERY disappointed in Atlantis, out of the 10 episodes there were only 3 good ones, and the bad ones were boring as hell. On the other hand, SG-1 was excellent with maybe 8 good episodes with a excellent series finally.
#92
Member
New details on 'Tthe first direct-to-DVD Stargate SG-1 The Ark of Truth'
http://www.gateworld.net/news/2007/0...of_truth.shtml
and the second upcoming direct-to-DVD movie Stargate: Continuum
http://www.gateworld.net/news/2007/0...e_arctic.shtml
http://www.gateworld.net/news/2007/0...of_truth.shtml
and the second upcoming direct-to-DVD movie Stargate: Continuum
http://www.gateworld.net/news/2007/0...e_arctic.shtml
#93
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Any spoilers in those links? I know what I read before (kinda wish I hadn't) aludes to the fact something doesn't happen throughout the remainder of S10 in SG-1.
Still another month until they are back on over here.
Not sure why they waited so long to bring them back - last year it was Jan/Feb if I remember correctly.
Well, hopefully S4 of SG-A will be better. I was hoping this year would be better, but it looks like S2 was the best so far. So many of the characters are garbage. At least Shep and McKay are good. Pretty much everybody else is worthless and very underwritten. I think if they ditched Taila it would see a marked improvement.
Still another month until they are back on over here.

Not sure why they waited so long to bring them back - last year it was Jan/Feb if I remember correctly.
Well, hopefully S4 of SG-A will be better. I was hoping this year would be better, but it looks like S2 was the best so far. So many of the characters are garbage. At least Shep and McKay are good. Pretty much everybody else is worthless and very underwritten. I think if they ditched Taila it would see a marked improvement.
#95
DVD Talk Legend
Originally Posted by xx2000xx
I watched all of the 2nd half of Atlantis and SG-1. You guys will be VERY disappointed in Atlantis, out of the 10 episodes there were only 3 good ones, and the bad ones were boring as hell. On the other hand, SG-1 was excellent with maybe 8 good episodes with a excellent series finally.
I imagine Richard Dean Anderson will be back for the movies and they'll focus on the original cast more? I wonder if Ben & Claudia will still have roles to play in the SG-verse or if they're done for good. I'll enjoy seeing Tapping as a regular on Atlantis, tho I can imagine McKay's drooling will get tedious quick.
#96
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Legend
Good news to hear Tapping will jump shows and while I really enjoy the occasional McKay/Carter interactions I agree they will have to tweak that relationship to keep it tolerable for a whole season. It might be a good opportunity to dump Taila, but I 've vaugely recall rumors that:
However, it is definetly not a rumor that: (major spoiler)
Besides Tapping, another addition to Atlantis will be:
Oh, and I completely agree with you about the reboot, adamblast. Having a lead actor who actually appears in most episodes is a good thing, and when you have an action show it's also good when he can actually do action stuff. I love RDA, and for his age he did a hell of a job for 6-7 years, but they obviously needed a new lead. The Goa'uld were getting tired too.
Spoiler:
However, it is definetly not a rumor that: (major spoiler)
Spoiler:
Besides Tapping, another addition to Atlantis will be:
Spoiler:
Oh, and I completely agree with you about the reboot, adamblast. Having a lead actor who actually appears in most episodes is a good thing, and when you have an action show it's also good when he can actually do action stuff. I love RDA, and for his age he did a hell of a job for 6-7 years, but they obviously needed a new lead. The Goa'uld were getting tired too.
Last edited by wmansir; 03-29-07 at 10:39 PM.
#97
DVD Talk Legend
I see they're keeping with their tradition of hiring folks from popular cancelled sci-fi shows. I hadn't heard about that "other" Atlantis addition.
Your second spoiler really surprises me.
Spoiler:
Your second spoiler really surprises me.
#98
Suspended pending providing a working email address
Joined: Jun 2003
Posts: 461
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I rip on Atlantis, but actually I like watching it.
I gotta tell you, Stargate is the "Star Trek" of the 21st Century. The concept is so fricking great, and Sci-Fi excutes it "well enough" to make it work.
I love everything to do with Stargate, it really is the modern face of sci-fi. Devlin and Emmerich came up with such a f'ing great concept, they deserve most of the kudos, and Wright and Cooper get credit for not screwing it up.
I gotta tell you, Stargate is the "Star Trek" of the 21st Century. The concept is so fricking great, and Sci-Fi excutes it "well enough" to make it work.
I love everything to do with Stargate, it really is the modern face of sci-fi. Devlin and Emmerich came up with such a f'ing great concept, they deserve most of the kudos, and Wright and Cooper get credit for not screwing it up.
#99
DVD Talk Special Edition
So what did you guys think of the mid-season premieres? I thought both were a little disapointing but, that's probably just because there was such a big gap in the airing of the two-parters. I'm sure that I will like both episodes a lot better when I rewatch them on dvd in the future.



