Kill Bill: Volume 2 thoughts
#526
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Joined: Aug 1999
Posts: 3,876
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Des Moines, WA
Originally posted by jiggawhat
This was one of the most boring movies I have ever seen. Except for the one or two fighting scenes the movie was frought with way to much dialogue.
This was one of the most boring movies I have ever seen. Except for the one or two fighting scenes the movie was frought with way to much dialogue.
Did you like any of Tarantino's other films? They are all very dialogue oriented.
#527
DVD Talk Hero
Joined: Aug 1999
Posts: 34,244
Received 2,045 Likes
on
1,391 Posts
From: Not necessarily Formerly known as Solid Snake
OK, time for a strange twist of fate . . . so I sat down and re-watched the first half before viewing the second half last night . . . I actually enjoyed the first half this time (though I still argue that the blood sprays are moronic and majorly detract from the film) . . . so then I was actually looking forward to the "conclusion" . . . *yawn!*
I am not knocking the second half for being a dialogue and story driven movie -- I love dialogue and story driven movies -- but the fact is that there was very little actual story and the dialogue was no where near the caliber that QT usually puts together. About the only part that really held me riveted was the training with Pai Mei. But even the payoff there was ludicrous!
Yes, I have ill feelings toward the whole "let's make two!" concept, but after seeing the second half I can possibly understand it a little more. The second half completely falls apart and loses any semblence of continuity (style-wise) from the first. It just seems to run out of steam and energy.
I am not knocking the second half for being a dialogue and story driven movie -- I love dialogue and story driven movies -- but the fact is that there was very little actual story and the dialogue was no where near the caliber that QT usually puts together. About the only part that really held me riveted was the training with Pai Mei. But even the payoff there was ludicrous!
Yes, I have ill feelings toward the whole "let's make two!" concept, but after seeing the second half I can possibly understand it a little more. The second half completely falls apart and loses any semblence of continuity (style-wise) from the first. It just seems to run out of steam and energy.
#528
Retired
Originally posted by jiggawhat
This was one of the most boring movies I have ever seen. Except for the one or two fighting scenes the movie was frought with way to much dialogue.
This was one of the most boring movies I have ever seen. Except for the one or two fighting scenes the movie was frought with way to much dialogue.
#529
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Joined: Apr 2001
Posts: 2,923
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: In the Universe.
Originally posted by C-Mart
That is the whole point. Tarantino movies are always jam packed with dialogue. In Kill Bill 1 we get a lot of action, and not much back story, but in this one we get most of the back story and not as much of the action. It makes the ending of the film much more relevant. The fact that we learn so much more about the people in this film vs. the first one shows why Elle, Bud and Bill were last on the list. They were the most important to The Bride. O-Ren and Vernita were the low level pawns of Bill, even though O-Ren became very powerful in her own right.
Did you like any of Tarantino's other films? They are all very dialogue oriented.
That is the whole point. Tarantino movies are always jam packed with dialogue. In Kill Bill 1 we get a lot of action, and not much back story, but in this one we get most of the back story and not as much of the action. It makes the ending of the film much more relevant. The fact that we learn so much more about the people in this film vs. the first one shows why Elle, Bud and Bill were last on the list. They were the most important to The Bride. O-Ren and Vernita were the low level pawns of Bill, even though O-Ren became very powerful in her own right.
Did you like any of Tarantino's other films? They are all very dialogue oriented.
I did like the Kill Bill, but most of his movies are blahh. I thought with that he might have become a little more interesting. I think he is really overrated. For me, movies can be made with more action oriented scenes (not talking about fighting) then dialogue filled.
#530
Moderator
Originally posted by jiggawhat
For me, movies can be made with more action oriented scenes (not talking about fighting) then dialogue filled.
For me, movies can be made with more action oriented scenes (not talking about fighting) then dialogue filled.
#533
Needs to contact an admin about multiple accounts
Joined: May 2003
Posts: 1,411
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
just had a kill bill marathon last night. the delted scene with mike jai white kicked SO MUCH FRIGGIN ASS. should have been in the final cut.
vol 1 is one of my favorite films of all time, but vol 2 is a bit of a let down. id give it a b+ i guess. still great, but very slow. elle and budds scenes were great, pei mei too, but everything else was just people talking....really...slowly... i know this was tarintino doing westerns, but it didn't excite me as much as the fast paced stuff of vol 1. and i dont think vol 2's dialouge was half as good as pulp, or jackie or reservor or true romance. superman thing put me to sleep
vol 1 is one of my favorite films of all time, but vol 2 is a bit of a let down. id give it a b+ i guess. still great, but very slow. elle and budds scenes were great, pei mei too, but everything else was just people talking....really...slowly... i know this was tarintino doing westerns, but it didn't excite me as much as the fast paced stuff of vol 1. and i dont think vol 2's dialouge was half as good as pulp, or jackie or reservor or true romance. superman thing put me to sleep
#534
Retired
Re: Re: Kill Bill: Volume 2 thoughts (part 2)
Originally posted by majorjoe23
So what's the deal with Elle Driver? Are we to assume she dies?
So what's the deal with Elle Driver? Are we to assume she dies?
#535
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
The purpose of the film was for (bleep) to kill each of the squad one by one, and everyone did meet their (fairly) obvious death at her hands. But Elle...
Spoiler:
Last edited by TheMadMonk; 08-11-04 at 03:20 PM.
#536
DVD Talk Godfather
Originally posted by C-Mart
That is the whole point. Tarantino movies are always jam packed with dialogue. In Kill Bill 1 we get a lot of action, and not much back story, but in this one we get most of the back story and not as much of the action. It makes the ending of the film much more relevant. The fact that we learn so much more about the people in this film vs. the first one shows why Elle, Bud and Bill were last on the list. They were the most important to The Bride. O-Ren and Vernita were the low level pawns of Bill, even though O-Ren became very powerful in her own right.
That is the whole point. Tarantino movies are always jam packed with dialogue. In Kill Bill 1 we get a lot of action, and not much back story, but in this one we get most of the back story and not as much of the action. It makes the ending of the film much more relevant. The fact that we learn so much more about the people in this film vs. the first one shows why Elle, Bud and Bill were last on the list. They were the most important to The Bride. O-Ren and Vernita were the low level pawns of Bill, even though O-Ren became very powerful in her own right.
#537
DVD Talk Legend
Joined: Apr 2002
Posts: 18,531
Received 444 Likes
on
313 Posts
From: Formerly known as Groucho AND Bandoman/Death Moans, Iowa
Originally posted by TheMadMonk
I don't consider
I don't consider
Spoiler:
#540
DVD Talk Legend
Originally posted by MSD
I have a quick question,
I have a quick question,
Spoiler:
Spoiler:
Originally posted by majorjoe23
Spoiler:
Spoiler:
Originally posted by TheMadMonk
I don't consider
I don't consider
Spoiler:
Spoiler:
#541
Banned
Originally posted by C-Mart
That is the whole point. Tarantino movies are always jam packed with dialogue.
That is the whole point. Tarantino movies are always jam packed with dialogue.
#542
Banned
Originally posted by fumanstan
I don't know, we learned an awful lot about O-Ren
I don't know, we learned an awful lot about O-Ren
#543
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Joined: Apr 2001
Posts: 2,923
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: In the Universe.
I wished they showed more stuff with Pai Mei and Beatrix. They should have gone more in depth with her training. I think that would have made this movie a lot better. For me. the more I think about this movie the worse it gets.
#544
Senior Member
Joined: Oct 2002
Posts: 338
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Pina Coladaburg
I always thought the scene where they finally reveal The Bride's name clearly.. was weird. (When they cut to Uma as a little girl in school). Aside from just proving that yes, that was her name, was there any significance or homage's going on there? To me, it was out of place and strange..
#545
Moderator
I thought that the the scene with fully-grown Beatrix in school was an homage to Annie Hall myself.
BTW, Ebert and Roeper had their "Best of 2004 So Far" show a few weeks ago. They both named Kill Bill Vol 2 as their #1 choice!
Also, I don't think the spoiler tags are necessary guys. We're on thread 2 of a multi-page conversation here.
BTW, Ebert and Roeper had their "Best of 2004 So Far" show a few weeks ago. They both named Kill Bill Vol 2 as their #1 choice!
Also, I don't think the spoiler tags are necessary guys. We're on thread 2 of a multi-page conversation here.
#546
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
I still think the "bleeping" of her name was the most pointless, un-necessary part of the movies. It really added nothing at all to the story or characters, imho.
I want to see Pai Mei get his own movie!
I want to see Pai Mei get his own movie!
#547
Moderator
Originally posted by TheMadMonk
I want to see Pai Mei get his own movie!
I want to see Pai Mei get his own movie!
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0076168/
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0079892/
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0080905/
#548
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Joined: Jan 2001
Posts: 3,583
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Virginia Beach, VA USA
Pai Mei is in a ton of movies.
You didn't need an in depth story on Budd's past because you learned everything you needed to know about him during his scenes in the strip club and with Bill. You learn as much as, if not more about Budd than any one else. He's deadly, probably just as deadly as Bill. He's highly remorseful about his past. He had a falling out, probably a violent one, with his brother in the last few years. Maybe over the killing of Beatrix. Maybe over something else. Of everyone, he's the only one that got the best of Beatrix. You get the feeling that she may have been scared of him because of the way she attacked him. Everyone else got called out, or paused in the middle of battle to talk. But she tried to take Budd out a fast as possible, and failed. He's sadistic, deciding to bury her alive instead of killing her outright.
Blah blah blah, yadda yadda yadda. You get the point. We got to find out a hell of a lot about Budd.
D
You didn't need an in depth story on Budd's past because you learned everything you needed to know about him during his scenes in the strip club and with Bill. You learn as much as, if not more about Budd than any one else. He's deadly, probably just as deadly as Bill. He's highly remorseful about his past. He had a falling out, probably a violent one, with his brother in the last few years. Maybe over the killing of Beatrix. Maybe over something else. Of everyone, he's the only one that got the best of Beatrix. You get the feeling that she may have been scared of him because of the way she attacked him. Everyone else got called out, or paused in the middle of battle to talk. But she tried to take Budd out a fast as possible, and failed. He's sadistic, deciding to bury her alive instead of killing her outright.
Blah blah blah, yadda yadda yadda. You get the point. We got to find out a hell of a lot about Budd.
D
#550
DVD Talk Hero
Joined: Aug 1999
Posts: 34,244
Received 2,045 Likes
on
1,391 Posts
From: Not necessarily Formerly known as Solid Snake
I get a kick out of everybody pointing to the second half saying that it reveals so much of the story . . . it actually does very little story telling (less than the first half I think). It fleshes out the final assassinations, and tosses a little back story in, but actually opens up many more questions than it answers.
To paraphrase QT in the interview on the disc "It's a f#$@ing revenge story! That IS the story!" Nonetheless, after 4+ hours, the story was never told. Sure, we know that "The Bride"/Beatrix Kiddo/Black Mamba/*BLEEP* was turned on by her former cohorts because SHE abandoned them. And then she goes on a revenge killing spree. However very little of the story is told (and to his credit QT seemingly admits that there really is NO story) . . . the real story is what exactly is this band of Anti-Charlie's Angels and what kept them together and took them apart. And don't start throwing me the easy answers, because they don't actually tell the story.
The only place in either half that actually tells a story is O-Ren's chapter, which was over inflated and too long. Pare that down and give it to me several times (once for each character) and THAT will tell me a story. Now we are opening up the cross-media world and encouraging comic books and novels and animes . . . the list goes on.
To paraphrase QT in the interview on the disc "It's a f#$@ing revenge story! That IS the story!" Nonetheless, after 4+ hours, the story was never told. Sure, we know that "The Bride"/Beatrix Kiddo/Black Mamba/*BLEEP* was turned on by her former cohorts because SHE abandoned them. And then she goes on a revenge killing spree. However very little of the story is told (and to his credit QT seemingly admits that there really is NO story) . . . the real story is what exactly is this band of Anti-Charlie's Angels and what kept them together and took them apart. And don't start throwing me the easy answers, because they don't actually tell the story.
The only place in either half that actually tells a story is O-Ren's chapter, which was over inflated and too long. Pare that down and give it to me several times (once for each character) and THAT will tell me a story. Now we are opening up the cross-media world and encouraging comic books and novels and animes . . . the list goes on.



