HD-DVD vs. Blu-Ray vs. everything else free-for-all: Round two
#451
DVD Talk Legend
Bundelling 5 movies?!
There's no way that'll happen without it being reflected in the price.
I can see 1 movie... and a slight chance of being 2... but 5 is out of the question.
There's no way that'll happen without it being reflected in the price.
I can see 1 movie... and a slight chance of being 2... but 5 is out of the question.
#452
DVD Talk God
Originally Posted by Vipper II
Can you HONESTLY see Best Buy "and the like" bundling 5 movies, which they currently price at $24.99+? And if this dual layer thing ever comes to fruition, I'm sure the price will go up even more.
#453
Banned by request
PS3 will not be marketed to gamers for its BD movie capabilities. If there is a bundled movie, it will probably be something really awful like Hitch. It will definitely be a Sony, title, though.
How about this? If the PS3 comes bundled from the factory with 5 movies, I will leave DVDTalk forever. If it comes bundled from the factory with less than 5 movies, Blitz agrees to leave DVDTalk forever.
How about this? If the PS3 comes bundled from the factory with 5 movies, I will leave DVDTalk forever. If it comes bundled from the factory with less than 5 movies, Blitz agrees to leave DVDTalk forever.
#454
Premium Member
Joined: Jan 2000
Posts: 25,157
Received 1,215 Likes
on
784 Posts
From: Grazing in a field somewhere...
Originally Posted by Suprmallet
PS3 will not be marketed to gamers for its BD movie capabilities. If there is a bundled movie, it will probably be something really awful like Hitch. It will definitely be a Sony, title, though.
How about this? If the PS3 comes bundled from the factory with 5 movies, I will leave DVDTalk forever. If it comes bundled from the factory with less than 5 movies, Blitz agrees to leave DVDTalk forever.
How about this? If the PS3 comes bundled from the factory with 5 movies, I will leave DVDTalk forever. If it comes bundled from the factory with less than 5 movies, Blitz agrees to leave DVDTalk forever.
But still, I agree with you and you'd probably even be safe with 1.
#455
Banned
Joined: Feb 2001
Posts: 15,957
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: NYC
Originally Posted by Suprmallet
How about this? If the PS3 comes bundled from the factory with 5 movies, I will leave DVDTalk forever. If it comes bundled from the factory with less than 5 movies, Blitz agrees to leave DVDTalk forever.
Good thing i wasn't drinking when i read this.
This is almost as good as the bet that I used to have with that one guy. What was his name? the banned one? I never did get his ass.
#456
Banned by request
Hmm, don't think I knew about that one.
Edit: So, wait, is Blitz saying we will see the PS3 bundled with 5 movies from retailers without a price increase?
Edit: So, wait, is Blitz saying we will see the PS3 bundled with 5 movies from retailers without a price increase?
Last edited by Supermallet; 08-27-06 at 01:43 AM.
#457
DVD Talk Legend
Originally Posted by Suprmallet
Hmm, don't think I knew about that one.
Edit: So, wait, is Blitz saying we will see the PS3 bundled with 5 movies from retailers without a price increase?
Edit: So, wait, is Blitz saying we will see the PS3 bundled with 5 movies from retailers without a price increase?
As far as them giving away free movies, Sony might give a single free movie with the PS3 to try and get the format out there, but that is about all you can expect.
#458
Banned by request
I know what a bundle is, what I'm trying to discern is if Blitz thinks retailers will bundle in extra movies for free or not.
A retailer could bundle in a PS3 with every BD on the market, but I promise you they will make you pay for it.
A retailer could bundle in a PS3 with every BD on the market, but I promise you they will make you pay for it.
#459
Premium Member
Joined: Jan 2000
Posts: 25,157
Received 1,215 Likes
on
784 Posts
From: Grazing in a field somewhere...
Originally Posted by Suprmallet
I know what a bundle is, what I'm trying to discern is if Blitz thinks retailers will bundle in extra movies for free or not.
A retailer could bundle in a PS3 with every BD on the market, but I promise you they will make you pay for it.
A retailer could bundle in a PS3 with every BD on the market, but I promise you they will make you pay for it.
#461
Banned
Joined: Feb 2002
Posts: 673
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
You actually thought i meant bundled FREE? You guys are reaching harder then i could ever imagine. I think its safe to say I meant forced bundles by STORES, which i specified. So to get a PS3 at launch, you need to get the system, extra controller, 2 games and 5 BD Movies or you dont get one, type of bundle, all for a huge amount of funds.
Im almost sure movies will be in bundle deals at stores to move more flicks with the system.
Im almost sure movies will be in bundle deals at stores to move more flicks with the system.
#463
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
Joined: Mar 2003
Posts: 4,389
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by RoboDad
But the fact that he is making that decision also brings into question how much disposable income he'll have left after the purchase of the console and peripherals. Once his shiny new PS3 is 'in da house', will he be more inclined to spend what cash he has left on games or BD movies?
This leads me to believe that the attachment rate for BD on the PS3 will be extraordinarily low. PS3 owners similar to 'the cousin' may Netflix a few titles here and there, but that won't turn the PS3 into the savior of the format.
This leads me to believe that the attachment rate for BD on the PS3 will be extraordinarily low. PS3 owners similar to 'the cousin' may Netflix a few titles here and there, but that won't turn the PS3 into the savior of the format.
My cousin is only 15, and I'm pretty sure he's going for the car. I made many of the points you guys did.
#464
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
Joined: Mar 2003
Posts: 4,389
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by kvrdave
Depends on demand and scarcity of the PS3. There were bundles over $1,000 that I saw with the 360. I expect that stores will bundle as much as they can so long as they sell. Having said that, I would expect any bundles to be made up of gamer stuff rather than movie stuff.
#465
DVD Talk Legend
Originally Posted by Blitz6Speed
You actually thought i meant bundled FREE? You guys are reaching harder then i could ever imagine. I think its safe to say I meant forced bundles by STORES, which i specified. So to get a PS3 at launch, you need to get the system, extra controller, 2 games and 5 BD Movies or you dont get one, type of bundle, all for a huge amount of funds.
Im almost sure movies will be in bundle deals at stores to move more flicks with the system.
Im almost sure movies will be in bundle deals at stores to move more flicks with the system.
The PS3 is already pricey, when you throw in 5 movies (and at least 1 game) - most consumers will just walk away when they see the price.
This all or nothing approach can backfire in a big way.
#466
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
Joined: May 2004
Posts: 4,582
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Dallas, TX
Originally Posted by lizard
For all the flak he is taking, Jay G.'s numbers strike me as very conservative. Even if not all PS3 owners with HDTVs hook them up to the HDTV and even if those that do, buy fewer movie discs than HD DVD owners (can we agree to accept that as a given?), the sheer number of PS3s out that ARE hooked up to HDTVs will make for a sizeable market for Blu-ray Discs.
IF MS has 10 million units sold by end of year, and 10% of those buy the addon drive, thats a million PROBABLE HD-DVD purchasers. Its almost guaranteed that they will buy the media.
Ive got 2 friends who have 360s and said that they are planning to purchase the addon drive to try out hd-dvd. Both said the PS3 is out of their price range and may purchase one when the price comes down.
#467
There's no incentive for retail stores to bundle BD movies with the PS3. They'll be focused on the gaming aspect of it. Any bundles will be made up of accessories and slightly-lower-demand games. They may bundle one movie to whet the appetite, but unless Sony hands down the commandment from on high, I find it highly unlikely.
The best chance would be Sony themselves stuffing a movie in the box like the aforementioned Hitch or Charlies Angels. There'd even be a nice little ad on the box indicating the inclusion of said movie.
The best chance any included movie has of being watched by the majority of gamers ready to get into the action is when the controllers are charging over the first 8 hours or so.
The best chance would be Sony themselves stuffing a movie in the box like the aforementioned Hitch or Charlies Angels. There'd even be a nice little ad on the box indicating the inclusion of said movie.
The best chance any included movie has of being watched by the majority of gamers ready to get into the action is when the controllers are charging over the first 8 hours or so.
#468
DVD Talk Legend
Didn't Sony already announce that they'd be including copies of The Fifth Element with their Blu-ray player? If they were to bundle something with the PS3, I'd expect it to be that.
#469
DVD Talk Legend
I think you will see multiple bundle options as happened with the Xbox360 and I definitely think they will try and force Blu-ray movies on people with at least some of the bundle options from stores that sell movies. The discs are not selling and this will be a way for stores to finally get rid of some of them by forcing them on desperate PS3 buyers. Its looking like PS3s will be very scarce this Christmas so people wanting one badly will probably have to except a bundle from many stores.
#470
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Originally Posted by pinata242
There's no incentive for retail stores to bundle BD movies with the PS3. They'll be focused on the gaming aspect of it. Any bundles will be made up of accessories and slightly-lower-demand games.
Of course it'll be too expensive for most teenagers to purchase, but then again the average age of gaming is far beyond that now. It's a different world in computer gaming these days...
#471
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Has there been any official word from Microsoft about pricing and release date of the HD DVD add-on drive for the 360? $200 wouldn't seem to give them much if any profit.
#472
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Originally Posted by Josh Z
Didn't Sony already announce that they'd be including copies of The Fifth Element with their Blu-ray player? If they were to bundle something with the PS3, I'd expect it to be that.
Originally Posted by RoboDad
...Again, without a crystal ball, no one can say for sure, but my hunch is that the attachment rate for BD (at least from PS3 owners) will be less than 1/20th of what HD DVD continues to produce, as a percentage of market share...
Originally Posted by Zman
...If you REALLY think that someone is going to drop $900 bucks to buy a PS3, movies, games, and accessories, you're dead wrong. There will be a VERY VERY small minority that drops that kinda load on a VG system...
#473
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
Joined: May 2004
Posts: 4,582
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Dallas, TX
I dont see how they can FORCE movies on people and make them pay for it.
There might be bundles with it as an option, BUT again, many of the people buying PS3's will NOT be able to view the BD movies.
They will be frustrated when they cant watch it on their RCA 25in tv.
There might be bundles with it as an option, BUT again, many of the people buying PS3's will NOT be able to view the BD movies.
They will be frustrated when they cant watch it on their RCA 25in tv.
#474
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
Joined: Mar 2003
Posts: 4,389
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by Burnt Thru
How do you figure? There's just as much incentive for stores to bundle movies as games, assuming they price correctly. 5 BDs with a PS3? That would probably add just over $100 to the final price, which would still sit well inside the $1000 360 bundles of last year. It's pretty much certain there'll be different bundles to appeal to different prospective demographics, which makes this BD bundling very likely.
Of course it'll be too expensive for most teenagers to purchase, but then again the average age of gaming is far beyond that now. It's a different world in computer gaming these days...
Of course it'll be too expensive for most teenagers to purchase, but then again the average age of gaming is far beyond that now. It's a different world in computer gaming these days...
#475
DVD Talk Legend
Originally Posted by digitalfreaknyc
As someone who has admitted zero interest in either format
[since you] won't be buying them nor the game consoles in question, I just wonder what you're getting out of this.
What I'd like to know is, as a stanch HD-DVD supporter, and one who has already purchased your preferred format, what are you getting out of this? If anyone is here to just argue, argue, argue, it would seem to be people like you.
And if you seriously think that BD is a viable contender, I'd love to know why.
It seems like the only people who believe it any more are the die-hard BD fans and...well, Sony, I guess.



