Everwood on The WB
#301
Member
Joined: Aug 2000
Posts: 215
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Portland, OR
Originally posted by Jadzia
When you have 1 character bringing over strange food, and all the other characters (even Andy who is usually more open-minded about things) rolls his eyes and makes jokes to the other characters about how the food is crappy, it does leave an impression to the viewers that it is ok to think that vegetarians are odd and eat crappy food.
When you have 1 character bringing over strange food, and all the other characters (even Andy who is usually more open-minded about things) rolls his eyes and makes jokes to the other characters about how the food is crappy, it does leave an impression to the viewers that it is ok to think that vegetarians are odd and eat crappy food.
#302
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
We get the Fox Movie Channel up here in St. Louis on basic Charter. No censoring, what-so-ever. It's GREAT! And they show most of their movies in widescreen. Whoop! (Oh.. wait... I'm a Billiken. What the hell do we say? Stupid Billiken.)
#303
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Joined: Oct 1999
Posts: 8,527
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Portland, OR
Whoa...discussion going out of control. Didn't mean to start any wars over vegetarians. Speaking just for myself, I didn't think anything negative about vegetarians because of the show (never have). But I think I can see WHY you would be aware about the possible negative connotations of it. No one likes to see a character that they may relate to or identify with, having any kinds of negative thoughts associated with them. If this story revolved around Dr. Abbott, I'd protest and say that not all doctors are pompous windbags.
I only meant to say that I don't think the writers were trying to make fun of vegetarians at all. I think they were trying to portray Linda as this well-traveled person who lives an alternative lifestyle which includes "alternative" foods. She only happens to be vegetarian.
I only meant to say that I don't think the writers were trying to make fun of vegetarians at all. I think they were trying to portray Linda as this well-traveled person who lives an alternative lifestyle which includes "alternative" foods. She only happens to be vegetarian.
#304
Originally posted by das Monkey
The show isn't mocking vegetarians. The show is depicting how non-vegetarians mock vegetarians ... which they do. I think you're being overly sensitive on this. If these characters didn't respond this way (considering how they typically act), that would be odd to me. Perhaps Linda could have brought over better transitional food like you mentioned earlier, but she's established herself pretty well as not needing anyone else's approval and doing things her own way.
Anyway, forgot to mention the 'Once More with Feeling' songbook they were carrying around. Nice touch.
das
• Quoth Jadzia •<HR SIZE=1>Linda announced that the food was all vegetarian. And this is followed by scenes of the rest of the characters rolling their eyes and complaining about how bad the food is.
As a vegetarian, it is just frustrating to have your diet mocked on TV shows all the time (pretty much the same scene was featured on Six Feet Under with Lili Taylor's character.)<HR SIZE=1>
The show isn't mocking vegetarians. The show is depicting how non-vegetarians mock vegetarians ... which they do. I think you're being overly sensitive on this. If these characters didn't respond this way (considering how they typically act), that would be odd to me. Perhaps Linda could have brought over better transitional food like you mentioned earlier, but she's established herself pretty well as not needing anyone else's approval and doing things her own way.
Anyway, forgot to mention the 'Once More with Feeling' songbook they were carrying around. Nice touch.

das
#305
• Quoth calhoun07 •<HR SIZE=1>If this subject is going to keep coming up, I'd like to add that I don't understand why vegetarians in general think their diet should be forced upon other people. Would a vegitarian think it was OK and just accept it if I brought over meat based dishes to their house? Would they not respond negatively as well? In fact, it is probably "politically correct" for people to just grin and bear it with vegitarians, but if the tables were turned, I'd be called a murderer or something of that nature, and the vegitarian would not touch my food at all. And don't forget that more animals die annually in combine accidents harvesting the food for vegitarians and those animals just go to waste, all in the name of vegitarianism. So, yeah, I think I have a justifiable reason to be offended by vegitarian dishes. <HR SIZE=1>
Um ... OK. In the context of the show, though, she made her intentions very clear. He invited her to dinner, and she said no, because she had a very strict alternative diet. He pressed further saying she could bring whatever food she wanted. He knew the score; she wasn't forcing anything on him.
das
#306
Originally posted by das Monkey
Have you been watching the show? Ephram ... sensitive to vegetarians?
Have you been watching the show? Ephram ... sensitive to vegetarians?
Originally posted by rayw69
So its not ok for people to think that vegetarians are odd and eat crappy food? Regardless of whether it is true or not, I'd like to think people have the right to their opinions.
So its not ok for people to think that vegetarians are odd and eat crappy food? Regardless of whether it is true or not, I'd like to think people have the right to their opinions.
I realize we are in in the minority, and I wouldn't expect most shows to be any different--- but I do admire Everwood and think it is written very well. I guess I just expect a more thoughtful approach from them, than say from a lame sitcom.
Surely there has to be a *few* vegetarian TV writers in Hollywood.

Sorry my offhand comment/observation caused such a stir, but I am happy that an Everwood thread finally made 2 pages.
Last edited by Jadzia; 10-15-03 at 04:32 PM.
#307
Originally posted by das Monkey
Um ... OK. In the context of the show, though, she made her intentions very clear. He invited her to dinner, and she said no, because she had a very strict alternative diet. He pressed further saying she could bring whatever food she wanted. He knew the score; she wasn't forcing anything on him.
das
• Quoth calhoun07 •<HR SIZE=1>If this subject is going to keep coming up, I'd like to add that I don't understand why vegetarians in general think their diet should be forced upon other people. Would a vegitarian think it was OK and just accept it if I brought over meat based dishes to their house? Would they not respond negatively as well? In fact, it is probably "politically correct" for people to just grin and bear it with vegitarians, but if the tables were turned, I'd be called a murderer or something of that nature, and the vegitarian would not touch my food at all. And don't forget that more animals die annually in combine accidents harvesting the food for vegitarians and those animals just go to waste, all in the name of vegitarianism. So, yeah, I think I have a justifiable reason to be offended by vegitarian dishes. <HR SIZE=1>
Um ... OK. In the context of the show, though, she made her intentions very clear. He invited her to dinner, and she said no, because she had a very strict alternative diet. He pressed further saying she could bring whatever food she wanted. He knew the score; she wasn't forcing anything on him.
das
#308
• Quoth calhoun07 •<HR SIZE=1>She wasn't? She would not eat dinner with anybody else unless they ate her diet. I see that as rather demanding and rude. It's like you order pizza for you and your roommate who's vegitarian, and you order a meat lover's pizza. That would be rude to my roommate who is a vegitarian. Compromise at the least and have both dishes that each other can like, and order the pizza with half and half. Or two pizzas. If I was asked by a vegitarian to come over for dinner and refused unless they would only eat my meat dishes, I would be treated as inconsiderate and rude, so why the double standard? <HR SIZE=1>
Double standard? May want to look up what that means. She didn't force them to eat her food. She never said that "she wouldn't eat dinner with anybody else unless they ate her diet." You made that up. She eats with the Abbots all the time, and they eat meat. What, so she's supposed to have Andy cook two meals just for her? That's rude. She politely declined, knowing it would be an inconvenience, and he insisted, offering to eat whatever she wanted in an attempt to learn about the foods she liked. That's her fault? Since this has upset you so, what should she have done differently? How could she have avoided this great offense? The only options I can come up with are:
1) Decline the invitation (she tried)
2) Cook food for everyone, multiple different dishes as a cultural experience (she did)
3) Cook food for herself and separate meaty food (which she wouldn't know how to cook) for others, making everyone feel uncomfortable
4) Cook food for herself and expect Andy to cook food for everyone else, making everyone feel uncomfortable
5) Expect Andy to cook two meals
I don't disagree that some vegetarians can be annoyingly holy about their life choice and derail the decisions of a group in selfish ways, but that's hardly what happened here. Honestly, what other option is there that would spare everyone this great injustice?
das
#312
DVD Talk Legend
Originally posted by Jadzia
Actually the food that Linda brought over reminds me of the food served at a nearby macrobiotic restaurant. It's possible that Linda is macrobiotic. I like eating at that restaurant, but it's the kind of place that I would never take a non-vegetarian to. The food is definitely more for die-hards and would not be the type of food that would convince a meat-eater that vegetarian food is not that different. I think if you're bringing vegetarian food to non-vegetarians you should make sure it is more accessible (stir-fries, curries, etc. that don't need meat or rely heavily on meat analogues.)
Actually the food that Linda brought over reminds me of the food served at a nearby macrobiotic restaurant. It's possible that Linda is macrobiotic. I like eating at that restaurant, but it's the kind of place that I would never take a non-vegetarian to. The food is definitely more for die-hards and would not be the type of food that would convince a meat-eater that vegetarian food is not that different. I think if you're bringing vegetarian food to non-vegetarians you should make sure it is more accessible (stir-fries, curries, etc. that don't need meat or rely heavily on meat analogues.)
#313
• Quoth rayw69 •<HR SIZE=1>Not that I love the arguing, but anything that keeps the Everwood thread bumped and gets people interested in the show isin my book. <HR SIZE=1>
It's not arguing ... it's a "discussion."

das
#314
• Quoth DRG •<HR SIZE=1>I thought this was silly as well. It's not so much that she likes the exotic dishes, or that she wanted them to try them, but that she just sort of sprung the extremes on them. It's such a culture clash of sorts, and I think a character with the intelligence of Linda would have been sensible enough to bring "training wheels" foods as a test for a group of vegetarian virgins before going full-out with the millet.<HR SIZE=1>
At least with Harold, we've found that Linda kind of enjoys springing the extremes on people. Recall her first day at the office. She's very comfortable with her world and doesn't exactly tread lightly around others. It may not be how you or I would act, but it's not really out of character.
das
#315
Member
Joined: Aug 2000
Posts: 215
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Portland, OR
Originally posted by DRG
I thought this was silly as well. It's not so much that she likes the exotic dishes, or that she wanted them to try them, but that she just sort of sprung the extremes on them. It's such a culture clash of sorts, and I think a character with the intelligence of Linda would have been sensible enough to bring "training wheels" foods as a test for a group of vegetarian virgins before going full-out with the millet.
I thought this was silly as well. It's not so much that she likes the exotic dishes, or that she wanted them to try them, but that she just sort of sprung the extremes on them. It's such a culture clash of sorts, and I think a character with the intelligence of Linda would have been sensible enough to bring "training wheels" foods as a test for a group of vegetarian virgins before going full-out with the millet.
#317
Moderator
Everwood (10/20): The best written drama that no one is watching...
... right das?
Tonight's episode had more Dr Abbot laugh-out-loud moments than I've even seen before. The game of charades was funny...
And poor Amy, things just aren't going right for her... but I like the bond that her and her brother are having.
Oh, and one more thing... props go out to Ephram for finally taking a chance on Madison... cue the Bon Jovi song... 'Shot doooowwwwwn... in a blaze of glooory!'
Final thought... how many weeks until Andy and Harold's sister - ahem - get in on?
Tonight's episode had more Dr Abbot laugh-out-loud moments than I've even seen before. The game of charades was funny...
"Andrew Brown? He's not a celebrity."
"Sure he was. He was on the cover of Time magazine."
"Didn't you read about he saved the life of those twins...?"
"Get out!" He yells in perfect Donatella Versace mode...
"Sure he was. He was on the cover of Time magazine."
"Didn't you read about he saved the life of those twins...?"
"Get out!" He yells in perfect Donatella Versace mode...
Oh, and one more thing... props go out to Ephram for finally taking a chance on Madison... cue the Bon Jovi song... 'Shot doooowwwwwn... in a blaze of glooory!'
Final thought... how many weeks until Andy and Harold's sister - ahem - get in on?
#318
I haven't seen the episode yet (gotta track my MNF wagers), but you won't hear any argument from me. Beautiful television show. It somewhat saddens me that so many people are missing out.
das
das
#320
DVD Talk Special Edition
Joined: Jul 2000
Posts: 1,809
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: San Diego, California
Such a good episode.
The ending was my favorite, with one of the greatest songs ever, Etta James' "At Last". With Amy asking Ephram to dance. Awww...
I did find Madison's "I Own This Bitch" comment hilarious. I need to get a t-shirt with that on it.
I've learned that to cure depression, all one has to do is buy a Kia Sorento. Wow, the car works wonders! I should go out and buy one now!
Kudos for continuity and bringing back the Preacher. It's kind of rare to have a storyline continue and conclude like that. Very good.
The ending was my favorite, with one of the greatest songs ever, Etta James' "At Last". With Amy asking Ephram to dance. Awww...
I did find Madison's "I Own This Bitch" comment hilarious. I need to get a t-shirt with that on it.
I've learned that to cure depression, all one has to do is buy a Kia Sorento. Wow, the car works wonders! I should go out and buy one now!
Kudos for continuity and bringing back the Preacher. It's kind of rare to have a storyline continue and conclude like that. Very good.
#321
DVD Talk Hero
It was nice to see Ephram take a chance on Madison, even if he did get shot down w/ the "older girl" argument, though she did it nicely. I hope Madison stays on the show for awhile.
It's weird - Amy and Bright are getting along and dispensing advice to one another, and Bright and Ephram are buddies now.
It's weird - Amy and Bright are getting along and dispensing advice to one another, and Bright and Ephram are buddies now.
#322
It was also a nice touch at the end how they hinted at Delia's crush on Bright again.
I'm really getting to like Bright. I hope he gets a love interest soon. I was
at his comment about Ephram: "Maybe I should date him."
I'm really getting to like Bright. I hope he gets a love interest soon. I was
at his comment about Ephram: "Maybe I should date him."
#323
Bright's finest moment was admitting that he didn't get the "what gear are you in?" joke at first.
Not too thrilled about the overpromotion of 'Episode 20', but if it gets people to tune in, I guess it's OK.
There's not much to say about this episode other than pointing out that it was wonderful, as usual. With a rough start to this year's television season, thank God for this show.
das
Not too thrilled about the overpromotion of 'Episode 20', but if it gets people to tune in, I guess it's OK.
There's not much to say about this episode other than pointing out that it was wonderful, as usual. With a rough start to this year's television season, thank God for this show.
das
#324
Senior Member
Joined: May 2002
Posts: 926
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Great episode. I was laughing so hard when they showed that whole line of little girls waiting to dance with Bright at the wedding, and Delia trying to monopolize him.
I was a litted miffed with the scene with Ephram and Madison where he kissed her and she rejected him (albiet pretty gently). When they showed the preview for this episode a week ago, they implied that Ephram and Madison would actually hook up, which made me happy for the guy. I guess I fell for their misdirection technique again... Oh well.
I only really started watching this show midway through last season, but every week, I look forward to it, and every week it doesn't dissapoint. An absolutely great show! The writing is just amazing: particularly the priest's speech to Dr. Brown before the wedding ceremony about God and Faith, and Andy's speech at the wedding. The writers for this show are top notch!
I was a litted miffed with the scene with Ephram and Madison where he kissed her and she rejected him (albiet pretty gently). When they showed the preview for this episode a week ago, they implied that Ephram and Madison would actually hook up, which made me happy for the guy. I guess I fell for their misdirection technique again... Oh well.
I only really started watching this show midway through last season, but every week, I look forward to it, and every week it doesn't dissapoint. An absolutely great show! The writing is just amazing: particularly the priest's speech to Dr. Brown before the wedding ceremony about God and Faith, and Andy's speech at the wedding. The writers for this show are top notch!
#325
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Joined: Oct 1999
Posts: 8,527
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Portland, OR
This really is the best family drama to come along since Party of Five. And really, these 2 are the only 2 I can think of that I can stand to watch. Just goes to show, a well-written family drama CAN be done! Kudos to the writers and I hope they can keep this up.



