Rock Star: Supernova
#801
DVD Talk Special Edition
Dilana's hopping thing was lame. Totally reminded me of Screech and Lisa's dance "The Sprain" on saved by the bell....her propagandhi inspired cover of cheap trick was shit...I love how they kept showing her face while people were playing. I think she's starting to realize 'oh fuck, I might not have this thing wrapped up'...Lukas can't write or sing a song to save his life...on the other hand Toby has totally made me a believer. That guy is funny...and good...
#802
DVD Talk Hero
Originally Posted by freshticles
Dilana's hopping thing was lame. Totally reminded me of Screech and Lisa's dance "The Sprain" on saved by the bell.
#804
DVD Talk Hero
Originally Posted by freshticles
awwww.I'm kinda sad that you thought you didn't like me
...I like you just fine
...I like you just fine
I was just kidding. That was a classic line. My wife was dying from that comment (although she is a freakishly big SBTB fan).
One day you should post some of your band's material. I'm sure it's better than what's on the radio right now.
#805
DVD Talk Special Edition
HEy...I don't think it would be allowed on the radio!...We were a hardcore punk rock band...you can check it out at www.myspace.com/newworldonfire
for now, I've formed a total joke shitty punk/thrash band called 'a canadian werewolf in...' which i sing (if it can be called that) in rather than play guitar... you can hear the worlds worst demo and see a video from our first show at www.myspace.com/canadianwerewolf
for now, I've formed a total joke shitty punk/thrash band called 'a canadian werewolf in...' which i sing (if it can be called that) in rather than play guitar... you can hear the worlds worst demo and see a video from our first show at www.myspace.com/canadianwerewolf
#806
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
I've been sick, so I haven't had a chance to post anything about this last week, but I wanted to get my two cents in. First, I don't like how Supernova selectively calls people out for something but allows someone else doing the same thing to slide. The biggest example I can think of for that is in regards to the criticisms about Dilana's song lyrics. Now I'm not saying that her lyrics are good, but Gilby keeps saying that her lyrics are too specific. And yet they say nothing about Lukas' song in that regard. I thought his song was pretty crappy and couldn't have been more obvious or unsubtle. And yet they say nothing.
I was really impressed with Storm's original song. I thought it was the best of the bunch. And though I am not that big of a Toby fan, I have to hand it to him that his original was pretty catchy and he's looking like more and more of a lock for Supernova. He just seems to have what they are looking for, though I kinda find him boring for the most part.
As for Dilana, her music knowledge does nothing but baffle me. So, she had never heard "Walk the Line" and had only heard the Limp Bizkit version of "Behind Blue Eyes" and yet the song that she chose for her elimination performance last week? "Psycho Killer" by Talking Heads. Now, granted, I'm no die hard Talking Heads fan but I had NEVER heard of that song and neither had my friends who watched the show with me. Very strange.
I was really impressed with Storm's original song. I thought it was the best of the bunch. And though I am not that big of a Toby fan, I have to hand it to him that his original was pretty catchy and he's looking like more and more of a lock for Supernova. He just seems to have what they are looking for, though I kinda find him boring for the most part.
As for Dilana, her music knowledge does nothing but baffle me. So, she had never heard "Walk the Line" and had only heard the Limp Bizkit version of "Behind Blue Eyes" and yet the song that she chose for her elimination performance last week? "Psycho Killer" by Talking Heads. Now, granted, I'm no die hard Talking Heads fan but I had NEVER heard of that song and neither had my friends who watched the show with me. Very strange.
#807
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Joined: Feb 2006
Posts: 3,278
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Florida, one time home of the space shuttle
Originally Posted by clckworang
I've been sick, so I haven't had a chance to post anything about this last week, but I wanted to get my two cents in. First, I don't like how Supernova selectively calls people out for something but allows someone else doing the same thing to slide. The biggest example I can think of for that is in regards to the criticisms about Dilana's song lyrics. Now I'm not saying that her lyrics are good, but Gilby keeps saying that her lyrics are too specific. And yet they say nothing about Lukas' song in that regard. I thought his song was pretty crappy and couldn't have been more obvious or unsubtle. And yet they say nothing.
I was really impressed with Storm's original song. I thought it was the best of the bunch. And though I am not that big of a Toby fan, I have to hand it to him that his original was pretty catchy and he's looking like more and more of a lock for Supernova. He just seems to have what they are looking for, though I kinda find him boring for the most part.
As for Dilana, her music knowledge does nothing but baffle me. So, she had never heard "Walk the Line" and had only heard the Limp Bizkit version of "Behind Blue Eyes" and yet the song that she chose for her elimination performance last week? "Psycho Killer" by Talking Heads. Now, granted, I'm no die hard Talking Heads fan but I had NEVER heard of that song and neither had my friends who watched the show with me. Very strange.
I was really impressed with Storm's original song. I thought it was the best of the bunch. And though I am not that big of a Toby fan, I have to hand it to him that his original was pretty catchy and he's looking like more and more of a lock for Supernova. He just seems to have what they are looking for, though I kinda find him boring for the most part.
As for Dilana, her music knowledge does nothing but baffle me. So, she had never heard "Walk the Line" and had only heard the Limp Bizkit version of "Behind Blue Eyes" and yet the song that she chose for her elimination performance last week? "Psycho Killer" by Talking Heads. Now, granted, I'm no die hard Talking Heads fan but I had NEVER heard of that song and neither had my friends who watched the show with me. Very strange.
Toby is my favorite for the opposite of what you said. I think he is so entertaining and brings songs to life. My money is on him.
#808
DVD Talk Legend
I heard of Pyscho Killer before I knew who the talking heads were. It was one of their radio hits 
Hell, there was even a parody of it called Psycho Chicken, which got a ton of airplay on the Dr. Demento show back in the late 80s.
Dilana is a musical dunce, plain and simple. She should not be singing. Not in public. She is kind of like a talentless female George Clinton.

Hell, there was even a parody of it called Psycho Chicken, which got a ton of airplay on the Dr. Demento show back in the late 80s.
Dilana is a musical dunce, plain and simple. She should not be singing. Not in public. She is kind of like a talentless female George Clinton.
#809
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
^^^ Well, I looked up the track on Rhapsody and it was on a 1977 album, the year I was born. So, if it got a lot of radio play during that time, I wouldn't have known about it. When I think of Talking Heads hits, I think of some of their '80s stuff first. And as for Dr. Demento, I don't think there is even a radio station where I live that has ever had that show.
And surely you aren't saying that George Clinton, one of funk's pioneers, is talentless!
And surely you aren't saying that George Clinton, one of funk's pioneers, is talentless!
#811
DVD Talk Hero
No suprise who got the fan favorite, they should be IN the finale.
Interesting choices, but again, way too much repetition. Magni is taking a HUGE risk singing a not-so-well known song. He must feel he'll be in the finale regardless.
Well I think that Dilana is going home, no matter what.
Interesting choices, but again, way too much repetition. Magni is taking a HUGE risk singing a not-so-well known song. He must feel he'll be in the finale regardless.
Well I think that Dilana is going home, no matter what.
#812
Originally Posted by clckworang
So, she had never heard "Walk the Line"
It was actually "Ring of Fire". To me, admitting you've never heard that is even worse than not hearing "walk the line".
#813
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Originally Posted by Big Boy Laroux
It was actually "Ring of Fire". To me, admitting you've never heard that is even worse than not hearing "walk the line".
#814
DVD Talk Legend
Joined: Jun 2003
Posts: 10,909
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Capitol of the Empire! Center of all Commerce and Culture! Crossroads of Civilization! NEW ROME!!!...aka New York City
She OBVIOUSLY knew Walk the Line....she said its her faviorite Chris Daughtry origional!
#817
DVD Talk Hero
Originally Posted by movieking
So does this end this week or not? I thought that it did.
Spoiler:
#818
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Joined: Feb 2006
Posts: 3,278
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Florida, one time home of the space shuttle
I actually think Loukas will do a good job with his song selection.
I think Dilana is gonna put her Dilana spin on hers, but I dont think there is to many ways to spin this song.
I think Dilana is gonna put her Dilana spin on hers, but I dont think there is to many ways to spin this song.
#819
DVD Talk Legend
Originally Posted by clckworang
^^^ Well, I looked up the track on Rhapsody and it was on a 1977 album, the year I was born. So, if it got a lot of radio play during that time, I wouldn't have known about it. When I think of Talking Heads hits, I think of some of their '80s stuff first. And as for Dr. Demento, I don't think there is even a radio station where I live that has ever had that show.
And surely you aren't saying that George Clinton, one of funk's pioneers, is talentless!
And surely you aren't saying that George Clinton, one of funk's pioneers, is talentless!
As for the '77 album, it got a LOT of airplay well into the late 80s.
#820
DVD Talk Legend
Originally Posted by Big Boy Laroux
It was actually "Ring of Fire". To me, admitting you've never heard that is even worse than not hearing "walk the line".
#821
DVD Talk Hero
Originally Posted by mllefoo
Especially since Social Distortion covered it. And probably a whole host of other "punk" bands.
#822
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Originally Posted by mllefoo
No, I'm saying Dilana is a talentless version of him. She tries too hard to look like him.
As for the '77 album, it got a LOT of airplay well into the late 80s.
As for the '77 album, it got a LOT of airplay well into the late 80s.
Originally Posted by DVD Josh
I like the SD version alot.
#825
DVD Talk Legend
Regardless, I think Dilana was lying when she said she'd never heard Behind Blue Eyes as done by the Who.
I think there are as yet undiscovered tribes in Papua New Guinea that would be aghast at Dilana's apparent ignorance of classic rock.
I think there are as yet undiscovered tribes in Papua New Guinea that would be aghast at Dilana's apparent ignorance of classic rock.



