Grey's Anatomy (ABC) -- Series Discussion Thread [MERGED]
#351
DVD Talk Hero
Thread Starter
Originally Posted by Jadzia
She was in this episode? I didn't recognize her. I actually liked that show when it was on, even though I think it only lasted like 2 or 3 episodes.
#352
DVD Talk Hero
Thread Starter
Grey's Anatomy - 11/20/05
"Thanks for the Memories"
Cast: Ellen Pompeo, Patrick Dempsey, James Pickens Jr, TR Knight, Sandra Oh, Katherine Heigl, Chandra Wilson, Isaiah Washington, Justin Chambers, Kate Walsh.
Director(s): Michael Dinner.
Producer(s): Shonda Rhimes , Shonda Lynn Rhimes, Mark Gordon, Betsy Beers, Jim Parriott.
Writer(s): Shonda Rhimes , Shonda Lynn Rhimes.
Original Airdate: November 20, 2005.
Grey's Anatomy
Spoiler:
Cast: Ellen Pompeo, Patrick Dempsey, James Pickens Jr, TR Knight, Sandra Oh, Katherine Heigl, Chandra Wilson, Isaiah Washington, Justin Chambers, Kate Walsh.
Director(s): Michael Dinner.
Producer(s): Shonda Rhimes , Shonda Lynn Rhimes, Mark Gordon, Betsy Beers, Jim Parriott.
Writer(s): Shonda Rhimes , Shonda Lynn Rhimes.
Original Airdate: November 20, 2005.
Grey's Anatomy
#353
DVD Talk Hero
11/20/05
Okay, I give up, I've run out of weekly superlatives for this show. Once again, a simple case forces the viewer to confront a poignant situation on a personal level (the guy who wakes up from a coma after 16 years, and has to find out his wife has finally moved on, and has missed seeing his son grow up). Can you imagine waking up, finding out that life has moved on, with a reduction in familial ties, and having to face a surgical decision that is a 50/50 proposition? Luckily for the coma guy, Meredith's bedside manner is one of her strengths as a doctor.
George and his dad and brothers provided some good laughs, though I knew his dad was going to get popped with buckshot, like the irony considering the family was on a turkey hunt. T.R. Knight does a great job with the comedic bits as George. He could be played as a spineless sap, but there's more than a hint of a spine, and definitely more surgical aptitude than you'd think just by looking at his disshelveled appearance, but he's got it going on in spite of his schlumpy predisposition.
Having Christina sneak out for booze and surgery was just so Christina. Having Christina and Bailey communicate regarding Bailey's pregnancy and Christina's recent pregnancy was a nice touch given the tough exteriors both women project as a basic personality trait.
Who knew Burke would prove to be so capable in the kitchen, and he continued to be the teacher to Izzy, who was hopelessly optimistic about her culinary acumen in preparing a Thanksgiving meal for her new immediate surgical family.
It appears that Meredith is finally getting past the hurt of the her now-dissolved relationship with Dr. McDreamy, and Derek seems to finally be in that place to give Addison and his marriage another chance. The ending stanza in this episode is pitch-perfect bittersweetness.
Okay, I give up, I've run out of weekly superlatives for this show. Once again, a simple case forces the viewer to confront a poignant situation on a personal level (the guy who wakes up from a coma after 16 years, and has to find out his wife has finally moved on, and has missed seeing his son grow up). Can you imagine waking up, finding out that life has moved on, with a reduction in familial ties, and having to face a surgical decision that is a 50/50 proposition? Luckily for the coma guy, Meredith's bedside manner is one of her strengths as a doctor.
George and his dad and brothers provided some good laughs, though I knew his dad was going to get popped with buckshot, like the irony considering the family was on a turkey hunt. T.R. Knight does a great job with the comedic bits as George. He could be played as a spineless sap, but there's more than a hint of a spine, and definitely more surgical aptitude than you'd think just by looking at his disshelveled appearance, but he's got it going on in spite of his schlumpy predisposition.
Having Christina sneak out for booze and surgery was just so Christina. Having Christina and Bailey communicate regarding Bailey's pregnancy and Christina's recent pregnancy was a nice touch given the tough exteriors both women project as a basic personality trait.
Who knew Burke would prove to be so capable in the kitchen, and he continued to be the teacher to Izzy, who was hopelessly optimistic about her culinary acumen in preparing a Thanksgiving meal for her new immediate surgical family.
It appears that Meredith is finally getting past the hurt of the her now-dissolved relationship with Dr. McDreamy, and Derek seems to finally be in that place to give Addison and his marriage another chance. The ending stanza in this episode is pitch-perfect bittersweetness.
#355
Member
Join Date: Nov 2002
Posts: 97
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Best line I think was when joe showed up and Christina asked if he brought liquor.
"Nope just a pie"
"Your a bartender, and you didn't bring liquor?"
"Your a surgeon, did you bring scalpels?"
"Nope just a pie"
"Your a bartender, and you didn't bring liquor?"
"Your a surgeon, did you bring scalpels?"
#357
Originally Posted by B.A.
I really enjoyed the ep, particularly Burke and Izzy in the kitchen. The only thing that annoyed me (as usual) was Christina. Isaiah Washington is so damn smooth on this show.
The whole thanksgiving dinner thing was a *yawn*. As for the PotW (patient of the week) Of course the man had to die .. just like last week, you could see it coming a mile away.
I still enjoy a lot of the banter and Mrs. McDreamy look darn good at the trailer. I actually like them better than Meredith. Alex needs to get involved. The characters need to make more "bad" choices. Burke is cool, but unfortunately in a mensa kind of way ... hehe Preston.
#358
DVD Talk God
Join Date: Feb 2000
Location: Directionally Challenged (for DirecTV)
Posts: 130,343
Received 625 Likes
on
503 Posts
Originally Posted by dunno260
Best line I think was when joe showed up and Christina asked if he brought liquor.
"Nope just a pie"
"Your a bartender, and you didn't bring liquor?"
"Your a surgeon, did you bring scalpels?"
"Nope just a pie"
"Your a bartender, and you didn't bring liquor?"
"Your a surgeon, did you bring scalpels?"
That was my favorite part too.
Overall, I didn't care much for this episode.
#360
DVD Talk Godfather
Join Date: Apr 1999
Location: Gateway Cities/Harbor Region
Posts: 63,387
Received 1,873 Likes
on
1,153 Posts
Originally Posted by Jadzia
I had to laugh that one of George's brothers was the "O face" guy from Office Space. I kept cracking up every time he talked.
I only saw parts of this ep because I had to work but that parts I saw were good. I love that "bartender/booze" line and I also love how the Sistah was more mellowed and less pushy this week. Or at least mellow and less pushy compared to what she normally is.
#361
Needs to contact an admin about multiple accounts
Join Date: Dec 2004
Posts: 130
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I wish they would just have an "accident" at Seattle Grace and kill off Christina. She is such an annoying character, or perhaps it is just her acting, but I actually turn the channel now when she comes on. Its just so grating...
#362
DVD Talk Godfather
Originally Posted by Patman
11/20/05
Okay, I give up, I've run out of weekly superlatives for this show. Once again, a simple case forces the viewer to confront a poignant situation on a personal level (the guy who wakes up from a coma after 16 years, and has to find out his wife has finally moved on, and has missed seeing his son grow up). Can you imagine waking up, finding out that life has moved on, with a reduction in familial ties, and having to face a surgical decision that is a 50/50 proposition? Luckily for the coma guy, Meredith's bedside manner is one of her strengths as a doctor.
George and his dad and brothers provided some good laughs, though I knew his dad was going to get popped with buckshot, like the irony considering the family was on a turkey hunt. T.R. Knight does a great job with the comedic bits as George. He could be played as a spineless sap, but there's more than a hint of a spine, and definitely more surgical aptitude than you'd think just by looking at his disshelveled appearance, but he's got it going on in spite of his schlumpy predisposition.
Having Christina sneak out for booze and surgery was just so Christina. Having Christina and Bailey communicate regarding Bailey's pregnancy and Christina's recent pregnancy was a nice touch given the tough exteriors both women project as a basic personality trait.
Who knew Burke would prove to be so capable in the kitchen, and he continued to be the teacher to Izzy, who was hopelessly optimistic about her culinary acumen in preparing a Thanksgiving meal for her new immediate surgical family.
It appears that Meredith is finally getting past the hurt of the her now-dissolved relationship with Dr. McDreamy, and Derek seems to finally be in that place to give Addison and his marriage another chance. The ending stanza in this episode is pitch-perfect bittersweetness.
Okay, I give up, I've run out of weekly superlatives for this show. Once again, a simple case forces the viewer to confront a poignant situation on a personal level (the guy who wakes up from a coma after 16 years, and has to find out his wife has finally moved on, and has missed seeing his son grow up). Can you imagine waking up, finding out that life has moved on, with a reduction in familial ties, and having to face a surgical decision that is a 50/50 proposition? Luckily for the coma guy, Meredith's bedside manner is one of her strengths as a doctor.
George and his dad and brothers provided some good laughs, though I knew his dad was going to get popped with buckshot, like the irony considering the family was on a turkey hunt. T.R. Knight does a great job with the comedic bits as George. He could be played as a spineless sap, but there's more than a hint of a spine, and definitely more surgical aptitude than you'd think just by looking at his disshelveled appearance, but he's got it going on in spite of his schlumpy predisposition.
Having Christina sneak out for booze and surgery was just so Christina. Having Christina and Bailey communicate regarding Bailey's pregnancy and Christina's recent pregnancy was a nice touch given the tough exteriors both women project as a basic personality trait.
Who knew Burke would prove to be so capable in the kitchen, and he continued to be the teacher to Izzy, who was hopelessly optimistic about her culinary acumen in preparing a Thanksgiving meal for her new immediate surgical family.
It appears that Meredith is finally getting past the hurt of the her now-dissolved relationship with Dr. McDreamy, and Derek seems to finally be in that place to give Addison and his marriage another chance. The ending stanza in this episode is pitch-perfect bittersweetness.
I have to agree with every paragraph above. Well said. I also have to agree with:
Originally Posted by Ayre
As for the PotW (patient of the week) Of course the man had to die .. just like last week, you could see it coming a mile away.
50-50, the worst possible odds. I think I might have walked out and taken every day thereafter as a gift. Enjoy life to the fullest. I mean he was out for 16 years!
#363
DVD Talk Hero
Thread Starter
Grey's Anatomy - 11/27/05
"Much Too Much"
Cast: Ellen Pompeo, Patrick Dempsey, James Pickens Jr, TR Knight, Sandra Oh, Katherine Heigl, Chandra Wilson, Isaiah Washington, Justin Chambers, Kate Walsh.
Director(s): Wendy Stanzler.
Producer(s): Shonda Rhimes , Shonda Lynn Rhimes, Mark Gordon, Betsy Beers, Jim Parriott.
Writer(s): Gabrielle Stanton, Harry Werksman.
Original Airdate: November 27, 2005.
Grey's Anatomy
Spoiler:
Cast: Ellen Pompeo, Patrick Dempsey, James Pickens Jr, TR Knight, Sandra Oh, Katherine Heigl, Chandra Wilson, Isaiah Washington, Justin Chambers, Kate Walsh.
Director(s): Wendy Stanzler.
Producer(s): Shonda Rhimes , Shonda Lynn Rhimes, Mark Gordon, Betsy Beers, Jim Parriott.
Writer(s): Gabrielle Stanton, Harry Werksman.
Original Airdate: November 27, 2005.
Grey's Anatomy
#364
DVD Talk Hero
Go look up "mortification" and you'll see Meredith's picture in the dictionary after she breaks her one-night-stand's penis and the entire hospital knows about it. Good for some laughs, for sure.
Burke's jaw pretty much hit the floor after Christina shows him what a frikkin' class A slob she is. Whoa. I kept hoping Burke would have just said, "Key, please." and walked out.
Alex and Izzy, guess that ain't happening anytime soon now.
Booger's subplot didn't really go anywhere, except for an excuse for him to go nutty with the toilet water.
The quints subplot was okay, quite a bit of surgery needed for those little girls.
Burke's jaw pretty much hit the floor after Christina shows him what a frikkin' class A slob she is. Whoa. I kept hoping Burke would have just said, "Key, please." and walked out.
Alex and Izzy, guess that ain't happening anytime soon now.
Booger's subplot didn't really go anywhere, except for an excuse for him to go nutty with the toilet water.
The quints subplot was okay, quite a bit of surgery needed for those little girls.
#365
DVD Talk Hero
How can you get it up for that nurse and not Izzy? I guess they're trying to make some connection with him not being able to get it up for girls he has feelings for.
The Meredith story was pretty funny. Bailey had some great lines.
The Meredith story was pretty funny. Bailey had some great lines.
#366
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Join Date: Aug 2001
Posts: 3,193
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I don't believe they put the "It puts the lotion in the basket or else it gets the hose again" song in this episode.
Pretty funny stuff with the one night stand, until they got needle came out... then it wasn't quite as funny.
Pretty funny stuff with the one night stand, until they got needle came out... then it wasn't quite as funny.
#367
DVD Talk Reviewer
Join Date: Aug 2001
Location: WAS looking for My Own Private Stuckeyville, but stuck in Liberty City (while missing Vice City)
Posts: 15,094
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I read that Sara Ramirez will be joining the cast for a couple episodes. Has anybody heard when?
#368
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Jul 2000
Posts: 1,693
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Well this show completely lost all credibility with George turning down Izzy at the beginning. I mean I'll still watch and love it, I'm just saying is all. George, you will never, ever do better than that in your life. Ever.
The Meredith storyline was great, but gotta have some more Doctor Bailey. She's always on her game.
The Meredith storyline was great, but gotta have some more Doctor Bailey. She's always on her game.
#371
DVD Talk Hero
Thread Starter
Originally Posted by MrX
Katherine Heigl's breasts deserve a best guest appearance emmy.
Meredith needs to learn a little self-respect.
Alex really has some issues.
Bailey is funny as shit.
Burke really should have demanded the key back and used force if necessary.
Mrs. Shephard is really hot. I noticed they added Kate Walsh's name to the openning credits - not sure if they had her as anything more than a guest star before.
#373
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Originally Posted by Red Dog
Give me a break - first Alex bangs the ugly nurse and second, he doesn't lock the door?
What's with turning Meredith into a total slut?
What's with turning Meredith into a total slut?
Second, maybe, Meredith has always been one to sleep around. She did meet Dr. McDreamy at the same bar. Anyway, when I don't find Meredith whiny or clingy or annoying - I find her to be hypocritical. Her line about who tries to turn one-night stands into relationships is sure rich coming from her.
#374
DVD Talk Hero
Thread Starter
Originally Posted by Red Dog
Give me a break - first Alex bangs the ugly nurse and second, he doesn't lock the door?
What's with turning Meredith into a total slut?
What's with turning Meredith into a total slut?
I think Meredith has been a slut all along.
#375
DVD Talk Legend
Originally Posted by B.A.
Great googly-moogly! I think the wife noticed the grin on my face last night when they made their special guest appearance.