24 5/21 (merged)
#101
Moderator
Originally posted by mrosen
Keeping the 24 hour format makes the show special and retains a hook for viewers.
Keeping the 24 hour format makes the show special and retains a hook for viewers.
#102
DVD Talk Godfather & 2020 TOTY Winner
Well, I certainly THINK Teri is dead, but the same thought keeps popping up in my mind:
What do Charles Haid in Hill Street Blues, Julianne Margolies in ER and Denis Franz in NYPD Blue all have in common?
They were all supposed to be killed in the pilots of their respective shows. Funny things can happen when network executives and show producers start tinkering....
What do Charles Haid in Hill Street Blues, Julianne Margolies in ER and Denis Franz in NYPD Blue all have in common?
They were all supposed to be killed in the pilots of their respective shows. Funny things can happen when network executives and show producers start tinkering....
#103
I really hope Teri is alive, so the next 24 hours can be dedicated to nothing but torturing her for "information" she doesn't have. Maybe they could get the guy from Alias to do the job. I'd watch that.
das
das
#104
Enormous Genitals
Joined: Oct 2000
Posts: 38,815
Received 897 Likes
on
472 Posts
From: a small cottage on a cul de sac in the lower pits of hell.
Originally posted by juiio
Agreed. Not to mention that Palmer almost assuredly wouldn't win the election after leaving his wife.
Agreed. Not to mention that Palmer almost assuredly wouldn't win the election after leaving his wife.
If done right, the Lady MacPalmer sub-plot could be the best part of next season.
#105
Banned
Joined: Mar 2000
Posts: 149
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: NE OHIO
Originally posted by Bandoman
I don't think he's going to divorce her or announce a separation. He's just not going to include her in any of the decision-making. She'll be left out of the loop, making public appearances just for show (which she will do simply to keep as close to things as possible while she plots.) She'll want revenge, but she won't want to destroy Palmer. She'll want to somehow blackmail him into letting her into his circle of power.
If done right, the Lady MacPalmer sub-plot could be the best part of next season.
I don't think he's going to divorce her or announce a separation. He's just not going to include her in any of the decision-making. She'll be left out of the loop, making public appearances just for show (which she will do simply to keep as close to things as possible while she plots.) She'll want revenge, but she won't want to destroy Palmer. She'll want to somehow blackmail him into letting her into his circle of power.
If done right, the Lady MacPalmer sub-plot could be the best part of next season.
#106
DVD Talk Special Edition
Joined: Jun 2000
Posts: 1,437
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Just got back from a trip.
Did anyone else find it strange that there was this magical camera recording in a room that was supposed to have no cameras, which is why Jamie was put in it in the first place? Does anyone else find it odd that the mole needed super-high clearance to get all the information the mole needed, yet it turned out to be Nina? (Could be explained by a higher-level mole.) Does anyone else find it unusual that no one bothered to check the security tape before midnight, to make sure it was a suicide and not another mole at work (which was clear that it could be since Jamie didn't have enough clearance to be the only mole)?
I thought this was an exciting episode, but I agree with many of das' statements. The camera thing was laughable, I'm sorry. I THOUGHT THEY TOOK JAMIE TO THAT ROOM BECAUSE THERE WAS NO CAMERA. IF THERE HAD BEEN A CAMERA THERE THAT GAINES MIGHT HAVE TAPPED, WOULDN'T THEY HAVE SHOT IT OUT OR SOMETHING RIGHT AWAY?
Did anyone else find it strange that there was this magical camera recording in a room that was supposed to have no cameras, which is why Jamie was put in it in the first place? Does anyone else find it odd that the mole needed super-high clearance to get all the information the mole needed, yet it turned out to be Nina? (Could be explained by a higher-level mole.) Does anyone else find it unusual that no one bothered to check the security tape before midnight, to make sure it was a suicide and not another mole at work (which was clear that it could be since Jamie didn't have enough clearance to be the only mole)?
I thought this was an exciting episode, but I agree with many of das' statements. The camera thing was laughable, I'm sorry. I THOUGHT THEY TOOK JAMIE TO THAT ROOM BECAUSE THERE WAS NO CAMERA. IF THERE HAD BEEN A CAMERA THERE THAT GAINES MIGHT HAVE TAPPED, WOULDN'T THEY HAVE SHOT IT OUT OR SOMETHING RIGHT AWAY?
#108
Senior Member
Joined: Oct 1999
Posts: 643
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Pitt Meadows, BC, Canada
Originally posted by dave955
Just got back from a trip.
Did anyone else find it strange that there was this magical camera recording in a room that was supposed to have no cameras, which is why Jamie was put in it in the first place? Does anyone else find it odd that the mole needed super-high clearance to get all the information the mole needed, yet it turned out to be Nina? (Could be explained by a higher-level mole.) Does anyone else find it unusual that no one bothered to check the security tape before midnight, to make sure it was a suicide and not another mole at work (which was clear that it could be since Jamie didn't have enough clearance to be the only mole)?
I thought this was an exciting episode, but I agree with many of das' statements. The camera thing was laughable, I'm sorry. I THOUGHT THEY TOOK JAMIE TO THAT ROOM BECAUSE THERE WAS NO CAMERA. IF THERE HAD BEEN A CAMERA THERE THAT GAINES MIGHT HAVE TAPPED, WOULDN'T THEY HAVE SHOT IT OUT OR SOMETHING RIGHT AWAY?
Just got back from a trip.
Did anyone else find it strange that there was this magical camera recording in a room that was supposed to have no cameras, which is why Jamie was put in it in the first place? Does anyone else find it odd that the mole needed super-high clearance to get all the information the mole needed, yet it turned out to be Nina? (Could be explained by a higher-level mole.) Does anyone else find it unusual that no one bothered to check the security tape before midnight, to make sure it was a suicide and not another mole at work (which was clear that it could be since Jamie didn't have enough clearance to be the only mole)?
I thought this was an exciting episode, but I agree with many of das' statements. The camera thing was laughable, I'm sorry. I THOUGHT THEY TOOK JAMIE TO THAT ROOM BECAUSE THERE WAS NO CAMERA. IF THERE HAD BEEN A CAMERA THERE THAT GAINES MIGHT HAVE TAPPED, WOULDN'T THEY HAVE SHOT IT OUT OR SOMETHING RIGHT AWAY?
#109
DVD Talk Legend
Joined: Jun 2000
Posts: 10,470
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Downers Grove, IL
Originally posted by Geoff H
I agree to an extent. But I think the writers could probably explain it away by saying that nobody actually even knew about the camera in there except for Bauer and his superiors.
I agree to an extent. But I think the writers could probably explain it away by saying that nobody actually even knew about the camera in there except for Bauer and his superiors.
#110
DVD Talk Special Edition
Joined: Jun 2000
Posts: 1,437
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Still doesn't make sense, though. She could have covered up the camera or done anything to it, and if anyone looked at the footage and asked, said it was because she was afraid Gaines might have access to it somehow. And it still makes no sense that no one looked at that footage until 11:40 at night...I remain disappointed...
#111
Dave,
What reason would they have to look at the footage? Everyone thought Jamey was the only mole except for maybe Jack, Tony and Nina. And, even when they realized there indeed was another dirty agent at CTU (not till around the late hours of that day), they still probably thought that Jamey killed herself. In thier minds, they were thinking, "Why would two moles at CTU work against one another?" I know I'd be thinking that, which is why checking the tape wasn't as important as keeping Palmer and Jack's family alive.
What reason would they have to look at the footage? Everyone thought Jamey was the only mole except for maybe Jack, Tony and Nina. And, even when they realized there indeed was another dirty agent at CTU (not till around the late hours of that day), they still probably thought that Jamey killed herself. In thier minds, they were thinking, "Why would two moles at CTU work against one another?" I know I'd be thinking that, which is why checking the tape wasn't as important as keeping Palmer and Jack's family alive.
#112
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Joined: Sep 1999
Posts: 9,021
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Heart of the Heart
wow...just watched the final episode tonight. yet another reason everyone should own a replaytv!
although i would like to know how in the hell Teri found Nina in her super secret room.
although i would like to know how in the hell Teri found Nina in her super secret room.
#113
DVD Talk Special Edition
Joined: May 1999
Posts: 1,606
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Virginia Beach
If you want to stretch the plausiblity, it is possible Teri heard a strange noise coming from that room. The strange noise being either the gunshot when Nina killed the female technician or Nina moving the equipment around on the metal cart.
Teri entered the room only seconds after both events had occurred.
Teri entered the room only seconds after both events had occurred.
#114
DVD Talk Special Edition
Joined: Jan 2000
Posts: 1,100
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Harrisburg, PA
Originally posted by das Monkey
I really hope Teri is alive, so the next 24 hours can be dedicated to nothing but torturing her for "information" she doesn't have. Maybe they could get the guy from Alias to do the job. I'd watch that.
I really hope Teri is alive, so the next 24 hours can be dedicated to nothing but torturing her for "information" she doesn't have. Maybe they could get the guy from Alias to do the job. I'd watch that.
"One in five, you little bitch! One in five!!"
#115
Admin Emeritus
Joined: Jan 2001
Posts: 12,842
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
2 Posts
From: Texas, our Texas! All hail the mighty state!
Originally posted by Professor Frink
But near the end Teri will escape and turn the tables on her captor, stabbing him in the neck with a needle!
"One in five, you little bitch! One in five!!"
But near the end Teri will escape and turn the tables on her captor, stabbing him in the neck with a needle!
"One in five, you little bitch! One in five!!"
#116
DVD Talk Legend
Originally posted by Rypro 525
on the dvd's, i want a commentary track so we can try to look for suspecious acitons, and also to have it out before season 2.
on the dvd's, i want a commentary track so we can try to look for suspecious acitons, and also to have it out before season 2.
#117
DVD Talk Legend
Joined: Jun 2000
Posts: 10,470
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Downers Grove, IL
Originally posted by kenbuzz
I keep hearing people talk about "the DVDs", but I've not been able to find out that there ARE going to be DVDs. Can someone point me in the right direction?
I keep hearing people talk about "the DVDs", but I've not been able to find out that there ARE going to be DVDs. Can someone point me in the right direction?
#118
Moderator
Originally posted by huzefa
I think they are talking about the eventual dvd's; a couple of years down the road that is. There's no way that Fox is gonna put this show out on DVD within the next year or two. Hell, they're not even rerun it.
I think they are talking about the eventual dvd's; a couple of years down the road that is. There's no way that Fox is gonna put this show out on DVD within the next year or two. Hell, they're not even rerun it.
#119
Admin Emeritus
Joined: Jan 2001
Posts: 12,842
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
2 Posts
From: Texas, our Texas! All hail the mighty state!
Originally posted by huzefa
I think they are talking about the eventual dvd's; a couple of years down the road that is. There's no way that Fox is gonna put this show out on DVD within the next year or two. Hell, they're not even rerun it.
I think they are talking about the eventual dvd's; a couple of years down the road that is. There's no way that Fox is gonna put this show out on DVD within the next year or two. Hell, they're not even rerun it.
People say "soon." I know, pretty vague... but when I hear "soon," I think within the next year. Maybe they think they'll get more $ from releasing it on video as opposed to re-running it?
#120
DVD Talk Special Edition
Joined: Jun 2000
Posts: 1,437
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by PacMan2006
Dave,
What reason would they have to look at the footage? Everyone thought Jamey was the only mole except for maybe Jack, Tony and Nina.
Dave,
What reason would they have to look at the footage? Everyone thought Jamey was the only mole except for maybe Jack, Tony and Nina.
And, even when they realized there indeed was another dirty agent at CTU (not till around the late hours of that day), they still probably thought that Jamey killed herself. In thier minds, they were thinking, "Why would two moles at CTU work against one another?"
Part of the problem with this plot twist is that there never was any major discussion of the mole, the logic (or lack thereof) of anyone being the mole, except at the very beginning of the show. Then it became clear there had to be another mole -- the safe house was hit, Kim's police car is hit, the terrorists have access to plans for a secret military facility -- and it's just like, hmm, couldn't be anyone we know...
I know I'd be thinking that, which is why checking the tape wasn't as important as keeping Palmer and Jack's family alive.
#121
I'm not trying to defend sloppy writing. I think the hours of 12pm to about 7pm were just filler and rather uneeded. It's obvious that the writers only wrote thirteen original episodes. But, also, they did say that they picked Nina to be the mole at around episode 8, so it's not like this was put together at 11pm, episode-wise. I think anyone can find things illogical with any plot if they nitpick at it.
Could someone have checked the tapes? Sure. You could also argue that they felt they didn't need to. From Jack being interrogated and meeting with Palmer in ep 14 to them figuring out the motives of the Drazens to trying to protect his daughter--give the guy a break, he can't do everything.
I'm just saying that there's reason to think that someone should have looked at the tape, but with the information the characters were given, and we as the audience were given, it was obvious they felt they didn't need to.
Could someone have checked the tapes? Sure. You could also argue that they felt they didn't need to. From Jack being interrogated and meeting with Palmer in ep 14 to them figuring out the motives of the Drazens to trying to protect his daughter--give the guy a break, he can't do everything.
I'm just saying that there's reason to think that someone should have looked at the tape, but with the information the characters were given, and we as the audience were given, it was obvious they felt they didn't need to.
#122
DVD Talk Special Edition
Joined: Jun 2000
Posts: 1,437
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Whatever. I mean, the whole thing to me is summarized by the
(1) camera appearing in the unmonitored room
(2) Nina pointlessly exposing herself by not disabling the camera first when she had a clear excuse not to, and
(3) Mason's demand that Jack provide other evidence besides his own testimony that Nina is a mole before Mason would even bother to have Nina detained.
Even if I give you that it made sense that no one checked the camera, that the camera was there, and that Nina didn't disable the camera before killing Jamie ... what about Mason's refusal to even put Nina in a secured room while Jack searched for corroboration for his allegations? Bear in mind that for the entire show it was clear the higher-ups thought that Nina was covering for Jack, and vice versa.
IMHO the last hour was laughably written. Drazen: "Hey, lets lure Bauer in here. OH S**T HE IS HERE AND HE HAS KILLED ALL OF US. OOPS."
I give the actors a lot of credit for making the last hour work as well as it did, and the writers deserve credit for building up the characters to the point that even when their actions made absolutely no sense, I still cared about what was happening.
(1) camera appearing in the unmonitored room
(2) Nina pointlessly exposing herself by not disabling the camera first when she had a clear excuse not to, and
(3) Mason's demand that Jack provide other evidence besides his own testimony that Nina is a mole before Mason would even bother to have Nina detained.
Even if I give you that it made sense that no one checked the camera, that the camera was there, and that Nina didn't disable the camera before killing Jamie ... what about Mason's refusal to even put Nina in a secured room while Jack searched for corroboration for his allegations? Bear in mind that for the entire show it was clear the higher-ups thought that Nina was covering for Jack, and vice versa.
IMHO the last hour was laughably written. Drazen: "Hey, lets lure Bauer in here. OH S**T HE IS HERE AND HE HAS KILLED ALL OF US. OOPS."
I give the actors a lot of credit for making the last hour work as well as it did, and the writers deserve credit for building up the characters to the point that even when their actions made absolutely no sense, I still cared about what was happening.
#123
I'll just answer your major question, you wrote:
"Even if I give you that it made sense that no one checked the camera, that the camera was there, and that Nina didn't disable the camera before killing Jamie ... what about Mason's refusal to even put Nina in a secured room while Jack searched for corroboration for his allegations? Bear in mind that for the entire show it was clear the higher-ups thought that Nina was covering for Jack, and vice versa."
In a way, you answered your own question. Nina and Jack had a past romantic history, as well as a work relationship. Mason blatantly saw this, which is why he understood, yet disliked, the fact that Nina would cover for Jack all the time. So, why would he suspect Nina even after Jack CLAIMS she's the mole? That's why he suggested that the information she gave Jack about Kim's death was just misinformation instead of a lie for the Drazen's.
Right after Mason saw the footage of Jamey being killed by Nina, he and other agents went in search for her, and found both Nina and Jack in the garage. It's not like he sat on his ass (at least not to me).
With all shows or movies, you have to suspend your disbelief, and this situation is no different. If every single thing a character in a show or movie did was out of complete logic, why would we watch? There'd be no drama or suspense. There'd be a lack of a story.
If the cops in the early episode of "24" secured the parking lot perimeter like they were supposed to do instead of letting Jack steal a car and drive out, there'd be no next episode.
Out of logic, in horror movies teenagers shouldn't walk towards the danger, but if they didn't, there'd be no suspense and no storyline.
Same difference here with the finale.
"Even if I give you that it made sense that no one checked the camera, that the camera was there, and that Nina didn't disable the camera before killing Jamie ... what about Mason's refusal to even put Nina in a secured room while Jack searched for corroboration for his allegations? Bear in mind that for the entire show it was clear the higher-ups thought that Nina was covering for Jack, and vice versa."
In a way, you answered your own question. Nina and Jack had a past romantic history, as well as a work relationship. Mason blatantly saw this, which is why he understood, yet disliked, the fact that Nina would cover for Jack all the time. So, why would he suspect Nina even after Jack CLAIMS she's the mole? That's why he suggested that the information she gave Jack about Kim's death was just misinformation instead of a lie for the Drazen's.
Right after Mason saw the footage of Jamey being killed by Nina, he and other agents went in search for her, and found both Nina and Jack in the garage. It's not like he sat on his ass (at least not to me).
With all shows or movies, you have to suspend your disbelief, and this situation is no different. If every single thing a character in a show or movie did was out of complete logic, why would we watch? There'd be no drama or suspense. There'd be a lack of a story.
If the cops in the early episode of "24" secured the parking lot perimeter like they were supposed to do instead of letting Jack steal a car and drive out, there'd be no next episode.
Out of logic, in horror movies teenagers shouldn't walk towards the danger, but if they didn't, there'd be no suspense and no storyline.
Same difference here with the finale.
#124
DVD Talk Special Edition
Joined: Jun 2000
Posts: 1,437
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
"Suspend disbelief" is not the same as "accept the major, developed characters act in ways contrary to logic and past behavior." It is also not "accept plot developments that are contrary to logic and past behavior."
Now, you might say I'm nitpicking, but I really don't think so. The writing for this show was generally pretty good. Your defense of the finale -- that I need a greater suspension of disbelief for the finale than I required for the other 23 hours -- makes my case, that the finale was not up to that standard. Other plots twists didn't bother me, because they made sense and didn't contradict what we knew, or make earlier actions by the characters non-sensical.
Now, you might say I'm nitpicking, but I really don't think so. The writing for this show was generally pretty good. Your defense of the finale -- that I need a greater suspension of disbelief for the finale than I required for the other 23 hours -- makes my case, that the finale was not up to that standard. Other plots twists didn't bother me, because they made sense and didn't contradict what we knew, or make earlier actions by the characters non-sensical.




