DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   Movie Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/movie-talk-17/)
-   -   "Transformers"...the (more than meets the eye) reviews thread. (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/movie-talk/504853-transformers-more-than-meets-eye-reviews-thread.html)

Defiant1 07-23-07 10:00 PM


Originally Posted by cupcake jesus
Why is Bumblebee a Camaro and not a VW? I'll give you one guess.

Simple. VW refused the producers from using their car. What did you want them to do? GM stepped up and voila, Bumblebee's a Camaro.


and why, if the organism inhabits the technology of the era, is Megatron a fighter jet, and not a steam engine or tall ship? And if he was trapped in the ice and discovered there (wasn't really clear on this), why isn't he bronze, iron, or stone?
I don't quite get what you mean. Megatron crash landed on Earth and remained in his native Cybertronian form until he was thawed out. He simply didn't bother to adopt a Terran alternate form.

mndtrp 07-23-07 10:36 PM


Originally Posted by Defiant1
I don't quite get what you mean. Megatron crash landed on Earth and remained in his native Cybertronian form until he was thawed out. He simply didn't bother to adopt a Terran alternate form.

I assumed he had more important things on his mind than blending in and hiding.

whoopdido 07-23-07 11:19 PM


Originally Posted by cupcake jesus
This is a reviews thread, so I'm not threadcrapping when I say: I saw the film yesterday, and it is terrible. The Starship Troopers and Men in Black could have been cut out entirely and not missed. The racial stereotyping was disgusting. The product placement offensive. Did HP pay for placement in the first hour, and Apple in the second? Who could forget the memorable XBox and Mountain Dew robots? Why is Bumblebee a Camaro and not a VW? I'll give you one guess.

The filmmakers insulted my intelligence at every turn, and made no effort for a non-fan to enjoy the film. Why bother with science, if logic is thrown out the window? There isn't nearly enough material in any of those vehicles to create these robots, and why, if the organism inhabits the technology of the era, is Megatron a fighter jet, and not a steam engine or tall ship? And if he was trapped in the ice and discovered there (wasn't really clear on this), why isn't he bronze, iron, or stone? Why does Optimus Prime change height based on situation?

I liked LeBouf in general, and enjoyed the one scene where he sees the Bumblebee robot for the first time. There was a Close Encounters/E.T. sense of wonder there, but by that time, the audience knows exactly what's going on, so there's no sense of disorientation. I also liked that Bumblebee had to "talk" using the available technology. I also thought that the kid from Elephant was charming.

I imagine that if there was no nostalgia attached to the brand, nobody would like this movie.

cheers,

-the Jesus

What racial stereotypes exactly?

Legolas 07-24-07 04:04 AM


Originally Posted by whoopdido
What racial stereotypes exactly?

Those who see racism at every corner, thus using the race card as both a sword and a shield, tend to be the real racists.

Draven 07-24-07 07:20 AM


Originally Posted by Defiant1
Simple. VW refused the producers from using their car. What did you want them to do? GM stepped up and voila, Bumblebee's a Camaro.

I pointed out in the initial Transformers thread that they didn't have to use the character of Bumblebee at all. When VW turned them down, they could have easily made him a different character (like Sunstreak) or invented a completely new character. No one needed Bumblebee to be in the movie.

Let's not kid ourselves, the only reason he was a Camaro was for product placement purposes.

Alvis 07-24-07 11:51 AM

Sorry, I can't read through 22 pages to find this. How come Bumblebee can suddenly talk at the end?

Doc MacGyver 07-24-07 11:53 AM


Originally Posted by Alvis
Sorry, I can't read through 22 pages to find this. How come Bumblebee can suddenly talk at the end?

Ratchet had been working on his voice box for a while. He fired that laser thing into it when they first arrived. It did its work by the end.


-Doc

Patman 07-24-07 12:29 PM

It could have been a combo of Ratchet's zap, and Bumblebee dealing with the AllSpark.

Doc MacGyver 07-24-07 12:48 PM


Originally Posted by Patman
It could have been a combo of Ratchet's zap, and Bumblebee dealing with the AllSpark.


word.


-Doc

exharrison 07-24-07 12:51 PM


Originally Posted by Draven
I pointed out in the initial Transformers thread that they didn't have to use the character of Bumblebee at all. When VW turned them down, they could have easily made him a different character (like Sunstreak) or invented a completely new character. No one needed Bumblebee to be in the movie.

Let's not kid ourselves, the only reason he was a Camaro was for product placement purposes.

They wanted Bumblebee because he is well-known and popular. They could have used Hot Rod but probably wanted to save his character for later. He was a Camaro because he couldn't be VW and they could stick with the same brand of cars and it is a car that a high school kid might want.

Doc MacGyver 07-24-07 01:13 PM


Originally Posted by exharrison
They wanted Bumblebee because he is well-known and popular. They could have used Hot Rod but probably wanted to save his character for later. He was a Camaro because he couldn't be VW and they could stick with the same brand of cars and it is a car that a high school kid might want.

I said it before in this thread (and managed to avoid getting castrated) but I actually prefer the movie Bumblebee to the cartoon. Though I would love to see Hot Rod turn up. I know a lot of people hated him, but he was second only to Optimus when I was little. What kind of car would he be though? I could definitely see him being a late model Dodge Charger - Daytona variant, if we're sticking with the American muscle car theme. That big-ass spoiler across his back would be reminiscent of his cartoon look.


-Doc

dan30oly 07-24-07 01:16 PM

I really liked the movie, but if your biggest gripe with the movie is that Bumblebee was a freakin' Camaro (yes, it was product placement, but there are few blockbusters that don't have that these days), then you should feel very happy with the movie.

If you really want something to grip about revolving around the bumblebee character here's this: How did Bernie Mac sell the car to the Whitwickys' without any kind of title or ownership papers???

Doc MacGyver 07-24-07 01:18 PM


Originally Posted by dan30oly
I really liked the movie, but if your biggest gripe with the movie is that Bumblebee was a freakin' Camaro (yes, it was product placement, but there are few blockbusters that don't have that these days), then you should feel very happy with the movie.

If you really want something to grip about revolving around the bumblebee character here's this: How did Bernie Mac sell the car to the Whitwickys' without any kind of title or ownership papers???

That lot was the definition of "shady." I just figured he'd done many below-the-radar, less-than-legal sales in the past and had a way of manufacturing said documents.


-Doc

atari2600 07-24-07 01:25 PM


Originally Posted by dan30oly
I really liked the movie, but if your biggest gripe with the movie is that Bumblebee was a freakin' Camaro (yes, it was product placement, but there are few blockbusters that don't have that these days), then you should feel very happy with the movie.

If you really want something to grip about revolving around the bumblebee character here's this: How did Bernie Mac sell the car to the Whitwickys' without any kind of title or ownership papers???

considering he had never seen that car, he was more than happy to sell it for cash to anyone. it was free money to him.

exharrison 07-24-07 02:18 PM


Originally Posted by Doc MacGyver
I said it before in this thread (and managed to avoid getting castrated) but I actually prefer the movie Bumblebee to the cartoon. Though I would love to see Hot Rod turn up. I know a lot of people hated him, but he was second only to Optimus when I was little. What kind of car would he be though? I could definitely see him being a late model Dodge Charger - Daytona variant, if we're sticking with the American muscle car theme. That big-ass spoiler across his back would be reminiscent of his cartoon look.


-Doc

He would probably be a Corvette so that they can keep it a GM product.


considering he had never seen that car, he was more than happy to sell it for cash to anyone. it was free money to him.
I think he was referring to the issue of the titles. Did the Witwicky's take the car with no papers or did Bernie Mac produce some papers in the back office?

fujishig 07-24-07 02:39 PM


Originally Posted by Mr. Cinema
Transformers continues to rake in the money, proving what a fun, popular film it is with audiences across the nation.

US total: $262.9+ million
foreign: $190.6+ million
total: $453.6+ million

The film still hasn't opened in the UK or Japan markets. It's well on its way to passing the $300 million mark here. Excellent news!


? Didn't it open in Japan before it did in the US?

JPRaup 07-24-07 02:42 PM

These are the opening dates
bolded havent opened yet as of today

Country Date
Italy 21 June 2007 (Taormina Film Festival)
USA 27 June 2007 (Los Angeles Film Festival)
Australia 28 June 2007
Hungary 28 June 2007
Indonesia 28 June 2007
Italy 28 June 2007
Malaysia 28 June 2007
Netherlands 28 June 2007 (limited)
New Zealand 28 June 2007
Singapore 28 June 2007
South Korea 28 June 2007
Taiwan 28 June 2007
Thailand 28 June 2007
Croatia 29 June 2007 (Zagreb)
Finland 29 June 2007 (limited)
Canada 2 July 2007
USA 3 July 2007
Belgium 4 July 2007 (Wilkinson American Movie Day) (premiere)
Denmark 4 July 2007
Egypt 4 July 2007
Finland 4 July 2007
Kuwait 4 July 2007
Netherlands 4 July 2007
Norway 4 July 2007
Russia 4 July 2007
Spain 4 July 2007
Sweden 4 July 2007
Bahrain 5 July 2007
Portugal 5 July 2007
Bulgaria 6 July 2007
Turkey 6 July 2007
Lithuania 7 July 2007
China 11 July 2007
Greece 12 July 2007
Israel 12 July 2007
Brazil 18 July 2007
Argentina 19 July 2007
Chile 19 July 2007
Panama 19 July 2007
Colombia 20 July 2007
Mexico 20 July 2007
Venezuela 20 July 2007
Belgium 25 July 2007
France 25 July 2007
Japan 25 July 2007 (Chiyoda, Tokyo) (premiere)
Switzerland 25 July 2007 (French speaking region)
Hong Kong 26 July 2007
UK 27 July 2007
Germany 2 August 2007
Austria 3 August 2007
Estonia 3 August 2007
India 4 August 2007
Japan 4 August 2007
Iceland 10 August 2007
Slovakia 16 August 2007
Slovenia 16 August 2007
India 17 August 2007
Poland 17 August 2007

Doc MacGyver 07-24-07 03:02 PM


Originally Posted by exharrison
He would probably be a Corvette so that they can keep it a GM product.?

Sunstreak's a corvette already. If you want to use the 'vette, just go with the character that already is one. Besides, the 'vette is a little girly for Hot Rod.


Originally Posted by exharrison
I think he was referring to the issue of the titles. Did the Witwicky's take the car with no papers or did Bernie Mac produce some papers in the back office?

That second quote wasn't from me. I addressed my (albeit baseless) assumption on the titles here:


Originally Posted by ME
That lot was the definition of "shady." I just figured he'd done many below-the-radar, less-than-legal sales in the past and had a way of manufacturing said documents.


-Doc

exharrison 07-24-07 03:28 PM


Originally Posted by Doc MacGyver
Sunstreak's a corvette already. If you want to use the 'vette, just go with the character that already is one. Besides, the 'vette is a little girly for Hot Rod.

Good point. What would you make him out of the GM line?


That second quote wasn't from me.
-Doc
Sorry, I just used the quote function and forgot to add the user to it.

Doc MacGyver 07-24-07 03:34 PM

No worries! As to what GM car I would make Hot Rod... I don't know. I can't really think of any (other than the Camaro, ironically) that would fit him... If they still made the Firebird it would work. They'll have more money for the sequel, why not more endoresements? Optimus wasn't GM, so it doesn't necessarily have to exclusively GM. I'm still going with the Daytona.

-Doc

orderandlaw 07-24-07 07:01 PM

Scott Ramsoomair of VGCats sums up my feeling quite well.

http://www.vgcats.com/comics/?strip_id=241

mikehunt 07-24-07 07:49 PM


Originally Posted by Alvis
Sorry, I can't read through 22 pages to find this. How come Bumblebee can suddenly talk at the end?

and what did he say. for some reason that bit of dialog had so little volume that I didn't make out what he said

exharrison 07-24-07 08:08 PM


Originally Posted by Doc MacGyver
No worries! As to what GM car I would make Hot Rod... I don't know. I can't really think of any (other than the Camaro, ironically) that would fit him... If they still made the Firebird it would work. They'll have more money for the sequel, why not more endoresements? Optimus wasn't GM, so it doesn't necessarily have to exclusively GM. I'm still going with the Daytona.

-Doc

Its true that Optimus wasn't, but the rest were part of a deal, so I would expect they would keep all characters that could be portrayed by a GM car as one. Optimus wasn't GM because he had to be big.

Alvis 07-24-07 08:10 PM


Originally Posted by mikehunt
and what did he say. for some reason that bit of dialog had so little volume that I didn't make out what he said

"I want to stay with Sam," or something like that.

dan30oly 07-24-07 08:30 PM

yeah, that was the another thing that really bothered me about this movie and Bay's "A boy and his car" theme.

They really couldn't come up with a better reason to stay on Earth than Bumble Bee having a thing for Sam??? Lame.

Overall, still a great movie despite much lameness.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 10:04 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.