DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   HD Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/hd-talk-55/)
-   -   Star Wars (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/hd-talk/577990-star-wars.html)

Anubis2005X 08-31-11 12:00 PM

re: Star Wars
 
Do we know if there are any alterations to the prequels? I don't care about 'em, I'm just curious...

leem6453 08-31-11 12:02 PM

re: Star Wars
 
I never thought I’d say this, but I think I’m leaning toward canceling my order now…if these reports are true. That Vader “noooo” cry sounds like a joke, which I hope it is. But I wouldn’t doubt it if Lucas did put it in there. Truly sad indeed.

I’ll just hold on to my 2006 DVD releases. Also I found a way to make the UOT anamorphic…I just convert them to XVID using AutoGK and plug my external into my HDTV and they are truly anamorphic…awesome. I just wish the quality was up to par, but they’re still very watchable. I also have Adywan’s cut which is awesome.

Boba Fett 08-31-11 12:03 PM

re: Star Wars
 
As far as canceling pre-orders go, I'm still on the fence but leaning towards it solely because the usage of a one to two frame color fix in a press release is borderline consumer fraud. I'm more angry about the shoddy technical fixes or lack thereof than anything else.

I was always intending on buying the 9-Disc set solely to have Empire in HD as it's my all time favorite film and it appears again, it escapes almost entirely unscathed.

The bonus features were the draw as a fan and to be completely honest, the versions of the movie I watch on DVD now are: Adywan's Cut, the 2004 cut of Empire and the non-anamorphic Jedi (Jedi Rocks is too much to stomach).

That said, I'll likely cancel the pre-order unless reports of how good the bonus features are/how many deleted scenes are truly included. I honestly feel guilty shelling out money for the archival stuff because Lucasfilm/Fox does interpret that as approval of sub-par work.

All in all though, Lucas can keep tinkering, he obviously has something to over compensate, but he can't erase the unaltered versions from my memory nor existence as they are out there on the Internet and this Blu-Ray release looks like one argument in favor of piracy.

Kal-El 08-31-11 12:26 PM

re: Star Wars
 
Can't believe I'm saying this myself but when the reviews come out and these changes are confirmed...I really might just cancel my pre-order.

Supermallet 08-31-11 12:35 PM

re: Star Wars
 
I am losing respect for anyone who buys this set. Don't let Lucas win again.

stingermck 08-31-11 12:39 PM

re: Star Wars
 
George's daughter is aware:


KRLgrrlKatie Lucas

@swankmotron @StarWars thank you for posting that. this alteration nonsense is bothering me.

17 minutes ago

Supermallet 08-31-11 12:44 PM

re: Star Wars
 
I think Lucas' family and friends (i.e. Spielberg) need to stage an intervention.

Bob_Bobbson 08-31-11 12:45 PM

re: Star Wars
 

Originally Posted by Kal-El (Post 10907609)
Can't believe I'm saying this myself but when the reviews come out and these changes are confirmed...I really might just cancel my pre-order.

Me too. As soon as I see some sort of confirmation (Either a statement from Lucasfilm or a review), I am cancelling my pre-order.

Also, there is something that I am going to do, that I would love if all the people cancelling (who have a twitter) would do. As soon as I cancel my order, I am going to tweet @Starwars and tell Lucasfilm that I did and why.

I'm sure that they aren't going to care, but it's worth a try.

Ranger 08-31-11 12:47 PM

re: Star Wars
 
So there is still hope if Katie doesn't like changes!

BTW, Spike TV has the Star Wars marathon this Labor Day weekend.
Schedule: http://www.theforce.net/latestnews/s...ves_140303.asp

Nick Martin 08-31-11 12:59 PM

re: Star Wars
 

Originally Posted by Ranger (Post 10907644)
So there is still hope if Katie doesn't like changes!


Ummm....you know she's saying she's annoyed by people complaining about the changes, not the changes themselves, right?

I mean come on, this is the "haters gonna hate" girl who apparently picked out the cover art.

That Bryan Young who tweeted about it wrote an article basically berating people who don't suck Lucas off so he's hardly anyone worth paying much attention to about this.

pinata242 08-31-11 12:59 PM

re: Star Wars
 

Originally Posted by Ranger (Post 10907644)
So there is still hope if Katie doesn't like changes!

You read her comment that she thinks the alterations are nonsense?

Because I read them that she thinks that people complaining about the alterations is what is nonsense.

In other words - she's definitely not on my side.

Boba Fett 08-31-11 01:00 PM

re: Star Wars
 

Originally Posted by Supermallet (Post 10907639)
I think Lucas' family and friends (i.e. Spielberg) need to stage an intervention.

Better yet, just send Ridley Scott and Harrison Ford over to the Ranch with a Blu-Ray of BLADE RUNNER to show him how it's done.

If that doesn't work, they let Rutger Hauer in the room and lock the door on the way out.

Boba Fett 08-31-11 01:05 PM

re: Star Wars
 

Originally Posted by pinata242 (Post 10907666)
You read her comment that she thinks the alterations are nonsense?

Because I read them that she thinks that people complaining about the alterations is what is nonsense.

In other words - she's definitely not on my side.

This.

I've read her tweets before and once joked that I now realized the prequels weren't the worst things Lucas created.

Then I found out she and the rest of his kids were adopted.

If I were a lesser man, I'd say Lucas is such a poor director he couldn't even direct a pregnancy.

PopcornTreeCt 08-31-11 01:08 PM

re: Star Wars
 
The thing that I think is funny is that Lucas has to know that these will be the least watched versions of his films and he just went nuts with them.

story 08-31-11 01:08 PM

re: Star Wars
 
Maybe I should place a pre-order so I can cancel it to send a better message than my so-far choice of not ordering whatsoever.

Ranger 08-31-11 01:10 PM

re: Star Wars
 
Well, I read the tweet as someone showing her a link of the 'nooo' video and she didn't like it. Don't ruin it for me!

boogieman03 08-31-11 01:10 PM

re: Star Wars
 

Originally Posted by Boba Fett (Post 10907684)

If I were a lesser man, I'd say Lucas is such a poor director he couldn't even direct a pregnancy.

rotfl

NAILS!

Doctorossi 08-31-11 01:24 PM

re: Star Wars
 

Originally Posted by Boba Fett (Post 10907684)
If I were a lesser man, I'd say Lucas is such a poor director he couldn't even direct a pregnancy.

Good thing you're too classy to say something like that! ;)

Nick Martin 08-31-11 01:31 PM

re: Star Wars
 

Originally Posted by Doctorossi (Post 10907717)
Good thing you're too classy to say something like that! ;)


That's why Boba Fett is badass.

Anubis2005X 08-31-11 01:34 PM

re: Star Wars
 
Yup, Katie, film preservation is complete NON-SENSE, ughhh...

Matt 08-31-11 01:57 PM

re: Star Wars
 

On Wednesday, a press representative for Lucasfilm confirmed that this change will be included in the Blu-ray release, writing in an email: “Yes—Darth says NO.”
New York Times: Lucasfilm Confirms Change to Blu-ray Release of ‘Return of the Jedi’

Mazje 08-31-11 02:12 PM

re: Star Wars
 
Done. Pre-order canceled. Thanks.

Mazje 08-31-11 02:17 PM

re: Star Wars
 
Amazon has the little form of "Why" when you cancel. I checked "Other" and commented "Product not as promised. I will not be ordering from anywhere. Amazon lost a sale due to Lucasfilm."

AnonomusBob15 08-31-11 02:25 PM

re: Star Wars
 

Originally Posted by Mazje (Post 10907793)
Amazon has the little form of "Why" when you cancel. I checked "Other" and commented "Product not as promised. I will not be ordering from anywhere. Amazon lost a sale due to Lucasfilm."


No promises were made. In fact, you knew Lucas would make more changes. Instead of making new films, Lucas just decides to update his old ones. His creative well ran dry.

Drexl 08-31-11 02:27 PM

re: Star Wars
 

Originally Posted by Boba Fett (Post 10907684)
If I were a lesser man, I'd say Lucas is such a poor director he couldn't even direct a pregnancy.

The pregnancy he can handle. But then he has to constantly change the baby's outfit.

I wonder if that ROTJ thing will become a meme, spawning videos of scenes from other movies with "noooooo" added whenever a character gets saved from death.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 10:39 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.