DVD Talk Forum
Page 84 of 178
« First
34
74
82
83
84
85
86
94
134
Last »
Show 40 post(s) from this thread on one page

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   HD Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/hd-talk-55/)
-   -   Star Wars (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/hd-talk/577990-star-wars.html)

Anubis2005X 08-31-11 04:42 PM
re: Star Wars
 
I'm tired of George's tinkering, but I'll still be buying these. At least they fixed a few things like the music in the trench run...

Ignohippo 08-31-11 04:42 PM
re: Star Wars
 
Originally Posted by pinata242 (Post 10907973)
Except this thread alone shows there's already a declining return on his meddlings.

I agree he plans to at some point, but it's a stretch of you to come in here and say "we". "We" ain't doin' shit.

BS. Eventually most people on here will buy them anyway.

pinata242 08-31-11 04:48 PM
re: Star Wars
 
Originally Posted by Ignohippo (Post 10908000)
BS. Eventually most people on here will buy them anyway.
Not I. I guarantee you.

dan30oly 08-31-11 04:51 PM
re: Star Wars
 
I just got around to cancelling my amazon pre-order.

Reason: Other.
Explanation: George Lucas is a douche.


I will likely be picking them up in the future. However, I won't pay more than $30 for this set.

bunkaroo 08-31-11 04:51 PM
re: Star Wars
 
Another thing the NO change does is piss on the fantastic musical tension there. Tension is building and building, and then bam, you get the Force theme and right there is the release and Vader finally redeems himself. You don't need cobbled together dialogue to tell us what imagery and music already tell us.

story 08-31-11 04:57 PM
re: Star Wars
 
Originally Posted by dogmatica (Post 10907688)
Maybe I should place a pre-order so I can cancel it to send a better message than my so-far choice of not ordering whatsoever.
I'm serious. Does anyone have a thought on this?

Travis McClain 08-31-11 05:02 PM
re: Star Wars
 
Originally Posted by bunkaroo (Post 10908012)
Another thing the NO change does is piss on the fantastic musical tension there. Tension is building and building, and then bam, you get the Force theme and right there is the release and Vader finally redeems himself. You don't need cobbled together dialogue to tell us what imagery and music already tell us.
That was always one of my favorite uses of the Force theme, too.

Originally Posted by dogmatica (Post 10908018)
I'm serious. Does anyone have a thought on this?
Um, yeah. My thought is that if you want to do it, you should do it. And if you don't really want to do it, then...don't.

It dawned on me earlier that I still want the Star Trek movie Blu-ray boxes. I missed out on the sales Amazon ran in the last month on each of those, but I'm hopeful maybe they'll run them again at those prices (or lower) for Black Friday. So, yeah, Star Wars has been seriously downgraded on my To Get list. In fact, I'm about to unsubscribe from this thread and just get away from all of this for a while. It's been a (mostly) fun debate even if we haven't really covered anything new, though I do thank those of you who shared links to comprehensive articles, interviews, etc. about the history of the series. There was a lot of neat stuff in those and I enjoyed reading them.

Supermallet 08-31-11 05:04 PM
re: Star Wars
 
Originally Posted by dogmatica (Post 10908018)
I'm serious. Does anyone have a thought on this?
I don't think canceled pre-orders mean shit. Total sales numbers is all that matters.

dan30oly 08-31-11 05:10 PM
re: Star Wars
 
Originally Posted by Supermallet (Post 10908026)
I don't think canceled pre-orders mean shit. Total sales numbers is all that matters.
I'm fairly certain that the sound of thousands of pre-orders being extinguished all at once will be felt by someone.

Bob_Bobbson 08-31-11 05:12 PM
re: Star Wars
 
Originally Posted by Ignohippo (Post 10908000)
BS. Eventually most people on here will buy them anyway.
Nope.

Part of the reason I'm cancelling is because I realized that after all these changes, every time I want to watch the movies I'll just pull out the unaltered 'bonus' DVDs anyway.

It's sort of a waste of money if I'm never going to watch them.

Supermallet 08-31-11 05:25 PM
re: Star Wars
 
Originally Posted by dan30oly (Post 10908037)
I'm fairly certain that the sound of thousands of pre-orders being extinguished all at once will be felt by someone.
My response to that would have to be...Noooooooo!

mcnabb 08-31-11 05:27 PM
re: Star Wars
 
I just want to make sure that the change in Jedi is not a practical joke??? Does Vader really say NOOO when he throws the Emperor down the shoot?

Jedi was the weakest of the OT to begin with, but Lucas continues to fuck that movie up even more. Geez, with the new Jedi Rocks and addition to Hayden as a force ghost, the movie is slowly moving towards Prequel quality at this point.

The Valeyard 08-31-11 05:51 PM
re: Star Wars
 
Originally Posted by Ignohippo (Post 10908000)
BS. Eventually most people on here will buy them anyway.
Proud to say my house will remain Star Wars Saga Blu-Ray Free for a very long time (unless the Unaltered OT is released......which will never happen).

You're more than welcome to pop by anytime in the future to check.

yoshimi 08-31-11 05:59 PM
re: Star Wars
 
These will still sell a gazillion copies.

Maxflier 08-31-11 06:03 PM
re: Star Wars
 
Originally Posted by yoshimi (Post 10908094)
These will still sell a gazillion copies.
True. But it could have sold 2 gazillion copies.

LosingMyMind 08-31-11 06:03 PM
re: Star Wars
 
This are the definitive versions of the movies (up to this point.) No way am I passing these up :)

MTRodaba2468 08-31-11 06:08 PM
re: Star Wars
 
Originally Posted by Obi-Wan Kenobi
I felt a great disturbance in the Force, as if millions of pre-sales suddenly cried out in terror and were suddenly silenced.

DieselsDen 08-31-11 06:09 PM
re: Star Wars
 
I don't see what's the big deal about the "No....NOOOOOOO!" Just mute the sound when scene occurs. So simple.

rennervision 08-31-11 06:13 PM
re: Star Wars
 
Originally Posted by mcnabb (Post 10908058)
Jedi was the weakest of the OT to begin with, but Lucas continues to fuck that movie up even more. Geez, with the new Jedi Rocks and addition to Hayden as a force ghost, the movie is slowly moving towards Prequel quality at this point.
Exactly. ROTJ is my least favorite, but it had a few scenes that served as powerful moments for the entire trilogy. Somehow, Lucas has managed to ruin practically every one of those - now making this movie utterly unwatchable. I would say the only thing left is Luke's initial dialogue with his father on Endor, where Vader resists Luke's plea to return to the good side. Wonder what CGI marvel Lucas will add to that scene in the next release?

mcnabb 08-31-11 06:36 PM
re: Star Wars
 
Originally Posted by DieselsDen (Post 10908104)
I don't see what's the big deal about the "No....NOOOOOOO!" Just mute the sound when scene occurs. So simple.
Thats a ringing endorsement to the final climatic scene that sums up either the Star Wars Trilogy or Star Wars Saga (depending on your perspective):

Mute it!

K&AJones 08-31-11 06:36 PM
re: Star Wars
 
Originally Posted by yoshimi (Post 10906825)
I'm also beginning to wonder where I can find a quality VCR and track down the widescreen, THX VHS box from '95. I might just recreate Christmas 1995 this year! :)
I just picked up some nice copies for $9 the other day. Lucas will have to pry them from my dead cold hands.[/QUOTE]

I think I actually still have this somewhere...and even a VCR. Now if I can just remember how to operate it...

Mazje 08-31-11 06:37 PM
re: Star Wars
 
I canceled my preorder and left a one star review at about three o'clock. There were 130 or so one star reviews. Now I see it's up to 160. The rating is at 3 stars. I realize it probably won't end up making a difference, but it's at least sending a message.

LosingMyMind 08-31-11 06:42 PM
re: Star Wars
 
Originally Posted by Mazje (Post 10908128)
I canceled my preorder and left a one star review at about three o'clock. There were 130 or so one star reviews. Now I see it's up to 160. The rating is at 3 stars. I realize it probably won't end up making a difference, but it's at least sending a message.
LOL I'll go rate it 5 stars now :)

Mazje 08-31-11 06:47 PM
re: Star Wars
 
Oh yeah, then I'll go back and rate it 3 stars! Then neither one of us will be happy!

Wait a minute...

Guru Askew 08-31-11 06:52 PM
re: Star Wars
 
Originally Posted by Mazje (Post 10908128)
I canceled my preorder and left a one star review at about three o'clock. There were 130 or so one star reviews. Now I see it's up to 160. The rating is at 3 stars. I realize it probably won't end up making a difference, but it's at least sending a message.
Yeah, a message that you could fit everybody leaving 1-star reviews into the smaller conference room at the Holiday Inn.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 03:03 AM.
Page 84 of 178
« First
34
74
82
83
84
85
86
94
134
Last »
Show 40 post(s) from this thread on one page


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.