Star Wars
#3126
DVD Talk Limited Edition
re: Star Wars
I got the Alien set when the price dipped to 50% of MSRP. I later bought the individual releases for 1 and 2....why I did this, I do not know. Those two are really all I need, yet I still can't bring myself to part with the set, as it's such a beautiful presentation.
#3127
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
re: Star Wars
Take this for what it's worth, but a friend of a friend who works at Lowry Digital said that after finishing the Indiana Jones 4K restoration, they are now working on a "new Star Wars 4K restoration"
#3129
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
re: Star Wars
I hated to bring back this thread but wanted to see if anyone with both the DVD and BR sets could answer this or at least have a good guess.
While looking for the SW: Clone Wars sets on Amazon I noticed something that caught my eye on the orinials released in DVD format....high prices for the 1997 and 2004 releases. Even the The Phantom Menance 2-Disc WS Eddition new comes in at $68.00 now. The 1977 LE WS New Hope is at $99.00!!. the 1977 Trilogy Set is at a whopping $319.00!
I haven't got the new BR version but thought about once-in-awhile. I have the Phanton Menance and Revenge of the Sith on DVD WS and even have the 2004 4-Disc Trilogy Set (new showing at $190.00).
Wasn't there much discussion about not just the PQ but certain scenes and CGI added to the newer releases that caused some SW fans to voice some concern? i wasn't sure why the commanding high prices for the older DVD versions over the BR, just didn't make much sense unless I was missing something. Thanks for the input and I guess I'll lock away my DVD copies now.
While looking for the SW: Clone Wars sets on Amazon I noticed something that caught my eye on the orinials released in DVD format....high prices for the 1997 and 2004 releases. Even the The Phantom Menance 2-Disc WS Eddition new comes in at $68.00 now. The 1977 LE WS New Hope is at $99.00!!. the 1977 Trilogy Set is at a whopping $319.00!
I haven't got the new BR version but thought about once-in-awhile. I have the Phanton Menance and Revenge of the Sith on DVD WS and even have the 2004 4-Disc Trilogy Set (new showing at $190.00).
Wasn't there much discussion about not just the PQ but certain scenes and CGI added to the newer releases that caused some SW fans to voice some concern? i wasn't sure why the commanding high prices for the older DVD versions over the BR, just didn't make much sense unless I was missing something. Thanks for the input and I guess I'll lock away my DVD copies now.
#3132
DVD Talk Legend
re: Star Wars
While looking for the SW: Clone Wars sets on Amazon I noticed something that caught my eye on the orinials released in DVD format....high prices for the 1997 and 2004 releases. Even the The Phantom Menance 2-Disc WS Eddition new comes in at $68.00 now. The 1977 LE WS New Hope is at $99.00!!. the 1977 Trilogy Set is at a whopping $319.00!
That said, it looks like all the DVD editions are out of print. So the rising prices could be because people want a DVD copy of these films instead of the Blu-ray, for whatever reason. Also, the LE DVDs of the original trilogy are currently still the only way to get the original unaltered versions of those films officially on DVD, so those are likely to command a higher price.
#3133
DVD Talk Limited Edition
re: Star Wars
Shows the high demand for an un-effed-with Original Trilogy.
#3135
DVD Talk Limited Edition
re: Star Wars
Has anyone caved on buying these Blurays that didn't get them when they first came out? I've still held off and don't plan to anytime soon.
#3136
DVD Talk Legend
#3137
Suspended
re: Star Wars
I hated to bring back this thread but wanted to see if anyone with both the DVD and BR sets could answer this or at least have a good guess.
While looking for the SW: Clone Wars sets on Amazon I noticed something that caught my eye on the orinials released in DVD format....high prices for the 1997 and 2004 releases. Even the The Phantom Menance 2-Disc WS Eddition new comes in at $68.00 now. The 1977 LE WS New Hope is at $99.00!!. the 1977 Trilogy Set is at a whopping $319.00!
I haven't got the new BR version but thought about once-in-awhile. I have the Phanton Menance and Revenge of the Sith on DVD WS and even have the 2004 4-Disc Trilogy Set (new showing at $190.00).
Wasn't there much discussion about not just the PQ but certain scenes and CGI added to the newer releases that caused some SW fans to voice some concern? i wasn't sure why the commanding high prices for the older DVD versions over the BR, just didn't make much sense unless I was missing something. Thanks for the input and I guess I'll lock away my DVD copies now.
While looking for the SW: Clone Wars sets on Amazon I noticed something that caught my eye on the orinials released in DVD format....high prices for the 1997 and 2004 releases. Even the The Phantom Menance 2-Disc WS Eddition new comes in at $68.00 now. The 1977 LE WS New Hope is at $99.00!!. the 1977 Trilogy Set is at a whopping $319.00!
I haven't got the new BR version but thought about once-in-awhile. I have the Phanton Menance and Revenge of the Sith on DVD WS and even have the 2004 4-Disc Trilogy Set (new showing at $190.00).
Wasn't there much discussion about not just the PQ but certain scenes and CGI added to the newer releases that caused some SW fans to voice some concern? i wasn't sure why the commanding high prices for the older DVD versions over the BR, just didn't make much sense unless I was missing something. Thanks for the input and I guess I'll lock away my DVD copies now.
You wander on to it and go "WOW! THEY ARE SELLING FOR $250!!!!".
See how that works?
You're going off prices of stuff no one has likely ever purchased. Go to eBay and see the true value. While these DVDs have "retained" (i.e. might sell for their original sale prices, not exceeded) their value, they are certainly not going for as much as Amazon would like you to believe. Plus, "sealed" copies sometimes go for more simply because people like to collect them.
The 4 disc 2004 set is going for about $50ish on eBay opened and complete.
Don't judge the marketplace from Amazon third party sellers. You will be very disappointed.
#3138
Suspended
#3139
DVD Talk Legend
#3140
Senior Member
Joined: Jun 2011
Posts: 862
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: The Cabin in the Woods
#3141
DVD Talk Legend
re: Star Wars
No. We got the DVd's for my son when they were released and that's good enough. One day when he's moved out, if they have a BR set of the OOT I'd consider picking it up but these were never really huge favorites anyway. The best part was going the to theatrical rereleases with my son more than the movies themselves
#3142
Banned
Joined: Apr 2008
Posts: 39,239
Likes: 0
Received 6 Likes
on
6 Posts
From: Formerly known as "Solid Snake PAC"/Denton, Tx
re: Star Wars
Not really a SW fan but I won't deny that SW and ESB are damn fine movies. ROTJ has it's issues but it's alright. I'll buy something SW related when those 3 come unaltered.
#3143
DVD Talk Godfather
re: Star Wars
On that note, I watched SW and it looked breathtaking. Amazing pic quality.
*or whatever you want to call it
#3144
DVD Talk Hero
re: Star Wars
Still haven't gotten them. I have the 2004 trilogy DVD set and for now that's good enough. Now that Disney owns Star Wars if they ever decide to release the unaltered original trilogy I'll get them.
#3145
DVD Talk Legend
re: Star Wars
#3146
DVD Talk Legend
re: Star Wars
#3147
Senior Member
Joined: Jul 2002
Posts: 825
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: SoCal
re: Star Wars
I did rent SW to see if the explosions had been fixed (they desaturate into black and white) and while the picture looked good- it wasn't good enough.
I might buy a single of ESB if it appears, but the DVDs are good enough.
And as an side, the scene where Vader throws the Emperor off the ledge works better when Vader says nothing. I saw the scene on cable last night- even cable knows which version is better.
#3148
DVD Talk Limited Edition
re: Star Wars
I do own the DVDs sets being discussed on this page with the bonus discs of the OOT. With upscaling, zooming, and a little imagination, they look just fine.
#3149
DVD Talk Legend
re: Star Wars
#3150
DVD Talk Limited Edition



