Blu-ray Disc Player Thread
#526
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Joined: Dec 2001
Posts: 2,575
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
http://www.amazon.com/Playstation-3-...6545374&sr=8-1
$460.91 for the PS3, Blu-ray remote, and extra Dualshock controller
Buy any Sony Blu-ray Set Top Player or PS3, and any 2 Sony Blu-ray discs, and receive any 2 additional Sony Blu-ray discs free:
http://www.amazon.com/gp/feature.htm...d_i=B001COU9I6
While it says 'any' Sony Blu-ray, they only list about 1 page of Blu-rays. I don't know if it would really work with 'any' Sony Blu-ray or just the ones listed.
#528
Suspended
#529
DVD Talk Hero
#531
DVD Talk Hero
#532
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Well, I finally pulled the trigger on a Blu-Ray player. Picked up Best Buy's Insignia branded player (newest version with ethernet and USB). It's hooked up via HDMI direct to my television (Sony 51" LCD Projection) and coax to my receiver. I also picked up Wall-E (2-Disc).
Now, my set is 1080i, and while it looked great I wasn't wowed like I thought I would be. Looking at Blu-Ray demos in store the image looked almost 3 dimensional. Now, those were were all live action movies-Iron Man and Pirates of the Caribbean specifically- being displayed on the latest LCD screens.
Now I am planning on picking up Tropic Thunder this evening to compare. Now, don't get me wrong, the image is crystal clear and at times during Wall-e it did take on an almost 3d look. Is the difference I think I am seeing due to my display resolution, projection type or am I just nuts?? Also, I've been watching hi-def content since the first set-top boxes came out years ago, so maybe I am just used to it.
Now, my set is 1080i, and while it looked great I wasn't wowed like I thought I would be. Looking at Blu-Ray demos in store the image looked almost 3 dimensional. Now, those were were all live action movies-Iron Man and Pirates of the Caribbean specifically- being displayed on the latest LCD screens.
Now I am planning on picking up Tropic Thunder this evening to compare. Now, don't get me wrong, the image is crystal clear and at times during Wall-e it did take on an almost 3d look. Is the difference I think I am seeing due to my display resolution, projection type or am I just nuts?? Also, I've been watching hi-def content since the first set-top boxes came out years ago, so maybe I am just used to it.
#533
DVD Talk Legend
Just out of curiosity, did the motion look smoother on those in-store sets? Like a video game that runs at 60fps instead of 30fps? I'm wondering if what you saw in the store was the motion interpolation feature that 120Hz LCDs have.
#534
DVD Talk Reviewer
Joined: Feb 2001
Posts: 7,834
Received 52 Likes
on
44 Posts
From: Formerly known as "12thmonkey"/Frankfort, IL
Well, I finally pulled the trigger on a Blu-Ray player. Picked up Best Buy's Insignia branded player (newest version with ethernet and USB). It's hooked up via HDMI direct to my television (Sony 51" LCD Projection) and coax to my receiver. I also picked up Wall-E (2-Disc).
Now, my set is 1080i, and while it looked great I wasn't wowed like I thought I would be. Looking at Blu-Ray demos in store the image looked almost 3 dimensional. Now, those were were all live action movies-Iron Man and Pirates of the Caribbean specifically- being displayed on the latest LCD screens.
Now I am planning on picking up Tropic Thunder this evening to compare. Now, don't get me wrong, the image is crystal clear and at times during Wall-e it did take on an almost 3d look. Is the difference I think I am seeing due to my display resolution, projection type or am I just nuts?? Also, I've been watching hi-def content since the first set-top boxes came out years ago, so maybe I am just used to it.
Now, my set is 1080i, and while it looked great I wasn't wowed like I thought I would be. Looking at Blu-Ray demos in store the image looked almost 3 dimensional. Now, those were were all live action movies-Iron Man and Pirates of the Caribbean specifically- being displayed on the latest LCD screens.
Now I am planning on picking up Tropic Thunder this evening to compare. Now, don't get me wrong, the image is crystal clear and at times during Wall-e it did take on an almost 3d look. Is the difference I think I am seeing due to my display resolution, projection type or am I just nuts?? Also, I've been watching hi-def content since the first set-top boxes came out years ago, so maybe I am just used to it.

I've yet to go Blu, but I did get an HD-DVD player last year. My plasma is a 1080i, and I've been wowed by some of the HD titles (Transformers and Sky Captain, for example). But, just like standard DVD, not all transfers are stunners I guess, but I would think Wall-E would be impressive. I know I'm floored by the SD quality of Finding Nemo on my set.
I plan on picking of the Sony 550 within a couple of weeks...
Last edited by Pointyskull; 11-20-08 at 08:23 AM.
#535
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
While your picture is good, my assumptions for your poorer than expected video quality is:
1) 1080i set
2) Insignia player
1) 1080i set
2) Insignia player
#536
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Well, maybe I'm explaining it wrong. The picture is nowhere near poor. It is crystal clear and extremely detailed.
I'm wondering if the live action stuff just looked better because I'm not used to seeing that much detail on regular DVD (and face it, aside from MGMHD and HDnet Movies, most movie channels crop their HD movies so you might not be seeing them at their best). I expect crystal clear from CG animated movies, not so much from filmed content.
#537
DVD Talk Limited Edition
It sounds like you experienced what I did - I've had HD Cable for about 4+ years, and I wasn't blown away by Blu-ray as much as others who previously didn't have HD in their homes. I remember the first time my cable company installed my HD cable box, and just being amazed by the visuals.
#538
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
It sounds like you experienced what I did - I've had HD Cable for about 4+ years, and I wasn't blown away by Blu-ray as much as others who previously didn't have HD in their homes. I remember the first time my cable company installed my HD cable box, and just being amazed by the visuals.
Edit:
Well, picked up a Samsung 46" 120hz 1080p set...and now...WOW! Hated losing the extra size of my Sony set, but I'd say it's a good trade-off.
Last edited by SmackDaddy; 11-21-08 at 05:28 PM.
#539
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Received my $75 check from LG today. Took a week after they called me last Monday to confirm the info I had emailed them.
#540
DVD Talk Legend
Ok guys, I need some help here. I have a PS3 for a player on one TV but now I'm looking to get a stand alone for my other tv. Being the Sony whore that I am my choices are the 350 and the 550. At $305 is the 550 worth it over the under then $200 black Friday deals on the 350?
I don't currently have use for all the audio decoders but the load time would be a factor for me.
I don't currently have use for all the audio decoders but the load time would be a factor for me.
#541
Senior Member
Ok guys, I need some help here. I have a PS3 for a player on one TV but now I'm looking to get a stand alone for my other tv. Being the Sony whore that I am my choices are the 350 and the 550. At $305 is the 550 worth it over the under then $200 black Friday deals on the 350?
I don't currently have use for all the audio decoders but the load time would be a factor for me.
I don't currently have use for all the audio decoders but the load time would be a factor for me.
A) no DVIX
B) no region hack
Those two things are also factors for me. My TV is 720p, so I really haven't been in a MAJOR hurry to switch (especially with the ridiculous player/disc prices of BR). That said I'm already starting to grab some BR discs when I find good deals. Hope there's a player on the market soon that fits my price/size/DIVX/region hack requirements.
#543
DVD Talk Legend
Ok guys, I need some help here. I have a PS3 for a player on one TV but now I'm looking to get a stand alone for my other tv. Being the Sony whore that I am my choices are the 350 and the 550. At $305 is the 550 worth it over the under then $200 black Friday deals on the 350?
I don't currently have use for all the audio decoders but the load time would be a factor for me.
I don't currently have use for all the audio decoders but the load time would be a factor for me.
Last edited by Sweet Baby James; 11-26-08 at 10:49 PM.
#545
DVD Talk Legend
#546
Member
Joined: Oct 2002
Posts: 85
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Is there any reason why you won't try Panasonic? The reviews that I have read all favor the 35 over the 350. Costco will have the 35 on sale for $199.99 December 5 through the 14th. It includes an HDMI cable and you would get Ratatouille and Nightmare Before Christmas via a mail-in rebate. Good luck.
#547
DVD Talk Legend
The $80 off deal applies to item numbers 359646 and 301111. Someone at AVS stated that item number 301111 is the Panasonic DMP-BD30 player(makes sense-30xxxx for this player, 35xxxx for the 35 player). If true, the price for the DMP-BD30 player will be $119.99($199.99 regular price less the discount). I know that this is last year's model and is Profile 1.1, but 120 clams is damn tempting! To answer your question, I'm pretty sure that those stores won't match a membership wharehouse store like Costco.
#548
Senior Member
Joined: Sep 2000
Posts: 341
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Irving, TX
350: HDMI connection
550: 7.1 Analog connections
If you have a receiver with HDMI - go 350. If not, go 550.
So I'ma be at Sears bright & early to get a 350. No KMart in Dallas that I can find. Where else is it rumored to be under $200?
#549
DVD Talk Reviewer
Joined: Feb 2001
Posts: 7,834
Received 52 Likes
on
44 Posts
From: Formerly known as "12thmonkey"/Frankfort, IL
Picked up the 350 at K-Mart this morning for $179...... 
Got there around 6:30, and was number 16 out of 30. Looked like the big items were Wii/Guitar Hero/Rock Band stuff

Got there around 6:30, and was number 16 out of 30. Looked like the big items were Wii/Guitar Hero/Rock Band stuff
#550
Per SlickDeals... http://www.sonystyle.com/webapp/wcs/...52921665368427
Sony S350 for $200 - $50 with coupon code DISCOVER50BR = $150 plus free shipping.
(sorry to rain on your parade, 12thmonkey
)
Sony S350 for $200 - $50 with coupon code DISCOVER50BR = $150 plus free shipping.
(sorry to rain on your parade, 12thmonkey
)



