I'll play.

Best

Memento - Limited Edition (Great flick)
Star Wars Trilogy
Pi

Worst

Major League 2 (Didn't like the second one)
Last Boy Scout, The
Freeway

Most Needed

Schindler's List
Band of Brothers
Godfather (Trilogy or single disks)

Muad`Dib

Best 3
-Band of Brothers
-Goodfellas
-2001: Space Odyssey
-All the great stupid-comedy you've got.

Worst 3
-Kung Pow: Enter the Fist
-Matrix Revolutions
-Never Say Never Again (out of all the bond movies, WHY!?)

Most Needed
-Blazing Saddles (if you like silly comedy like Airplane, Austin Powers, Mafia!)
-Seven (You've got Fight Club and 12 Monkeys, so i'd think you like this)
-Spartacus CC (to go along with the war and kubrick stuff you got)
-Sopranos (the rest of them)
-Raging Bull (incredible movie, and you've got goodfellas)
-From Russia With Love (best bond imo)

Sorry, I cheated.

Just made an account at DVD Aff. Check out my wish list since I have such a small collection, to get a better feel.

THE COLLECTION

best
arrested development season 1 (such an underrated will be classic series gone off the air way to soon)
star wars trilogy
trainspotting ce (no one has mentioned this great release)

worst
freeway
major league 2
made (hard to pick a third since limited titles, but i just didn't like this one)

need
godfather trilogy (you have a couple good gangster flicks, you need the godfather of them all)
scarface (it's pacino, it's de palma, it's all good)
die hard (every new collection deserves the mother of all action flicks)

ferret...sorry to say but i think you need some actuals in your collection for someone to "do" you.

Look I just wanted someone to check out my dvds, no need for all this sex-talk.

ps. By "actuals" do you mean generally more dvds, or I don't have enough titles that show what kind of movies I like? Either way I agree.

Bugg..you did so many and looks like you got unceremoniously skipped, i got yours...

Best:
1. "The Beast Within" (this one scared the bejesus out of me for so long and then came to revere)
2. "NYPD Blue: Season 1" (the best, most groundbreaking season of a tv show ever!)
3. "Halloween: Limited Edition" (nice to see another lover of the best versions)

Worst:
1. "Book of Shadows: Blair Witch 2" (nothing really needs to be said, does it?)
2. "Hard Target" (John Woo at his sell-out worst)
3. "Wag the Dog" (more like "Bit the Pooch")

Most Needed:
1. "Alien Quadrilogy" (go for the gold)
2. "Buffy S 6 & 7" (my fav show of all time, complete the series, if not for you then for me!)
3. "The Hitcher II: I've Been Waiting" (i thought it would suck, but you know what it doesn't...at all!)

I'll grade scott1598's list
***Updated to give some remarks. I forgot the first time.***

BEST 3:
Seven Samurai CC (Great movie that inspired The Magnificent Seven)
Casablanca SE (Not Bogey's best, but you gotta love how he handles being tough and sensitive in this movie.)
The Godfather Collection (Brando, Pacino, DeNiro, Caan, etc... I love this movie as you can tell by my signature.)

WORST 3:
8 Mile (I hate eminem)
Daredevil (This is why studios need to stop making comic book movies.)
Ginger Snaps (I gave it a chance, but couldn't finish it.)

MOST NEEDED:
Blue Velvet (David Lynch's finest)
Unforgiven (Clint, Freeman, Hackman, Harris... The last great western.)
Slacker CC (A great indie that keeps revealing more details with each viewing.)

joefrog91

Thank goodness .. a small collection!!!

BEST Ok, so I'm cheating ....

Trainspotting Excellent film with a sick OST .. everyone should see this film by the age of 14.

Amelie I hate picking easy ones, but this film was the antitote to such films in my collection such as Irreversible and Requiem for a Dream (only flaw: non-removable subs). A truly beautiful film.

Bridge on the River Kwai Those stubborn Brits .. love it.

ET: Ultimate Gift set What a great set truly worthy of the film it represents

Wrong Men & Notorius Women Hitchcock, need I say any more?


WORST Extremely difficult to pick (well selected collection, Joe)

Alien vs Predator I heard this movie was bad before seeing it for myself, so I already had a low opinion of it .. and it only got worse. This is coming from a fan of all four Alien (including III and IV)

The Ring Another Hollywood ripoff .. I haven't seen it, nor will I ever. Ringu is all that's necessary ...

Ben Stiller Show Never liked him, never will ..


MOST NEEDED

Yakuza Papers Take a stroll on the Japanese's take on Gangster life ..

Lost Highway You're probably still waiting for a good transfer, unlike Canada's version

Ikiru A great introduction into the world of Kurosawa

Gattaca Great take on futurist sci if

EDIT: Sorry about that Visitor Q. I'd already started before you put your placeholder up.

joefrog91

Best
Alien Quadrilogy
Lord of the Rings Trilogy Extended Edition
Monster Legacy Gift Set

Worst (You didn't have very many "bad" movies to choose from. )
Weird Science
Blair Witch Project
Jay and Silent Bob Strike Back

Most Needed
Once Upon a Time in the West (Even better than The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly IMO)
Once Upon a Time in America (A good mob movie)
The Road Warrior (Hey, why not? )

My list, more or less up to date:
http://www.dvdaficionado.com/dvds.ht...bsidianphoenix

people already did visitor q and all but we just did a lengthy trade so ill rate his

Best
The Seventh Seal: CC
Boogie Nights
Onibaba: CC

Worst (sorry, im sure most will disagree)
Cradle 2 the Grave
Kevin Smith films
28 Days Later

Most Needed
Badlands/Days of Heaven
Wes Anderson
Film Noir

A tip in doing mine is I dislike Kevin Smith, Lucas, Spielberg, Bay, Alien films, actually a whole lot of stuff so I don't know if it's worth trying to recommend.

even though it was a dupe...i got skipped for cubsin's, i'm just sayin'...

No sweat lost. This can be a time investment, so I totally understand ...

cfloyd3

Best:
Fight Club - Special Edition (Definitely one of my favs)
Pulp Fiction - Collectors Edition (Great Movie, great DVD)
Reservoir Dogs - Ten Years - Mr. Brown (I have Mr. Pink)

Worst:
Lost in Translation
Apocalypse Now
Fargo

Needed:
Seven Samurai - Criterion (An obvious ommission given your tastes it would seem)
Saving Private Ryan - DTS (Best War movie and you need some big sound for a demo disc )
Kill Bill 1 & 2 (you have Dogs and Pulp)

Hey CF .. good to see ya around. Cradle to the Grave is actually in my "to be sold" pile. I bought it for a buck from a rental store. 28 Days Later has promise, but several aspects went south about half way in (got it 7 bucks). Kevin Smith .. overrated, but I like some of his stuff. I'll have to check out Days of Heaven .. never heard of it before. Badlands is on the want list with a lower priority. Only Anderson film I saw was Rushmore .. didn't get into to. Perhaps I should give it another try as this was quite some time ago.

a few more

Daniel-A

==favs==
Josie and the Pussycats (Not a great film, but a guilty pleasure of mine)
Notorious - The Criterion Collection
Dances with Wolves - Special Edition (236 Minute Extended Version)

==worst==
Coyote Ugly
Driven
Signs - Vista Series

=needed=
Gattaca
Bambi
North by Northwest

fliggil

==favs==
Double Indemnity
Harvey
Marilyn Monroe: The Diamond Collection

==worst==
Forrest Gump
Gladiator
Vegas Vacation

==needed==
Grapes of Wrath ('40)
Mildred Pierce
Bicycle Thief

Dawg

==favs==
8˝ - The Criterion Collection
Big Lebowski
Punch-Drunk Love

==worst==
People Under the Stairs
Gangs of New York

==needed==
Magnolia
Hudsucker Proxy
Night of the Living Dead

BrentLumkin

==favs==
1941 - Collector's Edition
Ginger Snaps - Collector's Edition
Kiki's Delivery Service

==worst==
Buried Secret of M. Night Shyamalan
Cold Mountain
Indecent Proposal

==needed==
Lolita (Kubrick)
Mash (Altman film)
Crash

Best:

Band Of Brothers
The Good, The Bad, And The Ugly SE
The Office Series (counted them as one)

Worst:

Freddy Got Fingered
Skulls 3 ( no Skulls 2 )
White Chicks

Most Needed:

Magnolia
Seinfeld Season 3
Six Feet Under (try it out)


-------------

Anybody want to '3' me? I have been collecting since 99, but recently over the past several months I have majorly slimmed down my collection by about 200 discs and am VERY selective of what I want to own now(although I do buy some guilty pleasures such as Showgirls ).

http://www.dvdaficionado.com/dvds.ht...&id=conscience

Grolim,

Here's the breakdown:

Worst:

The Village (Honestly the worst movie last year, only good as a comedy)
Freddy Got Fingered (If this wasn't so bad, Driven would've taken its place)
Chronicles of Riddick (Pitch Black IS good, This is a mess start to horrid finish)

Best:

Alien Qudrilogy (A MUST for true collectors, great films, more discs than films)
Die Hard Ultimate Collection (Great Action Flicks, Great Extras)
Star Wars Trilogy (Enough Said...would've picked Matrix Collection on extras alone, but hate the last 2 films)

Needed:

X-Men 1.5 (You have X-2, & X-men 1.5 is a Great set with Great extras)
Traffic Criterion (You have the one disc, if you like the film at all you need the criterion)
Following (You have Chritopher Nolan's other 2 films, Memento & Insomnia, so get his first)

You've got a lot of average titles mixed with a lot of Great titles and good selection of different regions, but overall you don't have too many Awful titles.

Here's my list, be gentle:

http://www.dvdaficionado.com/dvds.ht...d=stonecountry

I picked up AVP just to complete both sets of Alien and Predator movies. It wasn't my finest hour.

And yes, I'm still waiting for a better Lost Highway dvd before buying it.

When I bought the remake of Lolita, for some reason I thought it was the original. I guess I just saw the title and didn't even bother to LOOK at the DVD, heh.

I do have M*A*S*H. I have the Five Star Collection actually.

I've never even heard of Crash, but I'll check it out now. Thanks a lot!

i know it's been done but i want in...... so here's another round for you joefrog91 (great collection BTW)

BEST
Fawlty Towers - one of the greatest comedy shows of all time
Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles - do I need to say anymore....
Fletch - i need this.....

WORST (tough but...)
Boondock Saints - never got into this movie, yet all my friends love it

MOST NEEDED
LOTR - not a fan?
SNL Best of Chris Farley - a must for any SNL collection
Deadwood? - give it a whirl...

Here's for naseeb:

Best
- Garden State (love this movie, and I feel like a hypocrite because I don't have it yet. I rented and loved it and will be buying soon)

- Lord of the Rings Extended Trilogy (another on my list)

- Pulp Fiction/Raging Bull

Worst

Shrek Full Screen (you gotta get the 2 disc widescreen )

Next Friday (did not like this one)

Lock, Stock and Two Smoking Barrels (ditto)

Most Needed

Halloween (not sure if you like horror but this is a classic)

Godfather

Goodfellas

this is for Willh51

Best 3:

Godfather, The - DVD Collection – my all time fave movie trilogy
GoodFellas - Two-Disc Special Edition (1990)
Tie between Heat & Raging Bull

Worst 3:

Van Helsing (2004) – Trashy…
Sky Captain and the World of Tomorrow - Special Collector's Edition (2004) – I just didn’t get it… IMO of course
Paycheck - Special Collector's Edition (2003) – also trashy…

Most Needed:

Some more Scorcese – especially the movies that have been released in the 2 box sets recently
Some Alfred Hitchcock - especially the movies that have been released in the 4 box sets recently
Some classic horror – from the Universal Monsters box set

I think you might have confused someone else's collection with mine. I don't own any of those movies.

Thanks

Can't defend myself against Van Helsing and Paycheck...guilt pleasures I suppose.

I am also working on getting some more Scorsese stuff and those Monster Collections when the cash flow is there. I also want Psycho, Vertigo, etc.

I'll take a crack at it. I'll edit this post in just a few minutes.

Best
- Casablanca - Two-Disc Special Edition
- Fear and Loathing in Las Vegas - The Criterion Collection
- Naked Lunch - The Criterion Collection

Worst
- Showgirls
- Rebel Rousers
- Ride in the Whirlwind

Most Needed
- Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind 2-Disc (Come on, it's a great film and the extra disc has some great stuff on it. Unload the one you have to help get the new release.)
- Band of Brothers
- Adaptation



http://www.dvdaficionado.com/dvds.html?id=brentlumkin (I have the main Owned folder, then three more folders for Box Sets, Pro. Wrestling, and Criterions.)