DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   DVD Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/dvd-talk-3/)
-   -   Rate All These People's Collections (merged) (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/dvd-talk/367437-rate-all-these-peoples-collections-merged.html)

phr33k 08-19-04 03:32 PM

yakuza from your list in your opinion what are the best 3 japanese films you own??

MrVette99 08-19-04 03:35 PM


Originally posted by shill66
I want MrVette99 to tell me the brutal truth about my collection!

http://shillpages.com/collect/sc-dvd0.shtml

WOW! That's a whole lot of films. Can I borrow some? :)

I've never seen any of the Dr Who stuff. My brother use to talk endlessly about the show.

BTW, nice web page. I like how it defaults to text and then after a click goes into detail mode. Lots of good work in the site. :)

-------------

BTW, you got a bug. Your return to index link points to .htm but the index is .shtml

:)

slop101 08-19-04 03:39 PM

Check my sig for my (mosty) up to date collection.

Feel free to tell me what I should lose - I need to do some pruning.

shill66 08-19-04 03:58 PM


Originally posted by MrVette99
BTW, nice web page. I like how it defaults to text and then after a click goes into detail mode. Lots of good work in the site. :)
Thank you!

BTW, you got a bug. Your return to index link points to .htm but the index is .shtml
Ah, thanks for noting that. It's fixed now with a redirect.

Joe1086 08-19-04 03:59 PM

Can someone rate mine? Check my sig.

Skyler 08-19-04 04:07 PM

What the heck, rate a newbie. Check my sig as well.

slop101 08-19-04 05:07 PM

Joe 1086 -

Decent collection - a bit mainstream - not that that's a bad thing - I just can't get a good sense of what you're into from your collection.

Stuff like Sympathy For Mr. Vengance bring your rating up, but stuff like Charlie's Angels (both!) seriously hurt it. (though I'll never understand how someone could like both "The Patriot" and "Naked Lunch" - not that you shouldn't, I just don't get it.

But you do have a lot of great films. I give you a 7.9/10 - You'd easily have a 9/10 if you got rid of the movies that kill your brain.

Joe1086 08-19-04 05:09 PM


Originally posted by slop101
Joe 1086 -

Decent collection - a bit mainstream - not that that's a bad thing - I just can't get a good sense of you're into from your collection.

Stuff like Sympathy For Mr. Vengance bring your rating up, but stuff like Charlie's Angels (both!) seriously hurt it. (though I'll never understand how someone could like both "The Patriot" and "Naked Lunch" - not that you shouldn't, I just don't get it.

But you do have a lot of great films. I give you a 7.9/10 - You'd easily have a 9/10 if you got rid of the movies that kill your brain.

Charlies Angels was gift, been trying to get rid of them for awhile now. I got about 20 movies as gifts, most of them I would of never considered getting.

TomOpus 08-19-04 07:21 PM


Originally posted by slop101
Check my sig for my (mosty) up to date collection.

Feel free to tell me what I should lose - I need to do some pruning.

Very nice collection :up: Lots of older movies! There's no way I would suggest what movies to lose. That's a pretty personal thing :)

TomOpus 08-19-04 07:24 PM


Originally posted by Skyler
What the heck, rate a newbie. Check my sig as well.
Well, that's a nice little collection. You sure like music DVDs :) A lot of good stuff there....

hey... wait.... what's this?? Britney Spears? Snow Dogs?!?!? Lizzie McGuire Movie?!?!?!??!


:D jus kiddin'... carry on. :)

toobsock 08-19-04 11:05 PM

Could someone who isn't a total douchebag (read: not MrVette99) please give a straight review?

TomOpus 08-20-04 12:25 AM


Originally posted by toobsock
Could someone who isn't a total douchebag (read: not MrVette99) please give a straight review?
I have a lot of the same movies you have... plus you have a good percentage of anime. Oh, and you have a few I still want to get. I'd give it a :up:

sataniko 08-20-04 02:23 AM

I'm interested to know what you guys think:

DVD Aficionado

Thanks!

Yakuza Bengoshi 08-20-04 06:29 AM


Originally posted by sataniko
I'm interested to know what you guys think
You win! That's the most unappealing assortment of DVDs I've even seen. Congrats!

QuiGonJosh 08-20-04 06:50 AM

rate it!

http://www.dvdaficionado.com/dvds.ht...d=tequila+dude

Skyler 08-20-04 09:08 AM


hey... wait.... what's this?? Britney Spears? Snow Dogs?!?!? Lizzie McGuire Movie?!?!?!??!
I have a 9 yr old Daughter. I just had to get "her" the Britney Live. The Charlies Angels, Hilary Duff, etc is hers. The Princess Diaries is hers, Princess Bride is mine, lol.

Calistoga 08-20-04 12:13 PM


Originally posted by QuiGonJosh
rate it!

http://www.dvdaficionado.com/dvds.ht...d=tequila+dude

Very impressive list of Box Sets! I like your Bond selections too.

QuiGonJosh 08-20-04 01:20 PM

selections? its all of the Bond movies... ;)

Dabaomb 08-20-04 02:11 PM


Originally posted by MrVette99
Sorry, you only get an A+

"It's The Great Pumpkin, Charlie Brown" in Full Screen that killed you. Had this been in WS, you'd have gotten an A+++.

If you watch this on a widescreen TV, A++. Or if you put heavy black contact paper accross the top and bottom of your 4:3 TV will also put you back to A++. But it doesn't matter now, once rated you're good/marked for 2 years. :)

riveting commentary. You're like Roger Ebert on crack.

Seriously, would anyone like to take a look at my collection. It's in my sig.

I gotta weed out a lot of the crap titles like Head of State and Ali.

stinkeye 08-20-04 02:23 PM

I'll play, click below. I'm mostly interested in recommendations loosely connected to what I have.

Uncle Ron 08-20-04 03:02 PM

Ok, I'll bite....so what do you guys think?

QuiGonJosh 08-20-04 05:23 PM

too many DVD's...too much s**t...get rid of some of the crap...slim it down...

TomOpus 08-20-04 05:48 PM


Originally posted by Skyler
I have a 9 yr old Daughter. I just had to get "her" the Britney Live. The Charlies Angels, Hilary Duff, etc is hers. The Princess Diaries is hers, Princess Bride is mine, lol.
Whew! I was hoping for an answer like that :lol::up:

I'm a big fan of DVDProfiler... but also use DVDAf. You might want to look into DVDAf because you can separate your collection into folders so your daughter could have her own folder. :)

TomOpus 08-20-04 06:01 PM


Originally posted by Uncle Ron
Ok, I'll bite....so what do you guys think?
You have a little bit of everything! Of course (my opinion) you need more cult movies but I'll still give your collection a big :up: btw...Nice folder-work on DVDAf :)

Uncle Ron 08-20-04 08:57 PM


Originally posted by QuiGonJosh
too many DVD's...too much s**t...get rid of some of the crap...slim it down...
Thats exactly what I've been doing lately. I was buying alot of movies that I barely watched after the first viewing. I paid so little for them (cost of a rental) that it was more cost effective to just buy them. Latlely, I've been selling off alot of those and buying more foreign discs. My buying habits have shifted from BestBuy and Walmart to Xploited Cinema and CDWow.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 01:07 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.