DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   Video Game Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/video-game-talk-15/)
-   -   Xbox One Pre-Release Thread: Upscaled to 1080p! (11/22/2013) (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/video-game-talk/608896-xbox-one-pre-release-thread-upscaled-1080p-11-22-2013-a.html)

Michael Corvin 09-13-13 08:34 AM

Re: Xbox One: Thoughts Turn Ironic on November 22nd
 

Originally Posted by chuckd21 (Post 11832662)
Microsoft does a lot of boneheaded shit, but I seriously doubt that three months after the public reveal of the PS4 they'd present a console that's not at least on par with the specs Sony presented. That would be asinine. Are there differences between the two? Of course. One has advantages over the other and vice versa. Will every game be amazing on PS4 and subpar on Xbox One? Of course not.

Well when you're competition is releasing an empty plastic shell, they can scale back on the specs.

Michael Corvin 09-13-13 08:35 AM

Re: Xbox One: Thoughts Turn Ironic on November 22nd
 

Originally Posted by chuckd21 (Post 11832662)
Microsoft does a lot of boneheaded shit, but I seriously doubt that three months after the public reveal of the PS4 they'd present a console that's not at least on par with the specs Sony presented. That would be asinine. Are there differences between the two? Of course. One has advantages over the other and vice versa. Will every game be amazing on PS4 and subpar on Xbox One? Of course not.

but seriously, maybe they were counting on that cloud computing more than they let on.

But yeah it could also just be nonsense.

Jay G. 09-13-13 08:46 AM

Re: Xbox One: Thoughts Turn Ironic on November 22nd
 

Originally Posted by Music (Post 11832665)
I guess console graphics drivers are different then PC graphics drivers... weird...

Yes, because a console OS is different than a PC OS.

flashburn 09-13-13 08:52 AM

Re: Xbox One: Thoughts Turn Ironic on November 22nd
 

Originally Posted by Deftones (Post 11832674)
yeah, this all reeks of Sony fanboy crap. basically a smear campaign. no doubt there will be differences in programming the game, but one won't be significantly better than the other.

I really have no reason to be biased (actually, I have good reason for being impartial). I'm just trying to help people understand why the performance difference is so great right now.

The differences in programming when it comes to rendering are completely different on each system. Sony has their own graphics driver, and MS has their's. They are different API's.

discostu1337 09-13-13 08:55 AM

Re: Xbox One: Thoughts Turn Ironic on November 22nd
 
The 50% more powerful rumor was from 1 undisclosed developer and debunked over a week ago. Moving on...

flashburn 09-13-13 08:57 AM

Re: Xbox One: Thoughts Turn Ironic on November 22nd
 

Originally Posted by chuckd21 (Post 11832662)
Microsoft does a lot of boneheaded shit, but I seriously doubt that three months after the public reveal of the PS4 they'd present a console that's not at least on par with the specs Sony presented. That would be asinine. Are there differences between the two? Of course. One has advantages over the other and vice versa. Will every game be amazing on PS4 and subpar on Xbox One? Of course not.

So do you not believe the specs, or do you not believe that there will be a performance difference? The specs are definitely real (but like that article said, things like the clock speeds aren't locked down yet).

Would you call MS completely throwing out their graphics driver a couple months ago and starting from scratch boneheaded? ;) Of course the differences in the end won't be as huge as that article states (as I already said), but there probably will be cases where doing an A/B comparison shows differences favoring the PS4 in most cases. I think a lot of the cases might be more subtle though, where a game is running at 1920x1080 on PS4 and 1800x900 on Xbox One, or AA/AF settings are different between the two. The sort of things that PC gamers often tweak to get an optimal framerate.

flashburn 09-13-13 08:58 AM

Re: Xbox One: Thoughts Turn Ironic on November 22nd
 

Originally Posted by discostu1337 (Post 11832700)
The 50% more powerful rumor was from 1 undisclosed developer and debunked over a week ago. Moving on...

It can be ~50% more powerful at certain things. In reality, it might translate to less than 5%, it just depends on what the workloads look like. There are also things that the Xbox One is better at than the PS4 due to the ESRAM.

Brack 09-13-13 08:59 AM

Re: Xbox One: Thoughts Turn Ironic on November 22nd
 
I love video game gossip articles like the bs article that doesn't name names. Where is the validity in any of it? It's all nonsense. Why would anyone realistic about this stuff post such crap?

Michael Corvin 09-13-13 09:03 AM

Re: Xbox One: Thoughts Turn Ironic on November 22nd
 

Originally Posted by discostu1337 (Post 11832700)
The 50% more powerful rumor was from 1 undisclosed developer and debunked over a week ago. Moving on...

Honestly, I don't give a shit(they'll both be awesome in their own ways), but if you're gonna be that arrogant post a link.

chess 09-13-13 09:32 AM

Re: Xbox One: Thoughts Turn Ironic on November 22nd
 

Originally Posted by discostu1337 (Post 11832700)
The 50% more powerful rumor was from 1 undisclosed developer and debunked over a week ago. Moving on...

A week ago?

Do you mean this "undisclosed developer" from People Can Fly, and how was it "debunked"?

http://i.imgur.com/D1GeI13.png

Dan 09-13-13 09:44 AM

Re: Xbox One: Thoughts Turn Ironic on November 22nd
 
Pfft. Facts. We don't need 'em! ;)

Brack 09-13-13 09:48 AM

Re: Xbox One: Thoughts Turn Ironic on November 22nd
 
Hearsay is now fact? Those tweets are meaningless.

chuckd21 09-13-13 09:50 AM

Re: Xbox One: Thoughts Turn Ironic on November 22nd
 

Originally Posted by flashburn (Post 11832703)
So do you not believe the specs, or do you not believe that there will be a performance difference? The specs are definitely real (but like that article said, things like the clock speeds aren't locked down yet).

I believe the listed specs for each console. I also believe that there might be performance differences. Furthermore I believe that some developers are liars, some "unnamed sources" are full of shit, and no one has played one final retail release of either product yet.

Brack 09-13-13 09:52 AM

Re: Xbox One: Thoughts Turn Ironic on November 22nd
 

Originally Posted by chuckd21 (Post 11832771)
I believe the listed specs for each console. I also believe that there might be performance differences. Furthermore I believe that some developers are liars, some "unnamed sources" are full of shit, and no one has played one final retail release of either product yet.

The fact that they're "unnamed sources" should lead to the conclusion of bs. That's how I take gossip and mudslinging, when people are too gutless to come out front and center.

chuckd21 09-13-13 09:53 AM

Re: Xbox One: Thoughts Turn Ironic on November 22nd
 
Maybe Madden will look better on the PS4, and then maybe the only way to pass the ball in PS4's version of Madden is to flick the <s>touchscreen</s> touchpad. In that example, who cares which version looks better, because I'm not doing that shit.

There'll be dozens of examples of this, on both sides. Each console will have strengths and weaknesses. If how a game looks is all that mattered, we'd all be buying the new Neo Geo systems this November.

flashburn 09-13-13 09:55 AM

Re: Xbox One: Thoughts Turn Ironic on November 22nd
 
Shit, there's a new Neo Geo system coming out this November?!

Brack 09-13-13 09:56 AM

Re: Xbox One: Thoughts Turn Ironic on November 22nd
 

Originally Posted by chuckd21 (Post 11832774)
Maybe Madden will look better on the PS4, and then maybe the only way to pass the ball in PS4's version of Madden is to flick the <s>touchscreen</s> touchpad. In that example, who cares which version looks better, because I'm not doing that shit.

There'll be dozens of examples of this, on both sides. Each console will have strengths and weaknesses. If how a game looks is all that mattered, we'd all be buying the new Neo Geo systems this November.

There are new Neo-Geo systems? Why are we even talking about the PS4 and Xbox One? ;)

Dan 09-13-13 09:57 AM

Re: Xbox One: Thoughts Turn Ironic on November 22nd
 
If Microsoft's Signature PCs* are any indication, then it's pretty safe to assume that they'll be able to optimize the hardware/software/drivers to the best possible potential.
Will it be BETTER than the PS4? No idea. But it'll be comparable, and that's all that these consoles need to be.

*computers built by the usual hardware-makers like Acer, Dell, and even Sony, but with MS-optimized software/drivers, and without crapware and other proprietary software. I read a big article about it once, but can't find it. Signature PCs were compared to their exact equal non-Signature counterparts, and were noticeably smoother-running and performed better overall. They were also about $100 more expensive, because most PCs are subsidized by the crapware-makers.

Music 09-13-13 09:58 AM

Re: Xbox One: Thoughts Turn Ironic on November 22nd
 

Originally Posted by chuckd21 (Post 11832774)
Maybe Madden will look better on the PS4, and then maybe the only way to pass the ball in PS4's version of Madden is to flick the <s>touchscreen</s> touchpad. In that example, who cares which version looks better, because I'm not doing that shit.

:lol:

chess 09-13-13 10:02 AM

Re: Xbox One: Thoughts Turn Ironic on November 22nd
 

Originally Posted by fumanstan (Post 11831673)
The Psychology of a Fanboy

http://lifehacker.com/the-psychology...sam-1300451596

May or may not be applicable here. :)


chuckd21 09-13-13 10:04 AM

Re: Xbox One: Thoughts Turn Ironic on November 22nd
 
You should read that article Chess.

chess 09-13-13 10:04 AM

Re: Xbox One: Thoughts Turn Ironic on November 22nd
 

Originally Posted by Dan (Post 11832764)
Pfft. Facts. We don't need 'em! ;)

/Thread Title.

chess 09-13-13 10:05 AM

Re: Xbox One: Thoughts Turn Ironic on November 22nd
 

Originally Posted by chuckd21 (Post 11832793)
You should read that article Chess.

Ditto.

flashburn 09-13-13 10:06 AM

Re: Xbox One: Thoughts Turn Ironic on November 22nd
 

Originally Posted by Dan (Post 11832782)
If Microsoft's Signature PCs* are any indication, then it's pretty safe to assume that they'll be able to optimize the hardware/software/drivers to the best possible potential.
Will it be BETTER than the PS4? No idea. But it'll be comparable, and that's all that these consoles need to be.

*computers built by the usual hardware-makers like Acer, Dell, and even Sony, but with MS-optimized software/drivers, and without crapware and other proprietary software. I read a big article about it once, but can't find it. Signature PCs were compared to their exact equal non-Signature counterparts, and were noticeably smoother-running and performed better overall. They were also about $100 more expensive, because most PCs are subsidized by the crapware-makers.

I'd love to read such an article. It's the first I've heard of "MS-optimized software/drivers", whatever that supposed to mean. I highly doubt they are writing or optimizing drivers for PC hardware they didn't manufacture.

chuckd21 09-13-13 10:07 AM

Re: Xbox One: Thoughts Turn Ironic on November 22nd
 

Originally Posted by chess (Post 11832796)
Ditto.

There's a difference between blindly defending a brand out of loyalty and arguing against rumor, speculation, fanboyism and total random horseshit.

And again, I bought both fucking consoles. If the hivemind was saying the Xbox One is pwning the PS4 in GFLOPS and teratransistor processing CPU speed trials I'd say the same things. No one knows shit. When the games come out, they can be compared. That's that.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 06:32 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.