DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   Video Game Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/video-game-talk-15/)
-   -   Harmonix's new project: Rock Band for 360 & PS3 (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/video-game-talk/496904-harmonixs-new-project-rock-band-360-ps3.html)

dvdsteve2000 09-11-07 06:18 PM


Originally Posted by Suprmallet
But remember that for Rock Band, it's not just about the guitar part, but the bass, drums, and vocals. I for one cannot fucking wait to belt out Detroit Rock City.

Wow, that's very true. I was thinking guitar only. I've been a guitar player for 20+ years but honestly I can't wait to sit behind the skins. RB release day is gonna be crazy, I won't know what to do first, lol.

flair 09-12-07 09:29 AM

What system is everyone getting this on? I'm leaning towards buying a ps3 to play it on for the cheaper wireless bundle. I wonder how difficult it will be to find people to play with though...

DaveWadding 09-12-07 10:47 AM

360 for me.

Supermallet 09-12-07 11:21 AM

360 all the way.

XavierMike 09-12-07 12:50 PM

PS3 for me.

Ghym 09-12-07 12:52 PM

360

Shagrath 09-12-07 12:55 PM

Achievements. Nuff said.

EDIT: Plus a larger install-base, and probably get DLC first as well.

MasterofDVD 09-12-07 01:18 PM

360 version all the way.

I traded in my PS3 to get the cash for this and GHIII. The thing was collecting dust and I knew these games, and their future sequels, would give me far more enjoyment than the PS3 had to date. While I am pissed the 360 version is more money to get a wireless guitar I am sure that feeling will fade away once the game is out.

dvdsteve2000 09-12-07 04:08 PM

If it was up to me I'd get the PS3, but unfortunately I'm the only person I know that has one. The game wouldn't be any fun if I couldn't shred my friends, so I'm goin' 360.

DaveWadding 09-22-07 03:39 PM

http://xbox360.ign.com/articles/822/822197p1.html

Supermallet 09-22-07 09:33 PM

God I can't wait to get my hands on this game.

Shagrath 09-23-07 06:33 AM


Originally Posted by Suprmallet
God I can't wait to get my hands on this game.

Same here! I'm a little disappointed that they're not sending the voice over live, but I guess that's a limitation of the technology more than anything.

It's good if you're playing with random people, but I wanted to hear the voice if I'm playing on Live with friends.

argh923 09-23-07 03:55 PM


Originally Posted by Shagrath
Same here! I'm a little disappointed that they're not sending the voice over live, but I guess that's a limitation of the technology more than anything.

It's good if you're playing with random people, but I wanted to hear the voice if I'm playing on Live with friends.

So wait...if you're playing with a band on live, you can't hear the vocalist?

That's ridiculous.

lordwow 09-23-07 04:04 PM

This voice thing is probably better for the people I'm playing with :lol:

flashburn 09-23-07 06:01 PM


Originally Posted by lordwow
This voice thing is probably better for the people I'm playing with :lol:

Yeah, but that is kinda the point, it would make things a lot more fun. I don't get why they can't do it.

argh923 09-23-07 09:24 PM

Not to mention it more or less makes it pointless to have a band online.

Really, REALLY stupid.

PerryD 09-24-07 07:45 AM

streaming live voice and keeping it in sync with decent voice quality is a lot tougher than just sending the button presses (basically just a few 1's and 0's) over the network.

aktick 09-24-07 08:08 AM

That is pretty disappointing, I kind of thought that having a singer in your online band was one of the big draws to this game all along. Since I'll very seldom have somebody over to play it, singing offline will be much less fun for me (the dog can only put up with so much of my screeching).

flashburn 09-24-07 08:17 AM


Originally Posted by PerryD
streaming live voice and keeping it in sync with decent voice quality is a lot tougher than just sending the button presses (basically just a few 1's and 0's) over the network.

I guess I didn't think about how with voice chat already working there probably is some lag sometimes but it isn't too noticeable but in a game like this it would be needed to be exact.

dta316 09-24-07 05:32 PM

Went into Gamespot and pre-ordered Rock Band for the 360. I noticed they just have the option of just buying the game or the big bundle or individual instrumnets.Does anyone know if there will be an option to buy just the game with a guitar?(just like GHII) I don't want to have to shell out another $80.00 for the guitar when I just paid $60.00 for the game.

MasterofDVD 09-24-07 06:23 PM


Originally Posted by dta316
Went into Gamestop and pre-ordered Rock Band for the 360. I noticed they just have the option of just buying the game or the big bundle or individual instruments.Does anyone know if there will be an option to buy just the game with a guitar?(just like GHII) I don't want to have to shell out another $80.00 for the guitar when I just paid $60.00 for the game.

Unlike GHIII I don't think there is a game & guitar combo for Rock Band.

flashburn 09-24-07 06:54 PM

They really should make another bundle that costs $10 more but includes the wireless guitar for the 360. It is amazing that the GH3 guitar bundle basically means you get the wireless guitar for only $40.

Michael Corvin 09-25-07 12:18 AM


Originally Posted by flashburn
They really should make another bundle that costs $10 more but includes the wireless guitar for the 360. It is amazing that the GH3 guitar bundle basically means you get the wireless guitar for only $40.

That and the rumored final list of songs, GHIII has the edge right now with 50 + another half dozen unconfirmed vs. Rock Band's 34 songs. Both will be heavy on DLC so that angle is a wash. Then the fact that you can't sing over live.

Guitar Hero III just looks more and more attractive every day.

Supermallet 09-25-07 01:21 AM

I still think both will be great. Activision is just refining what we've had before, which is why it looks so polished compared to Rock Band, which is trying to go in several different directions at once.

porieux 09-26-07 04:22 AM

Really excited for this game. They need to fix the voice over Live thing though, that's just ridiculous. Hopefully they will address this in an update, have they said anything about that? I don't buy that it's not doable, but I can believe that it's tricky. It's really a necessity though IMO.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 01:44 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.