Star Trek: TNG Appreciation Thread
#101
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Star Trek: TNG Appreciation Thread
I meant no offense. I appreciate TNG warts and all. I know the show backwards and forwards, can quote whole swathes of dialogue from just about any episode, I've met the cast and some of the crew over the years. I fucking LOVE this show. I just don't tie myself up in knots on how realistic it is. Roddenberry and Co. didn't go into great detail about the exact way the economy and a lot of other things worked in the Trek universe--which was smart on their part. When too much is explained in fiction it can damage the magic. (see: "Midi-chlorians")
I appreciate your contributions to this thread. Please don't take offense.
I appreciate your contributions to this thread. Please don't take offense.
I envy you meeting the cast. I haven't even ever met "my cousin" Gates.
Considering what your family did for you, you might find it interesting that despite the fact that I was very openly a huge Star Trek fan, my mother waited until TNG was off TV for about 10 years before she casually dropped into conversation one day, "Y'know, you have a relative that was on a Star Trek show."
#102
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Star Trek: TNG Appreciation Thread
Gates McFadden is your cousin?
#103
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Star Trek: TNG Appreciation Thread
Anyways, was bored yesterday and pulled up some Trek on Netflix, was looking for the episode where Q becomes human but found Peak Performance instead and watched that. I know we've talked before about how TNG didn't seem to be as serialized as later TV shows or even something like DS9, but watching the episode now, I can see there was a lot more going on. First, they outright state they don't like acting like the military, but they know the Borg are going to be a problem (this is after Q-Who) so they need to sharpen their skills. Then the Starfleet observer is constantly trashing Riker and it plays into the whole thing about Riker passing up his own command to be the Enterprise XO (where ends up staying for 15 years), then we see Wes and Geordi come up with an unorthodox plan under Riker's command, which again ties into how they resolved Best of Both Worlds part 2..
I think there was a lot more going on to tie together ongoing stories than we initially realized, and we should be better aware of that.
I think there was a lot more going on to tie together ongoing stories than we initially realized, and we should be better aware of that.
#104
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Star Trek: TNG Appreciation Thread
Oh, another thing from Peak Performance we saw later in the series - Riker picks Worf as XO over Geordi (because he's busy in engineering) and we see this later in The Most Toys when Data is presumed dead they promote Worf to Second Officer/Ops over Geordi, and in Parallels when Worf is in the reality where Riker is captain, Worf is again the XO.
#105
DVD Talk Legend
#106
DVD Talk Hero
#107
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Star Trek: TNG Appreciation Thread
They realized the Borg were insanely powerful, after the ass-beating the Enterprise received in Q Who. They wanted to know how quickly an outmatched ship would go down and if the crew could manage to pull a rabbit out of their hat (which they ended up doing in Best of Both Worlds 2).
Riker deserves credit for his bold tactics rescuing Picard, but it wouldn't have mattered if Data hadn't been there.
Oh, another thing from Peak Performance we saw later in the series - Riker picks Worf as XO over Geordi (because he's busy in engineering) and we see this later in The Most Toys when Data is presumed dead they promote Worf to Second Officer/Ops over Geordi, and in Parallels when Worf is in the reality where Riker is captain, Worf is again the XO.
Data at Ops was third in command line in TNG, but Georgi the chief engineer was fifth(?) behind Worf at tactical/security.
On VOY, Tuvok at tactical/security was third in line.
#108
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Re: Star Trek: TNG Appreciation Thread
Thanks. If you think I'm too eager to be in a debate, you wouldn't be the first person to think that and you'd probably be right. I love talking about Star Trek and find this particular subject fascinating.
I envy you meeting the cast. I haven't even ever met "my cousin" Gates.
Considering what your family did for you, you might find it interesting that despite the fact that I was very openly a huge Star Trek fan, my mother waited until TNG was off TV for about 10 years before she casually dropped into conversation one day, "Y'know, you have a relative that was on a Star Trek show."
I envy you meeting the cast. I haven't even ever met "my cousin" Gates.
Considering what your family did for you, you might find it interesting that despite the fact that I was very openly a huge Star Trek fan, my mother waited until TNG was off TV for about 10 years before she casually dropped into conversation one day, "Y'know, you have a relative that was on a Star Trek show."
Last edited by PatD; 02-14-21 at 07:31 PM.
#109
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Star Trek: TNG Appreciation Thread
Probably better than asking her if you can see proof that she is a natural redhead.
#110
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Star Trek: TNG Appreciation Thread
I'll tell you a quick story about meeting Gates McFadden. Forever I was pronouncing her last name: "Mc FAY-den". By the time I went to Calgary to meet the cast, I learned her last name was pronounced "Mc FAH-den". Anyway, back then, my social skills weren't quite as developed as they are now. In the autograph line for the "entire cast at once" autograph session, I went through a kind of "buffet line" with the TNG cast as each one signed my book. There was a point where the line stopped for a while and I was face-to-face with Gates McFadden. I didn't know what to say and I sucked at small talk. So I told her that for decades I had been pronouncing her last name wrong hoping to elicit a smile or a laugh. She was not amused. In fact she said with an annoyed tone: "well if you hadn't told me I wouldn't have known." I felt so so shook up after accidentally insulting Dr. Crusher herself. Later on, as I waited in line to pick up my picture after the group photo op, I saw her heading off to the back area where (I guess the celebs hang back) and we locked eyes for a moment. I waved at her. She waved back at me. So, I guess were cool.
Anyway, here's the book:

Anyway, here's the book:

#112
DVD Talk Hero
#114
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Re: Star Trek: TNG Appreciation Thread
If anyone is in the mood to watch TNG lately, may I recommend watching this two very similar-in-theme-but-insanely-different-in-quality episodes: "Shades of Gray" (season 2) and "The Inner Light" (season 5). Watch them back to back and see if your head doesn't explode in the realization that these two episodes belong to the same series.
#115
Re: Star Trek: TNG Appreciation Thread
If anyone is in the mood to watch TNG lately, may I recommend watching this two very similar-in-theme-but-insanely-different-in-quality episodes: "Shades of Gray" (season 2) and "The Inner Light" (season 5). Watch them back to back and see if your head doesn't explode in the realization that these two episodes belong to the same series.https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jJWKzONiSLM
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LPBayAKb-6o
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LPBayAKb-6o
#116
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Star Trek: TNG Appreciation Thread
In case anyone doesn't know, there was a writer's strike happening for part of the second season, that's why it's shorter, reuses a TOS Phase Two script (The Child, Uhura would have been the pregnant character) and why Shades of Gray had to happen (they needed something to fill airtime).
#117
Administrator
Re: Star Trek: TNG Appreciation Thread
The Inner Light is a heartbreaking reflection on legacy and the importance of culture.
#118
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Star Trek: TNG Appreciation Thread
Yeah, Disaster seems to have a mixed acceptance in some parts of the fandom. I just rewatched it recently also and it's still a very interesting and enjoyable story. It also brought up something that I find interesting. In this episode, Ensign Ro is surprised to learn that Deanna is not just the ship's shrink, she is a commissioned officer (Lt. Commander, O-4 I think), and thus becomes the ranking bridge officer during the crisis.
And then, in Chain of Command when Jellico takes over the Enterprise, he calls Deanna into the ready room and says something like "I was looking at your record and it says you're a commissioned officer, so I want you in proper uniform".
What these two things taken together tell me is that it's regular practice on some Starfleet ships to have ship's psychiatrists serving (and giving the captain advice on the bridge), that are civilians. Most people seeing Deanna Troi in one of her non-descript jumpsuits consider her just an advisor, like Neelix, Kes or Seven of Nine were on Voyager. So, that's why Ro and Jellico were surprised to learn she's an Academy trained officer also.
And the episode also sets up the amazing callback on DS9 when O'Brien tells Bashir that Worf delivered Molly and Bashir asks Worf if he wants to help again with Keiko's next baby and Worf practically throws himself out an airlock to keep that from happening.
And then, in Chain of Command when Jellico takes over the Enterprise, he calls Deanna into the ready room and says something like "I was looking at your record and it says you're a commissioned officer, so I want you in proper uniform".
What these two things taken together tell me is that it's regular practice on some Starfleet ships to have ship's psychiatrists serving (and giving the captain advice on the bridge), that are civilians. Most people seeing Deanna Troi in one of her non-descript jumpsuits consider her just an advisor, like Neelix, Kes or Seven of Nine were on Voyager. So, that's why Ro and Jellico were surprised to learn she's an Academy trained officer also.
And the episode also sets up the amazing callback on DS9 when O'Brien tells Bashir that Worf delivered Molly and Bashir asks Worf if he wants to help again with Keiko's next baby and Worf practically throws himself out an airlock to keep that from happening.
The following users liked this post:
tanman (02-15-21)
#119
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Re: Star Trek: TNG Appreciation Thread
Has any other TV show had such a dramatic upswing in quality like Star Trek: The Next Generation? This isn't a rhetorical question. I'm really curious, because I can't think of another.
Without belaboring things further: the best example is how Q is utilized in the early seasons compared to the later seasons:
Without belaboring things further: the best example is how Q is utilized in the early seasons compared to the later seasons:
Last edited by PatD; 02-09-21 at 06:24 PM.
#120
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Star Trek: TNG Appreciation Thread

I remember Season 1 as being pretty bad except for the crossover episodes with Buffy.
The show improved, and S 3-5 were great.
#121
DVD Talk Hero
#122
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Re: Star Trek: TNG Appreciation Thread
The following users liked this post:
milo bloom (02-10-21)
#123
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Re: Star Trek: TNG Appreciation Thread
In fact, they call a moment in pop culture when the property get's better: RIKER'S BEARD (as the opposite of "Jump the Shark") : https://www.urbandictionary.com/defi...er%27s%20Beard
Also, I think this show got *way* better after it's awful first season (at least before it went to TBS) :

#124





