Top Chef Season 2 Discussion Thread
#102
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Originally Posted by LiquidSky
The Sinead look works for Elia since she has a pretty face.....her and Ilan's hair must grow at the speed of light judging from the previews for next week's show.
I have a feeling Sam will win the contest. I started watching the program in the middle of the season and immediately had that feeling.
I have a feeling Sam will win the contest. I started watching the program in the middle of the season and immediately had that feeling.
Would have to agree that I think Sam will win.
#103
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Originally Posted by Sweet Baby James
Ilan was downright giddy about the whole situation(kinda reminded me of that character in "The Karate Kid" that told Johnny to get a body bag).
Originally Posted by Jadzia
Wasn't that a fashion trend in the 80's when Swatches were popular?
#104
Senior Member
Originally Posted by Sweet Baby James
They should just take a baseball bat to Marcel's knees and be done with it. These cheftestants are completely out of control this year. I think that I was more disturbed by Ilan's off camera taunting while Cliff was going Ric Flair on Marcel. Ilan was downright giddy about the whole situation(kinda reminded me of that character in "The Karate Kid" that told Johnny to get a body bag). Another question-is there a reason why Ilan has about 5 different watches on his arm?
#105
DVD Talk Legend
Thread Starter
Originally Posted by orderandlaw
I have to say that Cliff was more a Chris Masters than a Ric Flair.
Well, he did have Marcel in a Masterpiece, but if allowed to continue, a figure 4 would have been the finishing move.
#106
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Originally Posted by Jadzia
Wasn't that a fashion trend in the 80's when Swatches were popular?
#107
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Originally Posted by Sweet Baby James
I think that I was more disturbed by Ilan's off camera taunting while Cliff was going Ric Flair on Marcel.
Sam and Elia should have tried to stop it. I have a feeling Elia was guzzling a bottle of wine in the bathroom shaving "other" parts of her body while all of this was going on.
#108
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
Glad to see Cliff go, he showed me less then any other contestant, at least its the right final 4. That was a disturbing episode and I am glad the producers kicked him off, what a jerk
#110
DVD Talk Legend
Originally Posted by LiquidSky
. I have a feeling Elia was guzzling a bottle of wine in the bathroom shaving "other" parts of her body while all of this was going on.
Anyways, thanks all for reminding me that my wrists were always too big to wear swatch watches back then...Back in therapy for a few weeks.
#111
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Originally Posted by FantasticVSDoom
Hey, thats my fantasy ...................
Anyways, thanks all for reminding me that my wrists were always too big to wear swatch watches back then...Back in therapy for a few weeks.
Anyways, thanks all for reminding me that my wrists were always too big to wear swatch watches back then...Back in therapy for a few weeks.
#112
Senior Member
Originally Posted by Sweet Baby James
Well, he did have Marcel in a Masterpiece, but if allowed to continue, a figure 4 would have been the finishing move.
#113
DVD Talk Legend
Originally Posted by iggystar
You guys are killing me. I so had like five Swatches on my arm at one time! Ilan's trying to bring it back.
#114
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
Join Date: Nov 2001
Location: Beantown
Posts: 4,515
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Glad Cliff go the boot, I think the at least Illan should have too for egging him on so much. I continue to be amazed these "professional" think you should act like that, much less on tv. It's not like they're all in college, they're all competing for a big prize.
Cliff would have got the boot anyways from the sounds so it was no real loss anyways.
I'm hoping Marcel or Elia win, but even have a little less respect for Elia since she didn't seem to come to his aid or say something at the time, which I had expected.
I too think Sam is winning this thing
Cliff would have got the boot anyways from the sounds so it was no real loss anyways.
I'm hoping Marcel or Elia win, but even have a little less respect for Elia since she didn't seem to come to his aid or say something at the time, which I had expected.
I too think Sam is winning this thing
#115
Senior Member
Join Date: Oct 2006
Location: Virginia
Posts: 857
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Does it amaze you that the TV shows hosts and makers condemned their actions so much, but featured it so promimently on the program?
I thought it was a big load. Whether Cliff acted inappropriately or not, the hosts should have been high-fiving each other because it meant a water cooler topic for the show.
I thought it was a big load. Whether Cliff acted inappropriately or not, the hosts should have been high-fiving each other because it meant a water cooler topic for the show.
#116
Member
Join Date: Aug 2006
Location: Milwaukee, Wis
Posts: 149
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I agree that Marcel may not be my pick to win, but with that hair shaving stunt, the three guys don't deserve it either. Glad to see Cliff gone, unless your 15, you are way to old to be pulling that kind of prank. In the case of Sam, why couldn't he have stopped Cliff, that is the same as participating. At lastly, Ilan, that guy should have been booted because of his taunting Cliff to continue. Ilan also shows that he is the worst kind of bully, the little kid that picks on the weak kid, but has the big guy behind him to back him up
#117
Senior Member
Join Date: Oct 2006
Location: Virginia
Posts: 857
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
why couldn't Sam have stopped Cliff? Even if you take the situation at face value (which I surely don't, you and I only saw snibbits) blaming Sam is absurd. You want to book him on the Good Sumaritans Law, ala the last Seinfeld?
#118
DVD Talk Legend
Thread Starter
Sam can clearly be seen laughing it up on the couch while Cliff was throwing Marcel around like a ragdoll. Everyone should check out the blogs and boards over at www.bravotv.com . The producers edited this chain of events out of sequence. Ilan and Elia didn't shave their own hair until after the assault on Marcel had taken place(you can see Elia, with hair, laughing after Marcel was finally released by Cliff). This tells me that they knew that they had crossed the line with Marcel and thought that by shaving their own heads would make this appear to be more of a prank. They also show no remorse for their actions because they were all having a good time while shaving their own hair(after already trying to shave Marcel's hair). According to an interview with Marcel, Cliff also followed Marcel into his room, after the wrestling incident, and threw chocolate bars at him.
#119
Senior Member
Join Date: Oct 2006
Location: Virginia
Posts: 857
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
"This tells me that they knew that they had crossed the line with Marcel and thought that by shaving their own heads would make this appear to be more of a prank."
I don't think that inference would hold up in court.
I think I've entered a thread filled with people who were happy to see dodgeball removed from schools.
We should start a charity fund for Marcel so he can have some therapy for this horrific event he had to endure.
I don't think that inference would hold up in court.
I think I've entered a thread filled with people who were happy to see dodgeball removed from schools.
We should start a charity fund for Marcel so he can have some therapy for this horrific event he had to endure.
#120
DVD Talk Legend
Um, why didnt Marcel stop Cliff? Why didnt the camera people stop Cliff? Fact is, it wasnt that big of a deal really. Stupid? Yes. But its not like he was gang raped. Cliff was at fault and he got booted.
#121
DVD Talk Legend
Originally Posted by FantasticVSDoom
Um, why didnt Marcel stop Cliff?
#123
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Originally Posted by FantasticVSDoom
Um, why didnt Marcel stop Cliff?
#124
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Originally Posted by FantasticVSDoom
Um, why didnt Marcel stop Cliff? Why didnt the camera people stop Cliff? Fact is, it wasnt that big of a deal really. Stupid? Yes. But its not like he was gang raped. Cliff was at fault and he got booted.
And Jadzia...I was poor too. I scammed a few Swatches from guys who could careless about them and wore my sister's (she was too young to appreciate).
Half past paisley? :: Funny I actually got used to the things and could tell time, even with mine which had no number it was a white faced.
#125
DVD Talk Legend
Thread Starter
Viewer alert-
Tonight's episode is 75 minutes long, so be careful if you're recording it. Also, they'll edit this episode down to the usual 60 minutes for future airings, so make sure that you watch it tonight as to not miss any of the drama.
Tonight's episode is 75 minutes long, so be careful if you're recording it. Also, they'll edit this episode down to the usual 60 minutes for future airings, so make sure that you watch it tonight as to not miss any of the drama.