I remember reading in the thread here that people were having trouble with his line.

Edited to add link:

http://forum.dvdtalk.com/showpost.ph...&postcount=113

Not the same type of problem but it shows there were problems.

"You guys have been so hard on me the past few weeks"

God forbid everyone doesn't tell her how wonderful she is.

Elliot was a bit scared on his first song.

Kat murdered the melody of her first song.

Taylor is almost unwatchable when he sings angry, nice to see Paula channeling Courtney Cox on the stage behind the judges.

Kat needs to go. Right fucking now.

Hmmm...Elliott's first song was a little pitchy in places.

It was ok untill that fucked up rendition of the chorus.

And why does Paula always suck up to Elliott?

Wow how short is Kat's skirt when she's talking to Clive Davis? Wow.

i think you all can take back your bad words about Kat after that "over the rainbow" performance... it was awesome

Hey I think Kat's first song was great!

i didnt like it

God I was worried Paula would fall over there.

Elliot's second song was more in-line with his groove, but still not too inspired.

Kat's second song started well, then got really Zzzzzzz, but then she got a second wind, though the sitting on the floor still looks odd to me. She does sound better with less instruments backing her. Her dad had much more tears pouring from his eyes than usual.

Taylor's second song made him look like a kid in his facial expressions, but he was bringing home the passion.

This is the first time all season I've seen Taylor not be confident during a song. I don't agree with Simon in that was his "best performance".

and without doublestick tape!

I have to agree that was his best performance...When he is just up there singing, he is very good.

I suspect you will be in the minority on that one.

Meh, I took it as his emulating Mr. Cocker.

true.. because people are easily swayed by the judges

Elliott's second song - well sung, just didn't work for me for some reason.

Or, because it was a very good performance.

OK the audience needs to stop booing every time they think they hear a derogatory comment.

BTW, if the song is sharp, it's sharp.

meh, i disagree
i would have fallen asleep, if it hasnt been for the occassional screech to wake me back up

Wow Kat down on her knees again...

she knows where her bread is buttered