Lost -- "Abandoned" -- 11.09.2005
#126
DVD Talk Hero
Look at this:
http://img484.imageshack.us/img484/1...nsdeath2ib.jpg
Now I will revise my thinking...Ana was shooting at whoever was trying to kill Shannon.
http://img484.imageshack.us/img484/1...nsdeath2ib.jpg
Now I will revise my thinking...Ana was shooting at whoever was trying to kill Shannon.
#128
DVD Talk Legend
Originally Posted by DVD Josh
Look at this:
http://img484.imageshack.us/img484/1...nsdeath2ib.jpg
Now I will revise my thinking...Ana was shooting at whoever was trying to kill Shannon.
http://img484.imageshack.us/img484/1...nsdeath2ib.jpg
Now I will revise my thinking...Ana was shooting at whoever was trying to kill Shannon.
#129
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
No man, you're just reaching. for things that aren't there. You're speculating, without alot of proof.
What happened before the Tailies got there? So what do you think, Anna Lucia shot somebody before Shannon, and is just pointing a spent weapon at everyone else? Who the hell is that supposed to scare? Then she shows up right after Shannon was shot, pointing that same empty weapon? Remember, there was only one gun shot that we heard.
I don't think A-L was lying about how many bullets where in the gun. Why would she do that? She's using it to protect the group from "the others".
I agree with ALL of that, but how do we know what happened BEFORE the Tallies got there? It was late afternoon when we last saw them, but NIGHT when they arrived to where Shannon was. We don't know what happened in the interim. We also don't know if there were NO bullets in the gun in the first place, and Ana just wanted them to think there was.
Even though there is a spent gun, a gunshot, a bleeding lady, all of that does not equal with absolute certainty that it was Ana that shot Shannon. Not on this show at least.
Even though there is a spent gun, a gunshot, a bleeding lady, all of that does not equal with absolute certainty that it was Ana that shot Shannon. Not on this show at least.
I don't think A-L was lying about how many bullets where in the gun. Why would she do that? She's using it to protect the group from "the others".
Last edited by boogieman03; 11-10-05 at 09:54 AM.
#130
DVD Talk Legend
Originally Posted by DVD Josh
Look at this:
http://img484.imageshack.us/img484/1...nsdeath2ib.jpg
Now I will revise my thinking...Ana was shooting at whoever was trying to kill Shannon.
http://img484.imageshack.us/img484/1...nsdeath2ib.jpg
Now I will revise my thinking...Ana was shooting at whoever was trying to kill Shannon.
I don't get the signifigance of M-Rod not having sleeves? What does that have to do with anything?
#134
DVD Talk Hero
re: the sleeves. I have no clue. The image isn't mine, I found it on another board. I think that they are just saying that the shadowy figure facing Sayid is Ana.
#136
DVD Talk Hero
Originally Posted by boogieman03
No man, you're just reaching. for things that aren't there. You're speculating, without alot of proof.
What happened before the Tailies got there? So what do you think, Anna Lucia shot somebody before Shannon, and is just pointing a spent weapon at everyone else? Who the hell is that supposed to scare? Then she shows up right after Shannon was shot, pointing that same empty weapon? Remember, there was only one gun shot that we heard.
I don't think A-L was lying about how many bullets where in the gun. Why would she do that? She's using it to protect the group from "the others".
What happened before the Tailies got there? So what do you think, Anna Lucia shot somebody before Shannon, and is just pointing a spent weapon at everyone else? Who the hell is that supposed to scare? Then she shows up right after Shannon was shot, pointing that same empty weapon? Remember, there was only one gun shot that we heard.
I don't think A-L was lying about how many bullets where in the gun. Why would she do that? She's using it to protect the group from "the others".
I can tell you one thing - it's not original to point a spent gun at a person when your nerves are fried. At worst, they think you have a loaded gun for enough time for you to do something else. Also
Spoiler:
No, what I know think is that Ana shot the person/thing that IS responsible for killing Shannon, not Shannon herself. You are damn right, that's speculation, without alot of proof, but frankly, that's all ANY of us has right now.
#137
DVD Talk Reviewer
Joined: Feb 2001
Posts: 7,835
Received 52 Likes
on
44 Posts
From: Formerly known as "12thmonkey"/Frankfort, IL
Originally Posted by boogieman03
What the hell does "long gunshot wound" mean?
#138
the wound was a long in length wound not what would appear to be caused by a bulet.
dont go by me i'm just guessing.
dont go by me i'm just guessing.
#140
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
nevermind. So now we think that Shannon got stabbed and Ann shot or shot at the killer and the killer got away without being seen, whithout making a noise and while having people close in on him/her.
Last edited by boogieman03; 11-10-05 at 10:23 AM.
#141
DVD Talk Legend
I think the sleeves thing is this: Ana is wearing a tank top and the figure facing Sayid/dead Shannon in the other picture has longer sleeves. At least I think that is it.
#143
DVD Talk Godfather
Originally Posted by DVD Josh
Here's another mind-blower:
Walt appeared and told Shannon and Sayid to be quiet (Shhh). But what would they have to fear from the Tallies and Michael, Jin and Sawyer? Nothing, they are friendlies. It's more likely that there was something ELSE there that they needed to hide from, and that something else what shot Shannon.
Walt appeared and told Shannon and Sayid to be quiet (Shhh). But what would they have to fear from the Tallies and Michael, Jin and Sawyer? Nothing, they are friendlies. It's more likely that there was something ELSE there that they needed to hide from, and that something else what shot Shannon.
#144
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Originally Posted by cdollaz
I think the sleeves thing is this: Ana is wearing a tank top and the figure facing Sayid/dead Shannon in the other picture has longer sleeves. At least I think that is it.
#147
DVD Talk Legend
Originally Posted by joshyborra
I thought it was a little over the top for Boone's first line in the flashbacks..."Doesn't dying suck..." :-)
#148
Member
Joined: Feb 2001
Posts: 134
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by whotony
the wound was a long in length wound not what would appear to be caused by a bulet.
dont go by me i'm just guessing.
dont go by me i'm just guessing.
Ana didn't shoot Shaanon (I hate MR too, but I have to be fair). The wound looked more like a stake wound. remeber the body Jin found when looking for Michael w/ Ecko? Stake through the chest... I think she shot AT an OTHER. She said 1 bullet wouldn't do any good against them; but maybe she shot in reaction hoping toi scare them.
As for Shannon being the one that died; I hated this. The episode seemed to be like, hey, let's write a story about killing the actress that was giving us problems. Translates to don't question the powers that be or your off the show. JJ has too much power.
Spoiler:
Last edited by Therecanbonly1; 11-10-05 at 11:32 AM.




