The Babylon 5 Season FIVE Discussion Thread
#176
Enormous Genitals
Joined: Oct 2000
Posts: 38,840
Received 905 Likes
on
474 Posts
From: a small cottage on a cul de sac in the lower pits of hell.
I thought Lennier's action - or, rather, inaction - was out of character. Sure, he always loved Delenn, and sure, somewhere in the back of his mind he probably wanted Sheridan out of the way, but based on his prior behavior his deliberately leaving Sheridan - and another ranger - to die seemed to be something he would not do, ever. I know JMS was trying to show us anyone can be weak at a critical moment and that this doesn't define that person, but still, it just didn't ring true.
#177
You'll never see Mumy at a convention where he doesn't remind the audience that it wasn't his idea and that he fought with jms over it. Every time I see this episode it breaks my heart, but Lennier had been on a subtle descent for a while. His motives for becoming a Ranger weren't pure, and he was slowly losing himself. I think the key to this scene is simply the initial hesitation. That's all it took. I've always felt that when he runs off, it's more out of shame for the hesitation than a conscious desire to kill Sheridan. Once he hesitates, rational thought is no longer a factor. To let Sheridan out is to face his disgrace, and he instinctively flees. Honor is so important to the Minbari, and since Lennier has never truly disgraced himself, it's hard to know if that's really in character for him or not. I can see it both ways, but I do think it works.
das
das
#178
Senior Member
Joined: Aug 2003
Posts: 943
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by das Monkey
You'll never see Mumy at a convention where he doesn't remind the audience that it wasn't his idea and that he fought with jms over it. Every time I see this episode it breaks my heart, but Lennier had been on a subtle descent for a while. His motives for becoming a Ranger weren't pure, and he was slowly losing himself. I think the key to this scene is simply the initial hesitation. That's all it took. I've always felt that when he runs off, it's more out of shame for the hesitation than a conscious desire to kill Sheridan. Once he hesitates, rational thought is no longer a factor. To let Sheridan out is to face his disgrace, and he instinctively flees. Honor is so important to the Minbari, and since Lennier has never truly disgraced himself, it's hard to know if that's really in character for him or not. I can see it both ways, but I do think it works.
das
You'll never see Mumy at a convention where he doesn't remind the audience that it wasn't his idea and that he fought with jms over it. Every time I see this episode it breaks my heart, but Lennier had been on a subtle descent for a while. His motives for becoming a Ranger weren't pure, and he was slowly losing himself. I think the key to this scene is simply the initial hesitation. That's all it took. I've always felt that when he runs off, it's more out of shame for the hesitation than a conscious desire to kill Sheridan. Once he hesitates, rational thought is no longer a factor. To let Sheridan out is to face his disgrace, and he instinctively flees. Honor is so important to the Minbari, and since Lennier has never truly disgraced himself, it's hard to know if that's really in character for him or not. I can see it both ways, but I do think it works.
das
thought Lennier's action - or, rather, inaction - was out of character. Sure, he always loved Delenn, and sure, somewhere in the back of his mind he probably wanted Sheridan out of the way, but based on his prior behavior his deliberately leaving Sheridan - and another ranger - to die seemed to be something he would not do, ever.
#179
DVD Talk Legend
Originally posted by Bandoman
I just finished watching "Sleeping in Light". Is it wrong for a grown man to cry during a TV show?
Wow. Just - wow.
BTW -
Once again - wow. What a story.
I just finished watching "Sleeping in Light". Is it wrong for a grown man to cry during a TV show?

Wow. Just - wow.
BTW -
Spoiler:
Once again - wow. What a story.
Congratulations.
#180
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Joined: Apr 1999
Posts: 2,641
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Saint Clair Shores, MI, USA
I went out to a few used book stores yesterday. I picked up "To Dream In The City Of Sorrows", "The Shadows Within", and the first book of the Centauri Prime trilogy. I may have to turn to Ebay for the rest.
#181
DVD Talk Special Edition
Joined: Sep 1999
Posts: 1,742
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Orlando, FL
Originally posted by Gamblor187
I may have to turn to Ebay for the rest.
I may have to turn to Ebay for the rest.
#182
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Joined: Apr 1999
Posts: 2,641
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Saint Clair Shores, MI, USA
Originally posted by Kevin M. Dean
Amazon seems to have all of the more recent books. The science fiction book club also carries the 3 trilogies.
Amazon seems to have all of the more recent books. The science fiction book club also carries the 3 trilogies.
#183
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Legend
Today's Episode: "Sleeping in Light"
In Sheridan's final days, old friends gather to celebrate. Takes place in 2281, approximately twenty years after the end of the rest of the series.
Sheridan's disappearance echoes the disappearance of Valen, who is presumed dead but whose body was never found ("Atonement"). Was Valen spirited away by Lorien as well?
Why did the station fall into disuse over time? It's true that its political mission became irrelevant with the founding of the Interstellar Alliance, but that was only one of several purposes the station served: it was also a bustling trade hub located in a convenient area of space, an outpost of the Earth Alliance, a way station for people travelling elsewhere, and after the founding of the Alliance, a place of historical interest as well.
One possibility is that it became less and less convenient relative to other hubs as the Alliance equalized member races' technologies, causing, for instance, artificial gravity to become the norm. Better hyperspace navigation technology might have made it irrelevant as a waypoint and less necessary as a trading center.
Still, the argument about it being a hazard to navigation seems a bit odd; in the vastness of space, it's a tiny speck. Granted, it's possible to emerge out of control from the jumpgate and be on a collision course with the station ("Soul Hunter") but a slight change of orbital position would almost certainly eliminate that possibility.
Since Garibaldi is still alive and well in 2281, he wasn't killed by either Lyta or Bester during the Telepath War, which had already taken place by the time of Sheridan's death (Delenn mentioned it at the end of "Rising Star"). Was his mental block removed? Did he get his revenge on Bester, and did Lyta succeed in destroying the Corps?
Why didn't any Soul Hunters ("Soul Hunter") arrive to capture Sheridan's soul at Coriana 6? He almost certainly fits the profile of a soul worth preserving in their view. A few possibilities: he was taken away by Lorien, but didn't die per se; the Soul Hunters changed their policies or disbanded after the events of "The River of Souls"; or Lorien somehow prevented them from approaching.
Why did the station fall into disuse over time? It's true that its political mission became irrelevant with the founding of the Interstellar Alliance, but that was only one of several purposes the station served: it was also a bustling trade hub located in a convenient area of space, an outpost of the Earth Alliance, a way station for people travelling elsewhere, and after the founding of the Alliance, a place of historical interest as well.
One possibility is that it became less and less convenient relative to other hubs as the Alliance equalized member races' technologies, causing, for instance, artificial gravity to become the norm. Better hyperspace navigation technology might have made it irrelevant as a waypoint and less necessary as a trading center.
Still, the argument about it being a hazard to navigation seems a bit odd; in the vastness of space, it's a tiny speck. Granted, it's possible to emerge out of control from the jumpgate and be on a collision course with the station ("Soul Hunter") but a slight change of orbital position would almost certainly eliminate that possibility.
Since Garibaldi is still alive and well in 2281, he wasn't killed by either Lyta or Bester during the Telepath War, which had already taken place by the time of Sheridan's death (Delenn mentioned it at the end of "Rising Star"). Was his mental block removed? Did he get his revenge on Bester, and did Lyta succeed in destroying the Corps?
Why didn't any Soul Hunters ("Soul Hunter") arrive to capture Sheridan's soul at Coriana 6? He almost certainly fits the profile of a soul worth preserving in their view. A few possibilities: he was taken away by Lorien, but didn't die per se; the Soul Hunters changed their policies or disbanded after the events of "The River of Souls"; or Lorien somehow prevented them from approaching.
#184
DVD Talk Limited Edition
It's over 
One of the best hours of television ever IMHO. I have to admit, I cry all the time at movies but only twice have I ever cried watching a TV show and this episode was one of those times.

One of the best hours of television ever IMHO. I have to admit, I cry all the time at movies but only twice have I ever cried watching a TV show and this episode was one of those times.
#187
Enormous Genitals
Joined: Oct 2000
Posts: 38,840
Received 905 Likes
on
474 Posts
From: a small cottage on a cul de sac in the lower pits of hell.
I just picked up the Centauri Prime trilogy. I need my B5 fix.
When do the movies come out on DVD? What about Crusade? What's happening with the new B5 project?
When do the movies come out on DVD? What about Crusade? What's happening with the new B5 project?
Last edited by Bandoman; 05-18-04 at 09:23 AM.
#189
DVD Talk Hero
Ah, but there are still stories to be told:
Originally posted by JMS in 1999
Garibaldi's death (a much quieter passing than he would have imagined waiting for him), Franklin's final fate on a distant, unexplored planet, Delenn's final journey (a quest involving Valen, though no one else around her believes it), Lennier's sacrifice...it's all mapped out, on the theory that whether or not it ever gets used, *I* had to know it.
Garibaldi's death (a much quieter passing than he would have imagined waiting for him), Franklin's final fate on a distant, unexplored planet, Delenn's final journey (a quest involving Valen, though no one else around her believes it), Lennier's sacrifice...it's all mapped out, on the theory that whether or not it ever gets used, *I* had to know it.
#190
Senior Member
Joined: Aug 2003
Posts: 943
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by Josh-da-man
Ah, but there are still stories to be told:
Ah, but there are still stories to be told:
#192
DVD Talk Hero
Originally posted by dstrauss
IIRC, Lyta was supposed to appear in an episode of Crusade, but the scene was never shot.
IIRC, Lyta was supposed to appear in an episode of Crusade, but the scene was never shot.
It's the scene where
Spoiler:
#193
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Joined: Apr 2001
Posts: 2,118
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
for those wondering about movies thread in dvd talk about it.
http://www.dvdtalk.com/forum/showthr...hreadid=365185
http://www.dvdtalk.com/forum/showthr...hreadid=365185
#195
Member
Joined: Jan 2004
Posts: 92
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Plantation, FL.
Just finished "Sleeping in Light" and just wanted to thank everyone here for talking up B5, as I would never have thought to watch it otherwise. What a great journey it's been. I haven't participated much in these discussions as I've just about always been behind in episodes, but I enjoyed reading everyone's thoughts and comments after the fact. Of course, my feelings of satsifaction over the enjoyment this show gave me have been somewhat lessened having logged on not ten minutes after finishing the series to find out the sad news about Richard Biggs.
Oveall, I think Season 5 get a bad rap. I'd place it well ahead of Season 1 (although I suspect that one will improve on second viewing) and on par with Season 2. My only complaint about the second half of Season 5 is that I was really hoping to see more of the events that led to the Londo/G'kar scene that was shown in "War Without End".
das, don't know if you even remember doing this, but I wanted to thank you for trying to protect me from a Season 5 spoiler that I mentioned, in the Season 4 discussion thread, as having come across. Unfortunately, you couldn't protect me from myself
. Still, I appreciate the effort.
Once again, thank you all for talking this one up.
Oveall, I think Season 5 get a bad rap. I'd place it well ahead of Season 1 (although I suspect that one will improve on second viewing) and on par with Season 2. My only complaint about the second half of Season 5 is that I was really hoping to see more of the events that led to the Londo/G'kar scene that was shown in "War Without End".
das, don't know if you even remember doing this, but I wanted to thank you for trying to protect me from a Season 5 spoiler that I mentioned, in the Season 4 discussion thread, as having come across. Unfortunately, you couldn't protect me from myself
. Still, I appreciate the effort. Once again, thank you all for talking this one up.
#196
You're very welcome. I do remember, and I'm sorry I couldn't have been more successful.
I gave it a good shot, though.
I hope you realize now that it's time to "pay it forward."
Perhaps by bumping the LIVE NUDE GIRLS thread and sharing your experience.
das
I gave it a good shot, though.I hope you realize now that it's time to "pay it forward."
Perhaps by bumping the LIVE NUDE GIRLS thread and sharing your experience.das
#197
Senior Member
Joined: Aug 2003
Posts: 943
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by dsw13
Oveall, I think Season 5 get a bad rap. I'd place it well ahead of Season 1 (although I suspect that one will improve on second viewing) and on par with Season 2. My only complaint about the second half of Season 5 is that I was really hoping to see more of the events that led to the Londo/G'kar scene that was shown in "War Without End".
Oveall, I think Season 5 get a bad rap. I'd place it well ahead of Season 1 (although I suspect that one will improve on second viewing) and on par with Season 2. My only complaint about the second half of Season 5 is that I was really hoping to see more of the events that led to the Londo/G'kar scene that was shown in "War Without End".
It's been mentioned before in this thread, but it bears repeating, that the Psi Corps Trilogy, Legions of Fire, as well as The Shadow Within and To Dream in the City of Sorrows are all great reading, and fill in pretty interesting parts of the story.
#198
Member
Joined: Jan 2004
Posts: 92
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Plantation, FL.
Originally posted by das Monkey
I hope you realize now that it's time to "pay it forward."
Perhaps by bumping the LIVE NUDE GIRLS thread and sharing your experience.
das
I hope you realize now that it's time to "pay it forward."
Perhaps by bumping the LIVE NUDE GIRLS thread and sharing your experience.das
. (of course, if you were referencing the book, I have no opinion of its quality, having never been inclined to read it).
Originally posted by xVladx
Well, if you're interested in more detail on that, try reading Legions of Fire. It's a trilogy of books that (from what I've heard) pretty much fills in the exact gap you're talking about.
It's been mentioned before in this thread, but it bears repeating, that the Psi Corps Trilogy, Legions of Fire, as well as The Shadow Within and To Dream in the City of Sorrows are all great reading, and fill in pretty interesting parts of the story.
Well, if you're interested in more detail on that, try reading Legions of Fire. It's a trilogy of books that (from what I've heard) pretty much fills in the exact gap you're talking about.
It's been mentioned before in this thread, but it bears repeating, that the Psi Corps Trilogy, Legions of Fire, as well as The Shadow Within and To Dream in the City of Sorrows are all great reading, and fill in pretty interesting parts of the story.
#199
Senior Member
Joined: Aug 2003
Posts: 943
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by dsw13
I did see that in this thread, as well as others, and will likely get around to eventually tracking them down. Still, with the amount of times that they flashed forward to that particular scene over the course of the series, I was disappointed that the specifics of how they got to that point didn't make it into the final episodes. Of course, I might find when I read the books that the story behind it is so detailed that it would have required an additional season to really get into. If that's the case, it's certainly understandable that it wasn't covered.
I did see that in this thread, as well as others, and will likely get around to eventually tracking them down. Still, with the amount of times that they flashed forward to that particular scene over the course of the series, I was disappointed that the specifics of how they got to that point didn't make it into the final episodes. Of course, I might find when I read the books that the story behind it is so detailed that it would have required an additional season to really get into. If that's the case, it's certainly understandable that it wasn't covered.
Spoiler:
So far, I've only read the first book of Legions of Fire, and it does look to have more story than would have fit in any extra seasons.
Never mind the fact that Babylon 5 was meant to be a five year story, and there's a 16 year timespan between Objects at Rest and what we saw in War Without End.
#200
DVD Talk Hero
I just heard that the actor that plays Dr. Franklin died over the weekend.
Unfortunately, he had a heart attack instead of being surgically modified to power a Shadow vessel. If it had been the latter, being a sci-fi doctor, he probably could have saved himself.
Unfortunately, he had a heart attack instead of being surgically modified to power a Shadow vessel. If it had been the latter, being a sci-fi doctor, he probably could have saved himself.
Last edited by slop101; 05-24-04 at 04:16 PM.



