DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   Movie Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/movie-talk-17/)
-   -   A Good Day To Die Hard (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/movie-talk/599246-good-day-die-hard.html)

RichC2 02-23-12 07:56 AM

Re: ...and John McClane's son is... (Die Hard 5 talk)
 
http://www.google.com/#hl=en&output=...com+die+hard+5

:shrug: Seems to come right up. Still, better choice than I would have expected.

Solid Snake 02-23-12 08:14 AM

Re: ...and John McClane's son is... (Die Hard 5 talk)
 
Sooooo I'm assuming he's supposed to be a badass too?

MrSmearkase 02-23-12 08:17 AM

Re: ...and John McClane's son is... (Die Hard 5 talk)
 
Photo from his screen test;

http://img2.timeinc.net/ew/i/2012/02...n-test_510.jpg

islandclaws 02-23-12 11:05 AM

Re: ...and John McClane's son is... (Die Hard 5 talk)
 
At least he won't be paired with Justin Long's pussy ass in this one.

riley_dude 02-23-12 11:30 AM

Re: ...and John McClane's son is... (Die Hard 5 talk)
 

Originally Posted by RocShemp (Post 11125506)
Will we at least get a Lucy McClane cameo?

I certainly hope so.

Shannon Nutt 02-23-12 02:24 PM

Re: ...and John McClane's son is... (Die Hard 5 talk)
 
I've never seen him in anything, but he certainly passes the visual test. The kid looks like he could be McClane's son.

BTW, we should play "Caption This!" with that photo. :)

GoldenJCJ 02-23-12 06:24 PM

Re: ...and John McClane's son is... (Die Hard 5 talk)
 
I'm a sucker for anything Die Hard so I'll be seeing this opening weekend regardless but I'd rather Mary Elizabeth Winstead be McClane's sidekick as his ass kicking daughter.

Adam Tyner 02-23-12 06:53 PM

Re: ...and John McClane's son is... (Die Hard 5 talk)
 

Originally Posted by GoldenJCJ (Post 11126874)
but I'd rather Mary Elizabeth Winstead be McClane's sidekick as his ass kicking daughter.

This is the correct answer.

Michael Corvin 02-23-12 07:22 PM

Re: ...and John McClane's son is... (Die Hard 5 talk)
 
Lucy McClane (Winstead) returning would kick all kinds of ass.

I find it hilarious that they waited all those years between 3 & 4 to find the perfect script, and are turning around 5 in no time.

TGM 02-23-12 07:23 PM

Re: ...and John McClane's son is... (Die Hard 5 talk)
 
Winstead head said somewhere that she had not been asked back.

islandclaws 02-23-12 07:24 PM

Re: ...and John McClane's son is... (Die Hard 5 talk)
 

Originally Posted by Adam Tyner (Post 11126896)
This is the correct answer.

No, thanks. I'd rather see something more believable than Winstead trying to act hard.

GoldenJCJ 02-23-12 07:31 PM

Re: ...and John McClane's son is... (Die Hard 5 talk)
 

Originally Posted by Michael Corvin (Post 11126926)
Lucy McClane (Winstead) returning would kick all kinds of ass.

It seems like a no brainer to me. They already set up her character with Live Free or Die Hard and Winstead seems to be slowly picking up steam as a star. Why bring in some virtually unknown schlub for part 5 to play McClane's kid when the new character would be the same as the already established character?

My Other Self 02-23-12 09:10 PM

Re: ...and John McClane's son is... (Die Hard 5 talk)
 

Originally Posted by Michael Corvin (Post 11126926)
Lucy McClane (Winstead) returning would kick all kinds of ass.

I find it hilarious that they waited all those years between 3 & 4 to find the perfect script, and are turning around 5 in no time.

Live Free was tied up in development hell because of 9/11. Same reason True Lies 2 never got the green light. The story was tweaked and whatnot in the end but I don't think they had a hard time hammering out a story.

I haven't seen the movies in a little while but did they ever mention that McClane had a son?

bluetoast 02-23-12 09:13 PM

Re: ...and John McClane's son is... (Die Hard 5 talk)
 
Yeah I think in part 2 he talked to his son and daughter over the phone.

JumpCutz 02-23-12 09:15 PM

Re: ...and John McClane's son is... (Die Hard 5 talk)
 
People still care about Die Hard movies. :lol:

Die Hard was fantastic... the follow-ups, not so much.

Adam Tyner 02-23-12 09:25 PM

Re: ...and John McClane's son is... (Die Hard 5 talk)
 

Originally Posted by KillerCannibal (Post 11126931)
No, thanks. I'd rather see something more believable than Winstead trying to act hard.

Between Scott Pilgrim and The Thing, I think she's proven she can credibly kick ass.

RocShemp 02-23-12 09:31 PM

Re: ...and John McClane's son is... (Die Hard 5 talk)
 

Originally Posted by MrSmearkase (Post 11126083)

Interesting development with who's playing son. At least from the pic it looks like they'll have him man up. I find this interesting since Justin Long's character was originally conceived as John McClane's son. Lucy was the result of one of several rewrites.

Solid Snake 02-23-12 09:33 PM

Re: ...and John McClane's son is... (Die Hard 5 talk)
 
Storywise...wtf has the son been up to?

RocShemp 02-24-12 07:10 AM

Re: ...and John McClane's son is... (Die Hard 5 talk)
 

Originally Posted by Solid Snake PAC (Post 11127064)
Storywise...wtf has the son been up to?

That's like asking what the daughter has been up to prior to LFoDH. I bet it'll be barely addressed. Though looking at the screen test, maybe he's a rookie cop?

Michael Corvin 02-24-12 07:35 AM

Re: ...and John McClane's son is... (Die Hard 5 talk)
 
Rookie cop sounds good. Timeline-wise he'd be about 30 though. Then again, wasn't Lucy in college? She'd be around the same age.


Originally Posted by mcfly (Post 11127031)
I haven't seen the movies in a little while but did they ever mention that McClane had a son?

In the first movie. John McClane Jr.

CharlieK 02-24-12 08:35 AM

Re: ...and John McClane's son is... (Die Hard 5 talk)
 
http://images2.fanpop.com/images/pho...19-720-536.jpg

Solid Snake 02-24-12 03:24 PM

Re: ...and John McClane's son is... (Die Hard 5 talk)
 

Originally Posted by RocShemp (Post 11127239)
That's like asking what the daughter has been up to prior to LFoDH. I bet it'll be barely addressed. Though looking at the screen test, maybe he's a rookie cop?

well weren't they mentioned here and there?

Like..in DH1 we saw the kids. I....I don't remember DH2 really. and for DH3 I don't remember any mention of them aside from the wife being on the phone. And....DH4...can't remember any mention of the son.

MrSmearkase 02-24-12 03:31 PM

Re: ...and John McClane's son is... (Die Hard 5 talk)
 
/\ The kids were staying with Holly's parents in Die Hard 2.

Pizza the Hutt 02-24-12 03:41 PM

Re: ...and John McClane's son is... (Die Hard 5 talk)
 

Originally Posted by Solid Snake PAC (Post 11127064)
Storywise...wtf has the son been up to?

Going to school, graduating, getting a daytime job, moving in with his gf. Who gives a fuck?

bluetoast 02-24-12 04:07 PM

Re: ...and John McClane's son is... (Die Hard 5 talk)
 
Yeah. All the Die Hard movies are pretty much in real time, so they're about 8 hours of John McClane's life over the span of 20 years. Considering he has other things on his mind (at least in the first three), it makes sense that he doesn't talk about them much, if at all.

Now if it were like the 7 Up series and we were now on 35 Up and we see a person who was skipped for like 3 installments, then that would be worth knowing.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 03:34 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.