'The Road' - Nov. 2008
#151
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Joined: Jun 1999
Posts: 3,921
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
From: AUSTIN - Land of Mexican Coke
Re: 'The Road' - Nov. 2008
I just saw it tonight. I thought it was a powerful film. My wife was really blown away by it. And that kid was REALLY good. A fine young actor. I read the book earlier in the year, and thought it was OK. Wasn't a huge fan.
Anyway, we watched it in Plano, TX. The theater was probably 60% full. When it was over all I heard was "That sucked! That was terrible!" from various people all the way out the door and into the lobby. Last time that happened was the when I saw No Country For Old Men at the SAME theater opening weekend back in 2007. That Cormac McCarthy based film went on to win best picture. So . . . just throwing that out there.
But yeah, the Weinstein's need to retire and let someone else run their business.
Anyway, we watched it in Plano, TX. The theater was probably 60% full. When it was over all I heard was "That sucked! That was terrible!" from various people all the way out the door and into the lobby. Last time that happened was the when I saw No Country For Old Men at the SAME theater opening weekend back in 2007. That Cormac McCarthy based film went on to win best picture. So . . . just throwing that out there.
But yeah, the Weinstein's need to retire and let someone else run their business.
#152
DVD Talk Legend
Re: 'The Road' - Nov. 2008
Having no familiarity with the book, I'd say the movie met my expectations. I was expecting a pretty grim and serious drama and that's what I got, but actually it ended better than I was anticipating. Certainly well done, but I left having no desire to see it again.
#153
DVD Talk Legend
Re: 'The Road' - Nov. 2008
I feel exactly the same as you. Also from someone who didn't read the book. I'd rate the film 8.5/10. But since I have no desire to see it again, I won't be buying this on BD one day. Although I will highly recommend seeing it in the theater (to my friends and co-workers).
#156
DVD Talk Legend
#158
DVD Talk Legend
Re: 'The Road' - Nov. 2008
The Road hasn't gotten the reviews everyone was expecting (it currently stands at 71% on the RT meter), but to me it's one of the best of the year. Before I say anything else; yes I've read the book.
The Road is a dreary film, very cold and gray. There simply isn't a better adjective than depressing to describe the setting and story. However we get phenomenal performances from Mortensen and Smit-McPhee. I normally can't stand child actors, but Smit-McPhee portrays the boy well. Besides the flashbacks involving Charlize Theron, the movie follows the book to a T.
The cinematography, score, and production is 1st rate....the post apocalyptic world they lived in seemed very real.
This is definitely a Top Ten movie of 2009.
The Road is a dreary film, very cold and gray. There simply isn't a better adjective than depressing to describe the setting and story. However we get phenomenal performances from Mortensen and Smit-McPhee. I normally can't stand child actors, but Smit-McPhee portrays the boy well. Besides the flashbacks involving Charlize Theron, the movie follows the book to a T.
Spoiler:
This is definitely a Top Ten movie of 2009.
#160
Moderator
#161
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Joined: Jun 2004
Posts: 6,290
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: 'The Road' - Nov. 2008
Great movie! Especially if you have kids...this film really got to me even for hours after. Viggo Mortenson is one of the best actors working today. The kid was actually annoying, but maybe he's supposed to be like that. For this type of film, they should have casted someone better for the kid.
#162
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Re: 'The Road' - Nov. 2008
I listened to the unabridged audiobook of the novel last month before seeing the movie. And to repeat the cliche: the movie is not as good as the book. The film was rather faithful but seemed like a "Cliffs Notes" version of the novel to me, compressing a lot of events and concentrating a bit too much on hitting the highlights. I think having more voice-over narrative from Viggo as the Man would've helped the movie capture the book better.
Although it's faithful overall, here are some small differences I noticed between the book and the movie:
Overall, I liked the movie and give it 4 out of 5 stars, but it's still no substitute for the book.
Although it's faithful overall, here are some small differences I noticed between the book and the movie:
Spoiler:
Overall, I liked the movie and give it 4 out of 5 stars, but it's still no substitute for the book.
Last edited by dhmac; 12-07-09 at 10:08 AM. Reason: to correct some spelling
#163
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Joined: Apr 2000
Posts: 5,863
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Earth
Re: 'The Road' - Nov. 2008
This is still not playing near me, ridiculous. I really was looking forward to it but god only knows if i'll bother seeing it if it won't be out for a while. Interesting differences between the book and movie though.
#165
DVD Talk Legend
Re: 'The Road' - Nov. 2008
Great movie! Especially if you have kids...this film really got to me even for hours after. Viggo Mortenson is one of the best actors working today. The kid was actually annoying, but maybe he's supposed to be like that. For this type of film, they should have casted someone better for the kid.
Speaking of which, a man brought his very young child to this movie when I saw it. The kid couldn't have been more than 6 or 7 years old. What the hell was he thinking!?
BTW, after one week in limited release, the film dropped 50%. That's not a good sign for it's long term run when it goes wide.
#166
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Joined: Jun 2004
Posts: 6,290
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: 'The Road' - Nov. 2008
Speaking of which, a man brought his very young child to this movie when I saw it. The kid couldn't have been more than 6 or 7 years old. What the hell was he thinking!?
BTW, after one week in limited release, the film dropped 50%. That's not a good sign for it's long term run when it goes wide.
BTW, after one week in limited release, the film dropped 50%. That's not a good sign for it's long term run when it goes wide.
childrens movie - thats how i thought as a kid. Same goes for anything i saw that was animated, such as watership down and animal farm.
I remember watching lord of the flies and the blue lagoon ad a kid and they sort of disturbed me as well, but i liked watching them.
#167
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Joined: Feb 2001
Posts: 7,071
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: So Cal
Re: 'The Road' - Nov. 2008
I caught it today and I liked it. I'm a fan of the book - wrote part of my English MFA dissertation on it - and thought it was both faithful and well-directed. I knew John Hillcoat would be a good fit - The Proposition is basically a Cormac McCarthy movie. One thing I can see being an issue:
Spoiler:
#168
Moderator
Re: 'The Road' - Nov. 2008
I'd agree with that idea, do you have examples off the top of your head?
#169
DVD Talk Legend
Re: 'The Road' - Nov. 2008
So I see now movietickets lists a release date of 12/18 - I wonder if this is finally a significant wider release. Would love to see this but I'm driving all over creation in the winter to do so.
#170
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Re: 'The Road' - Nov. 2008
Even with a wide release on 12/18, it will be killed thanks to Avatar, Sherlock Holmes, and the other big title movies coming out in the next 2 weeks.
I can not believe how they managed to fuck up the release of this movie so far. Aside from holding onto it for a year, they dump it out in limited release while advertising it nationwide, then they (possibly) roll out a wide release at the worst possible time.
I can not believe how they managed to fuck up the release of this movie so far. Aside from holding onto it for a year, they dump it out in limited release while advertising it nationwide, then they (possibly) roll out a wide release at the worst possible time.
#171
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Joined: Apr 2000
Posts: 5,863
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Earth
Re: 'The Road' - Nov. 2008
Glad to see it's FINALLY playing near me as of 12/18 but only at the 4 screen place that shows more indy type/foreign movies. That's fine by me but I agree, doesn't bode well for the box office or award potential.
#174
Senior Member
Joined: Aug 2005
Posts: 340
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: San Diego, Calif
Re: 'The Road' - Nov. 2008
I don't recall this in the novel, but it would seem like the mark of an outcast of a particular group, much like a harsher version of notching someone's ear. Anyone would have a much harder time surviving on his own without an opposable thumb, particularly if you needed to use a gun or knife.
#175
Re: 'The Road' - Nov. 2008
Just got back from seeing this. Besides me and my dad, there was one other person in the theater
Although it added to the atmosphere of the emptiness the film conveyed.
It's been awhile since I read the book so the film felt fresh to me. This was the most depressing movie I've seen and that's a positive in my opinion since it captured the feel of the book and didn't feel Hollywood at all.
One thing that bugged me
Overall i and my father really enjoyed the film. He suggested watching Twilight to feel happy again
Although it added to the atmosphere of the emptiness the film conveyed. It's been awhile since I read the book so the film felt fresh to me. This was the most depressing movie I've seen and that's a positive in my opinion since it captured the feel of the book and didn't feel Hollywood at all.
One thing that bugged me
Spoiler:
Overall i and my father really enjoyed the film. He suggested watching Twilight to feel happy again



