Is Blu Ray better than DVD?
#26
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: Is Blu Ray better than DVD?
Is the OP even using HDMI cables?
There have been a couple of times that I've put in the DVD instead of the Blu-ray. I spent much of the movie feeling like something was just a bit off, like things looked a bit duller. Once the Blu-ray went in, the colors popped again, and the movie looked much better.
There have been a couple of times that I've put in the DVD instead of the Blu-ray. I spent much of the movie feeling like something was just a bit off, like things looked a bit duller. Once the Blu-ray went in, the colors popped again, and the movie looked much better.
The following users liked this post:
Doctor Kick (12-17-21)
#27
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Is Blu Ray better than DVD?
Unless something went horribly wrong in the mastering or the source material is bad, 1080p will always look better than 480p.
I notice that some older movies don't necessarily look a lot better on blu-ray than DVD; they were either filmed "soft" or have a lot of grain, or didn't receive a good HD master. I notice this quite a bit with 70s and 80s horror movies.
But blu-rays for films like Avatar or Transformers will blow the DVD out of the water.
And another factor, as mentioned above, is that often times the color timing is tinkered with, adding tints -- the dreaded "teal and orange," or what was done with the extended version of Fellowship of the Ring, which added a weird green tint to the entire movie and crushed blacks. And then there's the first blu-ray of Bram Stoker's Dracula...
I notice that some older movies don't necessarily look a lot better on blu-ray than DVD; they were either filmed "soft" or have a lot of grain, or didn't receive a good HD master. I notice this quite a bit with 70s and 80s horror movies.
But blu-rays for films like Avatar or Transformers will blow the DVD out of the water.
And another factor, as mentioned above, is that often times the color timing is tinkered with, adding tints -- the dreaded "teal and orange," or what was done with the extended version of Fellowship of the Ring, which added a weird green tint to the entire movie and crushed blacks. And then there's the first blu-ray of Bram Stoker's Dracula...
The following users liked this post:
Doctor Kick (12-17-21)
#28
DVD Talk Hero
The following users liked this post:
Doctor Kick (12-17-21)
#29
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Is Blu Ray better than DVD?
The following users liked this post:
Doctor Kick (12-17-21)
#30
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
The following 2 users liked this post by clckworang:
Doctor Kick (12-17-21),
Josh Z (12-17-21)
#31
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Re: Is Blu Ray better than DVD?
Unless something went horribly wrong in the mastering or the source material is bad, 1080p will always look better than 480p.
I notice that some older movies don't necessarily look a lot better on blu-ray than DVD; they were either filmed "soft" or have a lot of grain, or didn't receive a good HD master. I notice this quite a bit with 70s and 80s horror movies.
I notice that some older movies don't necessarily look a lot better on blu-ray than DVD; they were either filmed "soft" or have a lot of grain, or didn't receive a good HD master. I notice this quite a bit with 70s and 80s horror movies.
Some modern era tv shows also appear to do this, where it looked like a softening "crap-fying" filter was applied to the video. The worst culprits were shows like Criminal Minds and the first NCIS.
The following users liked this post:
Doctor Kick (12-17-21)
#32
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Re: Is Blu Ray better than DVD?
It depends on which metric one uses, and even then it would depend on the specific discs themselves. For the most part, the picture quality on a blue ray should be better than it's corresponding dvd. Not always the case, though. Where the argument can be made that dvd is "better" is in, as already mentioned, the "resuming from where you left off feature". Worked on every dvd, realy hit or miss, ore miss, on blue ray. Also, the sheer number of titles put out on dvd vs blueray is way higher. Dvds are also usually less money.
The following users liked this post:
Doctor Kick (12-17-21)
#33
DVD Talk Legend
The following 2 users liked this post by Norm de Plume:
Doctor Kick (12-17-21),
Sonic (12-16-21)
#34
Re: Is Blu Ray better than DVD?


Van Damme back in the day was a legend.

The following users liked this post:
Doctor Kick (12-17-21)
#35
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Is Blu Ray better than DVD?
I have that on DVD, I really like the movie. I'll have to keep an eye out for the SFCE, if I can find it for my kind of price. Upgrades like that on movies I really like are definitely a good thing.
The following users liked this post:
Doctor Kick (12-17-21)
The following 3 users liked this post by Gizmo:
#37
The following 2 users liked this post by Sonic:
Doctor Kick (12-17-21),
Kurt D (12-16-21)
#38
DVD Talk Legend
The following users liked this post:
Doctor Kick (12-17-21)
#39
Re: Is Blu Ray better than DVD?
Actually, the question is valid. It's not about an "extra" button press, the REAL reason is a Javascript artificial limitation. Discs authored with that abomination of Javascript code can't be started from where they left off because it's a "copy-protection" type of limitation. To get around this, every disc, when stripped of its Javascript code *will* resume play where it left off. But, of course the only way to do this is to strip off all that garbage yourself, re-author a proper copy, and burn that disc for your own personal viewing pleasure, WITHOUT all of those needlessly draconian limitations.
The following users liked this post:
Doctor Kick (12-17-21)
#40
The following 2 users liked this post by Sonic:
Doctor Kick (12-17-21),
Norm de Plume (12-17-21)
#41
Member
Thread Starter
Re: Is Blu Ray better than DVD?
The bad guy in Cyborg is awesome. Not sure if I’ve seen him in anything else. Hard Target’s always been my favorite Van Damme. That hair. He should’ve won an Oscar for that hair.
You guys seem pretty confident that Blu Ray is better. I have a 2 tv setup and I can’t see the difference. Some times I think I see a slight difference, but it’s not enough to where I can say oh yeah I definitely see it. Will try to compare something like avatar or transformers some time. I hate those movies though so may have to try something else🤣
You guys seem pretty confident that Blu Ray is better. I have a 2 tv setup and I can’t see the difference. Some times I think I see a slight difference, but it’s not enough to where I can say oh yeah I definitely see it. Will try to compare something like avatar or transformers some time. I hate those movies though so may have to try something else🤣
The following users liked this post:
Sonic (12-17-21)
#42
Re: Is Blu Ray better than DVD?
You guys seem pretty confident that Blu Ray is better. I have a 2 tv setup and I can’t see the difference. Some times I think I see a slight difference, but it’s not enough to where I can say oh yeah I definitely see it. Will try to compare something like avatar or transformers some time. I hate those movies though so may have to try something else🤣

The following users liked this post:
Doctor Kick (12-19-21)
#43
DVD Talk Reviewer/Moderator
Re: Is Blu Ray better than DVD?
No offense, but if you really don't know what a CRT TV is (or don't care to look it up) then I think the facts arising from your question would probably be irrelevant to you anyway?
The following 2 users liked this post by Kurt D:
Alan Smithee (12-20-21),
Doctor Kick (12-19-21)
#44
Member
Thread Starter
Re: Is Blu Ray better than DVD?
#45
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: Is Blu Ray better than DVD?
The bad guy in Cyborg is awesome. Not sure if I’ve seen him in anything else. Hard Target’s always been my favorite Van Damme. That hair. He should’ve won an Oscar for that hair.
You guys seem pretty confident that Blu Ray is better. I have a 2 tv setup and I can’t see the difference. Some times I think I see a slight difference, but it’s not enough to where I can say oh yeah I definitely see it. Will try to compare something like avatar or transformers some time. I hate those movies though so may have to try something else🤣
You guys seem pretty confident that Blu Ray is better. I have a 2 tv setup and I can’t see the difference. Some times I think I see a slight difference, but it’s not enough to where I can say oh yeah I definitely see it. Will try to compare something like avatar or transformers some time. I hate those movies though so may have to try something else🤣
The following users liked this post:
Doctor Kick (12-19-21)
#46
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Re: Is Blu Ray better than DVD?
(Independent of whether anybody can "see" the picture quality difference between bluray and dvd).
The primary reason why I ended up buying the bluray versions, was that the bluray was frequently around the same price or sometimes even less than the price of the dvd-only version.
The primary reason why I ended up buying the bluray versions, was that the bluray was frequently around the same price or sometimes even less than the price of the dvd-only version.
The following users liked this post:
Doctor Kick (12-19-21)
#47
Re: Is Blu Ray better than DVD?
It could also depend if the CRT (Cathode Ray Tube) TV is actually 1080 or not. And even if it is 1080, there were limitations with CRT, which is why Plasma and later LCD became much more popular.
Last edited by b2net; 12-19-21 at 12:53 PM.
The following users liked this post:
Doctor Kick (12-19-21)
#48
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Re: Is Blu Ray better than DVD?
^ Minor correction: CRT stands for Cathode Ray Tube, not continuous.
The following 2 users liked this post by rbrown498:
Doctor Kick (12-19-21),
Kurt D (12-19-21)
#49
The following users liked this post:
Doctor Kick (12-19-21)
#50
Member
Thread Starter
Re: Is Blu Ray better than DVD?
Definitely I always get the dvd if it’s cheaper. I have a lot of blu ray dvd combos because some times that’s all that’s available.