Dogma
07-01-12, 02:00 AM
#1
New Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jun 2012
Posts: 14
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Dogma
What do you all think of this film? Why was it considered controversial enough for studios to toss around the licensing for the home video release so much? How is Sony's effort with the blu-ray?
I read that Sony just lost the rights to this and it has me very interested, might be awhile before we see it again.
I read that Sony just lost the rights to this and it has me very interested, might be awhile before we see it again.
07-01-12, 02:05 AM
#2
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Dogma
Originally Posted by APx3OG
I read that Sony just lost the rights to this and it has me very interested, might be awhile before we see it again.
Even though it's OOP GuruAskew at Blu-ray.com (he posts here, too) explained the rights issues and all that in a post there.
This movie has a complicated ownership situation.
It was produced by Miramax under Disney's ownership and then sold off to Miramax founders Bob and Harvey Weinstein under pressure from Disney due to controversy. Lionsgate then distributed the film theatrically and at the time Lionsgate didn't have a home video branch. Universal was distributing Lionsgate titles and they refused to release it on video so it was ultimately picked up by Sony.
A lot has changed in the years since then (Miramax no longer having any ties to Disney, Lionsgate acquiring Trimark for their video distribution and then merging with Artisan and all their subsidiaries to form the largest video library in North America) but Lionsgate and Sony might not have anything to do with the movie all these years later. I know the Lionsgate logo is clipped from the beginning of the film on video. I don't think their involvement was ever for anything other than theatrical distribution.
The Weinstein brothers themselves probably own the rights to the film and I could see it popping up as a Weinstein Company release.
It was produced by Miramax under Disney's ownership and then sold off to Miramax founders Bob and Harvey Weinstein under pressure from Disney due to controversy. Lionsgate then distributed the film theatrically and at the time Lionsgate didn't have a home video branch. Universal was distributing Lionsgate titles and they refused to release it on video so it was ultimately picked up by Sony.
A lot has changed in the years since then (Miramax no longer having any ties to Disney, Lionsgate acquiring Trimark for their video distribution and then merging with Artisan and all their subsidiaries to form the largest video library in North America) but Lionsgate and Sony might not have anything to do with the movie all these years later. I know the Lionsgate logo is clipped from the beginning of the film on video. I don't think their involvement was ever for anything other than theatrical distribution.
The Weinstein brothers themselves probably own the rights to the film and I could see it popping up as a Weinstein Company release.
07-01-12, 02:47 AM
#3
Re: Dogma
I have the BD. I miss the amusing menus from the 2 disc set. Also the theatrical trailer is missing. (BTW, what's the deal with all these catalog titles forgoing the theatrical trailers on the Blu Ray versions of DVD titles that carried them before?)
And no, it does not have the "Judge Not" doc from the Vulgar DVD.
KS's movies have had a spotty history on BD:
Clerks [All extras from the 10th Anniversary edition]
Mallrats [MIA]
Chasing Amy [Different extras from the Criterion Edition]
Dogma [All extras except amusing menus and theatrical trailer]
Jay and Silent Bob Strike Back [Only the audio commentary]
Jersey Girl [MIA]
Clerks II [All extras]
Zack and Miri Make a Porno [All Extras]
Red State [not sure]
And no, it does not have the "Judge Not" doc from the Vulgar DVD.
KS's movies have had a spotty history on BD:
Clerks [All extras from the 10th Anniversary edition]
Mallrats [MIA]
Chasing Amy [Different extras from the Criterion Edition]
Dogma [All extras except amusing menus and theatrical trailer]
Jay and Silent Bob Strike Back [Only the audio commentary]
Jersey Girl [MIA]
Clerks II [All extras]
Zack and Miri Make a Porno [All Extras]
Red State [not sure]
07-01-12, 08:11 AM
#6
Senior Member
Join Date: Jul 2009
Location: Massachusetts
Posts: 720
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Dogma
Originally Posted by Graftenberg
I never even heard of Red State, had to look it up on IMDB. Why didn't it get a wide release?
07-01-12, 11:35 AM
#7
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Join Date: Aug 2010
Posts: 2,080
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Dogma
I used to be a huge Smith fan but I don't even own any of his movies on Blu.
Red State is available on Netflix and it was available for months before I got around to watching it (as opposed to 10 years ago when I would have traveled out-of-state to see the first showing) and I was pleasantly surprised.
It's almost unrecognizable as a Smith film, very violent and disturbing and the Parks and Goodman performances are arguably the best in any Smith films. I definitely don't think the film got its due due to the overall backlash Smith has experienced over the years and I also think the film itself was overshadowed by all the distribution drama.
But yeah check it out on Netflix.
Red State is available on Netflix and it was available for months before I got around to watching it (as opposed to 10 years ago when I would have traveled out-of-state to see the first showing) and I was pleasantly surprised.
It's almost unrecognizable as a Smith film, very violent and disturbing and the Parks and Goodman performances are arguably the best in any Smith films. I definitely don't think the film got its due due to the overall backlash Smith has experienced over the years and I also think the film itself was overshadowed by all the distribution drama.
But yeah check it out on Netflix.
07-01-12, 02:30 PM
#9
Re: Dogma
Kevin Smith had a special message included on his Clerks BD inquiring why anyone would even want on watch Clerks in 1080p. It was class Smith-ian self depreciation!
07-01-12, 04:36 PM
#10
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Dogma
Originally Posted by Match
Mallrats Bluray is being released July 2 in the UK. No bonus stuff or extras at all.
I'll wait for the US release date.
I'll wait for the US release date.
07-01-12, 04:55 PM
#11
New Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jun 2012
Posts: 14
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Dogma
I went ahead and picked up a copy from amazon while it's still in stock. The general consensus is this is a beautiful transfer and I look forward to getting it and watching it. I think it was pretty lucky that Sony put out this movie for as long as it did because a lot of other studios don't take care of their catalog titles like they do.
07-01-12, 08:28 PM
#12
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Re: Dogma
Originally Posted by mcfly
There's a wealth of extras on the DVD. I hope they include them on the US release, being my favorite Smith film.
I think the SE's "Governor's Ball" opening was a tad long, but after that I really enjoyed the little bits of extra footage seen everywhere else.
07-01-12, 09:26 PM
#13
DVD Talk Legend & 2021 TOTY Winner
Re: Dogma
It's probably a Canadian release, but inetvideo.com has this on BD for 3.99 (+2.95 shipping) right now.
07-01-12, 11:40 PM
#14
Re: Dogma
I would buy all the other Askewniverse movies and "Zack and Miri" on BD if they were put out with the loving care of their DVD counterparts. But, I refuse to buy "Jay and Silent Bob Strike Back" on Blu ray, if they aren't going to pony up the goods of the 2-disc DVD.
07-02-12, 05:38 PM
#15
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Dogma
JASBSB was a victim of bad timing. It was chosen to be one of Disney's earliest BD releases, from the days when they had to use the less efficient MPEG-2 video and PCM audio, and before dual-layer discs were viable. If it had been released about a year later, it probably would have contained everything.
07-02-12, 05:58 PM
#16
Banned
Join Date: Apr 2008
Location: Formerly known as "Solid Snake PAC"/Denton, Tx
Posts: 39,239
Likes: 0
Received 4 Likes
on
4 Posts
Re: Dogma
Originally Posted by PatD
I would buy all the other Askewniverse movies and "Zack and Miri" on BD if they were put out with the loving care of their DVD counterparts. But, I refuse to buy "Jay and Silent Bob Strike Back" on Blu ray, if they aren't going to pony up the goods of the 2-disc DVD.
07-02-12, 07:05 PM
#17
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Dogma
Originally Posted by Solid Snake PAC
wait...what's wrong w/ Zack and Miri?
We'll never see a Jay & Silent Bob Strike back SE now that Lionsgate is handling the distribution rights.
07-02-12, 08:27 PM
#18
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: Dogma
Originally Posted by mcfly
We'll never see a Jay & Silent Bob Strike back SE now that Lionsgate is handling the distribution rights.
07-02-12, 08:44 PM
#19
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Dogma
Originally Posted by Todd B.
Why not?
That, and Lionsgate isn't known for their elaborate SEs.
07-02-12, 09:12 PM
#20
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: Dogma
Oh, I didn't realize they'd already reissued the existing edition.
Nevertheless, they have released a lot of Miramax catalog titles over the past couple years, retaining all the special features from the original editions (The Crow, Cider House Rules, etc.). And they're even double dipping on Good Will Hunting in a couple months, adding new features. So, I think there's certainly hope that they will do a proper reissue of J&SBSB with all the extras.
Nevertheless, they have released a lot of Miramax catalog titles over the past couple years, retaining all the special features from the original editions (The Crow, Cider House Rules, etc.). And they're even double dipping on Good Will Hunting in a couple months, adding new features. So, I think there's certainly hope that they will do a proper reissue of J&SBSB with all the extras.
07-03-12, 12:06 PM
#21
Senior Member
Re: Dogma
There are a few extras from the DVD that aren't on the BD, but they're pretty much forgettable (the lady telling you not to watch the film, easter eggs of Smith and Mewes playing with Jay and Silent Bob action figures). There is a pretty informative booklet that comes with the DVD, though.
07-03-12, 12:54 PM
#22
Re: Dogma
Originally Posted by Solid Snake PAC
wait...what's wrong w/ Zack and Miri?
