General Blu-ray News and Discussion - Part 5
#201
Originally Posted by jiggawhat
Unfortunately, people who want to shit on BD come to this thread instead of posting in the HD-DVD thread where they belong. That's why there has been 5 parts to this one and only 2 for HD-DVD. And it looks like nothing has changed.
#202
I posted a few pages back, but just a reminder to those who own the Samsung 1400, the new 1.5 firmware is up on the site. The feedback seems to be that it has corrected alot of issues and the problem discs now play on the unit. Even though it's a 1.0 unit, it does decode TrueHD audio and can send DTS MA via bitstream. I believe it's only $329 on Amazon right now. And don't forget those 20% off BD player coupons at BB floating around.
#203
DVD Talk Legend
Just wanted to mention I saw Rambo last night and it kicked ass. I was happy to see it's a Lionsgate release. If they do this as another 7.1 PCM Blu-Ray, I think it will easily beat 3:10 To Yuma and War for the best 7.1 track yet. The sound was awesome in the theater.
#204
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Joined: Apr 2001
Posts: 2,923
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: In the Universe.
Originally Posted by bunkaroo
Just wanted to mention I saw Rambo last night and it kicked ass. I was happy to see it's a Lionsgate release. If they do this as another 7.1 PCM Blu-Ray, I think it will easily beat 3:10 To Yuma and War for the best 7.1 track yet. The sound was awesome in the theater.
#205
Originally Posted by bunkaroo
Just wanted to mention I saw Rambo last night and it kicked ass. I was happy to see it's a Lionsgate release. If they do this as another 7.1 PCM Blu-Ray, I think it will easily beat 3:10 To Yuma and War for the best 7.1 track yet. The sound was awesome in the theater.
#206
Suspended
Originally Posted by Mr. Cinema
Mutliple confirmations from AVS users that Circuit City stores are putting their HD DVD players on clearance. Supposedly, the A3 is marked down to $100 and the A30 at $149. Hard to tell if this is a regional thing or if it will be national. Here's a pic that one member took:
#207
DVD Talk Legend
Originally Posted by bunkaroo
But here's the flipside of the "no new HD DVD titles to compete with"....why weren't there?
#208
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Joined: Apr 2003
Posts: 2,745
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Houston, Texas
Originally Posted by Mr. Cinema
Mutliple confirmations from AVS users that Circuit City stores are putting their HD DVD players on clearance. Supposedly, the A3 is marked down to $100 and the A30 at $149. Hard to tell if this is a regional thing or if it will be national. Here's a pic that one member took:

#209
Suspended
Originally Posted by tonymontana313
Thanks for the news Mr Cinema. Btw, there is no problem with this being in the BD thread since it is pertaining to a major retailer dropping out the competition.
Toshiba had planned to discontinue the A3 and A35 weeks before Warners announcement. They were only planning on producing the A30 and Gen4 unit.
Venturer or someone else would handle the cheaper versions, Onkyo would do the more expensive. More CEs = Good...right?
Notice the price of the A30? $149.99.
Notice the price of the A3? $100.04
.04 = Clearance
.99 = NOT Clearance.
They are just moving units and several people have already confirmed Circuit City has more units on the way and are ordering more. All this is doing is helping out HD DVD.
#210
DVD Talk Legend
Originally Posted by GizmoDVD
Circuit City is not going anywhere.
Toshiba had planned to discontinue the A3 and A35 weeks before Warners announcement. They were only planning on producing the A30 and Gen4 unit.
Venturer or someone else would handle the cheaper versions, Onkyo would do the more expensive. More CEs = Good...right?
Notice the price of the A30? $149.99.
Notice the price of the A3? $100.04
.04 = Clearance
.99 = NOT Clearance.
They are just moving units and several people have already confirmed Circuit City has more units on the way and are ordering more. All this is doing is helping out HD DVD.

Toshiba had planned to discontinue the A3 and A35 weeks before Warners announcement. They were only planning on producing the A30 and Gen4 unit.
Venturer or someone else would handle the cheaper versions, Onkyo would do the more expensive. More CEs = Good...right?
Notice the price of the A30? $149.99.
Notice the price of the A3? $100.04
.04 = Clearance
.99 = NOT Clearance.
They are just moving units and several people have already confirmed Circuit City has more units on the way and are ordering more. All this is doing is helping out HD DVD.

#211
Suspended
Originally Posted by dsa_shea
Circuit City actually playing any major role in this war either way is actually really irrelevant. You sure seem ready and willing to counter every single post that just might signify the end of Hd-Dvd support by a retailer. Isn't it about time to cheer for them to say goodbye to that format so that we as consumers can just move on?
The reasoning is because its a good thing for Blu-ray? Really? So this is a Pro Blu-ray/Bash HD DVD thread?
Again, as you can see what I posted earlier, Toshiba planned on discontinuing the A3/A35 line. That has been known for a while, before Warners announcement. I don't see why the sudden shock of them selling off players that include Warner titles (as they no longer support them) and replacing them with another Universal/Paramount movie instead (or phasing out those certain player altogether but changing the in-box movies for players not yet boxed up). Why continue to promote another studios movie who just back stabbed you?
#212
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Joined: Apr 2003
Posts: 2,745
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Houston, Texas
Here we go again. Mods could we please have one format war thread so we don't have the BLU-RAY thread derailed yet again. Adam has already stated if you are not INTERESTED in BD, this thread is not for you! BD supporters can't even discuss releases without having to deal with discussions about downloads will win, FOX SUCKS!!!!, and who cares about numbers derailments. This is not meant as a jab to hd-dvd supporters because I do enjoy posting with most of y'all but there are some that just refuse to post anything productive to this thread. (Vent done)
#213
Originally Posted by GizmoDVD
No, but the entire CC thing was not needed in a BLU-RAY thread.
The reasoning is because its a good thing for Blu-ray? Really? So this is a Pro Blu-ray/Bash HD DVD thread?
Again, as you can see what I posted earlier, Toshiba planned on discontinuing the A3/A35 line. That has been known for a while, before Warners announcement. I don't see why the sudden shock of them selling off players that include Warner titles (as they no longer support them) and replacing them with another Universal/Paramount movie instead (or phasing out those certain player altogether but changing the in-box movies for players not yet boxed up). Why continue to promote another studios movie who just back stabbed you?
The reasoning is because its a good thing for Blu-ray? Really? So this is a Pro Blu-ray/Bash HD DVD thread?
Again, as you can see what I posted earlier, Toshiba planned on discontinuing the A3/A35 line. That has been known for a while, before Warners announcement. I don't see why the sudden shock of them selling off players that include Warner titles (as they no longer support them) and replacing them with another Universal/Paramount movie instead (or phasing out those certain player altogether but changing the in-box movies for players not yet boxed up). Why continue to promote another studios movie who just back stabbed you?
#214
Suspended
Originally Posted by tonymontana313
Here we go again. Mods could we please have one format war thread so we don't have the BLU-RAY thread derailed yet again. Adam has already stated if you are not INTERESTED in BD, this thread is not for you! BD supporters can't even discuss releases without having to deal with discussions about downloads will win, FOX SUCKS!!!!, and who cares about numbers derailments. This is not meant as a jab to hd-dvd supporters because I do enjoy posting with most of y'all but there are some that just refuse to post anything productive to this thread. (Vent done)
Problem is, you have people that have both Blu-ray and HD DVD and go in both threads to discuss. However when someone posts something that is not true or inaccurate, and someone that is slanted in the other formats direction see this and tries correcting it, its total chaos. I see the A30/A3 is on 'clearance' at Circuit City. Thats great. But we already know Toshiba was planning on discontinuing the A3/A35 versions. A30 may just be on sale to counter Best Buys price (20% coupon this week/2 free movies in store) or clearing stock for the 2 new pack-in movies that won't include '300'. Maybe CC is testing the waters for a lower price for Toshiba?
What we do know, however, is Toshiba is still making and selling HD DVD players, and Circuit City has more A3x on the way along with orders places for additional units, something the OP of the CC Clearance neglected (or maybe didn't know) posted.
#215
DVD Talk Legend
Originally Posted by Josh Z
Because it's January.
Why for two January's in a row has Blu-Ray shown up with titles but not HD DVD?
There have been several significant DVD and Blu-Ray day and dates this January. The only truly slow day could be 1/1, and even then there were a few day and dates.
For all I know it's not a format thing. It could just be HD DVD's misfortune that the two studios backing them right now seem to hibernate this month.
Personally I don't give a shit what month it is - put the titles out. Gift cards from the holidays have IMO put a pretty good dent in the myth that people are licking their financial wounds from the holidays, and thus are not spending.
Last edited by bunkaroo; 01-26-08 at 06:17 PM.
#216
Suspended
Originally Posted by bunkaroo
I always hear that reason. I was just waiting for someone to say it.
Why for two January's in a row has Blu-Ray shown up with titles but not HD DVD?
There have been several significant DVD and Blu-Ray day and dates this January. The only truly slow day could be 1/1, and even then there were a few day and dates.
For all I know it's not a format thing. It could just be HD DVD's misfortune that the two studios backing them right now seem to hibernate this month.
Personally I don't give a shit what month it is - put the titles out. Gift cards from the holidays have IMO put a pretty good dent in the myth that people are licking their financial wounds form the holidays, and thus are not spending.
Why for two January's in a row has Blu-Ray shown up with titles but not HD DVD?
There have been several significant DVD and Blu-Ray day and dates this January. The only truly slow day could be 1/1, and even then there were a few day and dates.
For all I know it's not a format thing. It could just be HD DVD's misfortune that the two studios backing them right now seem to hibernate this month.
Personally I don't give a shit what month it is - put the titles out. Gift cards from the holidays have IMO put a pretty good dent in the myth that people are licking their financial wounds form the holidays, and thus are not spending.
3:10 to Yuma = Lionsgate
Saw IV = Lionsgate
Resident Evil = Sony
Last year I think it was also a majority of Lionsgate films in January/February.
Since I don't really know the theatrical release dates on these, I assume they were September/October (2 month cycle). I was pissed last year when Universal did this (and Warner and Paramount as well) and did not release anything but a handful of titles between January and March. I was hoping they wouldn't pull this crap again...but they did. The catalog titles on Blu-ray don't look that great either for the next few months, but they simply have more new releases. I don't see more then 3-4 new releases I will be buying in the next 3 months on both formats combined.
Here is last years Blu-ray schedule... A lot of Lionsgate and Sony new releases. Not much else from Fox, Disney, Paramount or Warner besides catalog releases.
* Casino Royale (Sony)
* The Holiday (2006) (Sony)
* Hoosiers (MGM)
* Layer Cake (Sony)
February 27, 2007
* Bullitt (Warner)
* The Getaway (1972) (Warner)
* Nature's Colors with the World's Greatest Music (Concert Hot Spot)
* Nine Inch Nails Live: Beside You in Time (Interscope)
* Stranger Than Fiction (Sony)
February 20, 2007
* Babel (Paramount)
* Destiny's Child: Live in Atlanta (Sony BMG)
* The Prestige (Buena Vista)
* Vertical Limit (Sony)
February 13, 2007
* Broken Arrow (Fox)
* Chain Reaction (Fox)
* Chronos (Koch)
* The Departed (Warner)
* Entrapment (Fox)
* Ladder 49 (Buena Vista)
* The Marine (Fox)
* Phone Booth (Fox)
* Planet of the Apes (Fox)
* Reign of Fire (Buena Vista)
* The Sentinel (Fox)
* The Usual Suspects (Fox)
* The World's Fastest Indian (Magnolia)
February 06, 2007
* American Psycho (Lionsgate)
* First Blood (Lionsgate)
* Reservoir Dogs (Lionsgate)
* Running With Scissors (Sony)
* The Tailor of Panama (Sony)
* Young Guns (Lionsgate)
January 30, 2007
* Beerfest (Warner)
* Discovery Atlas: Australia Revealed (Discovery Channel)
* Discovery Atlas: Brazil Revealed (Discovery Channel)
* Discovery Atlas: China Revealed (Discovery Channel)
* Discovery Atlas: Italy Revealed (Discovery Channel)
* Flyboys (Fox)
* Hart's War (Fox)
* Open Season (Sony)
* The Wicker Man (2006) (Warner)
January 25, 2007
* District B13 (Magnolia)
January 23, 2007
* Alien vs. Predator (Fox)
* Black Rain (Paramount)
* Casanova (Buena Vista)
* Chicago (Buena Vista)
* Courage Under Fire (Fox)
* The Guardian (2006) (Buena Vista)
* The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy (Buena Vista)
* The Manchurian Candidate (2004) (Paramount)
* Men of Honor (Fox)
* Saw II (Lionsgate)
* Saw III (Lionsgate)
* Toto: Live in Amsterdam (Eagle Rock)
* We Were Soldiers (Paramount)
January 16, 2007
* Employee of the Month (Lionsgate)
* GoodFellas (Warner)
* Gridiron Gang (Sony)
* Resident Evil: Apocalypse (Sony)
* Scooby-Doo (2002) (Warner)
January 09, 2007
* Crank (Lionsgate)
Last edited by Gizmo; 01-26-08 at 06:23 PM.
#217
DVD Talk Legend
You forgot about Shoot 'Em Up from New Line. That was 1/1. I think War was 1/1 as well - another Lionsgate.
And, if Uni and Paramount have no significant day and date titles, put out some more catalog titles. Actually that goes for all studios.
It's simple.
EDIT: You don't think the catalog titles look good for Blu in the next few months? I assume you mean according to your personal preference, because there are some great titles coming out. Most of them were just mentioned a page or two ago.
I personally can't wait to get my hands on Run Lola Run, Gattaca, ID4 and Unbreakable, Commando, Predator, Baron Munchausen, Life Of Brian, etc., etc.
And, if Uni and Paramount have no significant day and date titles, put out some more catalog titles. Actually that goes for all studios.
It's simple.
EDIT: You don't think the catalog titles look good for Blu in the next few months? I assume you mean according to your personal preference, because there are some great titles coming out. Most of them were just mentioned a page or two ago.
I personally can't wait to get my hands on Run Lola Run, Gattaca, ID4 and Unbreakable, Commando, Predator, Baron Munchausen, Life Of Brian, etc., etc.
Last edited by bunkaroo; 01-26-08 at 06:48 PM.
#218
Suspended
Originally Posted by bunkaroo
You forgot about Shoot 'Em Up from New Line. That was 1/1. I think War was 1/1 as well - another Lionsgate.
And, if Uni and Paramount have no significant day and date titles, put out some more catalog titles. Actually that goes for all studios.
It's simple.
EDIT: You don't think the catalog titles look good for Blu in the next few months? I assume you mean according to your personal preference, ebacuse there are some great titles coming out. Most of them wer ejust mentioned a page or two ago.
I personally can't wait to get my hands on Run Lola Run, Gattaca, ID4 and Unbreakable, Commando, Predator, Baron Munchausen, Life Of Brian, etc., etc.
And, if Uni and Paramount have no significant day and date titles, put out some more catalog titles. Actually that goes for all studios.
It's simple.
EDIT: You don't think the catalog titles look good for Blu in the next few months? I assume you mean according to your personal preference, ebacuse there are some great titles coming out. Most of them wer ejust mentioned a page or two ago.
I personally can't wait to get my hands on Run Lola Run, Gattaca, ID4 and Unbreakable, Commando, Predator, Baron Munchausen, Life Of Brian, etc., etc.
I don't really see that many title. All the ones you listed I have no interest in besides maybe Unbreakable which I have on SD that I have yet to ever watch. Ive looked over the list for both formats...its at 3-4 new releases through March.
For me its
King of California (HD DVD version)
American Gangster (maybe)
Beowulf (maybe)
Bee Movie
30 Days of Night
Dan in Real Life (maybe)
I am Legend (Prefer to wait for the HD DVD version, but all depends)
Walk Hard (maybe)
So 8 total. 4 For sure, 4 maybe. Not a single catalog title.
Last edited by Gizmo; 01-26-08 at 06:53 PM.
#219
DVD Talk Legend
I'm in for:
Life of Brian
Adventures of Baron Munchausen
Unbreakable
I, Robot
These are really good catalog titles. I'm sure there are a few others I have missed that I will pick up. I'm hoping that ID4 will be revisitited somewhere down the road and then I will pick it up.
Life of Brian
Adventures of Baron Munchausen
Unbreakable
I, Robot
These are really good catalog titles. I'm sure there are a few others I have missed that I will pick up. I'm hoping that ID4 will be revisitited somewhere down the road and then I will pick it up.
#220
DVD Talk Special Edition
The catalog release announcements are pretty anemic for early to mid 08 (as far as what's been announced up to this point, that is). I guess it's ok for me since I just upgraded to Blu-ray, and I will have a chance to catch up because of it. Here is all I will be getting catalog-wise:
3/25: Bonnie & Clyde
5/6: Twister
Yep, that's it. I have never seen Life of Brian, though a stacked edition of it is a tempting blind buy. Still, I will probably just Netflix it. Other than that, I'm picking up new release stuff.
3/25: Bonnie & Clyde
5/6: Twister
Yep, that's it. I have never seen Life of Brian, though a stacked edition of it is a tempting blind buy. Still, I will probably just Netflix it. Other than that, I'm picking up new release stuff.
#221
Originally Posted by tonymontana313
Ok getting this thread back on topic, it seems like the next big release week for BD is March 11 with Hitman, ID4, I Robot, No Country for Old Men, Dogma, Gattaca, Dan in Real Life, Sleuth and August Rush. What are you guys looking to purchase that week? I'm personally looking at Hitman, ID4, I Robot, NCFOM, and Dogma.
#222
Banned by request
Mod Note: Even if you think a retailer clearing out HD DVDs is a good thing for Blu-ray, this isn't the place to discuss it. At the same time, the appropriate way to handle posts that are off topic is to bring them to a mod's attention instead of bashing or attacking the person who posted it. Now, unless Circuit City is planning to do something with their Blu-ray pricing, I don't want to see any more posts in here about them.
#223
Suspended
Harold and Kumar is getting re-released on DVD before the new movie comes out in April...no Blu-ray release though. Anyone know if Newline plans on releasing any catalog titles? So far the only one has been Pans...but even then it wasn't a very old release. I know we saw the "rumored" list due to the 7.1 soundtracks, but has there been any real news?
#224
DVD Talk Special Edition
No real news, but I wasn't impressed by that list of 7.1 soundtracks if those indeed turn out to be their first non-Pan's wave of catalog releases. It's likely we won't be getting "LOTR" for a while if they plan on doing it right, but I would think releases like "Seven" and "Boogie Nights" could still be great sellers for them. I know I'd pick them both up!
#225
DVD Talk Legend
Originally Posted by Dane Marvin
No real news, but I wasn't impressed by that list of 7.1 soundtracks if those indeed turn out to be their first non-Pan's wave of catalog releases. It's likely we won't be getting "LOTR" for a while if they plan on doing it right, but I would think releases like "Seven" and "Boogie Nights" could still be great sellers for them. I know I'd pick them both up!



