DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   Forum Feedback and Support (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/forum-feedback-support-4/)
-   -   What don't you like about v3? (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/forum-feedback-support/399021-what-dont-you-like-about-v3.html)

fumanstan 12-05-04 02:06 PM


Originally Posted by kevin75
maybe i am alone in this but the site is running hellishly slow for me. i am running safari on a G5 mac and it's frequently taking at least a minute for each page to load. sometimes it's better, but being on dial up, i hope this isn't permanant. i may have to try firefox instead and see if it does better.

No problems with speed for me. Or being logged out.

mikehunt 12-05-04 02:14 PM

I prefer the old tan and pink folders indicating if there had been a new post

speedyray 12-05-04 02:39 PM


Originally Posted by Celtic Bob
The only thing I don't like is that everytime I close IE I have to sign in again despite the fact that I checked off "Remember Me". :(

Agreed. Remember me does not work and it is irritating as hell. I would just assume have the old version. It appears only graphical upgrades were made. I am more concerned with not logging in twenty times a day.

Big Worms 12-05-04 02:39 PM


Originally Posted by mikehunt
I prefer the old tan and pink folders indicating if there had been a new post

Yes. The new icons seem too big.

speedyray 12-05-04 02:46 PM


Originally Posted by Trigger
Forum logged me out twice now and I haven't closed my browser or navigated away from the site.

Also - there's a somewhat neat feature where you point to a thread title and it displays the text of the first post, but it only works 1 out of 10 times. It's neat except that it doesn't work all the time and also because it obscures the other thread titles when it does work.

In response to the mouse over, I found that if you click the mouse button it will turn the feature on and off (just clicking where there is no link.)

* EDIT * Actually, it appears that does not work after more use

I am using Safari on a Dual Processor G4. Latest software. If this info helps any.

So far I greatly prefer the old system where I was logged in for about two years straight. I have logged four times today.

Jackskeleton 12-05-04 03:03 PM


Originally Posted by twikoff
is it just me.. or is everything just so damn big

<waiting for first adult reply>


that's what I'm thinking. everything looks over scale some. Needs a lot less flair and a lot more simple text.

Dazed 12-05-04 03:11 PM

I hate the sponsored links under the first message.

All the fonts/buttons seem too big.

how about an option to switch back to the old version ?

cynthia 12-05-04 03:15 PM

I wish the "Subscribe to this thread" option was back at the bottom. I hate having to go back up to the top of the page to subscribe.

I hope the old darker grey colors come back. I am getting snow blind.

GeoffK 12-05-04 03:16 PM

If you do advanced reply v. quick reply you get some nifty subscribe options... it's the best way to go.

cynthia 12-05-04 03:38 PM


Originally Posted by gkleinman
If you do advanced reply v. quick reply you get some nifty subscribe options... it's the best way to go.

Yes, but that's only if you post. I like to subscribe to some threads without posting. And the only way I see to do that is to go back to the top post on the page, and click on Thread Tools.

It's just a little extra work, I guess. I'm so used to reading all the posts in the thread, then having the add subscription link conveniently under the last post.

FantasticVSDoom 12-05-04 03:43 PM

I agree with the color complaints...Its like looking at a really bright yellow neon shirt. Plus I think the whole "change" thing is hard for everyone. I definitly like the idea of a paid premium type of service though. Count me as someone who would sign up if/when the time comes.

LorenzoL 12-05-04 03:56 PM

I don't mind the new upgrade. However, I wish we get our post count back.

sade 12-05-04 04:09 PM

Color + Font (yuk)

Sade

twikoff 12-05-04 04:36 PM


Originally Posted by LorenzoL
However, I wish we get our post count back.

i dont think you lost it... check your profile
if you mean the titles that reflect your current post count.. those are coming

Roto 12-05-04 04:50 PM


Originally Posted by twikoff
they were sep out before... but it was much smoother because i believe it feel into the two tone style we had before.. (not this current way where everything seems to be in its own little window)

i prefer the two tone style much more

Me too! If you can bring back the two tone style, alternating background for each post, and bring back the old flat colored smilies, that would be great!

The only new thing I noticed that I like so far is that each post has a link to its id number. Makes it much easier to link to another post :up:

Jackskeleton 12-05-04 05:03 PM


if you mean the titles that reflect your current post count.. those are coming
Perhaps he means a throw back to the days when they were under our user name. :o Oh, the memories.

twikoff 12-05-04 05:07 PM


Originally Posted by Jackskeleton
Perhaps he means a throw back to the days when they were under our user name. :o Oh, the memories.


:lol:
we now that wont ever come back

did you happen to notice how many posts you lost with the upgrade?
thanks to preacher.. i was able to tell i lost about 300 total.. not a big deal

although makes me wonder which threads were sacrificed

Rival11 12-05-04 05:10 PM

Love the upgrade not complaining about anything............well, maybe the fonts can be a little smaller but it's only a minor gripe.

DarkElf 12-05-04 05:10 PM


Originally Posted by twikoff
quick reply has been here for a long time
the nice addition to quick reply is the option to manually turn off your signature.. so you dont have to include it in every post

this is very nice for when you post many times in the same thread

... a feature really only applicable to you... :p

twikoff 12-05-04 05:14 PM

rival - suck up!!!

darkelf - shut up!!! :p

DarkElf 12-05-04 05:20 PM

Change is usually not a positive thing in the minds of many users. People get comfortable with how things are, and change upsets that comfort level. But most people get used to it, and usually end up liking it.

In general, I like the upgrade. Good job, Geoff. I don't like one of the new icons: :cool: looks like a snowball. Totally ruins my sig now. :(

And I've lost 2 posts today because I was somehow logged out of DVDTalk, despite never even leaving the thread, let alone the forum.

Oh, and one suggestion. I'd like to see the quick reply box be a bit taller. It's only tall enough for about 6 lines. I liked it better when I could see much more of the post in one shot rather than having to scroll.

Otherwise, looks great.

Rival11 12-05-04 05:20 PM


Originally Posted by twikoff
rival - suck up!!!

darkelf - shut up!!! :p

Ha - just realized how many posts you had in this thread. Don't worry, I'm sure you'll get everything you want..........it is almost Christmas twikoff :)

kilcher 12-05-04 05:51 PM


Originally Posted by DonnachaOne
I remember posting about premium services, but I don't recall asking for a general upgrade.

You can't have one without the other. vB3 makes it much much easier to institute a premium member program.

abintra 12-05-04 06:26 PM

I really don't like the colors in the main forums, not threads. I've only been visiting for a few minutes this time and already it hurrts the eyes. I find the contrast between the background and both link colors (new and old) very eye straining.

That's the only thing that I dislike, though it is a biggie given how bothersome it is to my eyes.

Bugg 12-05-04 07:06 PM

I don't care for the overall look. I prefer the older look where every other post is a lighter or darker shade. Like White and Light Grey. It's just to darn bright on the eyes now.

It does not have the DVD TALK look and feel.

johnglass 12-05-04 07:53 PM

I hate to threadcrap, but I just wanted to give a :thumbsup:. I like the new layout so far.

Mopower 12-05-04 08:23 PM

I don't mean to be rude but this layout really sucks. Maybe I just need to get used to it. So far I hate how big everything is. I don't like the layout. I don't like the ads after the first posts. I don't like how there isn't a line between peoples sigs and their posts. Well I guess it will just take time.

OldDude 12-05-04 08:33 PM


Originally Posted by Mopower
I don't like how there isn't a line between peoples sigs and their posts. Well I guess it will just take time.

There's a line for me. maybe the line is more subtle,but its there.

johnglass 12-05-04 08:36 PM


Originally Posted by OldDude
There's a line for me. maybe the line is more subtle,but its there.

Same here, this was fixed a few hours ago.

Mopower 12-05-04 08:37 PM


Originally Posted by OldDude
There's a line for me. maybe the line is more subtle,but its there.


Ya it's there now. I hadn't been on here since this morning. It wasn't working then. It's not too bad.

_tony_ 12-05-04 08:54 PM

http://64.233.167.104/search?q=cache...lk+forum&hl=en

RIP :(

Roto 12-05-04 08:59 PM

The more of them I see the more I think the new smilies look like easter eggs. Too pastel and a lame 3d effect.

twikoff 12-05-04 09:04 PM

yea
i hate most of the new smilies

terrible

DonnachaOne 12-05-04 09:39 PM

twikoff, what are you using? It's slow for me, though not much slower than normal.

DonnachaOne 12-05-04 09:43 PM


Originally Posted by Bugg
I don't care for the overall look. I prefer the older look where every other post is a lighter or darker shade. Like White and Light Grey. It's just to darn bright on the eyes now.

It does not have the DVD TALK look and feel.

I agree, if only because the bright white is hard to look at for long periods. I preferred the calmer grey of before.

DavidH 12-05-04 09:46 PM

I just dislike the overall look of it now. The previous look was much better. Also, the sponsor ad is just horrible.

twikoff 12-05-04 09:49 PM


Originally Posted by DonnachaOne
twikoff, what are you using? It's slow for me, though not much slower than normal.

IE6 on XP.. and the page loads have been super fast all day
I havent noticed any slowness at all

although i cant remember the pages ever loading slow

Grizzly 12-05-04 09:55 PM

the sponsored links thing IN the threads has got to go. i've been to many boards, and i've never seen that before and i just think that really blows. i realize the need to advertise, but please don't do it in the middle of a thread.

BJacks 12-05-04 10:04 PM

I don't really have a problem with the sponsored box. It takes one second to scroll past that, and if it helps Geoff, I can live with it.

Keyser Soze 12-05-04 10:16 PM


Originally Posted by ViewAskewbian
You know, it is like I always say: once something becomes vastly popular and more people hop onto the proverbial bandwagon said something begins to suck. I recall when this place was ad free and a very enjoyable place to visit, the other forum especially. This was before the SUB-FORUM madness. IMO, the Other Forum still isn't fun despite certain implementations to make it so. The community feel of the forum, the small town'ness that attracted me to it in 2001, has been broken down slowly and this last step of the CHANGE is a big one. It is now like a MAJOR city in here with advertising and assholes all over the place. It seems that a lot of threads now break out into some silly argument and each night I am seeing scantly clad women in ads (okay, so maybe that last one isn't such a big deal :p).

Anyway, just my two as a dude that's been here for awhile. As I said, things had been breaking down slowly but this change is like a wreaking ball to the forum and all these little pieces left reminding me how this place once ways, how it could be, are hidden by the new condo being built on the lot and all the crap that comes with it. Ebb and flow is the old line Geoff has used in the past but on viewing the site today I have to say there has been FAR TOO MUCH FLOW and the river it has created is polluted. One just needs to see the post difference in the WHAT WE LIKE and WHAT WE DON’T LIKE threads to know that.

Holy shit, mark today down in the history books... View made a post that actually made some sense!

As for me... I don't like the new look or the new color scheme. The look of this place reminds me of a hospital. There are alot of things I could list off that I don't like, but I'll wait and see what this place looks likes after Geoff tweaks with it for a few weeks.

Oh well... back to my raft.

-k
###


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 10:48 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.