Meatwad and orangecrush match, JasonF.

This HAS to be the top answer:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=84b949k8HCw

I had no idea what would be a common answer for this. Ninja Rap is the Ninja Turtles song from Vanilla Ice I didn't think people would remember the 3 Doors Down or Five for Fighting songs

RKillgore and fujishig are Jim Croce fans. 2 points each for "You Don't Mess Around With Jim."

Are you sure? When I googled "I'm your Superman lyrics," I got a hit on a song by someone named Brown Boy and a bunch of hits on a Rick Springfield song. The Flaming Lips song didn't come up on the first page.

Who remembers "Jimmy Olsen's Blues" from the Spin Doctors? brianluvdvd and Tracer Bullet, that's who!

Both were remembered:

Kryptonite by 3 Doors Down: -4 points
Nogura
dadaluholla
reverie
Rockmjd23

I'm a Whiny Emo Superhero by Five for Fighting: -2 points
The Bus
davidh777

I am ... I am Superman! And I can do anything! Except score more than 2 points.
JasonF
foggy

And, last but not least, the following people got 4 points for Our Lady Peace's Superman's Dead.
burnside986
CaptainMarvel
Trevor
maxfisher

1 dadaluholla -50
2 fujishig -46
3 burnside986 -44
4 CaptainMarvel -41
4 reverie -41
4 Trevor -41
7 Mboyd -40
8 foggy -39
9 The Bus -36
10 JasonF -35
11 ivelostr2 -31
12 maxfisher -30
13 davidh777 -29
14 Nogura -27
15 Nick Danger -26
16 Meatwad's Ghost -25
16 fumanstan -25
18 orangecrush -24
18 Lokimok -24
20 brianluvdvd -23
20 brainee -23
22 Tracer Bullet -18
23 Rockmjd23 -17
24 RKillgore -10
25 hitman tommy -8

Hey you skipped making fun of my answer!

By the way, I own a copy of this album. Highly recommended.

MBoyd rightly points out that I neglected to mention that he and Lokimok got -2 points each for Donnovan's "Sunshine Superman." Man, they're such hippy losers.

The points were already reflected on my spreadsheet, so the standings are correct.

I thought that was such an obvious answer too. I'm only 38!

8. R: Name one of the animal species in Maus

I had in mind the anthropomorphic animals when I asked this one, but the Bus reminded me that there were a few others that cropped up in the story.

No funny pictures this round because ... dude, it's the Holocaust. Show some respect, man!

First, a wrong answer (I think). Someone correct me if I'm wrong. If this is incorrect, it's worth 8 points:
Rats
brianluvdvd
Trevor
davidh777

Here are the unique answers this round:
Bear -- fumanstan
Dog -- orangecrush
Fish -- foggy
Lice -- the Bus
Moose -- brainee
Pig -- ivelostr2

-1 point unique bonus for these.

Yeah, but our song mentions Superman AND Green Lantern so we get bonus points.

(I must learn more about that Spider-Man album!)

I can't concentrate on this game now - The Head is on MTV2.

And the rest:

Cats -- 5 points
burnside986
Meatwad's Ghost
hitman tommy
Nick Danger
reverie

Frogs -- 5 points
JasonF
Nogura
CaptainMarvel
Rockmjd23
fujishig

Mouse -- 6 points
dadaluholla
Mboyd
RKillgore
Tracer Bullet
maxfisher
Lokimok

Factoring in the Google penalties for brainee and fumanstan, we get the following:

1 dadaluholla -44
2 fujishig -41
3 foggy -40
4 burnside986 -39
5 The Bus -37
6 CaptainMarvel -36
6 reverie -36
8 Mboyd -34
9 Trevor -33
10 ivelostr2 -32
11 JasonF -30
12 orangecrush -25
13 maxfisher -24
13 fumanstan -24
15 Nogura -22
15 brainee -22
17 Nick Danger -21
17 davidh777 -21
19 Meatwad's Ghost -20
20 Lokimok -18
21 brianluvdvd -15
22 Rockmjd23 -12
22 Tracer Bullet -12
24 RKillgore -4
25 hitman tommy -3

CHALLENGE: Where are the fish?

I have that book and have never read it. I am so ashamed.

Fish driving a jeep. Never noticed it before.

9. R: ×3 Name one of the costumed or powered characters in Watchmen

This may be the last one we do tonight because I think we may need to have some discussion on this, and I want the daytime crowd to have a chance to weigh in. Here's the deal: we had two people say "Nite Owl" without specifying which one and one person say "Silk Spectre" without specifying which one. I PM'ed all three and asked them to clarify. One person did; the other two did not. My inclination is to mark the two people who did not clarify as wrong answers. Does that seem fair to everyone?

Wait .. that's just stupid. We can keep going with the scores for this one as tentative. If there's overwhelming support to change the way I treat Nite Owl and Silk Spectre, we'll revise the scores.