Looks like Bus was right to avoid Shadowcat and Dazzler, but wrong about them being #1 and 2. They were actually #1 and 3. I will take that as a moral victory.

1 The Bus -69
2 foggy -66
3 Mboyd -58
4 fujishig -56
5 JasonF -47
6 Lokimok -46
7 CaptainMarvel -44
8 Tracer Bullet -41
9 maxfisher -40
10 Nogura -37
11 dadaluholla -36
11 orangecrush -36
13 brianluvdvd -35
14 ivelostr2 -33
15 reverie -32
15 davidh777 -32
17 Rockmjd23 -31
17 brainee -31
19 burnside986 -28
20 Trevor -26
20 fumanstan -26
22 Meatwad's Ghost -19
23 Nick Danger -2
24 RKillgore 6
25 hitman tommy 9

17. S: Name a real person who has appeared in a comic book.

Little-known trivia fact: Aquaman, Black Canary, and Green Arrow are real people!

But nobody named any of them. We did have quite a few unique answers. Unfortunately, since this isn't reverse sheep, that's a bad thing.

brainee remembered David Letterman from The Dark Knight Returns. That was actually "David Endocrine," but Letterman did appear in the above issue of Avengers. Unfortunately for brainee, nobody matched him.

Speaking of talk show hosts, remember this guy?

hitman tommy did not match anybody with his answer of Stephen Colbert.

And for our final talk show host ... here's Johnny!

reverie gets zero points (and I can find no evidence that Johnny ever appeared in a comic).

Grant Morrison appeared in his own run of Animal Man, which was absolutely brilliant. I chose to use this picture from a Simpsons comic instead. Either way, nobody matched Trevor.

Muhammad Ali fought Superman! And he had his own logo! Doesn't that make him a great answer?

Sorry, fumanstan. It does not. Nobody matched you.

And our last unique answer is the man himself:

Even though I love Stan Lee, I must award davidh777 no points for his unique answer.

Remember when Hitler was getting a sock in the jaw in just about every comic? Sorry, grampa -- only two people do for -2 points
orangecrush
Rockmjd23

And then there was the obvious Sheep answer:

-17 points
JasonF
burnside986
Nogura
brianluvdvd
foggy
Mboyd
CaptainMarvel
RKillgore
Tracer Bullet
Meatwad's Ghost
maxfisher
The Bus
fujishig
Nick Danger
Lokimok
dadaluholla
ivelostr2

Are you sure orangecrush meant Hitler? Wasn't his answer "that guy with the mustache"?

Challenge rejected!

1 The Bus -86
2 foggy -83
3 Mboyd -75
4 fujishig -73
5 JasonF -64
6 Lokimok -63
7 CaptainMarvel -61
8 Tracer Bullet -58
9 maxfisher -57
10 Nogura -54
11 dadaluholla -53
12 brianluvdvd -52
13 ivelostr2 -50
14 burnside986 -45
15 orangecrush -38
16 Meatwad's Ghost -36
17 Rockmjd23 -33
18 reverie -32
18 davidh777 -32
20 brainee -31
21 Trevor -26
21 fumanstan -26
23 Nick Danger -19
24 RKillgore -11
25 hitman tommy 9

At first, I thought he meant Wilford Brimley, but he sent me a second PM to clarify.

18. S: Name a title that Jack Kirby worked on, but never worked on with Stan Lee.

Damn it. I was waffling between Psylocke and Jubilee.

Would Rachel Summers have been a correct answer?

Kamandi was a great series. Unfortunately for Trevor, he was the only one who named it.

Obama is the new Superman.

I said Hitler you smarmy

Oh yeah, I'm gloating from my next to last place.

The Eternals was also unique. Sorry Tracer Bullet. I'm particularly sorry that you had to take a two-point Google penalty for an unmatched answer.

I was wondering if anything at Marvel would count since "Stan Lee Presents" is in the credits.

There were two bad answers submitted. One was Fantastic Four, submitted by ivelostr2. He realized his mistake in time and changed his answer.

The other bad answer?

Here's an issue of Captain America that Jack Kirby worked on without Stan Lee. However, ten years earlier, during the heyday of the Silver Age, Kirby had worked on Captain America with Stan Lee.

Still, a match is a match, and 4 people matched:
Nogura (-4 points)
orangecrush (-3 points)
Rockmjd23 (-4 points)
fumanstan (-1 points)

Points (with Google penalties applied) as indicated. And kudos to those of you who Googled up Captain America without getting hip to the fact that Lee and Kirby worked on it together.