The All-New, All Spectacular, Now That's a Comic Book Thread (Oct)
#53
Senior Member
Joined: Oct 2002
Posts: 952
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: NYC
Should I leave the content up? If so, for how long...I don't want to pay for the space forever.
Anyway, any suggestions you have would be appreciated.
Anyway, any suggestions you have would be appreciated.
#54
Suspended
Originally Posted by boredsilly
I think it was last month when someone was expelling the virtues of Don Rosa's "Life and Times of Scrooge McDuck". I would have NEVER bought this, but decided to give it a try because I always liked Ducktales...and damn if this isn't one of the finest comics I've ever read. I'm still in the beginning (up to the third story), but I'm spacing it out because its a fun, but dense read (lots of panels, lots of words, and the pictures are so gorgeous that I can't just skim them). So thanks to whomever it was who pointed this book out (I'm too lazy to go back and look).
As for the rest of you -- now you have two people who give Life and Times of Scrooge McDuck their highest recommendation! What are you waiting for!?! Pick up your copy today!
#56
Originally Posted by JasonF
That was me. Glad you're enjoying it.
As for the rest of you -- now you have two people who give Life and Times of Scrooge McDuck their highest recommendation! What are you waiting for!?! Pick up your copy today!
As for the rest of you -- now you have two people who give Life and Times of Scrooge McDuck their highest recommendation! What are you waiting for!?! Pick up your copy today!
#57
Suspended
Originally Posted by ytrez
Is there a HC coming? If so, I may wait.
http://www.gemstonecomics.com/issue.asp?ItemNo=27831
#58
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Originally Posted by Superboy
I picked up the Scrooge book. It was a great read, and reminded me that comics meant for kids can be enjoyed by adults.
I still can't get over how great the art is.
#59
DVD Talk Godfather
Hey, I seconded the recommendation for Scrooge in the last thread...
Anyway, I wish Gemstone did more of these big GNs instead of the smaller, thin collections they currently have. I started collecting those but stopped after around a year and a half because I didn't like the format... I'd much rather have either a traditional, thick GN or the oversized ones that Gladstone used to put out.
Anyway, I wish Gemstone did more of these big GNs instead of the smaller, thin collections they currently have. I started collecting those but stopped after around a year and a half because I didn't like the format... I'd much rather have either a traditional, thick GN or the oversized ones that Gladstone used to put out.
#60
Suspended
Originally Posted by fujishig
Hey, I seconded the recommendation for Scrooge in the last thread...
Anyway, I wish Gemstone did more of these big GNs instead of the smaller, thin collections they currently have. I started collecting those but stopped after around a year and a half because I didn't like the format... I'd much rather have either a traditional, thick GN or the oversized ones that Gladstone used to put out.
Anyway, I wish Gemstone did more of these big GNs instead of the smaller, thin collections they currently have. I started collecting those but stopped after around a year and a half because I didn't like the format... I'd much rather have either a traditional, thick GN or the oversized ones that Gladstone used to put out.
I agree with you on format. Give me a nice thick GN or an oversized, European-style album. The 64-page anthologies they put out don't work for me, both because they're too small and because they're too much of a mixed bag. Give me 64 pages of all Don Rosa or all Carl Barks and I'll probably bite. 64 pages with a single Barks story and 5 other stories by 5 other artists (none of whom is Rosa) and I'll probably pass.
#61
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Joined: Nov 2000
Posts: 7,206
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Denver
Anyone buy one of DC's black-n-white reprints? I think they're called Showcase. I'm just wondering if they're worth the $10.
Also, anyone hear if DC plans to continue reprinting old Batman stories in chronological order?
Also, anyone hear if DC plans to continue reprinting old Batman stories in chronological order?
#62
DVD Talk Legend
Originally Posted by James W. Powell
Anyone buy one of DC's black-n-white reprints? I think they're called Showcase. I'm just wondering if they're worth the $10.
500+ pages not worth $10?


Originally Posted by James W. Powell
Also, anyone hear if DC plans to continue reprinting old Batman stories in chronological order?
#63
Suspended
I wouldn't give up on Batman Chronicles just yet -- the first volume has only been out since March, and as recently as this summer, DC was talking about doing more volumes as well as a set of Superman Chronicles. It's possible the project is dead, but I think it's more likely that they're simply going slow.
As for Showcase, I haven't made it to the shop in a couple of weeks, but I'm definitely picking up both volumes that have been released (and the other three that they've announced, and probably every single one they produce, because I'm a sucker for massive inexpensive reprint volumes).
As for Showcase, I haven't made it to the shop in a couple of weeks, but I'm definitely picking up both volumes that have been released (and the other three that they've announced, and probably every single one they produce, because I'm a sucker for massive inexpensive reprint volumes).
#64
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Joined: Nov 2000
Posts: 7,206
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Denver
Originally Posted by Chew
If you like the Marvel B&W reprints, I have no doubt you'll like Showcase.
500+ pages not worth $10?

I sure would like to know that as well, but given the fact it's been a freakin' long time since the first one: doesn't seem too likely.
500+ pages not worth $10?


I sure would like to know that as well, but given the fact it's been a freakin' long time since the first one: doesn't seem too likely.

#65
Senior Member
Actually I've got to say reading Green Lantern in black and white really isn't as effective as one might hope, especially in the early adventures where many of his obstacles are yellow and he has to come up with a way around it. Not quite as effective when you can't tell what is and is not yellow.
#66
DVD Talk Legend
Originally Posted by Mhepburn20
Actually I've got to say reading Green Lantern in black and white really isn't as effective as one might hope, especially in the early adventures where many of his obstacles are yellow and he has to come up with a way around it. Not quite as effective when you can't tell what is and is not yellow.
#67
Senior Member
Joined: Jun 2001
Posts: 255
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
The first volume of the Superman Chronicles is due January 4th. Based on DC's Archives survey (link ) it looks like they're considering a Justice Society Chronicles next. I prefer this format to the Archives format, but not at this rate of releases.
Showcase Presents volumes of Justice League (December) and Green Arrow (January) are coming soon. I got both of the Showcase volumes last week, and for the most part they look very good (especially the Superman). The Green Lantern stories are hurt a little by not being in color, but the narration or thought bubbles make it pretty clear when things are yellow.
Of course, I've never read much Silver Age DC, so I'm reading many of these stories for the first time. I don't want to spring for $35+ reprints of material I'm not sure about.
Showcase Presents volumes of Justice League (December) and Green Arrow (January) are coming soon. I got both of the Showcase volumes last week, and for the most part they look very good (especially the Superman). The Green Lantern stories are hurt a little by not being in color, but the narration or thought bubbles make it pretty clear when things are yellow.
Of course, I've never read much Silver Age DC, so I'm reading many of these stories for the first time. I don't want to spring for $35+ reprints of material I'm not sure about.
#68
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Joined: Nov 2000
Posts: 7,206
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Denver
I'm still torn about buying 'em in hardcover. Aren't most of these in the Masterpiece series? (I think that's what they're called). But if they're doing the Chronicles, that'll be the way I go fo shizzle.
#69
Suspended
Originally Posted by Cathepsin
Showcase Presents volumes of Justice League (December) and Green Arrow (January) are coming soon. I got both of the Showcase volumes last week, and for the most part they look very good (especially the Superman).
The Green Lantern stories are hurt a little by not being in color, but the narration or thought bubbles make it pretty clear when things are yellow.
#70
Senior Member
Joined: Jun 2001
Posts: 255
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by James W. Powell
I'm still torn about buying 'em in hardcover. Aren't most of these in the Masterpiece series? (I think that's what they're called). But if they're doing the Chronicles, that'll be the way I go fo shizzle.
#72
DVD Talk Limited Edition
I love the Superman Showcase book, it's a blast. Those gimmicky '50s and '60s stories are just a hell of a lot of fun, much better than a lot of today's super-serious stretched-out storylines. I'm looking forward to the JLA and Jonah Hex volumes.
Next on my list would be
* Showcase Batman (50s-60s stuff)
* Showcase Sugar & Spike (!!)
* Showcase Swamp Thing (bet they could get all the '70s stuff in one book)
* Showcase The Atom (always loved this guy's Silver Age stories)
* Showcase Hawkman
* Showcase for some of the great anthology titles like Mystery in Space, Strange Adventures, etc...
I hope they keep doing these. They're cheap and a real blast.
Next on my list would be
* Showcase Batman (50s-60s stuff)
* Showcase Sugar & Spike (!!)
* Showcase Swamp Thing (bet they could get all the '70s stuff in one book)
* Showcase The Atom (always loved this guy's Silver Age stories)
* Showcase Hawkman
* Showcase for some of the great anthology titles like Mystery in Space, Strange Adventures, etc...
I hope they keep doing these. They're cheap and a real blast.
#74
DVD Talk Legend
Two shipments into October and I still have 9 books from September's order that haven't shipped yet. 
Are the number of late books getting worse for others as well?

Are the number of late books getting worse for others as well?



