Xbox One Pre-Release Thread: Upscaled to 1080p! (11/22/2013)
#1301
Re: Xbox One: This Thread Requires An Always On Internet Connection
I kind of don't care about the used thing. I buy games from Steam and have the same situation - albeit for much cheaper.
At first I was concerned about the issue with multiple Xboxes (like the example Spiderbite gave with Lego games and his kids) but then I realized I would just install it on the kids console (who wants to play it solo) and then install it on the main console and make sure the kid is logged in when we play together. Easy enough.
That and the fact I wouldn't own two XOs anyway... My daughter might inherit my 360. But she might not because I need the older console to keep playing pinball.
edit: I also love voice control for watching movies and such. So much easier to pause using voice than to hunt for a controller or remote.
At first I was concerned about the issue with multiple Xboxes (like the example Spiderbite gave with Lego games and his kids) but then I realized I would just install it on the kids console (who wants to play it solo) and then install it on the main console and make sure the kid is logged in when we play together. Easy enough.
That and the fact I wouldn't own two XOs anyway... My daughter might inherit my 360. But she might not because I need the older console to keep playing pinball.

edit: I also love voice control for watching movies and such. So much easier to pause using voice than to hunt for a controller or remote.
#1302
DVD Talk Godfather
Re: Xbox One: This Thread Requires An Always On Internet Connection
Tech Specs and comparison with the PS4, for those that like reading the technical aspects of consoles.
http://anandtech.com/show/6972/xbox-...-playstation-4
As a Systems Admin, reading stuff like this is cool.
http://anandtech.com/show/6972/xbox-...-playstation-4
As a Systems Admin, reading stuff like this is cool.

The Xbox One is powered by two independent OSes running on a custom version of Microsoft’s Hyper-V hypervisor. Microsoft made the hypervisor very lightweight, and created hard partitions of system resources for the two OSes that run on top of it: the Xbox OS and the Windows kernel.
The Xbox OS is used to play games, while the Windows kernel effectively handles all apps (as well as things like some of the processing for Kinect inputs). Since both OSes are just VMs on the same hypervisor, they are both running simultaneously all of the time, enabling seamless switching between the two.
The Xbox OS is used to play games, while the Windows kernel effectively handles all apps (as well as things like some of the processing for Kinect inputs). Since both OSes are just VMs on the same hypervisor, they are both running simultaneously all of the time, enabling seamless switching between the two.
Last edited by fumanstan; 05-22-13 at 10:34 AM.
#1303
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Xbox One: This Thread Requires An Always On Internet Connection
Great, more AMD. The overheating generation activate!
Looking at the specs, if MS sells this thing at $500 they'll be making a profit right off the bat.
Looking at the specs, if MS sells this thing at $500 they'll be making a profit right off the bat.
Last edited by RichC2; 05-22-13 at 10:34 AM.
#1305
DVD Talk Godfather
Re: Xbox One: This Thread Requires An Always On Internet Connection
#1306
DVD Talk Special Edition
Joined: May 2007
Posts: 1,418
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Virginia
#1307
Moderator
#1308
DVD Talk Godfather
Re: Xbox One: This Thread Requires An Always On Internet Connection
#1309
DVD Talk Special Edition
Re: Xbox One: This Thread Requires An Always On Internet Connection
#1310
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Legend
#1311
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Xbox One: This Thread Requires An Always On Internet Connection
Just gotta weigh in on people who hate the voice controls. I didn't think I'd care until I got a Kinect for the kids. Now, I'm sitting at my computer across the room with Netflix running on the Xbox. I get up to go to the bathroom and say "Xbox pause" as I walk past. It pauses, then I say "Xbox play" when I return. No need to even find where I left the controller. I actually think it's pretty great.
#1312
Moderator
Re: Xbox One: This Thread Requires An Always On Internet Connection
Glad it works for you. For me, it's more like:
"Xbox pause"
"Xbox pause"
"XBOX PAUSE"
"XBOX PAUSE"
"XBOX FUCK YOU YOU FUCKING PIECE OF SHIT"
Xbox: "Title not found".
"Xbox pause"
"Xbox pause"
"XBOX PAUSE"
"XBOX PAUSE"
"XBOX FUCK YOU YOU FUCKING PIECE OF SHIT"
Xbox: "Title not found".
#1314
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Xbox One: This Thread Requires An Always On Internet Connection
I don't mind the voice controls, but don't need them or use them much. It seems like they'd be smart to put some sort of media remote bundled with this thing, with a full keyboard.
#1315
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: Xbox One: This Thread Requires An Always On Internet Connection
The 'used game issue' will not be widely known by the public. It'll matter to us, but not to everyone. But the publisher will still favor the one where the game can't be resold. I'd be more shocked if Sony didn't incorporate the same thing.
I'm thrilled to see GameStop get the middle finger. Aside from crazy trade-in prices, I avoid that place.
I'm thrilled to see GameStop get the middle finger. Aside from crazy trade-in prices, I avoid that place.
I won't be shocked either way, but unless Sony's lying and has already firmly laid out plans for anti-used, I'd be surprised if they followed Microsoft's lead. There's just too much advantage in being the company that lets people actually use/own their games the same way they have for the past 25 years. I said ages ago that I highly doubted either company would go the anti-used route because of that advantage and the prisoner's dilemma nature of the decision. My best guess now is that Sony will announce no anti-used tech and Microsoft will try to compete by touting whatever 'solution' they've come up with but won't currently mention, which I'm leaning towards thinking will be 'de-authorize the game from your account for X Microsoft Points.'
My biggest problem with GameStop is their ridiculous selling of opened, used games as new. If not for that, I wouldn't think nearly as unfavorably of them. And speaking of the devil, I see their CEO released a statement that approximately 20% of their new sales are paid for with credit from used trade-ins. That's pretty huge if it's accurate. For simplicity's sake, if you just go off all games being the same price and GameStop offering 50% - 75% of the original price when they take a trade-in, you're looking at 27% - 40% of new games eventually getting traded back in and re-sold. Realistically, they're probably offering less than 50% on average, which would just make the percentage of sell backs even higher. If you knock used games out of the equation entirely, you immediately lose the 20% of new sales they're funding, as well as whatever proportion of that 27% - 40% (or more) are purchases people wouldn't have made if they knew they couldn't recoup part of their cost. It's not hard to see how getting rid of used games could immediately eliminate a huge percentage of current new sales. The argument, and what the publishers want of course, is that those who only buy used being forced to buy new would more than offset that loss. Seems like a pretty steep claim and it doesn't even take into account any other, more subtle ways that used sales may drive new sales.
#1316
DVD Talk Godfather
Re: Xbox One: This Thread Requires An Always On Internet Connection
The logic is why would EA (example) publish a game on XO that can only be used by ONE person, but also publish it to the PS4 which can be resold 5 times. Which console would EA, a publisher, prefer? Selling 5 copies to 5 people on XO, or selling 1 copy to 5 people on PS4?
Gamestop rakes in 10+billion a year in used sales. People will catch on fast. If one console goes with no used and the other allows it then the no used console will be headed for an early grave.
That's where you're wrong. Speak with your wallet. If you don't like these "advancements" then don't buy in. If XO falls on it's face, MS will have to rectify it.
#1317
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Re: Xbox One: This Thread Requires An Always On Internet Connection
I envision more fighting between my kids with the voice controls.
Son 1: "Xbox, play"
Daughter 1: "Xbox, pause"
Daughter 2: "Xbox, Bing princesses!"
Son 1: "Xbox, play"
Son 2: "Xbox, snap netflix"
Me: *disables voice controls*
Son 1: "Xbox, play"
Daughter 1: "Xbox, pause"
Daughter 2: "Xbox, Bing princesses!"
Son 1: "Xbox, play"
Son 2: "Xbox, snap netflix"
Me: *disables voice controls*
#1318
DVD Talk Godfather
Re: Xbox One: This Thread Requires An Always On Internet Connection
I read an article yesterday about how the Wii U being the only PowerPC console this generation is going to contribute further to the lack of big new games and publisher support, since just about everything else is now x86 and can easily be ported between PC, XO, and PS4. A lower powered PPC Wii U is going to be a harder sell in terms of development time and effort to port over to.
http://www.engadget.com/2013/05/21/x...paign=Engadget
#1319
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Joined: Jan 2000
Posts: 3,613
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Los Angeles, CA
Re: Xbox One: This Thread Requires An Always On Internet Connection
Not sure if this has been mentioned, but the TV controls utilizes IR blasters hooked up to your cable box. (Although some newer ones might apparently use HDMI control.) So switching to TV and back to game can happen seamlessly, but changing channels is going to take longer than it normally would.
I use the Voice Control with my Kinect now. The reason is because the Microsoft rechargeable battery kit I purchased doesn't actually charge the battery when I hook it up to the USB connection. The only way to charge the battery now is to fish out the standalone battery charging kit. So my controller is always dead and I primarily only use my 360 now for HBO Go.
What's weird is that to watch Game of Thrones Season 3 Episode 7, it won't let me say that. I have to try and figure out how to pronounce "Game of Thrones Sn 3 Ep 7" which is always a hilarious experience before delving into the show.
While I will still probably purchase this close to release date (and then resell it if it's rare and I can make money), the lack of backwards compatibility for the Arcade games really bothers me. If their whole point is to make the entertainment center easy, clean, and the ONE box, it's only the ONE box plus the 360. While I haven't loved my Wii U, Nintendo certainly got the BC right. I replaced my one Wii box with one Wii U box and I have improved functionality and did not lose anything. But for both Xbox and Playstation I'll have to have twice the boxes in very limited space. I would gladly pay $200 extra dollars on top of the PS4 or One purchase price to have full backwards compatibility (which would easily be covered by selling off the old system. ---> but see! that doesn't spur new sales for them of the older systems.) It does seem that PS4 has some kind of BC with the streaming Gaikai service, but I don't know if you still have to buy into that or if somehow it will be unlocked from old online passes.
This new development on the BC and the fees per account certainly make it clear why EA just days ago abandoned Online Passes. They were trying to make themselves look good, when in reality, there's still an online pass, it's just a play the game fee.
What hasn't been mentioned and would be nice (although I doubt it's the case) is if the new Arcade games purchased, based on x86 architecture, are cross-compatible with either my Surface tablet or Windows 8 machine.
I use the Voice Control with my Kinect now. The reason is because the Microsoft rechargeable battery kit I purchased doesn't actually charge the battery when I hook it up to the USB connection. The only way to charge the battery now is to fish out the standalone battery charging kit. So my controller is always dead and I primarily only use my 360 now for HBO Go.
What's weird is that to watch Game of Thrones Season 3 Episode 7, it won't let me say that. I have to try and figure out how to pronounce "Game of Thrones Sn 3 Ep 7" which is always a hilarious experience before delving into the show.
While I will still probably purchase this close to release date (and then resell it if it's rare and I can make money), the lack of backwards compatibility for the Arcade games really bothers me. If their whole point is to make the entertainment center easy, clean, and the ONE box, it's only the ONE box plus the 360. While I haven't loved my Wii U, Nintendo certainly got the BC right. I replaced my one Wii box with one Wii U box and I have improved functionality and did not lose anything. But for both Xbox and Playstation I'll have to have twice the boxes in very limited space. I would gladly pay $200 extra dollars on top of the PS4 or One purchase price to have full backwards compatibility (which would easily be covered by selling off the old system. ---> but see! that doesn't spur new sales for them of the older systems.) It does seem that PS4 has some kind of BC with the streaming Gaikai service, but I don't know if you still have to buy into that or if somehow it will be unlocked from old online passes.
This new development on the BC and the fees per account certainly make it clear why EA just days ago abandoned Online Passes. They were trying to make themselves look good, when in reality, there's still an online pass, it's just a play the game fee.
What hasn't been mentioned and would be nice (although I doubt it's the case) is if the new Arcade games purchased, based on x86 architecture, are cross-compatible with either my Surface tablet or Windows 8 machine.
#1320
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 3,227
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Ft. Wayne, Indiana
Re: Xbox One: This Thread Requires An Always On Internet Connection
I'm excited as well, and welcome this soul crushing abomination into my game room.
#1321
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Re: Xbox One: This Thread Requires An Always On Internet Connection
They will?
So publishers, the same ones that publish on both Sony and Microsoft platforms, won't prefer the fact that you can't sell/buy games? If one does, the next will likely follow or they might lose support from publishers.
It's not like this is just MS Produced games, it's all. EA, etc. The same publisher who publishes on PS4. They are going to favor the one that is going to sell more copies and has little fear of it's title being sold and re-sold 5 times.
If this thing sticks, I fully expect Sony to incorporate it as well (if they haven't already. Remember - we haven't even seen the damn console yet just the controller.
So publishers, the same ones that publish on both Sony and Microsoft platforms, won't prefer the fact that you can't sell/buy games? If one does, the next will likely follow or they might lose support from publishers.
It's not like this is just MS Produced games, it's all. EA, etc. The same publisher who publishes on PS4. They are going to favor the one that is going to sell more copies and has little fear of it's title being sold and re-sold 5 times.
If this thing sticks, I fully expect Sony to incorporate it as well (if they haven't already. Remember - we haven't even seen the damn console yet just the controller.
My point is, more gamers would buy the PS4 due to being able to buy and sell used games. I certainly would. I am not sony fanboy...all i have is a 360 and a PC.
Sony may be doing the very same thing MS is doing with used games. We don't know yet, but Sony could have one hell of a trump card if they allow used games.
i am a tech spec moron. if these numbers are accurate, the PS4 is the stronger console? I am using the "It has higher numbers" method.

Also, how much would it cost to get a computer that would match this tech?
Last edited by wlj; 05-22-13 at 12:09 PM.
#1322
DVD Talk Special Edition
Joined: May 2007
Posts: 1,418
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Virginia
#1323
DVD Talk Godfather
Re: Xbox One: This Thread Requires An Always On Internet Connection
As far as those specs on a computer, the "Jaguar" chip doesn't have a desktop or laptop equivalent out yet (but should, eventually), but given the lineage of the chip it isn't or shouldn't be that expensive. It's not nearly as fast as the typical Intel and AMD desktop processor alone, but the difference is in the integrated GPU in one efficient package, which AMD has been trying to push for laptops. The high speed DD3 RAM on the Xbox isn't too expensive, under $100. The GDDR5 on the PS4 would be pretty expensive though.
#1324
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Re: Xbox One: This Thread Requires An Always On Internet Connection
my hope is to get a laptop that will do what the new consoles will do at the very least. if Ican get a laptop for $1000 or less to do this, that would be great.
I know desktop PCs are better for gaming, but that isn't an option for me. It has to be a laptop.
I know desktop PCs are better for gaming, but that isn't an option for me. It has to be a laptop.



