DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   Video Game Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/video-game-talk-15/)
-   -   Alan Wake (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/video-game-talk/569150-alan-wake.html)

pinata242 10-15-10 12:15 AM

Re: Alan Wake
 
Plus new copies of the game still come with the first DLC free. That's a $7 value.

Rob V 10-15-10 07:12 AM

Re: Alan Wake
 
I d/l The Writer last night. How long did it take you to finish it Fox?

MoviePage 10-15-10 07:44 AM

Re: Alan Wake
 
I played through The Writer a couple of nights ago, and last night I finally got the "play through it without dying" achievement after...many attempts. Let's just say there's a lot of platforming in this episode, which is a bad idea for a game where the jumping/climbing is a bit imprecise.

More Alan Wake is always a good thing in my book though, so I enjoyed it.

foxdvd 10-15-10 08:17 AM

Re: Alan Wake
 

Originally Posted by Rob V (Post 10431672)
I d/l The Writer last night. How long did it take you to finish it Fox?

about an hour....

foxdvd 10-15-10 08:23 AM

Re: Alan Wake
 

Originally Posted by MoviePage (Post 10431692)
I played through The Writer a couple of nights ago, and last night I finally got the "play through it without dying" achievement after...many attempts. Let's just say there's a lot of platforming in this episode, which is a bad idea for a game where the jumping/climbing is a bit imprecise.
.

Yeah I played on normal, and figured I would get the achv no problem...I never even came close to dying, except the stupid platforming as I mentioned above. I don't have the patience to go back and do that again...

djones6746 10-15-10 12:04 PM

Re: Alan Wake
 

Originally Posted by mhg83 (Post 10431402)
How much do you think is a fair price to pay? It looks interesting but i think i'd wait till at least $20-$30 range.

The $25.00 I paid for it through Dell awhile back was a fair price to pay considering you are buying a game which was not complete in the first place. Original buyers of this game should not have to pay additional money in order to finish this game. Add-ons are simply that....add-ons. Yes..the signal was a free download however if I want to finish this game I will have to pay the additional $5.00 to finish it. Money is not the issue here.....it is the principal of the whole thing. I cannot imagine those who originally purchased this for $60.00 feel like it was worth it. I would have felt ripped off. As others have already stated, there is a lot of repetition from the beginning to the end and The Signal add-on multiplies this repetition beyond belief. I liked Alan Wake...did not love it. The story on the main disc which is not over at completion is good...awesome graphics!!! Overall, this game is worth $20-$30.00 in my opinion. It is already reduced to $39.99 after only being out for a few months. Under $30.00 would be your buy price... :cool:

pinata242 10-15-10 12:25 PM

Re: Alan Wake
 
I really do not understand how the 6 episodes are not a complete game. That sounds like a very jaded opinion. In my opinion, there was a full story told. Hell, it was actually the 2nd half of one person's story and the 1st half of another's.

Chew 10-15-10 12:58 PM

Re: Alan Wake
 

Originally Posted by mhg83 (Post 10431402)
How much do you think is a fair price to pay? It looks interesting but i think i'd wait till at least $20-$30 range.

If you don't mind used, Family Video has it for $20 (free shipping when you use "Pumpkins" coupon code this weekend)

http://www.familyvideo.com/catalog/p...cts_id=-347578

djones6746 10-15-10 01:01 PM

Re: Alan Wake
 

Originally Posted by pinata242 (Post 10432233)
I really do not understand how the 6 episodes are not a complete game. That sounds like a very jaded opinion. In my opinion, there was a full story told. Hell, it was actually the 2nd half of one person's story and the 1st half of another's.

How is it a full story? He is searching for his wife. Did he find his wife at the end of the main game? No.....

pinata242 10-15-10 01:02 PM

Re: Alan Wake
 

Originally Posted by djones6746 (Post 10432295)
How is it a full story? He is searching for his wife. Did he find his wife at the end of the main game? No.....

Did he rescue his wife? Yes.....

Was it even Alan's story?

Is Alan even real?

djones6746 10-15-10 01:03 PM

Re: Alan Wake
 

Originally Posted by pinata242 (Post 10432233)
I really do not understand how the 6 episodes are not a complete game. That sounds like a very jaded opinion. In my opinion, there was a full story told. Hell, it was actually the 2nd half of one person's story and the 1st half of another's.

How is it a full story? He is searching for his wife. Did he find his wife at the end of the main game? No..... If you are a Zelda fan, how would you feel if there was no conclusion to any of the Zelda games? You did not save the lands from darkness nor rescue the princess.

djones6746 10-15-10 01:04 PM

Re: Alan Wake
 

Originally Posted by pinata242 (Post 10432298)
Did he rescue his wife? Yes.....

Was it even Alan's story?

Is Alan even real?

LOL!!! That is true..... Am I even typing this post? Who are you? ;)

pinata242 10-15-10 01:05 PM

Re: Alan Wake
 

Originally Posted by djones6746 (Post 10432301)
How is it a full story? He is searching for his wife. Did he find his wife at the end of the main game? No..... If you are a Zelda fan, how would you feel if there was no conclusion to any of the Zelda games? You did not save the lands from darkness nor rescue the princess.

Not every story has to have the exact same structure, pace, or conclusion. This is a perfect example of open-to-interpretation. Granted, I haven't played the 2nd DLC yet to see if that changes my view of the main game.

I'm just saying I was satisfied with the 6 on-disc episodes and "concluding" cinematic.

Liver&Onions 10-15-10 01:10 PM

Re: Alan Wake
 
But this is America GodDammit! We need everything bundled up and neat and tidy at the end, we can't have lingering questions. Problems are all solved within 30 minutes (including 8 minutes of commercials) - so why can't they complete a story in a 10 hour game!?

foxdvd 10-15-10 01:10 PM

Re: Alan Wake
 
I felt the regular game was a full experience, with a cliff-hanger ending that made you try to fill in the blanks....the dlc actually took away from it a bit I think...while they were fun, they added nothing....sort of made it seem like the main game was not complete...which it is..

MoviePage 10-15-10 01:26 PM

Re: Alan Wake
 

Originally Posted by foxdvd (Post 10432316)
I felt the regular game was a full experience, with a cliff-hanger ending that made you try to fill in the blanks....the dlc actually took away from it a bit I think...while they were fun, they added nothing....sort of made it seem like the main game was not complete...which it is..

:up: My feelings exactly. I paid full price for Alan Wake on release day, and I was 100% satisfied with my purchase.

porieux 10-25-10 04:35 PM

Re: Alan Wake
 

Originally Posted by fumanstan (Post 10177058)
You should not play it out of principle for those ads!

Didn't need to, so far lack of interest has achieved the same effect with less self-righteous indignation.

pinata242 10-25-10 04:38 PM

Re: Alan Wake
 

Originally Posted by porieux (Post 10451712)
Didn't need to, so far lack of interest has achieved the same effect with less self-righteous indignation.

So, you won...?

porieux 10-25-10 04:41 PM

Re: Alan Wake
 

Originally Posted by pinata242 (Post 10451715)
So, you won...?

Who knows, maybe I lost. Depends how much I would have enjoyed the game.

Might still get around to playing it, sometime. If I do, I will mentally replace Alan Wake's voice with that of Garth Marenghi, that's for sure.

Matt 12-09-10 02:25 PM

Re: Alan Wake
 
Thinking about picking up a download code from eBay for cheap. What say you, people that finished it? Worth $15 or $20 or so? I realize with this method I'll be missing out on the free DLC, but that's okay with me.

(Bear with me here, I haven't read much of the thread in hopes of avoiding spoilers. . .)

Superman07 12-09-10 02:40 PM

Re: Alan Wake
 
Yeah, I suppose that's a fair price. I never played any of the DLC since I played through Gamefly, but if you're at least interested that sounds worth it. If they wrap up the larger story or brought out a sequel to finish it I'd be happy to go back and play the DLC since they're extra after the fact.

Mind you it's only $29 on Amazon so for a bit more you'd be sure it works, you'd save on the HDD space and you'd get the free DLC chapter.

pinata242 12-09-10 02:44 PM

Re: Alan Wake
 
I thought it was worth the $40 I paid for it. Well, since it included the "free" $7 DLC, I guess you can split hairs and say I only paid $33 for it.

Haters gonna hate, but it was solid fun.

Liver&Onions 12-09-10 02:47 PM

Re: Alan Wake
 
I'm a solid believer in this game, and I would've gladly paid full price for it.

chuckd21 12-09-10 03:19 PM

Re: Alan Wake
 
As someone who paid full price for it, anything full price or less is well worth it.

Raul3 12-09-10 04:44 PM

Re: Alan Wake
 
One of the best games of the year.

Liver&Onions 12-09-10 04:45 PM

Re: Alan Wake
 

Originally Posted by Raul3 (Post 10535936)
One of the best games of the year.

Tru-to the motherfucking-uth!

MoviePage 12-10-10 01:26 AM

Re: Alan Wake
 
This might actually be my favorite game of the year, and I've played pretty much every major title that's been released, not to mention a large quantity of minor titles.

Matt 12-10-10 02:08 PM

Re: Alan Wake
 
Well, you guys sold me on it. Just snagged a code for $10. :dance:

Thanks.

wlj 01-03-11 12:09 PM

Re: Alan Wake
 
I got this game for Christmas and I like it alot, however I am having a tough time with it. The combat is very difficult for me -- especially when surrounded. I am having to repeat certain sections several times which is reducing the impact and flow of the story. I should have started it on the easiest difficulty I guess. Any tips? I am usually a very good "action" game player. I love the Ninja Gaiden series and have beaten those games several times over.

Chew 01-03-11 12:18 PM

Re: Alan Wake
 
You don't have to battle all the enemies. Sometimes, a good strategy is just to run to the next light source. Once you're there, you're safe---they can't follow you anymore.

Liver&Onions 01-03-11 12:24 PM

Re: Alan Wake
 
Alan Wake is a normal guy - he won't be able to fight everything. It's OK to run, and absolutely necessary at times.

pinata242 01-03-11 12:33 PM

Re: Alan Wake
 
Especially on Nightmare difficulty.

I need to get my disc back so I can play through The Writer I got on the cheap!

djones6746 01-03-11 12:59 PM

Re: Alan Wake
 

Originally Posted by pinata242 (Post 10571428)
Especially on Nightmare difficulty.

I need to get my disc back so I can play through The Writer I got on the cheap!

You are not missing much....

Rob V 01-03-11 01:19 PM

Re: Alan Wake
 

Originally Posted by Liver&Onions (Post 10571417)
Alan Wake is a normal guy - he won't be able to fight everything. It's OK to run, and absolutely necessary at times.

The problem is Alan needs some cardio-vascular workouts in his routine. He tires way too fast -- which is unbelievable given the adrenaline he should have.

pinata242 01-03-11 01:21 PM

Re: Alan Wake
 
How many times has this thread seen this exact conversation? Right back to complaining about Wake's lack of aerobic exercise and conditioning.

thematahara 01-03-11 01:55 PM

Re: Alan Wake
 
This game is a mystery to me. I just couldnt get into it at all. I played through it and quickly traded it in. I dont think I've ever played a game that got such rave reviews and I thoroughly disliked it. I usually love games like this, but I couldnt ever figure out why I hated this one so much.

Liver&Onions 01-03-11 01:56 PM

Re: Alan Wake
 

Originally Posted by pinata242 (Post 10571546)
How many times has this thread seen this exact conversation? Right back to complaining about Wake's lack of aerobic exercise and conditioning.

Muse!
Cake!
Live!
Sponge!

Dan 01-03-11 02:11 PM

Re: Alan Wake
 
I got this game for $20 on Boxing Day. I was kind of regretting the purchase... but now I'll have to give it a shot. That is, if I can get Black Ops out of my 360.

Rob V 01-03-11 02:39 PM

Re: Alan Wake
 

Originally Posted by pinata242 (Post 10571546)
How many times has this thread seen this exact conversation? Right back to complaining about Wake's lack of aerobic exercise and conditioning.

4 times so far. It bears repeating because somehow people have missed this game for 11 months and keep asking the same questions :)

xmiyux 01-03-11 03:15 PM

Re: Alan Wake
 

Originally Posted by Liver&Onions (Post 10571600)
Muse!
Cake!
Live!
Sponge!

rotfl


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 03:06 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.