DVDChris over Fandango because I haven't played a bunch of the games on Fandango's list.

Corvin barely over Spainlinx0. Both had solid, solid lists. Castlevania SOTN, Mega Man 3, Contra, and Warioware twisted were some of my favorite games. However, Corvin had Mario Galaxy, Rock Band 2, Mega Man 2, and Eternal Darkness...all games I've spent hours upon hours invested in. So I had to go with Corvin.

Groucho over edstein, because I felt that edstein's list had way too many games that come out on all platforms. Tony Hawk, SSX, COD were all good, but I think Super Mario Bros 3, Kid Icarus, Star Fox, and Geometry Wars sealed the deal for me.

Jeremy over The Bus. This was another tough choice for me. But I ended up going with Jeremy's because of all the time I spent playing Zelda OOT, Final Fantasy 3, and the awesome variety in the other games he chose. The Bus had Mario Kart 64 which I loved, but some of the other games I was simply unfamiliar with...Fallout 3, Jet Set Radio, Garou, PixelJunk Monsters.

Orangecrush over Lordwow. This was anothr tough one. I ended up going with Orangecrush because I've played more off the games on his list. Lordwow had awesome games too with Super Mario World, RE4, Rogue Squadron 2, and Portal.

Vryce over JasonF was another tough choice. I've played about half the games on each list. I liked all the nostalgia in Vryce's list better, plus I've played the games in his list for longer periods of time. Bioshock was my favorite game last year, so it was tough to count Jason's list out.

Mattysemo247 over cruzness mainly for the variety in Mattysemo's list. cruzness' list seems VERY shooter/3rd person action heavy.

jdpatri over raul3 because jdpatri's list has a lot more old school games which still hold up in my opinion. Raul3 has a few games which I'm still unsure if we'll still be raving about them in 5-10 years from now...uncharted, left 4 dead, crackdown. Although Halo, GTA:VC and Street Fighter 2 are just awesome games.

DVDChris vs. Fandango – DVDChris had a great variety of different games. Fandango was a little RPG heavy (and most of the games I haven’t had a chance to play)

Michael Corvin vs. Spainlinx0 – Corvin has a lot of recent classics on his list (POP, SMG, and ED) that I can definitely relate to, I thought SpainlinxO was a little to Nintendo heavy (7 out of 10) and no current gen games

Edstein vs. Groucho – Edstein had one of my fav lists here. With games like GTAIV, GOW, COD2, and representing the SSX series. Groucho had some oldies but definitely goodies as well.

The Bus vs. Jeremy517 – This one was a hard pick for me. Both had great lists and a wide variety. Jeremy517 had the edge because of GOW2 & GTA:SA. Bus, I loved your pick for PixelJunk Monsters. That one totally slipped my mind.

Lordwow vs. Orangecrush18 – This one was easy for me because it’s the only list of the group that has a complete list of games I have played. Sorry Lordwow (love your ZAMN & Portal pics though)

Vryce vs. JasonF – This one was another difficult one for me. JasonF had a solid list (BS, GOW, MGS2) but Vryce had a very unique list. And I absolutely love Ico & SOTC. And with one of the best FPS of all time (COD4), gave him the edge.

Raul3 vs. jdpatri – Both had great lists here with a ton of variety, but Raul3 ultimately won my vote for Halo & Uncharted