Game of Thrones (S7E04) -- "The Spoils of War" -- 8/6/17
#276
DVD Talk Godfather
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 57,857
Received 1,740 Likes
on
1,397 Posts
From: Home of 2013 NFL champion Seahawks
Re: Game of Thrones (S7E04) -- "The Spoils of War" -- 8/6/17

And speaking of that : I do wonder how she managed to win the lifetime loyalty of thousands of fierce warriors raised for generations in a Patriarchal society simply by burning up all their chieftains. I get that they might be in awe of her and fear her, but conflagration murder of all one's leaders by immolation doesn't normally engender fierce devotion, even with demonstration of unique fireproofing abilities.
#277
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Game of Thrones (S7E04) -- "The Spoils of War" -- 8/6/17
I'd have to watch the scene, but I don't think it was a rape scene in the same way Sansa was. The fact that she actively sought out and learned the skills of love-making and falls deeply in love with Khal Drogo would confirm that. In either case, we are not talking about a politically-correct sociological description of that event in the context of "what is consent?". Dany herself mentions getting raped -- clearly she isn't speaking about her wedding night with Drogo.
and a quick google seems to indicate that many people view it as the rape she is referring to.
#278
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: Game of Thrones (S7E04) -- "The Spoils of War" -- 8/6/17
Who cares about Dany vs. the Lannisters? If this show doesn't end with Lyanna Mormont wielding Longclaw to kill the Night King, then everything else is meaningless.
#279
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Game of Thrones (S7E04) -- "The Spoils of War" -- 8/6/17
I hated Cersei in season one and I've been waiting for her to die for years. But after the way she dealt with the High Sparrow in season six I was all like "long may she reign." It helps that Lena Heady gives one of the best performance on the show. She's just such a great character. Basically the citizens of Westeros in a bad position of picking the Mad Queen they know versus the Mad Queen they don't know.
#280
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Joined: Jul 2002
Posts: 8,619
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: So Cal
Re: Game of Thrones (S7E04) -- "The Spoils of War" -- 8/6/17
Any chance that Tyrion was actually struck and dying in this battle and the events we actually see are the fever dreams of events played in his head, a la Jacob's Ladder and Mulholland Drive?
I think this possibility was set up in his first battle, where he was hit and passed out and when he wakes up, the battle is over.
I think this possibility was set up in his first battle, where he was hit and passed out and when he wakes up, the battle is over.
#281
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Game of Thrones (S7E04) -- "The Spoils of War" -- 8/6/17
Any chance that Tyrion was actually struck and dying in this battle and the events we actually see are the fever dreams of events played in his head, a la Jacob's Ladder and Mulholland Drive?
I think this possibility was set up in his first battle, where he was hit and passed out and when he wakes up, the battle is over.
I think this possibility was set up in his first battle, where he was hit and passed out and when he wakes up, the battle is over.
#282
DVD Talk Godfather
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 57,857
Received 1,740 Likes
on
1,397 Posts
From: Home of 2013 NFL champion Seahawks
Re: Game of Thrones (S7E04) -- "The Spoils of War" -- 8/6/17
#283
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Game of Thrones (S7E04) -- "The Spoils of War" -- 8/6/17
Any chance that Tyrion was actually struck and dying in this battle and the events we actually see are the fever dreams of events played in his head, a la Jacob's Ladder and Mulholland Drive?
I think this possibility was set up in his first battle, where he was hit and passed out and when he wakes up, the battle is over.
I think this possibility was set up in his first battle, where he was hit and passed out and when he wakes up, the battle is over.
No. Just no. Not only is there no chance this happened, but it would be terrible writing if it did.
#284
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Game of Thrones (S7E04) -- "The Spoils of War" -- 8/6/17
It was a fever dream.
#285
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Game of Thrones (S7E04) -- "The Spoils of War" -- 8/6/17
Fevre Dream.
#288
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Game of Thrones (S7E04) -- "The Spoils of War" -- 8/6/17
#289
Banned
Re: Game of Thrones (S7E04) -- "The Spoils of War" -- 8/6/17
I have never watched The Wire, but I think GOT is a different type of storytelling then The Sopranos and Mad Men. The Sopranos and Mad Men (which I loved) essentially were about Tony Soprano and Don Draper (along with exploring the supporting cast). So from Episode 1 until the final episode, you were focusing on their story and character development. GOT is a different type of show where it more ensemble and no true protagonist (although we all have our favorites). I have no problem with this season being more about the 'payoff' because it built such a narrative with each character that they've earned it.
Most shows would have have those dragons gone full bore in an earlier season, but GOT waited til Season 7 to really unleash one of them in battle. That takes patience. We waited 7 seasons for an Arya/Bran/Sansa/Jon Snow reunion, we waited 7 seasons for Dany meeting Jon Snow, we waited 7 seasons for each character to essentially choose a side for the final war. We have followed these characters on their own for 6 seasons in all of these different stories and many of them have never crossed paths (unlike Mad Men and The Sopranos where all of the characters interact in almost every episode). So the payoff this season and next season is rewarding and I wouldn't want it any other way.
Most shows would have have those dragons gone full bore in an earlier season, but GOT waited til Season 7 to really unleash one of them in battle. That takes patience. We waited 7 seasons for an Arya/Bran/Sansa/Jon Snow reunion, we waited 7 seasons for Dany meeting Jon Snow, we waited 7 seasons for each character to essentially choose a side for the final war. We have followed these characters on their own for 6 seasons in all of these different stories and many of them have never crossed paths (unlike Mad Men and The Sopranos where all of the characters interact in almost every episode). So the payoff this season and next season is rewarding and I wouldn't want it any other way.
Excellent post.

I was thinking the same thing after reading negative comparisons. Those are apples/oranges, IMO.
I liked MM, Sopranos, and Wire, too...but they weren't necessarily the greatest things ever. They also had their boring moments and missteps (not so much The Wire, but the other two definitely).
Also, consider some of the disadvantages GoT faces vs. those three:
(1) Having to meet expectations of avid (rabid) book readers who will pick at every variation from original;
(2) Having to overcome resistance to the "genre" labeling that sci-fi, fantasy, westerns, comedies, and others face. Those shows face a high hurdle in order to be taken seriously...something "contemporary" shows don't.
(3) Multiple location shootings, multiple expensive sets & costuming, CGI costs, weapons & animal training, fight choreography, etc...again, much more challenging than the standard things for those other shows.
(4) Huge ensemble cast & characters...often separated by geography so that a plethora of plot lines have to be interwoven without confusing, teasing, or frustrating the audience.
(5) Overcoming the "believeability" factor when attempting to portray supernatural creatures/events supporting serious drama. That's not an easy task.
As McNabb said, it's a different kind of show. The fact that it has captivated so many people (much credit to GRRM, of course, but the show could have been a disaster with poor translation from page to screen) and is being so passionately discussed is a great credit to those involved. Personally, I think GoT should be measured against similar genre shows telling epic stories...and in that, it's head and shoulders above any competitors in terms of quality acting, writing, music, cinematography, costuming, set design, and all other aspects of film-making. It's not perfect, but at this point it is almost unique in its field (particularly for the small screen).
I think the main question that should be asked is this: How well does GoT meet the goals of the filmmakers and the expectations of the audience. Personally, I think that it does both very, very well. As much as I like those other shows (along with Breaking Bad and other acclaimed shows), I have much more anticipation for each episode of GoT than any of those shows.
#290
TOTY Winner 2018 and Inane Thread Master
Joined: Dec 2003
Posts: 54,174
Received 1,734 Likes
on
1,421 Posts
From: "Are any of us really anywhere?"
Re: Game of Thrones (S7E04) -- "The Spoils of War" -- 8/6/17
I have never watched The Wire, but I think GOT is a different type of storytelling then The Sopranos and Mad Men. The Sopranos and Mad Men (which I loved) essentially were about Tony Soprano and Don Draper (along with exploring the supporting cast). So from Episode 1 until the final episode, you were focusing on their story and character development. GOT is a different type of show where it more ensemble and no true protagonist (although we all have our favorites). I have no problem with this season being more about the 'payoff' because it built such a narrative with each character that they've earned it.
Most shows would have have those dragons gone full bore in an earlier season, but GOT waited til Season 7 to really unleash one of them in battle. That takes patience. We waited 7 seasons for an Arya/Bran/Sansa/Jon Snow reunion, we waited 7 seasons for Dany meeting Jon Snow, we waited 7 seasons for each character to essentially choose a side for the final war. We have followed these characters on their own for 6 seasons in all of these different stories and many of them have never crossed paths (unlike Mad Men and The Sopranos where all of the characters interact in almost every episode). So the payoff this season and next season is rewarding and I wouldn't want it any other way.
Most shows would have have those dragons gone full bore in an earlier season, but GOT waited til Season 7 to really unleash one of them in battle. That takes patience. We waited 7 seasons for an Arya/Bran/Sansa/Jon Snow reunion, we waited 7 seasons for Dany meeting Jon Snow, we waited 7 seasons for each character to essentially choose a side for the final war. We have followed these characters on their own for 6 seasons in all of these different stories and many of them have never crossed paths (unlike Mad Men and The Sopranos where all of the characters interact in almost every episode). So the payoff this season and next season is rewarding and I wouldn't want it any other way.
#291
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Game of Thrones (S7E04) -- "The Spoils of War" -- 8/6/17
I've read a speculative article on Esquire claiming that
. Of course it's all speculation, so you never know.
Spoiler:
#292
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Game of Thrones (S7E04) -- "The Spoils of War" -- 8/6/17
^ I'm afraid of reading that spoiler. With all the GoT leaks recently I have no faith that any "speculation" articles aren't taken from leaked sources.
Maybe I'm being overly cautious but I'm not taking any chances for the rest of this season...and probably into the next.
Maybe I'm being overly cautious but I'm not taking any chances for the rest of this season...and probably into the next.
#293
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Re: Game of Thrones (S7E04) -- "The Spoils of War" -- 8/6/17
I'd have to watch the scene, but I don't think it was a rape scene in the same way Sansa was. The fact that she actively sought out and learned the skills of love-making and falls deeply in love with Khal Drogo would confirm that. In either case, we are not talking about a politically-correct sociological description of that event in the context of "what is consent?". Dany herself mentions getting raped -- clearly she isn't speaking about her wedding night with Drogo.
#294
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
#296
DVD Talk God
Re: Game of Thrones (S7E04) -- "The Spoils of War" -- 8/6/17
#297
TOTY Winner 2018 and Inane Thread Master
Joined: Dec 2003
Posts: 54,174
Received 1,734 Likes
on
1,421 Posts
From: "Are any of us really anywhere?"
#298
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
#299
DVD Talk Hero
#300
DVD Talk Hero






