The Walking Dead (S5E06) -- "Consumed" -- 11/16/14
#101
DVD Talk Godfather
Re: The Walking Dead (S5E06) -- "Consumed" -- 11/16/14
It wasn't even a big complaint or really bothered by it, I just thought they could have gotten from Point A to Point B in a better fashion.
Last edited by fumanstan; 11-18-14 at 01:27 PM.
#102
DVD Talk Hero
Re: The Walking Dead (S5E06) -- "Consumed" -- 11/16/14
I think she was intentionally run down. It seems to be how this group operates -- they take in injured people (who they may or may not have purposefully injured themselves), heal them, then use for slave labor under the pretense that they are "owed."
#103
DVD Talk Hero
Re: The Walking Dead (S5E06) -- "Consumed" -- 11/16/14
Yes, I'm aware that's what happened. I just disagree with Preterite that Carol being far enough ahead of Daryl and Noah so that the cops hit her but not see them would hardly be the only way that Carol could get captured in a convincing and interesting manner.
It wasn't even a big complaint or really bothered by it, I just thought they could have gotten from Point A to Point B in a better fashion.
It wasn't even a big complaint or really bothered by it, I just thought they could have gotten from Point A to Point B in a better fashion.

#104
DVD Talk Hero
Joined: Aug 1999
Posts: 34,257
Received 2,053 Likes
on
1,394 Posts
From: Not necessarily Formerly known as Solid Snake
Re: The Walking Dead (S5E06) -- "Consumed" -- 11/16/14
Didn't they spend 20 minutes covering their asses on Talking Dead? I don't watch it, but my understanding is that is the purpose of TD.
#105
Re: The Walking Dead (S5E06) -- "Consumed" -- 11/16/14
Personally I'm good with most minor logic issues, but those involving automobiles in this last episode are really hard to overlook.
#106
Re: The Walking Dead (S5E06) -- "Consumed" -- 11/16/14
Also, I hardly think it was the ONLY way Carol could have been captured. Especially in a way that happened to get her captured with Daryl and Noah conveniently out of the picture and unnoticed.
#107
DVD Talk Hero
Joined: Aug 1999
Posts: 34,257
Received 2,053 Likes
on
1,394 Posts
From: Not necessarily Formerly known as Solid Snake
Re: The Walking Dead (S5E06) -- "Consumed" -- 11/16/14
She was attacked and captured by the cops in a method that fit with their previous MO. It's also the only way Carol could have been captured on her own without getting Daryl involved, without nerfing Carol's badassness, and without the cops getting decimated (remember, the hospital crew does not "keep" those who fight back). The only other option would be for Carol to pull a Trojan Horse gambit, and there's no way Daryl would let her do that and no way Carol would voluntarily render herself the helpless victim she once was.
I swear, some folks fixate on the most inconsequential things. If that van scene had taken place on Z Nation, youse guys would still be applauding it.
I swear, some folks fixate on the most inconsequential things. If that van scene had taken place on Z Nation, youse guys would still be applauding it.
It would have made FAR more sense (in the big picture) for them to have pulled Carol out of the van wreckage while deliberately leaving Daryl behind. Noah sees this happen and then rescues Daryl, explains to him about the hospital, and they go from there. For the record, I don't have a huge issue with Carol being hit by a car. I actually found it funny. Still do.
I hate to say this, and I will take some flack for it. For as cheesy as Z Nation can be, I think it is winning the battle. Yes, some of the things they do are hokey and bizarre, but they have managed to stay within the rules of their universe. The Walking Dead show runners have continually changed the rules of their own game and defied physics as well as time and space. TWD deserves all the shit it takes because it brings it on itself. It is a good show. It could be better if they would quit being so damned sloppy.
Last edited by Abob Teff; 11-18-14 at 02:31 PM.
#108
DVD Talk Hero
Re: The Walking Dead (S5E06) -- "Consumed" -- 11/16/14
This show continues to get monster ratings. It's now regularly beating out Sunday Night Football in the coveted 18-49 demo. I have no doubt that AMC will continue airing this show for another decade, when Beth and Daryl's son gets lost in Canada.
#109
DVD Talk Godfather
Re: The Walking Dead (S5E06) -- "Consumed" -- 11/16/14
I've never watched Z-Nation, so I'm actually not familiar with references to that show at all.
#110
Moderator
Re: The Walking Dead (S5E06) -- "Consumed" -- 11/16/14
#111
DVD Talk Hero
Re: The Walking Dead (S5E06) -- "Consumed" -- 11/16/14
Yes, it was a joke. I don't even read the graphic novels. Mere wishcasting, people. I don't read spoilers for the show, either.
#113
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
You know, I thought about this show the other day. All of our electronic payment devices went down at work the week before a holiday. It was scary. You break one little thing in the digital age and everything falls apart. I really should have a paper map in my car.
I calibrated my HDTV-perhaps not well-and some scenes are still looking dark to me.
I was wondering when someone on this show would actually run out of gas. It's been years since the apocalypse, you'd think there wouldn't be any left anywhere.
Wonder if that post-apocalyptic city is a digital matte painting? Looks pretty good. That big crane shot on the bridge was impressive. Some of the camera moves are pretty fluid. Wish you could see some of that Super 16 grain, I suppose it's all removed when they digitally process the footage.
Interesting trick with the van drop. No wide shot though
.
So now Carol is feeling sympathetic enough to help someone? Daryl is right, the guy did try to kill them, why was she so eager to help. Though I suppose I'd have killed the zombie and left him to his own devices, at least given him a chance like he eventually decided to do. I'm. Guessing he'll be part of the group when all is said and done. I assume he and Daryl are heading back to the group and will come with the gang and raid it for Beth? Maybe Abraham and the crew will get back and Rick's crew won't be there?
I calibrated my HDTV-perhaps not well-and some scenes are still looking dark to me.
I was wondering when someone on this show would actually run out of gas. It's been years since the apocalypse, you'd think there wouldn't be any left anywhere.
Wonder if that post-apocalyptic city is a digital matte painting? Looks pretty good. That big crane shot on the bridge was impressive. Some of the camera moves are pretty fluid. Wish you could see some of that Super 16 grain, I suppose it's all removed when they digitally process the footage.
Interesting trick with the van drop. No wide shot though
.So now Carol is feeling sympathetic enough to help someone? Daryl is right, the guy did try to kill them, why was she so eager to help. Though I suppose I'd have killed the zombie and left him to his own devices, at least given him a chance like he eventually decided to do. I'm. Guessing he'll be part of the group when all is said and done. I assume he and Daryl are heading back to the group and will come with the gang and raid it for Beth? Maybe Abraham and the crew will get back and Rick's crew won't be there?
#114
DVD Talk Legend
Re: The Walking Dead (S5E06) -- "Consumed" -- 11/16/14
The gas thing is problematic. Gas starts to literally gel after a few months of storage as the light ends evaporate.
Maybe they should have a scene where the characters hit a Home Depot and get some fuel stabilizer.
Maybe they should have a scene where the characters hit a Home Depot and get some fuel stabilizer.
#115
DVD Talk Hero
Re: The Walking Dead (S5E06) -- "Consumed" -- 11/16/14
GPS would still work, right? I was thinking about that when they were trying to figure out how to get to DC.
#117
DVD Talk Legend
Re: The Walking Dead (S5E06) -- "Consumed" -- 11/16/14
Since you asked ...
It would have made FAR more sense (in the big picture) for them to have pulled Carol out of the van wreckage while deliberately leaving Daryl behind. Noah sees this happen and then rescues Daryl, explains to him about the hospital, and they go from there. For the record, I don't have a huge issue with Carol being hit by a car. I actually found it funny. Still do.
It would have made FAR more sense (in the big picture) for them to have pulled Carol out of the van wreckage while deliberately leaving Daryl behind. Noah sees this happen and then rescues Daryl, explains to him about the hospital, and they go from there. For the record, I don't have a huge issue with Carol being hit by a car. I actually found it funny. Still do.
I hate to say this, and I will take some flack for it. For as cheesy as Z Nation can be, I think it is winning the battle. Yes, some of the things they do are hokey and bizarre, but they have managed to stay within the rules of their universe. The Walking Dead show runners have continually changed the rules of their own game and defied physics as well as time and space. TWD deserves all the shit it takes because it brings it on itself. It is a good show. It could be better if they would quit being so damned sloppy.
And you complain about cars flipping. Yeesh.
#118
Re: The Walking Dead (S5E06) -- "Consumed" -- 11/16/14
Leaving Daryl alive is the only flaw with picking up Carol after the van crash. It might have worked if Daryl had gotten out of the van before it tilted, but then the van would have had to topple on its own rather than having a mob of zombies moving it. But then folks would be complaining about how stupid Carol was for getting into the teetering van, and how silly it was for the hospital cops to have picked up Carol before Daryl could get down there.
#120
TOTY Winner 2018 and Inane Thread Master
Joined: Dec 2003
Posts: 54,138
Received 1,725 Likes
on
1,415 Posts
From: "Are any of us really anywhere?"
Re: The Walking Dead (S5E06) -- "Consumed" -- 11/16/14
yeah that editing job with the van was not good and the outcome was also not very believable. but, this show rivets me to no end. i don't have much attention span of late, but damn if i can't sit still for an hour of this show!!
#121
Re: The Walking Dead (S5E06) -- "Consumed" -- 11/16/14
Anyone have any idea what that male cop was up to when he got out of the car? Was pretty dark and I couldn't make out if it was anything significant or not.
#122
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Re: The Walking Dead (S5E06) -- "Consumed" -- 11/16/14
If she was hit intentionally, then they did a really poor job of conveying that. It looked pretty natural to me. I didn't really have any problem with her getting hit. I'm just scratching my head a bit as to why they were in such a rush to get outside. It seemed like hiding out might have been the better option.
#123
DVD Talk Hero
Joined: Jun 2000
Posts: 39,675
Received 1,667 Likes
on
1,184 Posts
From: Somewhere between Heaven and Hell
Re: The Walking Dead (S5E06) -- "Consumed" -- 11/16/14
If she was hit intentionally, then they did a really poor job of conveying that. It looked pretty natural to me. I didn't really have any problem with her getting hit. I'm just scratching my head a bit as to why they were in such a rush to get outside. It seemed like hiding out might have been the better option.
#124
DVD Talk Legend
Re: The Walking Dead (S5E06) -- "Consumed" -- 11/16/14
#125
DVD Talk Godfather
Re: The Walking Dead (S5E06) -- "Consumed" -- 11/16/14

That's the way I took it.



