View Poll Results: Who will leave Redemption Island tonight?
Voters: 10. You may not vote on this poll
Survivor: Redemption Island -- "Too Close for Comfort" -- 5/11/11
#1
DVD Talk God
Thread Starter
Survivor: Redemption Island -- "Too Close for Comfort" -- 5/11/11

By djariya at 2011-05-11
Synopsis:
Spoiler:
Episode 13 of 14
This Sunday (May 15th) is the 2 Hour Finale and Reunion show.
Guess Auto isn't around today. I guess I will step in.
#2
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Re: Survivor: Redemption Island -- "Too Close for Comfort" -- 5/11/11
I'm not sure how to vote in the poll, because I'm hoping at least four people are sent to the jury tonight--3 from RI and 1 voted out.
#3
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: Survivor: Redemption Island -- "Too Close for Comfort" -- 5/11/11
#4
DVD Talk Limited Edition
#5
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
#7
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Survivor: Redemption Island -- "Too Close for Comfort" -- 5/11/11
#10
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Re: Survivor: Redemption Island -- "Too Close for Comfort" -- 5/11/11
That was Rob's first mistake of the entire game and it could end up being fatal.
I guess the immunity idol is still alive. Doesn't Jeff usually say something when it's the last time it's allowed to be used?
I guess the immunity idol is still alive. Doesn't Jeff usually say something when it's the last time it's allowed to be used?
#12
DVD Talk Limited Edition
#13
DVD Talk Limited Edition
#14
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Re: Survivor: Redemption Island -- "Too Close for Comfort" -- 5/11/11
#15
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Re: Survivor: Redemption Island -- "Too Close for Comfort" -- 5/11/11
If Rob loses this game to a Redemption Island contestant who didn't have play the game then the show has hit rock bottom.
#16
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: Survivor: Redemption Island -- "Too Close for Comfort" -- 5/11/11
But, he has an out. There's no way, once they become a group of 5 again, when the RI winner returns, that IF Natalie and the rest of the group somehow decide Rob must go that they'd wait for the final 4 to do it. Why give Rob one final chance to win his way right into the final?
So, if there's going to be a Natalie betrayal, it should happen at 5. Rob uses his immunity idol and Natalie's exposed, he's safe, and like in almost any other scenario, he probably has to win the final 4 immunity anyway.
I just would hate to have it come down to the jury voting out of spite again. Matt seemed completely oblivious to Andrea explaining to him that she didn't want him out, but he kept going from one side to the other and HE played himself out of the game. Matt's not a happy guy right now. And Ralph is still pissed that the Ometepes didn't roll out the red carpet for the Zaps, when I'm sure it was pretty equal in what I saw in both tribes not wanting to make friends. Only when the Zaps were in trouble did they want to suddenly become "friends."
Glad to see Ralph go after he was suck a dick to Andrea.
I really like everyone left except Phillip, so I wasn't happy about seeing any of them go home, but Ashley was the one I wanted to go and, finally, we saw something go not according to script and she won. Grant seemed like a great guy. Maybe he can get back in the game, but I can't understand what Rob meant by his "calculations" of why to keep Grant. It sure seemed like it's been his plan for a long time to take Natalie and Phillip if he gets the chance, so why would it matter to him when to cut Grant's throat? Seems dangerous to leave him in when he could potentially win any immunity challenge or several in a row.
#17
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Survivor: Redemption Island -- "Too Close for Comfort" -- 5/11/11
Matt could make a strong case if he makes it off of Redemption Island because he had to beat everyone else one-on-one to make it back into the game twice.
#18
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: Survivor: Redemption Island -- "Too Close for Comfort" -- 5/11/11
I completely agree that no one from RI should win.
Aside from less food and less companionship, Matt never had to play the real Survivor game. It's not his fault. It's the idiots who came up with the idea, although it wouldn't have been so bad (I think) to do it one time up until the merge.
Doing it again was a terrible idea imo.
#20
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Re: Survivor: Redemption Island -- "Too Close for Comfort" -- 5/11/11
They aren't playing the game. There is no strategy. They're just bonding in their hatred of those "dicks" left in the game. Granted that is what the jury does, but the jury doesn't then get to pick the winner from their own.
I mentioned earlier this year that I'm not a huge Rob fan, but he has played a masterful game. To lose to Mike or to Matt just seems wrong; neither one had to play Survivor with the other members of the jury. I would be ok with Grant or Andrea winning b/c they would at least have to argue their case a little more.
#21
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Sep 2009
Posts: 1,361
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Survivor: Redemption Island -- "Too Close for Comfort" -- 5/11/11
Some might argue that Rob being a 4th time contestant playing against 1st timers let alone against a handpicked cast of morons is rock bottom irregardless of how the rest of the season plays out.
#22
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Survivor: Redemption Island -- "Too Close for Comfort" -- 5/11/11
Does it really make a difference who comes back from RI? Would the remaining 4 actually ally with any of them? Either the returning RI person is gone, or if they win II then Ashley is done. The only question to me is if Philip and Natalie would betray Rob at the 5 (exposing themselves as he uses the HII) or at the 4. I doubt it, so barring a RI returnee/Ashley immunity run, I think we are looking at Rob-Philip-Natalie F3.
#23
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Re: Survivor: Redemption Island -- "Too Close for Comfort" -- 5/11/11
Usually going into the finale, I have a strong favorite whom I want to see win and maybe one other person I wouldn't mind seeing win. This season, I don't really care who wins. None of them have really done anything that exciting or spectacular. I guess I'd have to go with Rob for getting everyone on his tribe to trust him and not vote him out. Then at least he wouldn't have to spend another 10 years trying to win the game. I guess seeing Phill win would be pretty amazing too, but I have no strong feelings about anyone else left.
#24
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Sep 2009
Posts: 1,361
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Survivor: Redemption Island -- "Too Close for Comfort" -- 5/11/11
If there was ever 1 Survivor jury who had every reason to be bitter and spiteful it is this one. If you start hoarding food from people and make them sleep on the ground you deserve whatever they throw at you from the jury.
#25
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Survivor: Redemption Island -- "Too Close for Comfort" -- 5/11/11
