DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   TV Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/tv-talk-14/)
-   -   Favorite Star Trek captain? (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/tv-talk/578536-favorite-star-trek-captain.html)

Charlie Goose 08-29-10 05:42 AM

Re: Favorite Star Trek captain?
 

Originally Posted by Chew (Post 10343828)
Let's see how much the results change, if any, from 9 years ago.
http://forum.dvdtalk.com/tv-talk/131...k-captain.html

I voted for James T. Kirk in that poll and my vote remains the same, mister.

Thrush 08-29-10 08:02 AM

Re: Favorite Star Trek captain?
 

Originally Posted by Chew (Post 10343828)
Let's see how much the results change, if any, from 9 years ago.
http://forum.dvdtalk.com/tv-talk/131...k-captain.html

Whatever happened to Das Monkey? And Picard FTW.

That'sAllFolks 08-29-10 11:55 AM

Re: Favorite Star Trek captain?
 
Picard
Kirk

I ddn't like Sisko's mannerisms. He was just irritating.

Superboy 08-29-10 12:08 PM

Re: Favorite Star Trek captain?
 
Kirk. He's the only one who didn't go batshit.

Janeway went batshit since the premier episode.

Picard went batshit during the movies.

Sisko went batshit during the war.

Archer went batshit fighting the Xindi

Tracer Bullet 08-29-10 12:27 PM

Re: Favorite Star Trek captain?
 
Sisko was the greatest captain because he was able to do what was necessary to protect the Federation. He understood that there is a price to paradise that is paid for by the people on the frontier.

TheKing 08-29-10 02:43 PM

Re: Favorite Star Trek captain?
 
Kirk. James T.

Picard seemed to have to run all of his ideas through a committee instead of making the decisions on his own. Sure, Kirk had Bones and Spock, but he seemed to more more or less already had a decision made and just wanted backup from his friends.

TGM 08-29-10 02:49 PM

Re: Favorite Star Trek captain?
 
http://blogs.laweekly.com/ladaily/as...mb-292x216.jpg

how 'bout some love for hamburgerface?

Supermallet 08-29-10 03:17 PM

Re: Favorite Star Trek captain?
 
It's a pretty easy choice between Picard and Kirk when you watch Generations. The whole movie you see Picard crying about his nephew, and then when Kirk shows up you wake up and go, "Oh, there's a movie happening!" Granted, it sucked, but Kirk is definitely the highlight.

Similarly, when Spock prime is onscreen in Star Trek '09, you sit up and pay attention.

dhmac 08-29-10 08:54 PM

Re: Favorite Star Trek captain?
 

Originally Posted by tallguyme (Post 10344818)
http://blogs.laweekly.com/ladaily/as...mb-292x216.jpg

how 'bout some love for hamburgerface?

Beep!

Nick Martin 08-29-10 10:23 PM

Re: Favorite Star Trek captain?
 
http://www.rabittooth.com/sisko.jpg

http://www.rabittooth.com/kirkfu2.jpg


Imagine what "Star Trek" could have been with this guy:

http://www.rabittooth.com/jackson.jpg

Fist of Doom 08-29-10 11:09 PM

Re: Favorite Star Trek captain?
 

Originally Posted by Nick Martin (Post 10345531)
Imagine what "Star Trek" could have been with this guy:

http://www.rabittooth.com/jackson.jpg

"Vulcan, motherfucker! Do you speak it?!"

Defiant1 08-29-10 11:13 PM

Re: Favorite Star Trek captain?
 

Originally Posted by gmanca (Post 10344116)
Geez, I guess I need to watch DS9 even though I keep putting it off. Does anyone know why it doesn't have a syndicated deal like Voyager?

I don't know for sure but DS9 from about season 3 onwards, it became pretty serialized, with long story arcs. That makes syndication harder. From what I remember, DS9's original ratings were fine, on par with Voyager's, and it was never in danger of being cancelled. *cough cough* Enterprise.

Anyways, I vote for The Sisko.

Supermallet 08-30-10 01:58 AM

Re: Favorite Star Trek captain?
 

Originally Posted by Nick Martin (Post 10345531)

Imagine what "Star Trek" could have been with this guy:

http://www.rabittooth.com/jackson.jpg

"I'm sick of these motherfucking tribbles on this motherfucking starship!"

Damfino 08-30-10 02:22 AM

Re: Favorite Star Trek captain?
 
Jeff Hunter's original portrayal of Captain Pike should have been included.

Thrush 08-30-10 07:50 AM

Re: Favorite Star Trek captain?
 

Originally Posted by Defiant1 (Post 10345586)
I don't know for sure but DS9 from about season 3 onwards, it became pretty serialized, with long story arcs. That makes syndication harder. From what I remember, DS9's original ratings were fine, on par with Voyager's, and it was never in danger of being cancelled. *cough cough* Enterprise.

Yep, DS9 had good ratings.


Deep Space Nine spent most of its lifetime as the number one syndicated first-run show on television despite its falling number of viewers. Even when it became a near-serial show (usually, long-term serial shows are ratings disasters -- witness Babylon 5) airing in prime-time in less than 60 percent of the nation, DS9 managed well over a 4.0 average in its final two years. As a general rule, a syndicated show needs to maintain a 3.0 to be successful, DS9 always maintained that despite the strikes against it. Look at the other sci-fi shows similar to DS9: Earth: Final Conflict is regarded as a decent show ratings-wise, staying in the lower 3.0 range and Babylon 5 is the hot potato of science fiction television -- it's done so poorly that no one wants to hold on to it.

As a serial, more cultish television show, DS9 is right behind the X-Files on the all-time list of successes even with extreme disadvantages.
http://www.trektoday.com/articles/ratings_history.shtml

Sean O'Hara 08-30-10 09:06 AM

Re: Favorite Star Trek captain?
 

Originally Posted by Thrush (Post 10345826)

I love how the writer felt the need to repeatedly mention what a flop Babylon 5 was.

And of course that saw about long-term arcs being ratings poison was received wisdom back in the '90s, but starting with Buffy and picking up with 24 and Lost, we know what bullshit that was.

cleaver 08-30-10 09:48 AM

Re: Favorite Star Trek captain?
 
Picard is the best actor and you've got to worry about Kirk around your girl. Kirk has the best resume though, probably saved the universe the most times.

Meglos 08-30-10 09:59 AM

Re: Favorite Star Trek captain?
 
These two guys:

http://i38.tinypic.com/5medqr.jpg

NORML54601 08-30-10 11:01 AM

Re: Favorite Star Trek captain?
 
Kirk>Picard

For all the horrible episodes they made during the first & second seasons, I do think Archer had the best transition of any of the captains. He went from a happy-go-lucky goof ball to a total badass willing to torture, attack, & steal to complete his mission.

Trevor 08-30-10 11:31 AM

Re: Favorite Star Trek captain?
 

Originally Posted by Chew (Post 10343828)
Let's see how much the results change, if any, from 9 years ago.
http://forum.dvdtalk.com/tv-talk/131...k-captain.html

Looks like the forum is getting smarter. Or just older.

Anubis2005X 08-30-10 12:41 PM

Re: Favorite Star Trek captain?
 

Originally Posted by Nick Martin (Post 10343843)
Benjamin LaFayette Sisko, with TOS movies era Kirk, and Picard as second and third.

Nobody can bark orders like Sisko, nobody...

Superboy 08-30-10 01:51 PM

Re: Favorite Star Trek captain?
 
I'd like to see the other captains go toe-to-toe with a Jem H'adar and win.

Nick Martin 08-30-10 02:38 PM

Re: Favorite Star Trek captain?
 

Originally Posted by Superboy (Post 10346551)
I'd like to see the other captains go toe-to-toe with a Jem H'adar and win.

Even Worf is intimidated by him.

I remember an old interview in which Ron Moore said something along the lines of, "You see Sisko at the table with these two imposing Klingons (Worf and Martok, in season 5 or 6, I think) and Avery's the badass of the room".

Obviously paraphrasing, but that was the idea. :)

alfredog1976 08-30-10 04:01 PM

Re: Favorite Star Trek captain?
 
I just zipped through and finished watching all the 7 seasons of DS9 and I have to say, I have new found respect for Sisko. He can certainly kick both Kirk & Picard's asses and did things those 2 would never do. But I have to say, Picard is still my fav captain.

McHawkson 08-30-10 04:38 PM

Re: Favorite Star Trek captain?
 

Originally Posted by Meglos (Post 10346049)

Ah, that's the part where Sisko kissed up - friggin' brown nose...


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 04:45 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.