Ocampa (3)

alk3hol
Nogura
JasonF

I almost put him but I figured Hoshi was a better answer since she wasn't annoying and she was hot.

Talaxian (2)

Damfino
Tracer Bullet

Darn it, how did someone else pick Founder, but not Betazoid?

I'd also let the half-stuff slide.

Trill (2)

achau9598
NORML54601

Vulcan (2)

wendersfan
wishbone

So far the vote is 2-1 against counting half-humans as correct answers. Anyone else want to weigh in?

Klingon (2)

Scrumtrulescent
Groucho

I vote no, but I'm also feeling a bit vindictive at the moment so you might want to throw my vote out.

What does Memory-Alpha say?

*



brainee, Klingon-human hybrid

I'd think if you told B'Elanna that she couldn't be counted as Klingon, she may not be too happy. Or Spock that he's not Vulcan...

We're now 3-1. I'm going to rule brainee's and Suprmallet's answers as wrong pending a further ruling.

So if a question asked for a non-Vulcan and you answered Spock, would that be a right answer?

This means that wrong answers are worth 5 points. No one got a unique bonus.

The Standings*

Scrumtrulescent -29
Jimmy James -26
Groucho -26
gmanca -26
Rockmjd23 -26
achau9598 -26
wendersfan -26
wishbone -26
FatTony -25
WallyOPD -25
the big train -25
Suprmallet -23
wmansir -23
reverie -21
Damfino -21
Tracer Bullet -21
Nogura -20
Palaver -17
Red Dog -17
RKillgore -17
alk3hol -17
JasonF -14
NORML54601 -14
feenst -12
brainee -12
The Bus -6
Fist of Doom -5
kvrdave -1

*pending final decision on the half-human question

TB - why was cardassian a wrong answer?

There weren't any Cardassian main characters.

Growing Up Cardassian is not a Star Trek show.

They shouldn't be wrong. If you asked a biologist what species Spock was, the right answer isn't Vulcan ... it's Vulcan-human hybrid. Whether Spock would get offended or not has no bearing on the answer. I looked up a bunch of Trek info sites, and these characters are always listed as hybrids for their species.

It would be wrong.

Blame the wording of the question, but that's what we're stuck with. Non is the equivalent of zero. Half /= zero.

Hmm.. good counter-point. In the context of a game, it makes it a hard argument. Really though, in the end I'd go with how they're mostly portrayed. To the average person who doesn't know Trek, Spock *is* a Vulcan.

Like I said though, going with nit-picky game rules, it's a hard call.

Edit:
I'll conceed then.

It says hybrids for both Spock and B'Ellana.

Which is why it's a good answer to choose for a reverse sheep question, right?

I hope you did that after you submitted your answers.