What was one of the flaws of one of your favorite tv shows?
#1
DVD Talk Legend
Thread Starter
What was one of the flaws of one of your favorite tv shows?
Mission Impossible(original)-Too many re-appearing guest stars. If they were in love with William Windom-make him a semi-regular. Plus not enough episodes with Lesley Ann Warren wearing a mini-skirt.
#4
Member
Join Date: Apr 2009
Location: Henderson, NV
Posts: 136
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: What was one of the flaws of one of your favorite tv shows?
LOST- Random filler in the first 2(maybe 3) seasons. Example: Jack's tattoo flashback, most of Kate's flashbacks after season 1, Sawyer and Kate in bear cages.
#5
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Re: What was one of the flaws of one of your favorite tv shows?
Just want you to know I'm here for in a few years when LOST is over, and you are left wondering why you chose a user name from a TV show character .
#6
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Join Date: Apr 2003
Location: Southside Virginia
Posts: 6,457
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: What was one of the flaws of one of your favorite tv shows?
Newsradio: It probably didn't do enough to cater to the casual fan not following it from night to night on the schedule. It also didn't use the Catherine character nearly enough, which is what led to KA leaving.
#7
DVD Talk Godfather
Re: What was one of the flaws of one of your favorite tv shows?
Along the same lines, Spin City shedding characters left and right towards the end until it was pretty much the Michael J. Fox & Heather Locklear show (and then the Sheen/Locklear show). It was the ensemble cast that made the show work so well and they ruined it towards the end.
#8
DVD Talk Limited Edition
#10
DVD Talk Hero
Re: What was one of the flaws of one of your favorite tv shows?
Arrested Development - It ended. Oh and I never cared about the characters all that much, but that's sort of the "unlikeable" angle that made it so likable.
30 Rock - Insubstantial plots in most episodes, stuff doesn't "come together" very often. And yet the chaos is an asset.
Lost - Inconsistent directing and writing. While it's generally an excellent show, some of the episodes are just exceptionally poor in terms of execution. (Filler done okay: Little Hurley Sunshine episode. Filler done wrong: Jack's Tattoos. Substantial done poorly: Season 5 finale.)
30 Rock - Insubstantial plots in most episodes, stuff doesn't "come together" very often. And yet the chaos is an asset.
Lost - Inconsistent directing and writing. While it's generally an excellent show, some of the episodes are just exceptionally poor in terms of execution. (Filler done okay: Little Hurley Sunshine episode. Filler done wrong: Jack's Tattoos. Substantial done poorly: Season 5 finale.)
#11
DVD Talk God
Re: What was one of the flaws of one of your favorite tv shows?
Hunter (not the old 80's version, but the late 90's revival): Transferring him from the LAPD to the San Diego PD
Friday Night Lights: The murder plot from season 2
Grey's Anatomy: Bringing back Denny Duquette from the dead multiple times.
CSI: Miami: Bringing back Tim Speedle from the dead
CSI: Hooking up Gil and Sara, Killing off Chandra West in the Pilot, which unfortunately gave us Jorja Fox. Making Louise Lombard's character speak with an American accent.
Ugly Betty: the whole Henry-Gio-Betty love triangle
NYPD Blue: Dumping Esai Morales and bringing in Currie Graham as the new Captain.
Martial Law: Firing Tom Wright as the Captain and bringing in Gretchen Egolf. Firing Louis Mandylor and hiring Arsenio Hall.
The OC: Pointlessly killing off Marisa after season 3 even though her character was already leaving the show to be with her father.
Cold Case: Anytime they attempted to give Lily a personal life, it was a disaster.
Without a Trace: Pointlessly hooking up Samantha and Martin. Also, bringing in Mary Elizabeth Mastantonio to be Jack's GF only to get rid of her after she had a miscarriage. Bringing in Steven Weber as the Boss to start the season.
Friday Night Lights: The murder plot from season 2
Grey's Anatomy: Bringing back Denny Duquette from the dead multiple times.
CSI: Miami: Bringing back Tim Speedle from the dead
CSI: Hooking up Gil and Sara, Killing off Chandra West in the Pilot, which unfortunately gave us Jorja Fox. Making Louise Lombard's character speak with an American accent.
Ugly Betty: the whole Henry-Gio-Betty love triangle
NYPD Blue: Dumping Esai Morales and bringing in Currie Graham as the new Captain.
Martial Law: Firing Tom Wright as the Captain and bringing in Gretchen Egolf. Firing Louis Mandylor and hiring Arsenio Hall.
The OC: Pointlessly killing off Marisa after season 3 even though her character was already leaving the show to be with her father.
Cold Case: Anytime they attempted to give Lily a personal life, it was a disaster.
Without a Trace: Pointlessly hooking up Samantha and Martin. Also, bringing in Mary Elizabeth Mastantonio to be Jack's GF only to get rid of her after she had a miscarriage. Bringing in Steven Weber as the Boss to start the season.
Last edited by DJariya; 05-22-09 at 09:40 PM.
#12
Re: What was one of the flaws of one of your favorite tv shows?
Alias: Never truly solving the mystery of Rambaldi. In other words, it had one of the most disappointing conclusions in television history.
#13
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Re: What was one of the flaws of one of your favorite tv shows?
24: some episodes are structured as 90% talky and 10% action, with the last 10 minutes having the action.
I don't mind that it's a talky episode, but saving the action for the end pisses me off. It's like the writers just crammed it in there so the episode won't suck. Mix it up!
I don't mind that it's a talky episode, but saving the action for the end pisses me off. It's like the writers just crammed it in there so the episode won't suck. Mix it up!
Last edited by MLBFan24; 05-22-09 at 09:30 PM.
#15
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
Re: What was one of the flaws of one of your favorite tv shows?
The X-Files - Losing Duchovny for the last two seasons.
Millennium - Disregarding the "viral apocalypse" ending of season 2 and calling it a "minor outbreak" in Season 3.
Deadwood -
Millennium - Disregarding the "viral apocalypse" ending of season 2 and calling it a "minor outbreak" in Season 3.
Deadwood -
Spoiler:
#16
DVD Talk Legend
Re: What was one of the flaws of one of your favorite tv shows?
#18
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: What was one of the flaws of one of your favorite tv shows?
Babylon 5: Some wooden acting (especially in earlier episodes) and special effects that don't hold up very well
#19
DVD Talk Gold Edition
#20
DVD Talk God
Re: What was one of the flaws of one of your favorite tv shows?
Criminal Minds: I hated the way Lola Glaudini's character Elle Greenaway was written out. Rather than writing her out in a dignified way like resigning or getting killed in the line of duty, she starts experiencing psychological problems that stemmed from her attack at the end of season 1 and basically became obsessed and extremely neurotic.
Also hated the way Mandy Patinkin's Jason Gideon was written out, but he put the writers and producers in a bind when he just chose to not show up and then quit which put the show behind schedule.
Also hated the way Mandy Patinkin's Jason Gideon was written out, but he put the writers and producers in a bind when he just chose to not show up and then quit which put the show behind schedule.
#21
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Jul 2000
Posts: 1,693
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: What was one of the flaws of one of your favorite tv shows?
Sports Night - Casey and Dana's on-again, off-again bit felt like a cheap attempt to attract more female viewers to an otherwise intelligent show free of those kinds of cliches
#22
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: May 2007
Posts: 1,023
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: What was one of the flaws of one of your favorite tv shows?
Smallville. The overuse of kryptonite{and that's an understatement}, not to mention the inconsistent use of it. Also the season 8 finale{most of it}.
#23
DVD Talk Hero
Re: What was one of the flaws of one of your favorite tv shows?
Buffy the Vampire Slayer - Buffy was a spoiled preppy brat, and I never really bought that her character could actually be as clever, strong, and heroic as she was protrayed.