Star Wars: The Clone Wars -- CGI animated series -- Discussion Thread
#451
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Star Wars: The Clone Wars -- CGI animated series -- Discussion Thread
#452
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Star Wars: The Clone Wars -- CGI animated series -- Discussion Thread
One weird thing about the likenesses is how some thing like the Clone Trooper armor, droids, and some aliens (Jar-Jar) look like almost exactly their movie counterparts, but the human characters are extremely stylized (Dooku, especially). It's kind of off-putting in an anti-uncanny valley kind of way. The human characters look like puppets, and it frequently comes off looking Team America World Police. And quite a few lightsabre battles and other fight scenes look like they're from an X-Box game.
And then, a while back I rewatched The Phantom Menace, and the big Gungan/Battle Droids fight looked like it could have been from the Clone Wars cartoon.
And then, a while back I rewatched The Phantom Menace, and the big Gungan/Battle Droids fight looked like it could have been from the Clone Wars cartoon.
#453
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Star Wars: The Clone Wars -- CGI animated series -- Discussion Thread
The character design is one thing that put me off watching the show for so long, since it looks so janky at first glance. I've gotten used to it now, and It's been improving. I think I noted a big improvement on the human models at the beginning of season 3.
I did find reference to the CGI design being based on the 2D show:
https://web.archive.org/web/20071011...5/indexp2.html
I also didn't watch the show initially because I was miffed at it, for seeming to be Lucas doing a knock-off of the excellent 2D series Genndy Tartakovsky had made. Seeing the awful reviews of the movie, and the middling reviews of the first season, made it easier to ignore.
In terms of some characters and things looking like it's straight from the movies, they probably are. I imagine since it was totally in-house, they just grabbed the assets from the movies and used them, maybe tweaking them a bit and adjusting textures and such to fit a CGI show instead of merging it with live action.
I did find reference to the CGI design being based on the 2D show:
https://web.archive.org/web/20071011...5/indexp2.html
While the new Clone Wars series has a clearly defined look and style, Plunkett did refer to the characters of the original 2-D Cartoon Network series when designing the new CG animated characters.
[ Clone Wars Character Designer Kilian Plunkett ]"We looked at how Paul Rudish and Genndy [Tartakovsky] approached the characters to see if we could find certain shapes or features that had a similar feel and adapt them to work in three dimensions," explains Plunkett. "This meant finding shapes that are not quite as angular or severe but still have a stylized graphic 'swoop' to them
[ Clone Wars Character Designer Kilian Plunkett ]"We looked at how Paul Rudish and Genndy [Tartakovsky] approached the characters to see if we could find certain shapes or features that had a similar feel and adapt them to work in three dimensions," explains Plunkett. "This meant finding shapes that are not quite as angular or severe but still have a stylized graphic 'swoop' to them
In terms of some characters and things looking like it's straight from the movies, they probably are. I imagine since it was totally in-house, they just grabbed the assets from the movies and used them, maybe tweaking them a bit and adjusting textures and such to fit a CGI show instead of merging it with live action.
#454
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Star Wars: The Clone Wars -- CGI animated series -- Discussion Thread
Almost done with season 4.
Spoiler:
#455
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Star Wars: The Clone Wars -- CGI animated series -- Discussion Thread
Three episodes of the show left. .
I found a guide online that breaks down how to watch the final episodes of the series and Revenge of the Sith so they more or less line up. Think my girlfriend and I are going to do the final episodes and movie like that.
I found a guide online that breaks down how to watch the final episodes of the series and Revenge of the Sith so they more or less line up. Think my girlfriend and I are going to do the final episodes and movie like that.
#456
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Star Wars: The Clone Wars -- CGI animated series -- Discussion Thread
#457
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Star Wars: The Clone Wars -- CGI animated series -- Discussion Thread
Or, you could save some time and watch this brief animated recap of RotS:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MCmReoDi4sE
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MCmReoDi4sE
#458
DVD Talk Legend
Join Date: Aug 2001
Location: Second star to the right and straight on 'til morning.
Posts: 16,055
Received 1,077 Likes
on
676 Posts
Re: Star Wars: The Clone Wars -- CGI animated series -- Discussion Thread
I just finished this series rewatch myself now to include the final season.
There's a really interesting uber edit of Revenge of the Sith out there that edits in the cartoon series battle, Clone Wars final 4 episodes and the deleted scenes from the live action film in one 4 hr and 19 min cut. It's pretty interesting to view it in that context.
There's a really interesting uber edit of Revenge of the Sith out there that edits in the cartoon series battle, Clone Wars final 4 episodes and the deleted scenes from the live action film in one 4 hr and 19 min cut. It's pretty interesting to view it in that context.
#459
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Star Wars: The Clone Wars -- CGI animated series -- Discussion Thread
Still watching the show, but I've been taking it slower recently. I did pause to rewatch the 2D Clone Wars, which was recently added to D+. I feel that series still holds up, basically a 2 hour movie set between episodes 2 and 3 that tells a better story than either of those films. The CGI series clearly took a lot of inspiration from the show, expanding on a lot of the characters and concepts introduced in it.
I'm in the middle of season 5.
Overall, the series is good, but I'm not sure if I'd call even any particular story arc great. It's also maybe overlong, with a number of arcs that likely don't contribute to the overall series story. I feel a bit exhausted with it. Lately, when selecting something to watch for the night, I find myself looking for other things to watch, settling on The Clone Wars if there's nothing more compelling.
I'm in the middle of season 5.
Spoiler:
Overall, the series is good, but I'm not sure if I'd call even any particular story arc great. It's also maybe overlong, with a number of arcs that likely don't contribute to the overall series story. I feel a bit exhausted with it. Lately, when selecting something to watch for the night, I find myself looking for other things to watch, settling on The Clone Wars if there's nothing more compelling.
#460
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Star Wars: The Clone Wars -- CGI animated series -- Discussion Thread
Finally finished the series.
I'm moving on to Rebels next, then may circle back to The Bad Batch series after that.
Spoiler:
I'm moving on to Rebels next, then may circle back to The Bad Batch series after that.