TV Death Watch
#1
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Hero
TV Death Watch
TV Death Watch
A look at shows facing cancellation before the fall
The networks have started working on new fall series, which means pink slips are coming for some of your old favorites. Here's what could be on the chopping block.
NBC
Did you ever imagine the day when Law & Order would be canceled? We're not saying it's going to happen — it probably won't. But costs on the show have risen while its ratings have dropped, which means its renewal is no longer automatic every year. NBC's other middling crime dramas — Law & Order: Criminal Intent, Crossing Jordan and Medium — are more vulnerable. The network has also yet to decide on another season for The Apprentice.
Stick a fork in Studio 60. It held little of the audience from its lead-in, Heroes, and began to slip even further in its last two airings. Prospects are better for Friday Night Lights, which has a small but steady following and is a favorite with critics (it also doesn't hurt that NBC owns it).[ On the comedy side, the network has to decide if it's willing to show patience with the funny but struggling 30 Rock. Word is it will swap time periods with Scrubs later this season to see how it does with The Office as a lead-in.
ABC
The network's comedies continue to get clubbed by competition from American Idol. So it could be the end for According to Jim, George Lopez, In Case of Emergency and Knights of Prosperity. What About Brian has failed to grow its audience, but insiders put its chances of returning at 50-50. While Men in Trees doesn't hold much of Grey's Anatomy's audience, it's a favorite among ABC execs and could survive to a second season. Remember, you can't cancel everything.
CBS
Second-year crime drama Close to Home has been an underachiever between Ghost Whisperer and Numbers, and CBS will look hard for an upgrade in the time period. With mid-season comedy Rules of Engagement working, it's uncertain that The Class will graduate to a second season. Jericho will also have to get closer to the ratings it scored in the fall to survive.
Fox
Brad Garrett's sitcom 'Til Death will get a shot after the American Idol results show before the network decides on its fate. Producers are looking to cast Michael Rapaport in new shows, which means The War at Home might be over. With Standoff banished to Friday nights, the chances of it being rescued from cancellation are slim.
CW
It's goodbye to the Gilmore Girls unless stars Lauren Graham and Alexis Bledel decide to sign on for another season. Veronica Mars will likely solve her final case this spring. Monday sitcoms All of Us and The Game are vulnerable. If 7th Heaven doesn't get canceled after this season, you'll know that the CW's new-show development is lousy.
A look at shows facing cancellation before the fall
The networks have started working on new fall series, which means pink slips are coming for some of your old favorites. Here's what could be on the chopping block.
NBC
Did you ever imagine the day when Law & Order would be canceled? We're not saying it's going to happen — it probably won't. But costs on the show have risen while its ratings have dropped, which means its renewal is no longer automatic every year. NBC's other middling crime dramas — Law & Order: Criminal Intent, Crossing Jordan and Medium — are more vulnerable. The network has also yet to decide on another season for The Apprentice.
Stick a fork in Studio 60. It held little of the audience from its lead-in, Heroes, and began to slip even further in its last two airings. Prospects are better for Friday Night Lights, which has a small but steady following and is a favorite with critics (it also doesn't hurt that NBC owns it).[ On the comedy side, the network has to decide if it's willing to show patience with the funny but struggling 30 Rock. Word is it will swap time periods with Scrubs later this season to see how it does with The Office as a lead-in.
ABC
The network's comedies continue to get clubbed by competition from American Idol. So it could be the end for According to Jim, George Lopez, In Case of Emergency and Knights of Prosperity. What About Brian has failed to grow its audience, but insiders put its chances of returning at 50-50. While Men in Trees doesn't hold much of Grey's Anatomy's audience, it's a favorite among ABC execs and could survive to a second season. Remember, you can't cancel everything.
CBS
Second-year crime drama Close to Home has been an underachiever between Ghost Whisperer and Numbers, and CBS will look hard for an upgrade in the time period. With mid-season comedy Rules of Engagement working, it's uncertain that The Class will graduate to a second season. Jericho will also have to get closer to the ratings it scored in the fall to survive.
Fox
Brad Garrett's sitcom 'Til Death will get a shot after the American Idol results show before the network decides on its fate. Producers are looking to cast Michael Rapaport in new shows, which means The War at Home might be over. With Standoff banished to Friday nights, the chances of it being rescued from cancellation are slim.
CW
It's goodbye to the Gilmore Girls unless stars Lauren Graham and Alexis Bledel decide to sign on for another season. Veronica Mars will likely solve her final case this spring. Monday sitcoms All of Us and The Game are vulnerable. If 7th Heaven doesn't get canceled after this season, you'll know that the CW's new-show development is lousy.
#3
DVD Talk Legend
Joined: Jul 2000
Posts: 20,195
Likes: 0
Received 7 Likes
on
7 Posts
From: Sesame Street (the apt. next to Bob's)
Veronica Mars will likely solve her final case this spring.
I hope The Class makes it too. And although I don't watch L&O regularly, it should stick around.
The other ones mentioned I couldn't care less if they're cancelled or not.
#4
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Originally Posted by Chew
I already dropped Smallville and CW looks to be getting rid of Mars. If they get rid of Supernatural too, I won't be watching the network at all.
The Class is okay - it gets better with each passing episode. However if it doesn't do something fast, it should get cancelled. How can they be this far into the season and still hacking out characters (Holly Ellenbogen, Perry Pearl, Kyle's boyfriend Aaron, and now possibly Yonk Allen)?
Suprisingly nothing is being said about The New Adventures of Old Christine which is supposed to take over The Class timeslot after next week I think...
If Veronica Mars and Supernatural bite it, that is the end of the CW for me.
Last edited by rfduncan; 03-02-07 at 08:17 AM.
#5
Moderator
I really hope "The Class" gets a sophomore season.
#6
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 3,662
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: H-Town, TX
NBC - Well, I've got every episode of Studio 60 sitting on my DVR and every episode of Friday Night Lights sitting on my computer. Looks like I should go ahead and just delete the former and give the latter a shot. The only other shows of theirs I care about are Heroes and The Office, and both of those are bonafide hits so no worries there.
ABC - I don't watch anything on there but Lost and Grey's Anatomy. I'll be curious as to what they decide to do with Lost as far as an enddate is concerned. I hope they announce next year is its last. I'm also curious about the Kate Walsh/Addison spinoff. She's my favorite character on that show.
CBS - The most successful network, yet the only show of theirs I give a rat's ass about is The Class and it could be done after next Monday. I hope not as it's really improved over the course of the season. Remember, Friends had a shaky first year too before really hitting its stride in the 2nd season. Patience, CBS.
Fox - The O.C. is done which is a damn shame considering they had a great comeback this year, so that just leaves 24. And that show is all but guaranteed a 7th season. Hopefully the writers get their act together though cuz this year sucks so far.
CW - Veronica Mars is likely done which is a shame. I think this season is a lot more consistent than last year. And regardless, it's a great show that deserves to stick around. Smallville will be back. Season 6 ain't too bad actually(Lana notwithstanding), so that's good news. The only other show of theirs I watch is One Tree Hill. Honestly I don't know why since it hasn't been good since Season 1, but yet I still find myself rooting for a 5th year.
ABC - I don't watch anything on there but Lost and Grey's Anatomy. I'll be curious as to what they decide to do with Lost as far as an enddate is concerned. I hope they announce next year is its last. I'm also curious about the Kate Walsh/Addison spinoff. She's my favorite character on that show.
CBS - The most successful network, yet the only show of theirs I give a rat's ass about is The Class and it could be done after next Monday. I hope not as it's really improved over the course of the season. Remember, Friends had a shaky first year too before really hitting its stride in the 2nd season. Patience, CBS.
Fox - The O.C. is done which is a damn shame considering they had a great comeback this year, so that just leaves 24. And that show is all but guaranteed a 7th season. Hopefully the writers get their act together though cuz this year sucks so far.
CW - Veronica Mars is likely done which is a shame. I think this season is a lot more consistent than last year. And regardless, it's a great show that deserves to stick around. Smallville will be back. Season 6 ain't too bad actually(Lana notwithstanding), so that's good news. The only other show of theirs I watch is One Tree Hill. Honestly I don't know why since it hasn't been good since Season 1, but yet I still find myself rooting for a 5th year.
#7
Please don't cancel "Law & Order Criminal Intent." No, no, no. NO.
Amen to that.
Originally Posted by rfduncan
If Veronica Mars and Supernatural bite it, that is the end of the CW for me. 

#9
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Joined: Nov 2001
Posts: 9,921
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Guelph, Ontario
I like a lot of these bubble shows... I will be extremely pissed off if they cancel Friday Night Lights, 30 Rock, What About Brian, The Class, Men In Trees, Veronica Mars. I'm not even willing to entertain the thought that Supernatural is in trouble, because it's one of my favourites.
MATT
MATT
#10
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
The next two episodes of NBC’s “30 Rock” could help determine whether the critically beloved but low-rated sitcom will return for a second season.
“Rock” will go on a six-week hiatus after next week’s episode, leaving the Thursday 9:30 p.m. timeslot to the new show “Andy Barker, P.I.,” before returning in April. These two weeks are important because “Rock” will air against reruns of powerhouse timeslot competitors “Grey’s Anatomy” on ABC and “CSI” on CBS.
Networks are in pilot mode now, beginning to narrow down which new and returning shows will make their fall schedule. NBC is only expected to pick up one of its freshman series for next fall, either “Rock” or “Friday Night Lights.” (A third rookie, "Studio 60 on the Sunset Strip," looks all but dead.) "Rock" and "Lights" have similar season averages, and so NBC will be looking for growth potential when it decides which to bring back.
Airing against original episodes of “Grey’s” and “CSI” the past month, “Rock” actually has been shrinking, not growing. When the show took over the Thursday slot in late November, its first three episodes against minimal competition averaged a 2.9 adults 18-49 rating.
Its three most recent episodes have averaged a 2.5, a decline of 14 percent. If it can grow again over its next two outings, that might help convince NBC the show has potential much like “The Office,” which was renewed two years ago with similarly low ratings.
It doesn’t hurt that recently critics seem to have adopted “Rock” as the new “Arrested Development,” a similarly smart but low-rated show. Publications from TV Guide to Entertainment Weekly to countless blogs are championing its renewal.
The competition isn’t entirely light tonight. “Rock” will face a new challenge in Fox’s smash “Are You Smarter than a 5th Grader,” which had the network’s best debut in 18-49s in more than 14 years earlier this week.
In tonight’s “Rock,” guest star LL Cool J plays a hip-hop producer who helps Jack (Alec Baldwin) launch a new line of champagne.
http://www.medialifemagazine.com/ar...ticle_10480.asp
“Rock” will go on a six-week hiatus after next week’s episode, leaving the Thursday 9:30 p.m. timeslot to the new show “Andy Barker, P.I.,” before returning in April. These two weeks are important because “Rock” will air against reruns of powerhouse timeslot competitors “Grey’s Anatomy” on ABC and “CSI” on CBS.
Networks are in pilot mode now, beginning to narrow down which new and returning shows will make their fall schedule. NBC is only expected to pick up one of its freshman series for next fall, either “Rock” or “Friday Night Lights.” (A third rookie, "Studio 60 on the Sunset Strip," looks all but dead.) "Rock" and "Lights" have similar season averages, and so NBC will be looking for growth potential when it decides which to bring back.
Airing against original episodes of “Grey’s” and “CSI” the past month, “Rock” actually has been shrinking, not growing. When the show took over the Thursday slot in late November, its first three episodes against minimal competition averaged a 2.9 adults 18-49 rating.
Its three most recent episodes have averaged a 2.5, a decline of 14 percent. If it can grow again over its next two outings, that might help convince NBC the show has potential much like “The Office,” which was renewed two years ago with similarly low ratings.
It doesn’t hurt that recently critics seem to have adopted “Rock” as the new “Arrested Development,” a similarly smart but low-rated show. Publications from TV Guide to Entertainment Weekly to countless blogs are championing its renewal.
The competition isn’t entirely light tonight. “Rock” will face a new challenge in Fox’s smash “Are You Smarter than a 5th Grader,” which had the network’s best debut in 18-49s in more than 14 years earlier this week.
In tonight’s “Rock,” guest star LL Cool J plays a hip-hop producer who helps Jack (Alec Baldwin) launch a new line of champagne.
http://www.medialifemagazine.com/ar...ticle_10480.asp
#11
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
I wonder how Veronica Mars would do on another station, like CBS, or something. The CW just seems to be a dark cloud for a lot of shows that might fare better elsewhere.
#12
DVD Talk Godfather
30 Rock isn't as wildly brilliant as Arrested Development, but it comes pretty close and a lot of its jokes are a bit smarter. I don't need the show to exist for ten years, but it would be nice to get another season or two.
#13
DVD Talk Legend
I'll be extremely pissed if 30 Rock and Supernatural gets cancelled. In regards to Veronica Mars, I made peace that this will be the final season for the show.
I can't blame UPN/CW for the lack of ratings that this show gets. They have done everything possible even putting it on CBS one summer, in order to add viewership. For example, UPN, place this show after America Next Top Model, their highest watched show at that time and in CW, they placed it after Gilmore Girls.
Veronica Mars wouldn't have lasted a full season let alone three in any other network.
Originally Posted by Vipper II
I wonder how Veronica Mars would do on another station, like CBS, or something. The CW just seems to be a dark cloud for a lot of shows that might fare better elsewhere.
Veronica Mars wouldn't have lasted a full season let alone three in any other network.
#14
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Why doesn't Veronica Mars get good ratings? I'll miss it.
#15
DVD Talk Special Edition
Joined: Oct 2002
Posts: 1,491
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From a recent "Ask Ausiello" (TvGuide.com):
I just e-emailed Mars' main man Rob Thomas for an update [on news of a fourth season], and here's what he wrote back: "We're very much on the fence for a fourth season. My amateur handicapping of our situation — 60/40 in our favor. We are shooting the finale as a season finale — not as a series finale. There will be no alternate. If they do try to get rid of us, we're not going to make it easy for them."
Still doesn't look great, but at least there's still a small chance we could see it come back.
I just e-emailed Mars' main man Rob Thomas for an update [on news of a fourth season], and here's what he wrote back: "We're very much on the fence for a fourth season. My amateur handicapping of our situation — 60/40 in our favor. We are shooting the finale as a season finale — not as a series finale. There will be no alternate. If they do try to get rid of us, we're not going to make it easy for them."
Still doesn't look great, but at least there's still a small chance we could see it come back.
#16
DVD Talk Legend
Originally Posted by dvd182
From a recent "Ask Ausiello" (TvGuide.com):
I just e-emailed Mars' main man Rob Thomas for an update [on news of a fourth season], and here's what he wrote back: "We're very much on the fence for a fourth season. My amateur handicapping of our situation — 60/40 in our favor. We are shooting the finale as a season finale — not as a series finale. There will be no alternate. If they do try to get rid of us, we're not going to make it easy for them."
Still doesn't look great, but at least there's still a small chance we could see it come back.
I just e-emailed Mars' main man Rob Thomas for an update [on news of a fourth season], and here's what he wrote back: "We're very much on the fence for a fourth season. My amateur handicapping of our situation — 60/40 in our favor. We are shooting the finale as a season finale — not as a series finale. There will be no alternate. If they do try to get rid of us, we're not going to make it easy for them."
Still doesn't look great, but at least there's still a small chance we could see it come back.
I don't like the idea of ending this season with a cliffhanger especially if CW decides to cancel the show. I want some sort of resolution dammit!
#17
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Originally Posted by LorenzoL
I don't like the idea of ending this season with a cliffhanger especially if CW decides to cancel the show. I want some sort of resolution dammit!
#19
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Joined: Aug 2002
Posts: 3,032
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Gilmore Girls will be gone, I think both the stars want to finally branch out and give it a shot at the actual big screen.. Veronica MARS will also be axed. The rest, eh, who knows.
#22
DVD Talk Legend
Originally Posted by MrX
30 Rock was up a million viewers from last week.
#23
Moderator
Originally Posted by Bandoman
Who do I write to to complain about NBC's likely cancellation of Studio 60? 

#24
Moderator
Originally Posted by MrX
30 Rock was up a million viewers from last week.
#25
DVD Talk God
I read there is a strong chance that Medium could land on CBS next fall if NBC cans it. CBS/Paramount, who produces the show, signed a very lucrative deal with Lifetime that if the show reaches 100 episodes for syndication, Lifetime will pay CBS 1.35M per episode. I can definitely see CBS pairing it with Ghost Whisperer on Friday's if they cancel Close to Home.



