DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   TV Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/tv-talk-14/)
-   -   American Idol -- The Auditions Thread (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/tv-talk/452485-american-idol-auditions-thread.html)

Deftones 01-25-06 11:43 PM

Holy moly. When the guy w/ was doing the Michael Jackson thing came out and got hugs from his family, did anyone see the grill on the chick hugging him? Wow, those were summer teeth!

gotrice487 01-26-06 12:03 AM


Originally Posted by Deftones
Holy moly. When the guy w/ was doing the Michael Jackson thing came out and got hugs from his family, did anyone see the grill on the chick hugging him? Wow, those were summer teeth!

I was thinking the exact same thing!

TomOpus 01-26-06 08:19 AM


Originally Posted by Heat
It was interesting to see more of how the audition process works. There was one scene where they were showing a guy on the stadium floor with a row of booths separated by black curtains behind him (8 or 10?) which is where I assume the first round of auditions take place.

And there was a point where Ryan Seacrest said something like "you obviously have something that the selectors liked".

Of course Simon, Paula, and Randy don't see 20,000 or 30,000 people in each city. What I wonder is, are the bad singers told during the earlier auditions that they sound great which is why they are being sent on? This would explain why some people who can't sing look shocked when told that by Simon, Paula, and Randy.

I knew a girl that tried out a couple years ago. She said the selectors look at 3 or 4 at a time. You get 30 seconds and they will only pick one. She was miffed because, out of her group, they went with the goofball singer. Since she didn't make it past this round, she wasn't sure if there was another round before the Simon/Paula/Randy round.

SMB-IL 01-26-06 12:56 PM


Originally Posted by Deftones
Holy moly. When the guy w/ was doing the Michael Jackson thing came out and got hugs from his family, did anyone see the grill on the chick hugging him? Wow, those were summer teeth!

You should have seen it in HD -- they got a close-up on her and my head actually whipped back! It scared me! -eek-

hahn 01-26-06 08:31 PM

Surprised that no one has mentioned Katharine McPhee. She was the one with a mother who is a vocal teacher. I think her training shows in that she may have the widest vocal range of any of the contestants and just amazing control. However, there was something in her voice that was just SLIGHTLY off last night, though it may have just been the nerves. I think the high notes got a little too screechy for my tastes. But the judges didn't seem to notice. All 3 of them absolutely loved her. The potential for greatness is there, plus, she also has the looks to pull it off.

JacksModernLife 01-26-06 09:11 PM

people on other forums are saying that
Spoiler:
Kelly P and Paris
definitely make it to the top 12.

TimeandTide 01-26-06 09:34 PM


Originally Posted by hahn
Surprised that no one has mentioned Katharine McPhee. She was the one with a mother who is a vocal teacher. I think her training shows in that she may have the widest vocal range of any of the contestants and just amazing control. However, there was something in her voice that was just SLIGHTLY off last night, though it may have just been the nerves. I think the high notes got a little too screechy for my tastes. But the judges didn't seem to notice. All 3 of them absolutely loved her. The potential for greatness is there, plus, she also has the looks to pull it off.

Agreed. She's my favorite so far. Not as strong a vocalist as Paris (is anyone?), but the girl is hot. Reminds of Food Network's Rachel Ray, but taller and younger.

And JacksModernLife, you might want to spoiler-ize that.


people on other forums are saying that
Spoiler:
Kelly P and Paris definitely make it to the top 12.


JacksModernLife 01-26-06 10:24 PM

i don't know how...but I didn't know that was that big of a spoiler...i can spoilerize it if someone tells me how

TimeandTide 01-26-06 10:32 PM


Originally Posted by JacksModernLife
i don't know how...but I didn't know that was that big of a spoiler...i can spoilerize it if someone tells me how

Just type [ spoiler ] before the text you want to hide, and then [ /spoiler ] afterwards. (Without the extra spaces in the brackets, of course.)

JacksModernLife 01-26-06 10:58 PM

thanks!

Iron_Giant 01-26-06 11:24 PM


Originally Posted by SMB-IL
You should have seen it in HD -- they got a close-up on her and my head actually whipped back! It scared me! -eek-

Sad to say, but my whole family noticed it at the same time.

Iron_Giant 01-26-06 11:30 PM


Originally Posted by Joeboo835
It'll come down to Paris and picklee (pickler?). Paris has the best voice and PIcklee has the story and looks (although I think Paris isn't ugly by any means). Should be interesting.

Agreed with what you said, the 2 P's are leading the pack by a mile.

I have saving most of the AI to my pc through HD, I am bummed, I think I must have forgotten to turn back on the recording after a commercial - so I missed recording Paris.

Groucho 01-26-06 11:32 PM


Originally Posted by JacksModernLife
people on other forums are saying that
Spoiler:
Kelly P and Paris
definitely make it to the top 12.

Impossible to know for sure since the final 12 isn't picked yet, and relies on audience voting.

However, it's a pretty safe assumption.

Patman 01-26-06 11:43 PM


Originally Posted by hahn
Surprised that no one has mentioned Katharine McPhee. She was the one with a mother who is a vocal teacher. I think her training shows in that she may have the widest vocal range of any of the contestants and just amazing control. However, there was something in her voice that was just SLIGHTLY off last night, though it may have just been the nerves. I think the high notes got a little too screechy for my tastes. But the judges didn't seem to notice. All 3 of them absolutely loved her. The potential for greatness is there, plus, she also has the looks to pull it off.

Proof positive that no one reads my posts. :D

JacksModernLife 01-26-06 11:58 PM


Originally Posted by Groucho
Impossible to know for sure since the final 12 isn't picked yet, and relies on audience voting.

However, it's a pretty safe assumption.

maybe its the top 16 girls then???

Deftones 01-27-06 12:41 AM


Originally Posted by SMB-IL
You should have seen it in HD -- they got a close-up on her and my head actually whipped back! It scared me! -eek-

I had to switch AI to my SD Tivo due to scheduling conflicts, but after last night, I'm glad I did! -eek-

xx2000xx 01-27-06 01:32 AM


Originally Posted by Iron_Giant
Agreed with what you said, the 2 P's are leading the pack by a mile.

I have saving most of the AI to my pc through HD, I am bummed, I think I must have forgotten to turn back on the recording after a commercial - so I missed recording Paris.

Here you go, this is the Paris audition video.

http://s43.yousendit.com/d.aspx?id=2...A16WWB2OCR5F12

She is amazing. If she has some decent charisma, she'll win for sure.

Gil Jawetz 01-27-06 07:48 AM

Are these in the correct order? Did they really think that the vocal-coach-mom girl has a better voice than Paris? I mean, she was good, but was she really THAT good?

taa455 01-27-06 08:03 AM

Paris is by no means winning "for sure". Her voice is kind of squeaky sometimes. But she is good and has amazing potential.

Heat 01-27-06 09:36 AM

Paris was a good singer, but I'm not sold on the idea that she's the best we've seen so far plus remember the auditions still have three more cities.

And her speaking voice was, well, different.

We'll be seeing a lot more of her (Paris), so I'll have plenty of time to form a better opinion, one way or the other.

And I hope that they have it again where the final 12 are 6 guys and 6 girls. Let's face it, out of what they've shown, the girls are dominating.

Groucho 01-27-06 09:46 AM


Originally Posted by Heat
And I hope that they have it again where the final 12 are 6 guys and 6 girls.

I agree. I was against the format when they introduced it last season, but in the end I thought it ended up really well.

big whoppa 01-27-06 01:12 PM

I haven't heard any outstanding voices. At best, some of them are just good. Outside of AI, none of them would likely get a second look.

OsageOne 01-27-06 02:54 PM


Originally Posted by hahn
Surprised that no one has mentioned Katharine McPhee. She was the one with a mother who is a vocal teacher. I think her training shows in that she may have the widest vocal range of any of the contestants and just amazing control. However, there was something in her voice that was just SLIGHTLY off last night, though it may have just been the nerves. I think the high notes got a little too screechy for my tastes. But the judges didn't seem to notice. All 3 of them absolutely loved her. The potential for greatness is there, plus, she also has the looks to pull it off.

I did NOT get a chance to look at AI the other night. Can anyone provide a link to Katharine McPhee's audition video?

Dr. Henry Jones, Jr. 01-27-06 02:59 PM


Originally Posted by Heat

And I hope that they have it again where the final 12 are 6 guys and 6 girls. Let's face it, out of what they've shown, the girls are dominating.

If the girls are dominating, then wouldn't the 6 guys and 6 girls format be one that isn't wanted? That would unnecessarily boot out more talented females earlier than deserved, if all the guys suck in comparison.

big whoppa 01-27-06 08:03 PM

For those who care. I didn't see or hear these guys.


Twin "Idol" Wannabes Booted

By Sarah Hall 1 hour, 58 minutes ago

Fox has dashed Terrell and Derrell Brittenum's dreams of becoming the next American Idols.
ADVERTISEMENT

The 28-year-old identical twin brothers were "uninvited" from the competition after their criminal records became public fodder, their lawyer said.

"It was an amicable breakup," attorney Maurice Bennett said on an Atlanta radio station. "The guys understood why. It's amazing how these things work."

The Brittenums made their mark on American Idol during the first episode of the fifth season, when they wowed the judges at the Chicago auditions and earned passes to Hollywood.

But the Tennessee natives' brush with glory turned out to be short-lived, as the brothers soon landed behind bars on charges that they used another man's identity and financial information last June to purchase a 2005 Dodge Magnum in Atlanta. Both Brittenums refused extradition to Georgia, which led to additional charges against them.

Fox has remained mum on whether the brothers would be seen in future episodes of the talent search. However, the New York Post reports that the network put the kibosh on a planned live performance by the Brittenums Wednesday night on MSNBC's Scarborough County, indicating that they are probably still under contract.

According to Bennett, both brothers were released from jail on bond Sunday morning and were preparing to travel to Los Angeles for the next round of eliminations when they received word that their presence was no longer welcome.

Though the twins may have blown their shot at Idol worship, they reportedly have other opportunities to consider. Bennett claims to have been contacted by "several" record labels interested in signing the brothers.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 09:00 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.