DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   TV Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/tv-talk-14/)
-   -   American Idol - Final 6 - 04/26/05 (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/tv-talk/420102-american-idol-final-6-04-26-05-a.html)

Quake1028 04-27-05 09:05 PM

So who were the bottom 3?

CRM114 04-27-05 09:07 PM

Anthony
Constantine
Vonzell

twikoff 04-27-05 09:09 PM

allegations of an affair between an idol judge and a contestant.. (coming up next on my local news)

who was paula hitting it with??
william hung?

twikoff 04-27-05 09:13 PM

meh
its corey clark.. the one that was kicked off the show last year, when his criminal records were uncovered
he claims paula was sleeping with him and promising him millions towards his musical career.
so I assume its BS

Patman 04-27-05 09:15 PM

One of the changes AI could do is to actually reveal the weekly vote totals for each contestant. It's stupid that they do not release this information.

atlantamoi 04-27-05 09:16 PM


Originally Posted by ChrisHicks
I'm calling it now...Scott is going to win this thing. -ohbfrank-

The funny thing to me is... Scott is probably the ONLY person left that if I heard on the radio I wouldn't run to turn it off. He is not much to look at and he has pitch problems. Not much of a performer. But produce the guy in a studio and I'll take his voice over all of 'em. He's got that Paul Young sound and it's not that common. Even though I probably like all of the others better as far as personality goes, not one of them would I care one iota about hearing what they do after this show. Yeah, that includes Bo, but I've always disliked the Black Crowes, so there ya go.

twikoff 04-27-05 09:17 PM


Originally Posted by Patman
One of the changes AI could do is to actually reveal the weekly vote totals for each contestant. It's stupid that they do not release this information.

yea.. but that might discourage votes.. if someone wins by a HUGE landslide.. the people wont bother voting for that person the next week, because they will feel that person is safe

and if a person just barely scraps by.. more people will vote to try and pick them up

while some of this happens now... it would become MUCH more of a popularity contest than it already is.. because the singing would mean even less.

twikoff 04-27-05 09:19 PM


Originally Posted by twikoff
meh
its corey clark.. the one that was kicked off the show last year, when his criminal records were uncovered
he claims paula was sleeping with him and promising him millions towards his musical career.
so I assume its BS


oh yea.. the other part of the news report is that another network is going to do a behind the scenes look at AI...
I assume this is without FOX's approval.. I wonder what kindof dirt they are going to uncover!

Goldberg74 04-27-05 09:24 PM

<center><img src="http://www.dvdtalk.com/forum/images/smilies/jawdrop.gif" width="75" height="500">&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;<img src="http://www.dvdtalk.com/forum/images/smilies/jawdrop.gif" width="75" height="500">&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;<img src="http://www.dvdtalk.com/forum/images/smilies/jawdrop.gif" width="75" height="500">&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;<img src="http://www.dvdtalk.com/forum/images/smilies/jawdrop.gif" width="75" height="500"></center>

SBrooks1 04-27-05 09:24 PM

Mark my words, if Scott wins this thing he will end up being another Fat Joe rapper. Scott is a wigger and will end up with a rap/hip hop career after this is over. If you actually think he will continue crooning these pop/slow songs after this competition is over, you're insane. He had Method Man from the Wu-Tang Clan (my fav rap group of all time) in the audience last night. That should tell you something right there. Don't get me wrong, he's got a decent voice but I DO NOT want to hear him after this is over. I just know he'll end up in some horrible hip-pop song that will be remixed 10x after it's released. Ugh.....I think I just threw up in my mouth a little.

beencrazier 04-27-05 09:26 PM

I wasn't expecting that

D300 04-27-05 09:30 PM


Originally Posted by twikoff
oh yea.. the other part of the news report is that another network is going to do a behind the scenes look at AI...
I assume this is without FOX's approval.. I wonder what kindof dirt they are going to uncover!

That's going to be on ABC's Primetime Live on May 4th.

Goldberg74 04-27-05 09:33 PM

Ladies and gentlemen, the next American Idol...

http://www.aamericanidol.com/wp-content/scott.jpg

... and for a little light reading:


Staying power
How does Scott Savol keep his spot each week on ‘American Idol’?
Scott Savol must have some loyal fans out there. Who are you people?

COMMENTARY
By Craig Berman
MSNBC contributor
Updated: 4:14 p.m. ET April 21, 2005


There are two inexplicable events that have occurred to people involved in "American Idol" this season. The first is Ryan Seacrest's getting a star on the Hollywood Walk of Fame. The second is the staying power of Scott Savol, who has more lives than Wile E. Coyote.

Seacrest, at least, earned his star through his radio work and not his gig as the "Idol" host — his honor is due to work not associated with the show. Savol's success is even tougher to figure. Every week he's in serious trouble on Tuesday night, every Wednesday he's in the bottom three … and every week he manages to survive.

This week was no exception. Once again, Savol was among the lower trio, along with Anthony Fedorov and Anwar Robinson. And once again, Savol got to make the hurried walk back to safety as Robinson became the sixth finalist to be sent packing.

Robinson's ouster wasn't too much of a shock. He's consistently won praise for his vocals, and Paula Abdul and Randy Jackson have called him "technically" the best singer in the competition. But for some reason he never really connected with the audience, and it's seemed for weeks like it was only a matter of time before he faded away.

He was arguably the most composed of the singers eliminated thus far, accepting his fate with his trademark smile and a final Earth, Wind & Fire tune. Savol gets to continue his personal rendition of Flirting With Disaster for another week.

Read the rest of this said long article... click here.

Heat 04-27-05 09:45 PM

Hey, I voted for Scott this week on the phone - ten times.

As for Constantine, that was a total shock to me, I was expecting him to be in the final two, losing to Carrie. Looks like a Bo / Carrie matchup now.

paulringodaman 04-27-05 09:46 PM

The only reason Scott is in: Nothing good has come out of Cleveland and people are voting just to get us in the spotlight.

SMB-IL 04-27-05 09:47 PM


Originally Posted by twikoff
...scott and anthony will be gone in the next 2 weeks...

Yeah, how many weeks have people written this?

Pharoh 04-27-05 09:47 PM


Originally Posted by CRM114
And Scott lives on. For two reasons: people feel sorry for him and he can actually sing. I don't know about tone deaf but it seems like he stays on key to me. :shrug: And I don't even like that kind of music...

Anthony should be going home although Constantine wasn't THAT much better...



I want to like Scott, I really do. Not only because he is from my area of the world, but also because in the begining I had pegged him as having one of the best voices. However, as of late he has been one of the weaker performers, and last night he was terrible. He should not be in the top three.

I think/fear that Vonzell is going home next. While I don't think she deserves to win, she definitely belongs in the top three. (I also agree with how beautiful she looks.) Methinks Scott will take her place in that top three, along with the golden children Bo and Carrie.

At least I was one of the few who got the vote right this time.
:banana:

SMB-IL 04-27-05 09:48 PM


Originally Posted by paulringodaman
The only reason Scott is in: Nothing good has come out of Cleveland and people are voting just to get us in the spotlight.

You have the Rock n Roll Hall of Fame.

A place that Scott will only visit.

Groucho 04-27-05 09:56 PM

Constantine made a risky move by abandoning his loyal fan base in order to go after Bo's market share. But he's no "rocker," he's a poser. Those ridiculous kicks said it all.

twikoff 04-27-05 09:56 PM


Originally Posted by SMB-IL
Yeah, how many weeks have people written this?

but most people also had an asterick saying that constantine deserved to go MUCH more, we just didnt think it would happen yet

Josh-da-man 04-27-05 10:02 PM

So... will Constantine being voted out strengthen Bo? I could see some of his fans moving over to Bo.

Still can't believe Constantine went before Scott. Christ on a badger, he looks like something Legolas would shoot full of arrows.

Goldberg74 04-27-05 10:08 PM


Originally Posted by Josh-da-man
Still can't believe Constantine went before Scott. Christ on a badger, he looks like something Legolas would shoot full of arrows.

rotfl

Jray 04-27-05 10:15 PM

Paula was SOOOOOO over the top tonight. I cracked up when her face started contorting... when they showed her all teary-faced I completely lost it. That is so unbelievably outrageous. Balling like her kid had lost or something. And then hugging Constantine's mom?!?! Are you freaking kidding me?!?!

The faces of the other contestants when they announced it was priceless! I rewound the DVR and paused it to see Scott and Carrie both go :jawdrop:.

While I agree that Scott probably won't make it much further, I still continue to be dumbfounded by the people that hate on him for no reason other than they can. He probably looks better than half the people that make fun of him and he sure as hell can sing better than any of them.

BlackCapTen 04-27-05 10:21 PM

I thought Paula was going to make out with Constantine's mom.

I was pretty surprised at the result, but I can see him (with or without his band) putting out an album and doing well. I wonder if he's still contracted with Idol even though he's eliminated..?

Patman 04-27-05 10:22 PM

Connie's band released their CD with William Hung's label. :D


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 07:27 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.