Lost -- "Do No Harm" -- 04.06.2005
#151
Senior Member
Joined: Feb 2003
Posts: 630
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Texas
I'm surprised no flight attendants have surfaced yet. We had the pilot early on but still no flight attendants. That would seem like a natural person to explore for a main character.
#152
Retired
Originally Posted by Red Dog
My opinion of the carbon blobs usually isn't high
, but I would just figure personal information like this would be natural to know. Who knows - maybe me knowing mine for 25+ years is because my father was a doctor.
, but I would just figure personal information like this would be natural to know. Who knows - maybe me knowing mine for 25+ years is because my father was a doctor.And most people don't care enough to hassle as we just foolishly assume (hope) we'll never need to know.

Or that are fortunately extremely healthy like me and avoid doctors and needles as much as possible.
#153
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Joined: Oct 1999
Posts: 8,527
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Portland, OR
Originally Posted by brizz
She blew a tire. And i'm almost positive that Locke has admitted taht he'd been in the chair for four years prior to the crash. Not sure that would jive.
Spoiler:
#154
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Originally Posted by sabre
I thought Boone was an interesting character, one of the most complicated characters on the whole island. Smart to pair up with locke to find out how to survive on the island. Killing him off killed me on the show. I'm done with it. The show is not going anywhere, literally and figuratively. I know the rest of you will yell at me now but eventually you'll see it too. This shows rating are going to die in it's second season. Like i said i'm done with it. I hope smallville comes back on the air with new episodes.
Also, I think it's a bit presumptive to assume that your way of thinking is the right one, and we are all waiting to overcome our collective brainwashing.
#155
DVD Talk Limited Edition
I'm not as done as sabre but my patience is wearing thin. The article I read a few months ago with David Fury said that ABC Wanted to string it out and I think that's going to be the shows undoing. Maybe that's why he decided to leave. I can't quote him but he said something along the lines of how long are people going to hang in there if they aren't getting answers.
Last night we got more questions and nothing answered as usual.
Sorry to see Boone go. I am going to miss those eyes.
Last night we got more questions and nothing answered as usual.
Sorry to see Boone go. I am going to miss those eyes.
#156
Retired
I agree. If I stop watching it will be because it's too drug out.
I mean it's been a couple months since they first found that hatch, and they've still shown us nothing about what's in it. Same with other mysteries.
I mean it's been a couple months since they first found that hatch, and they've still shown us nothing about what's in it. Same with other mysteries.
#157
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Question, where is the African American Woman that talked to Charlie a few times at the beginning of the season? You never see her which seems a bit odd to me.
#158
DVD Talk Special Edition
Joined: Jul 2001
Posts: 1,831
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Honolulu, Hawaii
Originally Posted by Josh-da-man
About what was seen in the preview... just because something was shown doesn't mean it will actually occur on the island. It could be part of a dream or vision. In fact, I'd count on it. When they show you something "shocking" in the previews, it's seldom what it appears to be.
#159
DVD Talk Legend
Originally Posted by riley_dude
Question, where is the African American Woman that talked to Charlie a few times at the beginning of the season? You never see her which seems a bit odd to me.
#160
DVD Talk Legend
Joined: Jul 2000
Posts: 20,195
Likes: 0
Received 7 Likes
on
7 Posts
From: Sesame Street (the apt. next to Bob's)
Originally Posted by 12thmonkey
I got a different meaning from the article. I took it to mean the writers had (for better or worse) leaked that a main character was going to die, and the fakeouts with Charlie and Shannon were simply precursors to actually killing off a principal, in this case: Boone.
#162
Member
Joined: Apr 2004
Posts: 106
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Salt Lake City
Originally Posted by treszoks
I'm surprised no flight attendants have surfaced yet. We had the pilot early on but still no flight attendants. That would seem like a natural person to explore for a main character.
#163
Banned
Joined: Oct 2004
Posts: 2,249
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Sand Point
So will Abrahms put Somerhalder on Alias next season to make up for this? 
Or stick him in Mission: Impossible 3?
Buh bye.

Or stick him in Mission: Impossible 3?
Originally Posted by sabre
I thought Boone was an interesting character, one of the most complicated characters on the whole island. Smart to pair up with locke to find out how to survive on the island. Killing him off killed me on the show. I'm done with it. The show is not going anywhere, literally and figuratively. I know the rest of you will yell at me now but eventually you'll see it too. This shows rating are going to die in it's second season. Like i said i'm done with it. I hope smallville comes back on the air with new episodes.
Last edited by Legolas; 04-07-05 at 05:15 PM.
#164
Member
Joined: Apr 2001
Posts: 174
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: TX
Originally Posted by Legolas
So will Abrahms put Somerhalder on Alias next season to make up for this? 

#165
Member
Joined: Oct 2001
Posts: 162
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I'm surprised no flight attendants have surfaced yet. We had the pilot early on but still no flight attendants.
#166
Member
Joined: Mar 2005
Posts: 76
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by Maquis
Correct me if I'm wrong, but didn't Jack's wife say that she caused the accident? Did she say she fell asleep at the wheel? I do remember her say that she flipped and crossed the median, smashing into oncoming traffic...
If the accident tied in, I would say she smashed into Locke's car, putting him into a wheelchair.
If the accident tied in, I would say she smashed into Locke's car, putting him into a wheelchair.
#167
DVD Talk Godfather
Originally Posted by riley_dude
I'm not as done as sabre but my patience is wearing thin. The article I read a few months ago with David Fury said that ABC Wanted to string it out and I think that's going to be the shows undoing. Maybe that's why he decided to leave. I can't quote him but he said something along the lines of how long are people going to hang in there if they aren't getting answers.
Last night we got more questions and nothing answered as usual.
Last night we got more questions and nothing answered as usual.
I HAVE TO HAVE ANSWERS NOW OR I"M NOT WATCHING ANYMORE. Boo hoo.
I look at it like the X-files, you have your mythology episodes and sprinkled in with those you have your stand-alone episodes. All are entertaining in their own way. Some people will be fans of the sci-fi/story-arc aspect and others will be entertained by the great character piece they are building. And some will love both.
#168
DVD Talk Legend
Originally Posted by LorenzoL
Similar to what they do in the reality shows series, is going to be "recap" show concentrating on the major characters, the "mysteries" surrounding the island and the relationships with each other and the island.
#169
DVD Talk Legend
Originally Posted by sabre
I thought Boone was an interesting character, one of the most complicated characters on the whole island. Smart to pair up with locke to find out how to survive on the island. Killing him off killed me on the show. I'm done with it. The show is not going anywhere, literally and figuratively. I know the rest of you will yell at me now but eventually you'll see it too. This shows rating are going to die in it's second season. Like i said i'm done with it. I hope smallville comes back on the air with new episodes.
#171
Retired
Originally Posted by Michael Corvin
I don't need answers every week.
I mean we're like 20 episodes in and they've pretty much answered nothing. No idea what the thing is in the jungle. No idea why Locke can walk after crash. No idea whats in the hatch. No idea where Ethan came from. And so on.
I think people are afraid it will end up like the X-files where nothing major every truly gets answered.
#172
DVD Talk Hero
Originally Posted by Josh Hinkle
I don't think anyone wants answers every week. Just some everyonce in a while.
I mean we're like 20 episodes in and they've pretty much answered nothing. No idea what the thing is in the jungle. No idea why Locke can walk after crash. No idea whats in the hatch. No idea where Ethan came from. And so on.
I think people are afraid it will end up like the X-files where nothing major every truly gets answered.
I mean we're like 20 episodes in and they've pretty much answered nothing. No idea what the thing is in the jungle. No idea why Locke can walk after crash. No idea whats in the hatch. No idea where Ethan came from. And so on.
I think people are afraid it will end up like the X-files where nothing major every truly gets answered.
I haven't yet gotten that feeling from "Lost" yet. I won't be able to judge until I see the season finale.
The problem with a series like "Lost" or "X-Files" that 1) relies on secrets and mysteries, and 2) is a monster hit, is that the studios see a formula that they want to milk as long as possible. So when you start solving the mysteries, you lose the show's hook. But at the same time, you run the risk of convoluting the show's mythology and running it into the ground without resolving anything. X-Files again.
"Lost" is a limited concept for a show. They're only going to be able to take it so far. There's a lot they can do within that framework, but at some point, the mysteries will have to be solved and the show will have to end. I should that ABC is smart enough to let the storyline run its natural course, and that four or five "tight" seasons of the show would be preferable to six or seven that just drag on and on until the audience is depleted and the series is inceremoniously cancelled.
#173
DVD Talk Special Edition
Joined: Apr 2000
Posts: 1,181
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Pataskala, OH
Originally Posted by Groucho
I don't watch the previews or read spoilers, but as soon as they showed Claire going into labor, I knew Boone was dead. It's the oldest cliché in the book. I can just imagine the writers patting themselves on the back over the whole "Juxtaposition of Life and Death" thing, when in reality this sort of thing is Fiction 101. Yawn, very predictable.
There was another possible element, conception (Sayid and Shannon). Assuming sex really happened, as I'm guessing it did...
Don't know my blood type.
#174
DVD Talk Legend
I am strongly in the this is the x-files on an island camp there are so many unanswered questions, that if it was me on the island I'd be figuring out.
1st thing I would do is walk the island, around the outside, take about 3 or 4 people and check it out. Start getting out there and seeing stuff. Too much nothing happening, no way if I was stranded on an island I would not have covered as much as I could by end of week 1.
Its week 4+ and no-one has walked all the way around? and by the looks of it Lockes treks into the island are all of 2 minutes with the speed that people run from one place to the next.
1st thing I would do is walk the island, around the outside, take about 3 or 4 people and check it out. Start getting out there and seeing stuff. Too much nothing happening, no way if I was stranded on an island I would not have covered as much as I could by end of week 1.
Its week 4+ and no-one has walked all the way around? and by the looks of it Lockes treks into the island are all of 2 minutes with the speed that people run from one place to the next.
#175
Senior Member
Joined: Aug 1999
Posts: 792
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: South Shore Massachusetts
I'm really surprised there was is so much confusion in this thread about the number of survivors. The whole reason we know there was 48 was through dialogue in the first episode.... when Jack&Kate&Charlie find the cockpit, the pilot asks Jack how many survivors and Jack tells the pilot there was 48 survivors.
Then the marshall died leaving 47
Then the lady died swimming leaving 46
Then Ethan killed Scott or Steve leaving 45
Then Boone dying left 44
Claire's baby being born doesn't count as a "survivor", there are still 44 original "survivors".
Then the marshall died leaving 47
Then the lady died swimming leaving 46
Then Ethan killed Scott or Steve leaving 45
Then Boone dying left 44
Claire's baby being born doesn't count as a "survivor", there are still 44 original "survivors".



