DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   TV Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/tv-talk-14/)
-   -   Lost - 09/29/04 (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/tv-talk/388050-lost-09-29-04-a.html)

B.A. 09-30-04 08:30 AM


Originally posted by Hiro11
Can someone give me a somewhat detailed synopsis of what happened? (maybe in spoiler tags) I had to work late yesterday and missed this show.
watch it Saturday night.

Geofferson 09-30-04 08:32 AM

Great episode last night.

A damn polar bear?!? :hscratch:

cdoug57 09-30-04 08:40 AM

Just another voice here for a great episode.

Really enjoyed the shot of Kate on the beach. More, more.

What else can the doc do? How long before he delivers the baby? Will the marshall live? What did Kate do? Almost as many questions as there were at the end of Soap.

Good stuff.

Meatpants 09-30-04 09:01 AM

My guess, re: Kate, is that it will either be a "in self-defense murder" or a Shawshank Redemption-type thing. Obviously she's not going to be "bad", so defending herself against an abusive boyfriend or something along those lines would work.

Cusm 09-30-04 09:02 AM

I think that Lange knows something about the island.
It was a horrible idea to split this into 2 episodes, it completely screwed up the flow of the show and left you guessing at stuff that should have been answered in a pilot, you can tell that a genius network exec made this decision.
The thing about the polar bear is that it is an exclusive carnivore. It would need to eat some big prey, and so far they have not showed any signs of a food source. Of course where there is one, there are more, but I do not think this could possibly have been what got the pilot or knocked down the trees.

renaldow 09-30-04 09:02 AM

The polar bear: It was in the comic book that the boy was looking at earlier in the episode.

The island: It is going to be like the planet in Star Trek that creates fantasies around your thoughts. It created the nightmare creature from the collective unconscious of the castaways fear, and the polar bear for the little boy. Wouldn't surprise me if his dog was what it really was or used to be.

The little boy: Will save them all by using what he finds in the comic book and the island's abilities.

Meatpants 09-30-04 09:08 AM


Originally posted by renaldow
The polar bear: It was in the comic book that the boy was looking at earlier in the episode.

The island: It is going to be like the planet in Star Trek that creates fantasies around your thoughts. It created the nightmare creature from the collective unconscious of the castaways fear, and the polar bear for the little boy. Wouldn't surprise me if his dog was what it really was or used to be.

The little boy: Will save them all by using what he finds in the comic book and the island's abilities.

Man, you just saved me a whole bunch of Wednesday nights. ;)

I thought JJ said there would be a scentifically plausible explanation? In either case, I will try to enjoy the ride as long as it lasts.

Back to Kate:

http://www.pix8.net/pro/pic/4499m90iG/126492.jpg

Chew 09-30-04 09:11 AM


Originally posted by Meatpants
I thought JJ said there would be a scentifically plausible explanation?
Yes, he did. No dinosaurs and no alternate earth.


Originally posted by Meatpants
Back to Kate:


:drool:

rfduncan 09-30-04 09:12 AM


Originally posted by renaldow
The little boy: Will save them all by using what he finds in the comic book and the island's abilities.
Remember this is a series and not a single episode of Star Trek. Abrams has said there is little to no sci-fi aspect to the show.

Also regarding time passage, the baby may not be born until the end of the season. I have read in various articles that the passage of time can be as little as half a day per episode. The two-hour pilot only covers how much time? A day and a night? The only passive time reference (i.e. without seeing days into nights or someone counting the days and saying "we've been here X weeks") we have is the fat guy getting skinnier and the pregnant woman giving birth.

Chew 09-30-04 09:15 AM


Originally posted by rfduncan
Abrams has said there is little to no sci-fi aspect to the show.

I think we need to make this point a Lost sticky. ;)

dom56 09-30-04 09:33 AM

Merry is a
Spoiler:
junkie
-eek-

B.A. 09-30-04 09:35 AM


Originally posted by renaldow
The polar bear: It was in the comic book that the boy was looking at earlier in the episode.
My brother-in-law pointed that out to me this morning.

I think I will re-watch it Saturday (if I have time) and see if I missed anything else.

Dr. DVD 09-30-04 09:37 AM

What's wrong with a Polar Bear?

Private Joke: "They're the most vicious killers in the animal kingdom."

renaldow 09-30-04 09:50 AM


Originally posted by rfduncan
Remember this is a series and not a single episode of Star Trek. Abrams has said there is little to no sci-fi aspect to the show.

'Little to no' means there is some.

Meatpants 09-30-04 09:53 AM


Originally posted by renaldow
'Little to no' means there is some.
I think being in an alternate universe would qualify as "a lot" ;)

Decker 09-30-04 09:58 AM

Great show. I'm hooked already.
Doesn't somebody on that island want to build a shelter yet? Everyone's going to get sunburned pretty soon.

maxpower 09-30-04 09:59 AM

Here's a little recap/review from AICN

http://www.aint-it-cool-news.com/display.cgi?id=18525

Apparently this "2 hour" pilot is a mere 83 minutes long.

I just caught the last 30 minutes ...so when I heard they would run both eps on saturday..I thought great, now I can catch up. But good lord...37 minutes of commercials!?!.. I will make sure to change the station and make good use of PIP. I know it will not make a difference but ....if 30 min eps have 6 mins of commercials then ABC is putting in an additional 14 minutes!

Deftones 09-30-04 10:12 AM


Originally posted by maxpower
Here's a little recap/review from AICN

http://www.aint-it-cool-news.com/display.cgi?id=18525

Apparently this "2 hour" pilot is a mere 83 minutes long.

I just caught the last 30 minutes ...so when I heard they would run both eps on saturday..I thought great, now I can catch up. But good lord...37 minutes of commercials!?!.. I will make sure to change the station and make good use of PIP. I know it will not make a difference but ....if 30 min eps have 6 mins of commercials then ABC is putting in an additional 14 minutes!

Acutally, most one hour shows are about 45 minutes long sans commercials, so it's not like it was a ton less of show.

tofu 09-30-04 10:21 AM

I'm so addicted to this show. Darn you JJ Abrams. I like how we get to see a little bit of what each person was like on the plane.

Why didn't they try and bring the bear back to camp (although it would be tough)? Polar bear would be some good eating.

I gonna hypothesize that
Spoiler:
they're on some top secret animal genetics testing facility or they were trying to build a zoo there. Pretty soon, we'll see a crazy elephant. That's not too sci fi right?

Verbal Gorilla 09-30-04 10:30 AM


Originally posted by Feneant
More than caracter development- something most don't mention here, is that the message has been playing for 16 years and they ask 'where are we?'. It's impossible for a message on Earth to played for 16 years without being picked up so to me, it's as if they ended up either in another era or another planet.
That is a total underestimation of the size of earth. There are still 10 of thousands of islands that man has not stepped foot on yet, not to mention vast stretches of places like Antartica or the Amazon or the Sahara. Also keep in mind that it is greatly dependent on the strenght of the signal. What if extends for only 1-2 miles. Do you really think it is impossible for a place on earth to exist that someone hasn't passed within 2 miles from with radio equipment that is turned on and tuned to the right frequency for 16 years?

But no one has mentioned the most obvious impossibility.....They took down a freakin polar bear with a tiny handgun!!!

Groucho 09-30-04 10:46 AM

Those who said that splitting the pilot episode in two was a big mistake weren't kidding! My wife hated last week's episode. I really had to beg and plead to get her to watch again this week. After seeing the entire two hours, she's excited about the show, and can't wait until next week.

You've gotta wonder how many people were turned off by the incomplete first episode, and won't return.

As soon as the kid found the handcuffs I knew that the "least likely" person would turn out to be the prisoner: Kate. My prediction was correct. The sixteen years thing gave me chills.

Also, can we please not turn this thread into the "Mature Forum"?

Shannon Nutt 09-30-04 10:49 AM


Originally posted by Dr. DVD
What's wrong with a Polar Bear?

Private Joke: "They're the most vicious killers in the animal kingdom."

If this was a Jon Peters produced show, it would have been a giant spider -wink-

Josh H 09-30-04 10:50 AM

Another great episode, shaping up to be a great series. Way too many commercials though, seems like way more than during most hour long shows.

Michael Corvin 09-30-04 10:55 AM


Originally posted by Groucho


Also, can we please not turn this thread into the "Mature Forum"?

Wha? I enjoyed the pics. If it is on during family hour than it isn't all that mature is it? lol.

Anyway. Wow! This is gonna be like 24, much better on dvd where you can watch 3-4 ep. at a time. I'm hooked.

Meatpants 09-30-04 10:59 AM


Originally posted by Groucho
Also, can we please not turn this thread into the "Mature Forum"?
I thought about that before I posted the pic, but give me a break, it was on at 7:15 pm.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 09:55 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.