Roger Waters' Dark Side of the Moon
02-09-23, 09:05 AM
#1
DVD Talk Legend
Thread Starter
Join Date: Aug 2001
Location: Just around the corner to the light of day.
Posts: 16,010
Received 1,057 Likes
on
660 Posts
Roger Waters' Dark Side of the Moon
Roger Waters Says He’s Re-Recording ‘The Dark Side of the Moon’ — Without Pink Floyd (msn.com)
Roger Waters said he has been re-recording the 1973 album The Dark Side of the Moon “[because] not enough people recognised what it’s about, what it was I was saying then,” according to an interview with The Telegraph journalist Tristram Fane Saunders.
In the profile, Waters claimed he’s been working on the new version for months, and that he’s been doing it from scratch—without the help or knowledge of Pink Floyd members David Gilmour and Nick Mason.
Besides Waters, the only collaborators on the new album are reportedly Waters’ longtime collaborator and multi-instrumentalist Gus Seyffert, a “Baptist minister” who plays a Hammond organ, and Seyffert’s girlfriend, the singer Bedouine. Waters is said to play a bass solo on “Us and Them,” and reportedly adds his own vocals over the original album’s instrumentals, including a “prose poem over ‘On The Run.’”
Saunders, who claims he is only one of “handful” of people who have listened to the solo album “from start-to-finish,” described parts of the re-recording as “very good.” In particular, Saunders touts “Time” as “terrific with his old man’s timbre” and the “Money” as a “country-tinged” cut reminiscent of “late Johnny Cash.”
The Pink Floyd founder is reportedly planning a big release, which might be complicated seeing as Gilmour and Mason still own the band’s name. Gilmour, who has been in a decades-long feud with Waters, has been critical of his former bandmate. On Monday, he reposted a tweet by his wife Polly Samson — who wrote several of the band’s tracks — that denounced Waters’ support of Russia.
“Sadly @rogerwaters you are antisemitic to your rotten core,” wrote Samson on Twitter. “Also a Putin apologist and a lying, thieving, hypocritical, tax-avoiding, lip-synching, misogynistic, sick-with-envy, megalomaniac. Enough of your nonsense.” Gilmour retweeted the post, and in a show of support, wrote, “Every word demonstrably true.”
Representatives for Roger Waters did not immediately return Rolling Stone’s request for comment.
Over the past six months, Waters has also used his platform as a sounding board for controversial political takes. On Wednesday, Waters spoke at the United Nations Security Council meeting and condemned Russia’s invasion of Ukraine as “illegal,” but also said it was “not unprovoked.”
His remarks on the war in Ukraine were more subdued than some of the others Waters has made in the past, including in an interview with Rolling Stone. Last year, Waters claimed his name is on a “kill list that is supported by the Ukrainian government.” In that same conversation, the singer shifted the blame from the ongoing war from Russia to NATO, suggesting that the organization essentially left Putin with no other choice but to invade Ukraine.
When contemplating Dark Side, Waters seemed dismissive of his former bandmates, whom he called “Faux Floyd” “I wrote The Dark Side of the Moon. Let’s get rid of all this ‘we’ c–p!,” he told The Telegraph. “Of course we were a band, there were four of us, we all contributed – but it’s my project and I wrote it. So… blah!”
Roger Waters said he has been re-recording the 1973 album The Dark Side of the Moon “[because] not enough people recognised what it’s about, what it was I was saying then,” according to an interview with The Telegraph journalist Tristram Fane Saunders.
In the profile, Waters claimed he’s been working on the new version for months, and that he’s been doing it from scratch—without the help or knowledge of Pink Floyd members David Gilmour and Nick Mason.
Besides Waters, the only collaborators on the new album are reportedly Waters’ longtime collaborator and multi-instrumentalist Gus Seyffert, a “Baptist minister” who plays a Hammond organ, and Seyffert’s girlfriend, the singer Bedouine. Waters is said to play a bass solo on “Us and Them,” and reportedly adds his own vocals over the original album’s instrumentals, including a “prose poem over ‘On The Run.’”
Saunders, who claims he is only one of “handful” of people who have listened to the solo album “from start-to-finish,” described parts of the re-recording as “very good.” In particular, Saunders touts “Time” as “terrific with his old man’s timbre” and the “Money” as a “country-tinged” cut reminiscent of “late Johnny Cash.”
The Pink Floyd founder is reportedly planning a big release, which might be complicated seeing as Gilmour and Mason still own the band’s name. Gilmour, who has been in a decades-long feud with Waters, has been critical of his former bandmate. On Monday, he reposted a tweet by his wife Polly Samson — who wrote several of the band’s tracks — that denounced Waters’ support of Russia.
“Sadly @rogerwaters you are antisemitic to your rotten core,” wrote Samson on Twitter. “Also a Putin apologist and a lying, thieving, hypocritical, tax-avoiding, lip-synching, misogynistic, sick-with-envy, megalomaniac. Enough of your nonsense.” Gilmour retweeted the post, and in a show of support, wrote, “Every word demonstrably true.”
Representatives for Roger Waters did not immediately return Rolling Stone’s request for comment.
Over the past six months, Waters has also used his platform as a sounding board for controversial political takes. On Wednesday, Waters spoke at the United Nations Security Council meeting and condemned Russia’s invasion of Ukraine as “illegal,” but also said it was “not unprovoked.”
His remarks on the war in Ukraine were more subdued than some of the others Waters has made in the past, including in an interview with Rolling Stone. Last year, Waters claimed his name is on a “kill list that is supported by the Ukrainian government.” In that same conversation, the singer shifted the blame from the ongoing war from Russia to NATO, suggesting that the organization essentially left Putin with no other choice but to invade Ukraine.
When contemplating Dark Side, Waters seemed dismissive of his former bandmates, whom he called “Faux Floyd” “I wrote The Dark Side of the Moon. Let’s get rid of all this ‘we’ c–p!,” he told The Telegraph. “Of course we were a band, there were four of us, we all contributed – but it’s my project and I wrote it. So… blah!”
The following 2 users liked this post by Maxflier:
John Pannozzi (03-07-23),
tommyp007 (02-09-23)
02-09-23, 09:35 AM
#3
Moderator
Re: Roger Waters' Dark Side of the Moon
I do think it would be interesting to hear David Gilmour sing "Time" now that 50 years have passed. It's amazing the feelings I have listening to that song now compared to when I was a teenager. Otherwise, that's my level of interest in something like this.
02-09-23, 09:41 AM
#4
DVD Talk Legend
Thread Starter
Join Date: Aug 2001
Location: Just around the corner to the light of day.
Posts: 16,010
Received 1,057 Likes
on
660 Posts
Re: Roger Waters' Dark Side of the Moon
But you can hear him singing it from recordings online from his tour in 2016.
The following users liked this post:
Toby Dramit (02-09-23)
02-09-23, 11:09 AM
#5
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: Roger Waters' Dark Side of the Moon
I’m very conflicted on all this Floyd stuff from the last week but the strongest feeling is fuck David Gilmour who is grossly calling Waters antisemitic because Waters rightfully calls out the apartheid state in Israel.
He has every right to hate Roger Waters who by all accounts is a real asshole but labeling him anti semetic doesn’t just potentially hurt Roger Waters but is meant to make other people think twice before calling out a real injustice that’s going on.
Plus if Roger Waters is anti semetic what does it say about David Gilmour to have not brought it up for the ten plus years he worked with him or the 40 years since then ? And it’s not like they just worked together. I don’t know all of the political leanings and bigotries of the people i’ve worked with for years but they knew each other since they were kids. He played on a Roger Waters song sung from a fascists’ pov fantasizing about concentration camps. If that song is coming from someone you have ANY suspicions of harboring any anti semetic feelings and you don’t say a word about it AND put your name/bands name on the song too that’s not good.
Second strongest feeling is no one wants a Roger Waters reimagined version of Dark Side of the Moon. That’s not going to be good.
He has every right to hate Roger Waters who by all accounts is a real asshole but labeling him anti semetic doesn’t just potentially hurt Roger Waters but is meant to make other people think twice before calling out a real injustice that’s going on.
Plus if Roger Waters is anti semetic what does it say about David Gilmour to have not brought it up for the ten plus years he worked with him or the 40 years since then ? And it’s not like they just worked together. I don’t know all of the political leanings and bigotries of the people i’ve worked with for years but they knew each other since they were kids. He played on a Roger Waters song sung from a fascists’ pov fantasizing about concentration camps. If that song is coming from someone you have ANY suspicions of harboring any anti semetic feelings and you don’t say a word about it AND put your name/bands name on the song too that’s not good.
Second strongest feeling is no one wants a Roger Waters reimagined version of Dark Side of the Moon. That’s not going to be good.
02-09-23, 11:48 AM
#6
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Roger Waters' Dark Side of the Moon
Can't be any worse than the version mounted by the Flaming Lips.
I guess we'll have to wait for both Waters and Gilmour to pass before we get any further vault material. I've heard contrary to reports that pro-shot tour video and soundboards from their classic period do in fact exist.
I guess we'll have to wait for both Waters and Gilmour to pass before we get any further vault material. I've heard contrary to reports that pro-shot tour video and soundboards from their classic period do in fact exist.
02-09-23, 01:47 PM
#7
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
Re: Roger Waters' Dark Side of the Moon
Heh.
Will this be waters attempting to "re-write floyd history" ?
Will this be waters attempting to "re-write floyd history" ?
02-09-23, 02:01 PM
#8
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: Roger Waters' Dark Side of the Moon
Has Roger been looking at Taylor Swift? 
This is not that type of scenario.
This sounds bat shit crazy to even try and touch the album again. I would rank it in the top 10 or 20 all-time greatest albums.
This is not that type of scenario.This sounds bat shit crazy to even try and touch the album again. I would rank it in the top 10 or 20 all-time greatest albums.
The following users liked this post:
PhantomStranger (02-10-23)
02-09-23, 02:59 PM
#11
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Roger Waters' Dark Side of the Moon
Assuming it's ever released, I'll listen to it out of curiosity. I can't imagine that any aspect of it will be an improvement over the original. Considering it took 4 years to release the Animals remix over some liner notes, this one will probably be held up even longer. Unless complete re-recordings don't have to have any approvals from the rest of the contributors of the original album.
02-09-23, 06:09 PM
#12
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Roger Waters' Dark Side of the Moon
I’m very conflicted on all this Floyd stuff from the last week but the strongest feeling is fuck David Gilmour who is grossly calling Waters antisemitic because Waters rightfully calls out the apartheid state in Israel.
He has every right to hate Roger Waters who by all accounts is a real asshole but labeling him anti semetic doesn’t just potentially hurt Roger Waters but is meant to make other people think twice before calling out a real injustice that’s going on.
He has every right to hate Roger Waters who by all accounts is a real asshole but labeling him anti semetic doesn’t just potentially hurt Roger Waters but is meant to make other people think twice before calling out a real injustice that’s going on.
Neither do I, for that matter, save for some anecdotal observations which are barely more than rumors but with some degree of substantiation. And without a doubt, criticism of Israeli policy is not antisemitic. Anything beyond that, we know fuck-all. If Gilmour does or doesn't want to say more, for whatever reason, that's his business.
Back to the subject matter; Floyd is my #4 favorite band, Waters is an incredible artist, and I couldn't be less interested in this mess.
02-09-23, 06:37 PM
#13
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: Roger Waters' Dark Side of the Moon
I agree that we know fuck all about Roger Waters doing anything or saying anything anti semetic. Something tells me that those calling him out for being anti semetic would make it clear why they were doing so if there was anything there beyond criticizing the Israeli government. I mean it makes no sense not to explain it if he is anti semetic.
And yeah it’s true i don’t know Roger Waters but i do know he’s a well known asshole and i can’t see how there’s never been a report (that i’m aware of) of him being racist along with the complaints of his legendary assholery Again it makes no sense to me.
If there are reports of him behaving inappropriately I’m all ears. I don’t stalk him but have read a few books on him and floyd. Seen him live 4 times. Watched multiple interviews and it’s a new allegation as far as i know.
And yeah it’s true i don’t know Roger Waters but i do know he’s a well known asshole and i can’t see how there’s never been a report (that i’m aware of) of him being racist along with the complaints of his legendary assholery Again it makes no sense to me.
If there are reports of him behaving inappropriately I’m all ears. I don’t stalk him but have read a few books on him and floyd. Seen him live 4 times. Watched multiple interviews and it’s a new allegation as far as i know.
02-09-23, 06:48 PM
#14
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Roger Waters' Dark Side of the Moon
So does this mean Waters will stop milking The Wall and will spend the next 20+ years (or until her dies) milking DSOTM now?
02-09-23, 07:36 PM
#15
DVD Talk Godfather & 2020 TOTY Winner
Re: Roger Waters' Dark Side of the Moon
I agree that we know fuck all about Roger Waters doing anything or saying anything anti semetic. Something tells me that those calling him out for being anti semetic would make it clear why they were doing so if there was anything there beyond criticizing the Israeli government. I mean it makes no sense not to explain it if he is anti semetic.
He also apologized in 2020 for perpetuating anti-Semitic tropes regarding billionaire Sheldon Adelson
Former Pink Floyd frontman Roger Waters, a leading BDS campaignerMusician Roger Waters has apologised for “evoking an antisemitic trope” in relation to a Jewish billionaire and for suggesting that Israelis trained US police in restraint manoeuvres such as killed unarmed black man George Floyd.
Waters, who co-founded the band Pink Floyd, was quick to issue a lengthy apology for comments he made in an interview with the Middle East Media Research Institute earlier this week. He posted the apology on his website, titled ‘A note from Roger: Just to be clear.’
The star’s mea culpa referred to him calling wealthy casino owner and Republican donor Sheldon Adelson the “puppet master pulling the strings of [US president] Donald Trump, [US Secretary of State] Mike Pompeo, and what’s his name, the ambassador [to Israel, David Friedman].
Waters, who co-founded the band Pink Floyd, was quick to issue a lengthy apology for comments he made in an interview with the Middle East Media Research Institute earlier this week. He posted the apology on his website, titled ‘A note from Roger: Just to be clear.’
The star’s mea culpa referred to him calling wealthy casino owner and Republican donor Sheldon Adelson the “puppet master pulling the strings of [US president] Donald Trump, [US Secretary of State] Mike Pompeo, and what’s his name, the ambassador [to Israel, David Friedman].
02-09-23, 07:44 PM
#16
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Roger Waters' Dark Side of the Moon
I agree that we know fuck all about Roger Waters doing anything or saying anything anti semetic. Something tells me that those calling him out for being anti semetic would make it clear why they were doing so if there was anything there beyond criticizing the Israeli government. I mean it makes no sense not to explain it if he is anti semetic.
And yeah it’s true i don’t know Roger Waters but i do know he’s a well known asshole and i can’t see how there’s never been a report (that i’m aware of) of him being racist along with the complaints of his legendary assholery Again it makes no sense to me.
If there are reports of him behaving inappropriately I’m all ears. I don’t stalk him but have read a few books on him and floyd. Seen him live 4 times. Watched multiple interviews and it’s a new allegation as far as i know.
And yeah it’s true i don’t know Roger Waters but i do know he’s a well known asshole and i can’t see how there’s never been a report (that i’m aware of) of him being racist along with the complaints of his legendary assholery Again it makes no sense to me.
If there are reports of him behaving inappropriately I’m all ears. I don’t stalk him but have read a few books on him and floyd. Seen him live 4 times. Watched multiple interviews and it’s a new allegation as far as i know.
Whatever the root cause of him labeling Waters as antisemitic, it certainly seems like it isn't because of any support for Israel or lack of concern for Palestinians.
02-09-23, 07:49 PM
#17
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: Roger Waters' Dark Side of the Moon
This is an anti-Semitic image he likes to fly at his shows.
He also apologized in 2020 for perpetuating anti-Semitic tropes regarding billionaire Sheldon Adelson
So now you know fuck-all about him being anti-Semitic outside of his vehement opposition of all things Israel.
He also apologized in 2020 for perpetuating anti-Semitic tropes regarding billionaire Sheldon Adelson
So now you know fuck-all about him being anti-Semitic outside of his vehement opposition of all things Israel.
Calling it out as anti semetic is like yelling at The Russo Brothers for the cruelty of Thanos’ snap plan.
02-09-23, 07:56 PM
#18
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: Roger Waters' Dark Side of the Moon
By all accounts, Gilmour is sympathetic enough to the Palestinian cause that in 2013 he even reunited with Roger Waters at a charity gig to benefit children of Palestinian refugees.
Whatever the root cause of him labeling Waters as antisemitic, it certainly seems like it isn't because of any support for Israel or lack of concern for Palestinians.
Whatever the root cause of him labeling Waters as antisemitic, it certainly seems like it isn't because of any support for Israel or lack of concern for Palestinians.
It’s not cool for someone to publicly call someone racist or anti semetic without giving ANY reason. Especially if the accuser has known the accused his entire life and thus would automatically be given some level of credibility on the matter of the accused character. Not cool at all.
The following 2 users liked this post by TGM:
JackoOnHisBacko (02-15-23),
tommyp007 (02-09-23)
02-09-23, 08:38 PM
#21
DVD Talk Godfather & 2020 TOTY Winner
Re: Roger Waters' Dark Side of the Moon
Does he fly the Rebel Flag or giant lawn jockeys at his shows as well? Is that okay as well, given the context?
Do you get to decide what images are offensive to Jewish people, or is it okay with you if the Anti-Defamation League makes that call?
- For a period of time in 2010, Waters’ shows featured video of an array of symbols that placed the Jewish Star of David next to dollar signs. Waters defended himself, writing on his website that “there are no hidden meanings in the order or juxtaposition of these symbols.” However, by an October 6, 2010 show in New York City, the video no longer showed the two symbols next to each other.
The following users liked this post:
TGM (02-09-23)
02-09-23, 08:56 PM
#22
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: Roger Waters' Dark Side of the Moon
It is actually. The pig is one of many symbols in the show for a racist fascist uprising that Roger Waters’ character is the head of.
If you’re not familiar with The Wall it’s way more like a play than a normal concert.
If you are familiar with the wall then i feel like you’re arguing in REALLY bad faith saying things like that pig is something “He likes to fly” . It’s a prop in a stage show with a specific purpose and it sure as fuck isn’t “Anti Semitism is cool”
If you’re not familiar with The Wall it’s way more like a play than a normal concert.
If you are familiar with the wall then i feel like you’re arguing in REALLY bad faith saying things like that pig is something “He likes to fly” . It’s a prop in a stage show with a specific purpose and it sure as fuck isn’t “Anti Semitism is cool”
02-09-23, 08:57 PM
#23
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Roger Waters' Dark Side of the Moon
Well until I hear a reason i feel pretty safe assuming it’s because of criticism of the government as i’ve never heard of Waters treating anyone different based on race or religion but have heard him criticize the government of israel plenty. If you think that’s unfair you may have a point but that’s really David Gilmours problem IMO.
fuck David Gilmour who is grossly calling Waters antisemitic because Waters rightfully calls out the apartheid state in Israel.
Gilmour never mentioned Israel, and has demonstrated sympathy for the Palestinian cause. And besides antisemitism, Gilmour also tacitly agreed with Waters being categorized a hypocrite, misogynist, liar, thief, tax-cheat, megalomaniac, and a fraud. Why are all the latter acceptably reasonable (in terms of credibility) but not the former?
02-09-23, 08:59 PM
#24
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: Roger Waters' Dark Side of the Moon
Because Roger Waters is a known asshole so i can’t argue against any of those other things but more importantly as i said previously when people label those who call out Israel’s apartheid state as anti semetic it’s more than an attack on just the person but a warning to others to shut the fuck up about what’s going on and i’m not down with that. I’m not in a lot of teams but #TeamNotThat
02-09-23, 09:04 PM
#25
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Roger Waters' Dark Side of the Moon
IIRC the pig also had the Christian cross and the Muslim crescent star, as well as dollar signs, Mercedes-Benz symbols, Shell oil symbols, etc. I don't know if Waters is truly antisemitic (I have my suspicions) but IMO the pig is an equal-opportunity offender making a larger point about religion as a tool of the military industrial complex or some such shit.
