Why Isn't "Jane Says" Mentioned More Often as a Best Song of the '80s?
#77
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Joined: Mar 2001
Posts: 7,935
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Atlanta
Re: Why Isn't "Jane Says" Mentioned More Often as a Best Song of the '80s?
I found it interesting some of the comments about Jane's Addiction and the metal scene in Los Angeles. They sort of had the look and I'm sure in Los Angeles it would have been easy to see the similarities, but from an East coast perspective, I never thought of them like that. Firmly alternative rock with way better ideas/music than the lunkhead late 80's glam scene. Perry definitely helped pave the way for alternative rock to explode, if not with his band then with Lollapalooza. I remember going to the first one in 1991 and it was not clear at the time that Nirvana was going to blow up big. There was a great deal of excitement that SOMEONE had enough balls to put together a big show like that. It was a very fresh idea that I didn't really connect too much with the grunge movement.
#78
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Joined: Jul 2002
Posts: 8,619
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: So Cal
Re: Why Isn't "Jane Says" Mentioned More Often as a Best Song of the '80s?
#79
#80
DVD Talk Special Edition
Re: Why Isn't "Jane Says" Mentioned More Often as a Best Song of the '80s?
Well, I'm one of those people who found the song tiring and monotonous back in the day, so there's strike one against it.
Strike two was the fact that it's one of the most overplayed songs in the history of white people's music... not so much on college\rock radio (although there is that), but at parties, bars, road trips, etc. Combine the tediousness of the song with hearing it at least 47 times a week back then, and you can see why it might get on one's nerves.
Strike three were those airhead chicks who loved Jane's back then. I thought for a while there that I might strangle the next girl who said "ohmygawd! I loooooovvvve Jane's Addiction!1!1!11!!".
On a more personal level, I'm an East Coast guy all the way, and Jane's was a West Coast band that really didn't appeal to me on any level. I mean, I could listen to the band and see why people would like them, but their music, artwork, appearance, ethos... all said "Los Angeles", and in my book, no good band ever came out of California.
Strike two was the fact that it's one of the most overplayed songs in the history of white people's music... not so much on college\rock radio (although there is that), but at parties, bars, road trips, etc. Combine the tediousness of the song with hearing it at least 47 times a week back then, and you can see why it might get on one's nerves.
Strike three were those airhead chicks who loved Jane's back then. I thought for a while there that I might strangle the next girl who said "ohmygawd! I loooooovvvve Jane's Addiction!1!1!11!!".
On a more personal level, I'm an East Coast guy all the way, and Jane's was a West Coast band that really didn't appeal to me on any level. I mean, I could listen to the band and see why people would like them, but their music, artwork, appearance, ethos... all said "Los Angeles", and in my book, no good band ever came out of California.
#81
Banned by request
Re: Why Isn't "Jane Says" Mentioned More Often as a Best Song of the '80s?
The Doors, X, The Beach Boys, The Byrds, Love, Frank Zappa, Captain Beefheart, The Germs, Black Flag, NOFX, The Minutemen, Bad Religion, Social Distortion, Faith No More, Metallica, The Red Hot Chili Peppers, Camper Van Beethoven, Stone Temple Pilots, Megadeth, Pavement, The Brian Jonestown Massacre, Sly and the Family Stone, Santana, and Sparks are not good bands/artists?
#82
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: Why Isn't "Jane Says" Mentioned More Often as a Best Song of the '80s?
#83
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Re: Why Isn't "Jane Says" Mentioned More Often as a Best Song of the '80s?




