DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   Music Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/music-talk-28/)
-   -   Nirvana Boxset in November [tracklist thread merged in] (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/music-talk/383869-nirvana-boxset-november-%5Btracklist-thread-merged-%5D.html)

zak52 11-20-04 07:31 AM

Target has this in their ad for $27.98.

auto 11-20-04 08:33 AM

Wow. That's a great price. I am impressed.

It this confirmed.

If so, is this a tuesday price or a black friday price?

Gunshy 11-20-04 11:56 AM


Originally posted by zak52
Target has this in their ad for $27.98.
Where'd you see that price? I looked at their on-line ad pages and didn't see it :(

-Gunshy

zak52 11-20-04 01:18 PM

The ad doesn't start until tomorrow.

nodeerforamonth 11-20-04 01:29 PM


Originally posted by Hollowgen
i know. i have the sub pop compilation. but isn't the point of the set to collect all these tunes into one package?
No, not at all. The point of a "best of" or "greatest hits" is to collect all the tunes into one package.

Only fans of Nirvana are going to spend all that money to buy the box set. And fans of Nirvana already have all the songs that have been released before. Why just repackage the same songs they already have?

The point of the box set is give the fans access to rare and raw recordings that they may not have heard before.

I think the track listing is just about perfect. They did the right thing.

Spiderbite 11-20-04 01:35 PM


Originally posted by nodeerforamonth
The point of the box set is give the fans access to rare and raw recordings that they may not have heard before.

I think the track listing is just about perfect. They did the right thing.

Exactly...which to me is the way ALL boxsets should be. Boxsets that are just the normal songs from all the albums thrown into a box are too numerous to count.

This is by the far the perfect boxset. I honestly cannot wait until this comes out...and I haven't gotten excited about anything released music-wise in recent years.

Ravenous 11-20-04 10:01 PM

Can SOMEONE help me out here?
 
I have loved Nirvana for many years and really want this set, but I have a small question.

Are these songs, live, demos, studio tracks, what?
Endless, Nameless
D-7
Curmudgeon
Moist Vagina
Marigold

I have the singles that these songs are on as BSides and LOVE these songs, but its not clear what these songs will be on the box. I want this set, but if these tracks arent as they appear on the singles, what the point?

Also, I dont mind that I know your right is acoustic on this release. I have the MP3 of the GH version and damn is it annoying... to me.

The Antipodean 11-20-04 10:11 PM

Look a mere one page earlier in this thread and you'll find the answer I believe.

Ravenous 11-20-04 11:44 PM

Well, is a radio session live? Was moist vagina originally a demo or a full on production used as a Bside, or a demo used as a Bside? The parenthesis arent clear at all.

sinister 11-21-04 01:13 AM

my walmart broke street date so i picked it up tonight. it's very good but the dvd seems too short. i hope more of their live shows and videos get released later with 5.1 dolby or dts sound. i need more nirvana on dvd.

Hollowgen 11-21-04 10:28 AM


Originally posted by sinister
my walmart broke street date so i picked it up tonight. it's very good but the dvd seems too short. i hope more of their live shows and videos get released later with 5.1 dolby or dts sound. i need more nirvana on dvd.
cost?

Damfino 11-21-04 03:05 PM


Originally posted by zak52
Target has this in their ad for $27.98.
It could be a mis-price but Circuit City and Best Buy will probably match it!

nodeerforamonth 11-21-04 05:21 PM

Saw the ad in today's paper: Target $27.98. Can't beat that!

sinister: isn't the DVD about 100 minutes? That's a good length! (though of course more would be better!)

auto 11-21-04 05:28 PM

I'll be at Target tuesday morning before work.

Ravenous 11-21-04 06:27 PM


Originally posted by sinister
my walmart broke street date so i picked it up tonight. it's very good but the dvd seems too short. i hope more of their live shows and videos get released later with 5.1 dolby or dts sound. i need more nirvana on dvd.
Mind answering these questions for me?

Are these songs, live, demos, studio tracks, what?
Endless, Nameless
D-7
Curmudgeon
Moist Vagina
Marigold

WestEndRiot 11-21-04 07:16 PM


Originally posted by Ravenous
Mind answering these questions for me?

Are these songs, live, demos, studio tracks, what?

Endless, Nameless....radio appearance - 1991
D-7.....radio appearance - 1990
Curmudgeon.....listed as b-side, sounds like a studio track (non-demo) - 1992
Moist Vagina....demo - 1993
Marigold....like Curmudgeon, listed as studio track b-side - 1993

not being a huge nirvana fan, i find Marigold to be my favorite track. a much better version than what is found on Grohl's Late! Pocketwatch tape.

as for the comments on the ideal purposes of a box set...i think it all depends on the artist and their catalog of work. the box set that comes to mind is the 10 disc Led Zeppelin set. being that each of the records had been remastered and even though they only added <gasp> four additional tracks, i think that box served it's purpose quite well, for new and old fans alike. that being said, to a true Nirvana fan (of which i probably am not) i suppose this is a dream come true, even if you've already searched these tracks out on various comps and bootlegs.

for the record, my favorite box set is Cash: Unearthed even if the 5th disc is recycled.

Ravenous 11-21-04 08:45 PM

Shit! Sounds like Im going to have to keep my singles with the B-sides of these songs since theyre all studio.

Now I may not even get the set :mad:

focker 11-21-04 10:41 PM


Originally posted by Ravenous
Shit! Sounds like Im going to have to keep my singles with the B-sides of these songs since theyre all studio.

Now I may not even get the set :mad:

:hscratch: You'd be happier if these tracks were the same ones that you already have on other CDs rather than new versions you've never heard before? Why?

Hollowgen 11-21-04 11:21 PM

... i'd kinda like the set to consist of the b-sides and rarities in their "official" forms, in addition to the never officially released demos, etc.

ah hell, i just wish they'd do something almost as exhaustive as into the black.

mrlumpy 11-22-04 11:41 AM

I'm pretty excited that they didn't just compile all of the b-sides that I spent time tracking down myself. That Cure box set made my wife's Cure singles collection a freakin' waste of time and money. The Nirvana set doesn't do that to my Nirvana collection. Yay!

Hollowgen 11-22-04 12:29 PM


Originally posted by mrlumpy
I'm pretty excited that they didn't just compile all of the b-sides that I spent time tracking down myself. That Cure box set made my wife's Cure singles collection a freakin' waste of time and money. The Nirvana set doesn't do that to my Nirvana collection. Yay!
realize that not everyone wanted to/could track down all of those import singles, and indie compilations! i have a bunch, but man alive, i'm not rich.

FrozenMetalHead 11-22-04 01:20 PM

Here's a detailed track-by-track review of the box set

http://www.nirvanaclub.com/box/#tracklisting

And an overall boxset review by the same site

http://www.nirvanaclub.com/box/#nfcreview

Hollowgen 11-23-04 02:03 AM

anyone been able to confirm the price at target?

right now, (before rebates or anything), it looks as if best buy will have the best price...

shaggy 11-23-04 03:47 AM


Originally posted by Hollowgen
anyone been able to confirm the price at target?

right now, (before rebates or anything), it looks as if best buy will have the best price...

Its 27.98 in the flyer. Now that if they have any thats a different story.

auto 11-23-04 08:59 AM


Originally posted by Hollowgen
anyone been able to confirm the price at target?

right now, (before rebates or anything), it looks as if best buy will have the best price...

Price at Target is $27.98. Picked mine up first thing this morning.


Originally posted by shaggy
Its 27.98 in the flyer. Now that if they have any thats a different story.
The Target I went to (Ann Arbor, MI) had five copies. That's why I got there early. :)

Great looking set.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 04:13 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.