DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   Movie Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/movie-talk-17/)
-   -   Directors with three or more consecutive masterpieces (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/movie-talk/650424-directors-three-more-consecutive-masterpieces.html)

Decker 05-05-20 12:23 PM

Re: Directors with three or more consecutive masterpieces
 

Originally Posted by OldBoy (Post 13735933)
well, it's highly regarded as a superhero/comic film. it did a lot for genre, i think. so maybe not masterpiece like The Godfather certainly, but iconic nonetheless. Hellboy could be called out too, but it was highly regarded as well...

Blade II has a Metacritc score of 52 and a Rotten Tomato score of 57%. That is not universal acclaim, and it's no Masterpiece.

atrium 05-05-20 01:18 PM

Re: Directors with three or more consecutive masterpieces
 
Some very solid runs...

Ingmar Bergman:
Cries and Whispers (classic) -> Scenes from a Marriage (very good) -> The Magic Flute (very good)

Robert Bresson:
The Diary of a Country Priest (very good) -> A Man Escaped (classic) -> Pickpocket (very good)

Charlie Chaplin:
City Lights (classic) -> Modern Times (classic) -> The Great Dictator (classic) -> Monsier Verdoux (very good)

Carl Theodor Dreyer:
The Passion of Joan of Arc (classic) -> Vampyr (very good) -> Day of Wrath (very good)

Federico Fellini:
Nights of Cabiria (very good) -> La Dolce Vita (classic) -> 8 1/2 (classic)

Howard Hawks:
To Have and Have Not (very good) -> The Big Sleep (classic) -> Red River (classic)

Stanley Kubric:
Dr. Strangelove (classic) -> 2001 (classic) -> A Clockwork Orange (classic) -> Barry Lyndon (classic) -> The Shining (very good)

Martin Scorsese:
Mean Streets (classic) -> Alice Doesn't Live Here Anymore (very good) -> Taxi Driver (classic)

Andrei Tarkovsky:
Ivan's Childhood (very good) -> Andrei Rublev (classic) -> Solaris (classic) -> The Mirror (classic) -> Stalker (very good)

Billy Wilder:
A Foreign Affair (very good) -> Sunset Boulevard (classic) -> Ace in the Hole (very good) -> Stalag 17 (very good) -> Sabrina (classic) -> The Seven Year Itch (very good) -> Witness for the Prosecution (very good)


Kurosawa and Ozu always seemed to bookend their great films with meh films...

atrium 05-05-20 01:39 PM

Re: Directors with three or more consecutive masterpieces
 
A few more...

Woody Allen:
Sleeper (very good) -> Love and Death (very good) -> Annie Hall (classic)

Sergei Eisenstein:
Strike (very good) -> Battleship Potemkin (classic) -> October (very good)

Satyajit Ray:
Pather Panchali (classic) -> Aparajito (very good) -> The Music Room (very good)

Alain Resnais:
Hiroshima Mon Amour (very good) -> Last Year at Marienbad (classic) -> Muriel, or the Time of Return (very good)

Nick Danger 05-05-20 01:57 PM

Re: Directors with three or more consecutive masterpieces
 

Originally Posted by Geddlo (Post 13735877)
John Hughes and Mel Brooks both had streaks of great movies and if you count writing or producing, it gets more impressive

So far as I'm concerned, Mel Brooks made two classics: Blazing Saddles and Young Frankenstein. Before and after were The Seven Chairs, which was pretty good, and Silent Movie which was once-funny.


Originally Posted by tommyp007 (Post 13735771)
I'm the first to mention Billy Wilder!!?? From 1950-1960 we get in order

Sunset Boulevard
Ace in the Hole
Stalag 17
Sabrina
The Seven Year Itch
The Spirit of St Louis
Love in the Afternoon
Witness For the Prosecution
Some Like it Hot
The Apartment.

Do people still admire The Seven Year Itch? Marilyn Monroe was sexy as hell, but as soon as she leaves the screen the rest of the movie is a bad 50s sitcom. Even Billy Wilder said bad things about it.

I haven't seen Love in the Afternoon or Spirit of St Louis. That still leaves Wilder with two separate runs of three masterpieces.

atrium 05-05-20 02:07 PM

Re: Directors with three or more consecutive masterpieces
 

Originally Posted by Nick Danger (Post 13736009)
So far as I'm concerned, Mel Brooks made two classics: Blazing Saddles and Young Frankenstein. Before and after were The Seven Chairs, which was pretty good, and Silent Movie which was once-funny.



Do people still admire The Seven Year Itch? Marilyn Monroe was sexy as hell, but as soon as she leaves the screen the rest of the movie is a bad 50s sitcom. Even Billy Wilder said bad things about it.

I haven't seen Love in the Afternoon or Spirit of St Louis. That still leaves Wilder with two separate runs of three masterpieces.

The Producers is another Brooks masterpiece imo. And The Seven Year Itch is a deliberate parody of those 50s Hollywood romances.

Calling The Spirit of St. Louis and Love in the Afternoon 'masterpieces' is a huge stretch.

Nick Danger 05-05-20 02:11 PM

Re: Directors with three or more consecutive masterpieces
 

Originally Posted by atrium (Post 13736014)
The Producers is another Brooks masterpiece imo. And The Seven Year Itch is a deliberate parody of those 50s Hollywood romances.

Calling The Spirit of St. Louis and Love in the Afternoon 'masterpieces' is a huge stretch.

I'm not a big fan of The Producers. It's an hour-long setup for one scene, although the scene is one of the funniest things in cinema history.

IBJoel 05-05-20 02:31 PM

Re: Directors with three or more consecutive masterpieces
 
Oldboy, I think one could make the argument that QT's entire filmography has been masterpieces, although I'd probably say it goes from Pulp Fiction to at least Django Unchained. I actually haven't seen his last two films, yet.

atrium 05-05-20 02:38 PM

Re: Directors with three or more consecutive masterpieces
 

Originally Posted by IBJoel (Post 13736024)
Oldboy, I think one could make the argument that QT's entire filmography has been masterpieces, although I'd probably say it goes from Pulp Fiction to at least Django Unchained. I actually haven't seen his last two films, yet.

That's gonna be a no for me dawg

Decker 05-05-20 03:46 PM

Re: Directors with three or more consecutive masterpieces
 

Originally Posted by atrium (Post 13736032)
That's gonna be a no for me dawg

Even QT was pretty cognizant of when it is appropriate to use that terminology.
https://cimg2.ibsrv.net/gimg/dvdtalk...725bbe2e94.gif


OldBoy 05-05-20 03:47 PM

Re: Directors with three or more consecutive masterpieces
 

Originally Posted by IBJoel (Post 13736024)
Oldboy, I think one could make the argument that QT's entire filmography has been masterpieces, although I'd probably say it goes from Pulp Fiction to at least Django Unchained. I actually haven't seen his last two films, yet.

i wouldn't disagree and i would throw in the ones he wrote, like Natural Born Killers and True Romance as well. and his last 2, H8 and OUaTiH are masterpieces as well...

OldBoy 05-05-20 03:50 PM

Re: Directors with three or more consecutive masterpieces
 

Originally Posted by Decker (Post 13735945)
Blade II has a Metacritc score of 52 and a Rotten Tomato score of 57%. That is not universal acclaim, and it's no Masterpiece.

true. but everybody thought it was the best in trilogy by far and made a boatload of $$ ;)

OldBoy 05-05-20 03:53 PM

Re: Directors with three or more consecutive masterpieces
 
Luc Besson: La Femme Nikita, Léon: The Professional, The Fifth Element.

dex14 05-05-20 04:00 PM

Re: Directors with three or more consecutive masterpieces
 

Originally Posted by tommyp007 (Post 13735771)
I'm the first to mention Billy Wilder!!?? From 1950-1960 we get in order

Sunset Boulevard
Ace in the Hole
Stalag 17
Sabrina
The Seven Year Itch
The Spirit of St Louis
Love in the Afternoon
Witness For the Prosecution
Some Like it Hot
The Apartment.

No, I did in post 10. I only listed the first three. The only other one I'd consider that is is The Apartment, but the chain is broken.

LorenzoL 05-05-20 04:07 PM

Re: Directors with three or more consecutive masterpieces
 

Originally Posted by Decker (Post 13735929)
^ I'm sorry, did you just call Blade II a Masterpiece? rotfl

To be fair, he also called Shutter Island and Brothers Bloom masterpieces too.

dex14 05-05-20 04:10 PM

Re: Directors with three or more consecutive masterpieces
 

Originally Posted by LorenzoL (Post 13736112)
To be fair, he also called Shutter Island and Brothers Bloom masterpieces too.

And that The King of Comedy wasn't!

redtornado 05-05-20 04:30 PM

Re: Directors with three or more consecutive masterpieces
 
Kevin Smith - Clerks, Mallrats, Chasing Amy, Dogma

Chad Stahelski - John Wick, John Wick II, John Wick III

The Russo Brothers - Captain America Civil War, Avengers: Infinity War, Avengers: Endgame

devilshalo 05-05-20 04:37 PM

Re: Directors with three or more consecutive masterpieces
 

Originally Posted by atrium (Post 13736032)
That's gonna be a no for me dawg

I think Hateful 8 is overly long and tedious.

Hazel Motes 05-05-20 06:02 PM

Re: Directors with three or more consecutive masterpieces
 
This thread needs to stop.

rocket1312 05-05-20 06:20 PM

Re: Directors with three or more consecutive masterpieces
 
At some point I assume the forum will be downsized to two threads, one titled "movies I like" and one titled "movies I don't like".

atrium 05-05-20 06:40 PM

Re: Directors with three or more consecutive masterpieces
 
I, too, hate being forced at gunpoint to come into threads I don’t like

tommyp007 05-05-20 06:45 PM

Re: Directors with three or more consecutive masterpieces
 

Originally Posted by dex14 (Post 13736109)
No, I did in post 10. I only listed the first three. The only other one I'd consider that is is The Apartment, but the chain is broken.

Indeed you did. Sorry.

Hazel Motes 05-05-20 06:47 PM

Re: Directors with three or more consecutive masterpieces
 
I was just being a little sarcastic after seeing the thread descend into hailing The Russo Brothers as directors of 3 straight masterpieces.

atrium 05-05-20 06:53 PM

Re: Directors with three or more consecutive masterpieces
 
Touché. If there’s one thing this thread taught me, there’s maybe 10 directors in history who have made 3 masterpieces in a row

dex14 05-05-20 07:32 PM

Re: Directors with three or more consecutive masterpieces
 

Originally Posted by Hazel Motes (Post 13736222)
I was just being a little sarcastic after seeing the thread descend into hailing The Russo Brothers as directors of 3 straight masterpieces.

The real pity is no hailing if You, Me, and Dupree.

rocket1312 05-05-20 08:02 PM

Re: Directors with three or more consecutive masterpieces
 
Joe Russo did direct the following Community episodes back to back to back:

Cooperative Calligraphy
Advanced Dungeons and Dragons
Intermediate Documentary Filmmaking

For my money, those are three masterpieces.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 11:40 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.